The New York Herald Newspaper, June 5, 1860, Page 4

set ee ae ill aM 4 NEW YORK HERALD, TUESDAY, JUNE 5, 1860.—TRIPLE. SHEET. er a ee TEE CHICAGO DIVORCE CASE. — ce benewatpe fhe Case of Mr. [sane U Burch, the Basker of Chicego, and his Wife, Mary W. Bureh. tive Iaw’’ alone, to be upheld only by words of me for the: Ublecrartese The cose of Somersets, a which made are heey crates 1 in oug sate 1 hare cat rule was ceciered, bes been imocsched oe this bisa, if have eae watch I po Rs} 4 ae the Dr cfiraios of ladepencence bas boon ato. IT have spoken , and fi ‘ee . acbeo also. Ad bere the Seva‘or from Loulsiaas (Mr. | severedy, | ret) bas taken the cad He hes dwelt on the at | caling Berton tat, in the bistory of Eognen law there were | tell their unimpeacholle st ry. u M oH id a ou lior Cases WDETe BOOLLTATY pri ~~ welfare Bo permit me Wsay thet oo such Cases, even if they ro ote ne tak wack base exist 19 autbendc reports, Can impair the iofluence of tals | paid wil ficd a reponse im aemorous anaie ” { bdsene thet we Ke, ord authority Pog) ae knows woll that | J have sad which t+ net sustained by welt yo mded uo old av Ar OATOUs CBO 18s POOF aaswer to aa argument bas emuny, day which Cipla wbich is brought into eativity by the deme wats ” rae of em aovencing civiligation, apd which once vob nized cep sever be Gemied; thas jurisprudence is > beams nining ia & warrow circle, and newar Of Kansas asa free Sate ‘@ some ligot, hb, slow'y emerging | Them will the tar! o ah: be repel'ed, and the pre Grows and spreads with human | ¢ nsion of property in man be ‘Such an act, clas at imysove@ent, until at lart 1: becomes as broas and goas- | ing this rel as the ligt of cay. When the Senater in thin ape, Ternerys ! om ads eens pry ens = sh canedaete teats beac, poe Bye Fy RO wom shall be tustedied. coorgiinny tank God, it makes slavery imposible wnier the conts’ | under the natomal porrmments when’ the et ae national tumon, he vasnly tugs to dregdoun @ luminary from the wherever i floats, on sea or land, within the SOME OLD FALLAOS RETAILED. ‘the - lh O E wi"e ‘The enormity of the pretepsion that slavery is sanc- the name of , will once again be reve: Kawed By the constitution becomes sull more apparent @s te Amrwan vharta of Human | E ak z 7. ti £ are the happumens; tbat, to scure these rights, govern: | sciences, conomies, refinements, rites, ments are ipsttuted emong men, deriving “their just wi sega le, — inte onan You a Nor does | rej 1%, but it wil oaly today. 3 declaration, binying the conscience of all who epjoy | sacred ani: dete ‘redom and davery end, he privilegen Wocoured, etand aloes, ‘There sonterr ween ths tbiagh of hake Ther same quation soll” Bational act lese Spown, but in itself a to the Gret, | be soun curried befure thas high trebunal, supreme over Se Maratal Copgrese, ry ant eva ted —T- er aur ure ne eae charg mo F 0 uly appoupced:“+Let it be rememoered that it has ever rom ." an aroused people, dnutructiog @ new President, 2 the ie ao wnat ohh ban atone the ight pf! eer ie mn ta ceedihes were the 1! of human wpeteet Bature By the Diessings of the Autaor of these iy rw OPA A Se ys ; belo ot nae eapenssch Reaes”” Yoe, eoover at J Bese: siege cde ae 2 ndeu! "Now, vor oy tis we aoe wane Savona Toot hertedictiens a power | Bould expisin the reagoas which wo are ere lavited to Seeqereo! past inoneuet ih iner"tve datsst | boc ewe, ant wy othe hoo Brean are, grep! with these $ v0 nati coors, and fawning at the feet of British aristeoracy, declarations. Here is tne sational heart, the national | seexiog for pity, but real the rich and just reward of focl, the sationa!l will, the ations! voice, which contempt, ‘slsnderer of «sand men reappears is Tutt iwapire our interpretation of the constitution, the Senate. We hea hoped that be relievet enter into and diffuse iteelf through aii the national ‘rom the mieerable outpouriags lation. * es the Sry yon ym which = bea ad fe suLute iberty, ana uit of happiness," aac ~ fo more grieral words, “the rights of human nuare,” | cusly ‘sile to om po cg gee hed fare fa wet Without owstinetion of race, or recogoition of (be curse Of | Henge. In are disappomte Ham. oe the bee's of our vational institutions. They n-ed | % gir, in the heroic ages of ths worl mo neeenuemaee’ Bot, ia etrict are Toe were often but they are the many utterances ip the coavention which framed | que posecscion and exercise of some virtue, wisdom, ‘te constitution: of Gouverneur Morris, of Peoptyivacia, . meee aks Ge Goald never peur Io upald’ eh coke ana courage comestic ry; it was a nefarious ation; of EB bricge Gerry, of Haseachue-lin, who eeid thet we bed pene ya wag poy nr ner peti ena Dothing to do with (he c ‘oduct of the Stules as to slavery, Dat we eugbt to be careful Dot to give any BaDcton to it;” pp ey pe ae ee Roger Sherman and Quiver Ellsworth, of Connecit: | ir, we do not bere latend ts’ be gulvy of any such apo cut, avd Mr. Gorham, cf Massachusetts, who all | theosis of malignity and meanners Wedo not intend to concurred with Mr. Gerry; and cnoecially Of | comeribute, by any conduct om oar part, to swell the Mr. Madcon, of Virginia, who, in mild juritical | Pane et the sbrine of tois new icol. No, sir, ai though _, “thought it #ropg to admit in the constitution the | wisn no expectation but ihe ‘of impro we are lore that there could be property In maa.” Acd, lest'y, | ros incuuee by emp puuicument aun temas &s If to crimpirte the elaborate work of freecom, 437 10 | text or pnpishment ballootog Sbrovgn the give «pression to all these otterances. the word'saervi | fori incrensca volumes of siancer no’) ta je,’ which bad bern allowed in the clavse on the ap have remained quiet portionment +f representatives. was struck out, Sed the word Meervice”) | aubeuiated inetoad: . nis Goal exclusion from couatitution of ~auere See crptees ppenowes LS idea > property \b mam as on tbe motion T eapeost to-cey the barberem of slavery, anal 0 Mr. Rendolph, of Virgivle; and tho reason assigara ‘or | petiowe that what the S-oator bas veld 1 might Well print the substitati'h accordi:g to Mr. Madison, tn ow autbea | in the appendix of my epecch as an iiusrotos Adjourned. g: tie report cf ibe debate, was (bat “the former was tbouget 10 exprers the coadition of viaves, and the later tbe opligaions Of tree persons” Thus’ atevery pout, a by great vatiopal declaratioos, by frank utterances ia the House of Representatives. convention, apd bs @ positive ect in ac) sting the text of Wasnincron, June 4, 1860. the constitution wes the idea of property io man un ‘The House acted on the Senate's amend nents to the equivocalty rejected. Thi pretapeion, which msy be dis | post Office missed @8 Utiorly baseless, becomes absurd woen it ts DeGteacy bill, aad moa cooourred in that considered to #hat resu't it Decersari'y coaducts. If the | Striking out the proviso for the restoration of the sus Darberiem of slavery, in all ite eee serene a reaily | pended inland mail service, and requiring proposals from embo led fn tbe copetitotion, 80 esto be beyons the resca wat of probinition ether Congrekaicpal or local, in the Ter | e ‘ biter Sar carezing Ge mall borepen Charies tories, then, for (be game reason. it mort be deyoad the | ton aed Havens reart of pr. b/bition or abolition, even by jocal suthority Among other dilis reported from the committes were ip (be States theweelweal and. jast go loog as the ovat! | whe got a “ totive contmues vechanged, Territories aod Sist @ alike most be open to ail its Dresting wiluemses Avd yet tois By Mr. Apams, (8. opp ) of Ky , authorizing a daily mai; Bretneten which, ip te patural coosequencra, overturns | service Inland between Sen Fraocisce and Olympia, Wash rigbte. 1s put forwerd by Seomtors who profess to be the epecial guardiace of State righta, ingten Torteary, Hn eam aot ennseting OF ‘THE EQUALITY OF RTATRS I disdain to cwell oo that other a'gument, brought forward by Senators, wb, denying the equality of maa, Sproousty assert the equality of the States; aod trom | “hr tonya (rep) of Ine. ees eae! this princivie, true im many respects, jump’ to the cou ~d Cane iat’ “devemasiore “ake cotta, in ‘tae | C& 8 DM! appropriating $160,000 for « Fost UMice tx Brook name ‘of equality, to take their slaves {ato the nanoval Te riories under the solema saeguarts of tna copstitotion But this agument comes Deck to the first pretemmon, that elaves are recogoized as “property” in tbe constitution. To tet pretension, siready amply ex 4, we are always brought, por cap any sounding at ations of State equality svoia i And yet this ver: azgoment betrays the inconsistency 0” ite authors if pereons belo to rervice in the slave States are‘ property” ‘under the cov rtitotion, toem, uccer the provisl o—knoen ae the © three fins” rule—ebich fouece representation ip the other Bouse on such persors, there property Tepreseptation from the slave Stats, #10 voice ani vole, while there # po euch property representation from out venti’ ventana free Saves = With glaring lorquality, tae Tepreseotetion Mr Basux, (AL D.,) ON. Vf the © pb pr Pe ye gg Pia property while | Cm Privling, resorted back the jolat’ ressiuuoe reduciog the representatin of the free States is founded pony ap ht ad Printing, ead sald he woald cali lt simply on“ persone,” leaving ali thelr boauciess Tmilheve of preyerty werepresente. Thus, whichever | o¢ wares Private bills were paseod under s guspension way we approach it, the abeurdity of this pre- tesion becomes menifest Armaming the pretension of | om motion ot Mr. Momus, (rep ) ne roperty iv mad up er tbe Constitution, you flay * 1 * Keon the whore theory of State equality, for yoo House took up bod ng Tod ye a gigevtic iorquality betwern the siave State: free States: apd seraourg the equality of States to the Adjourned, Hovee of Representavves a clare ebere, you slap in ibe Tece toe whole pretension ef property in man under the Sapreme Court—spectal Term. a POPULAR SoVERELOWTY. Reine Hien. Sutgn Gathorinns, I dinca’n to ¢we'l also om that other ment, which MORE DOMESTIC DIFFICULTIES. in the tame of po ular rowere'goty, races to se June 4—John Walton ve. Bien Mo Walton —Tho plain ‘ci the Territories the wicked power— Con eae ee a essateoion ot terms, rigGiet oa. | UT wes for a di¥crce on tbe ground of it treatment whica Was votniast | he alleges, readers it uneaie for him to live with bis wife. Shee | | te sppears that the plaintll wa distiller in this city act from the cepe bt of the governed,” ant as if any. | portersing Considerable proverty; the lady before ber where within a, of 1) cg ey @arriage With bim kept e boardwg bouse and was, as contains pe pebeDoE, reso word — senc! twice as {ni ovtrege, sae ‘which carefully excluies he | 8 Tepresentea, widowed; she alse stated that iden of property in man, while it surroueds ull perroos | abe bad three pons, two of whom were cbildree of her with the b ghert eafrgear Gres Duebepe (Mr J: Mreye) ama the other by the second coulis exiet. bueband (Mr Russell) ane bad ao aaopted niece ‘vereigoty witbm the sobere Of tme conetitation who was then fa the eo the busbead alinges felse Limbavions Claitning for al! the largest liberty of a irae | rrpresentaboor op toe part of the and (oat iustesd civilization it compresses all within .bs Coosirainu of jas | Of bavirg bad two h sbande rhe bat bes three Bofors bia fice; por dors it allow apy man to aesert & ‘tb do | rel’; that tbe secons husband was stil! Living wm Obio, ant what be pleaten except when he pleases to [0 Aa | that tbe opted piece was a cud of Ber own by aoouer well within the T. rritories atts mpt to make aking we per y cuteice the cumerous watr@cnel bouds thet bed tempt to make a slave. But this preteosion, rroandec ber. The plaoufl also alleges f amenning manifestations on Woe re | beboid a fantious band = ~ hireo-tin w bere inomscived are free, to’ Mrs. Waites “i tbreatenipg himself aad Proceeding origibally from a yais effort to avotd te tm NPvpE pee Conoety te ES Os racing duemive Orpeen freedom ans slavery—we a depuis a tone bee om 19g & delusive parasé of freedom as a cloak for slavery — trod epraking eittythe voice of Jecom whe its hanin are the Slave of Rose—ecy or dieesimned with the other Kiatred Pretewstone (or rlavery. while the Sever from lilioms ‘who bas @andered so jar ia its sapport, wr. 1 _ ——— re mem ser Wilo's ond. ‘Wedged in tbat ember which be troy st rend. RRA ME OF THR ARGC ENTS | | Joye 4—This morniug ihe Judge seoounced thet, as the And bord Ulam ihe ranch of the argument, whiet | Board of Supervisors had failed to provite noiMcteat ac have treated ‘atiy ret, parity tewmet | eommodation for this Court, be should direst the Sheriff to , but heey because the barby | i Oe saith runitahed: ruperssdes all wacr | 60%, in which he was aathoriand un‘er the etatule. Ra But epouge bes bere tome on ths heat = Atthe | bad beld epecial term im thie room, but it was toully on SE reprusien, bow gainer “the copstiatioa, may tae Hi Ht H | 3 wt together. foe serum | suited for jory trials; and tor the cos venience ant com fort of and ‘end continue W6 bois them | the Goart i Anemos, a8 well as the counsel ant their saves \oto the Terr norws , he wosla atjoere the bericerr uow! as im the Saale, stands om tro os, ret Wat man | Ty moreicg a xt. ‘ may bold property in mas. avd rrcomtiy tha: tale pro ‘The Clerk was then directed to enter an order on the a, fo resogutses 1 the constiveticn we have seh | minutes for the Sherif! of the chy amd cocuty of New the prewnded property in man stands on Bo ressen, York to provide suiusbie accumimodauion for we Juug ee while the two epee! arguments by which it hat bese | Of the Superier Court. easertec— first an efleget \oferiority of race, and ss watiy — Calet Justice the avcieot curse of Ham—are grossly iaseM sect ap. | Ths ‘inane Sos cabaoae ) ngs = Bold such « pretertion And we bere ext even that | i: my this pretension Det s* little suoport in the coortiat im | 10 same reasons, ty week refuge im the Supre as ie reason, that lorry (fof tech an ofrnmior Cpe j reom, part 2 ners hence can fd mepgert only oe ie’? Sametion , an pope “orreeiatiine clearness, 1 thie Dewwa Fels, } Rurrog ate’s Office, quesnoued te the “rosie, consistent with the prio p —# Pefore Kdward © Went, Surrrogate. of On Od raB OE? Cte Ee ton. thet Bo wee) onetuve sect i WILL OF BARAIEY WaITiNe. Gon, ia words of Virremeuole clearowme,” own be tongs in | the Constitu'ien, White @ harmoey with the Dostaration | ‘This inetromeut was admitted to probate rosterday s a tee smurdagoranense comuatoes eine ears. | TRO property of the testatrin, who was 4 witow, amonot ‘apd capeciai's the eet of the Convention ip wusetitat. C4 to about $90.000. which by her will she dlstributet toe “eurvicn” for “ter ewnde,” on the ground Ubat ne Song ber ceareat relatives m suns varying from $2,000 Inter expreeere ‘the contin of elawee ' all attet thit 81 Ke. Fretenss Ral man cin hid property im maw wae caer Sally, oreynd oly and ommplitily minded from de om The Expedition i the Sorth Puie to ‘Minton, te tht Ht has vo somtdinee of duprert Os Cet Leave im we Weems, ? at; bor 1h pretowon, woICD iF UnSanyorted The Ar tie Cacmitier ot the American Geographical Im the Constitution Delpse by the two arguteot, oar in Society connder ik cas Wo (be public, who Dave abown & We came of Bae quality, aed tr Ofer we the Came of op wnioress @ the pre jrotes expedition to the Pole popular sovereignty, bouh of which ere properly put | Regione, te inform them Uiat, aided by tbe uberal s sorit) arive © Our Weter cites, Postow ‘aed Phiiadeipbie, the sam THe AFAGO CONT RNTION necessary for De Layer to toian his out’, has been ob ir, the tree principles, won, reversiog the arsumy | ered The eudseription® will De immedate’y called io, Hone of slave maniere, makes frecsom Navomalent #4 and, Previvrnoe permitiing, the Axpediusa wii wal ed very eoctioonl, white every just claim of toe tiers states f » Sinvib's Boner about the 2tn lowtan’ aD the irreemuble prevomi rice of (ew For oo ® 2 & Stout Crat.. weil secured for the roogh wenger of her loog ip Phiteteiptie ie cally wie FTEPD of ace (osm! ame to ber already Kdera: qoworip tow The em crigwally set dowm ae the lowret © IDS euler ore BB Um COM BOO ED for he eating Ie of (he pobseription. nae been edtRNEM. AHO Nr. Llayen ei: onl; yet 1m tha lowem eum, 1 be an ersoutial rereame of bich ia demtradie ov 69 long | ACA FO FEPLETOUS SL ex praning: The Treare | @ Peres, fio: Rguart L Vive, No 18 Broad@ay: Gyrus 1 comattinitiom. of ths om Force. oorriet sharery wm thy tarry | ® Pind 80 61 trekimnn aH Fuld Ne fortes, and o'ts Io the devies of polatictans, that tne people of ot Water etreet; Henry & Te Gut, rook. the ferrviores, 9 the rarcie of a dehones pope | C bet member Of the COMMIIIEE. will reOH hererer lar _wrervtignty, Moy plaxt aaery ture This re | may be etl contributed, (nh money oF in wtores sot | ponerse ip Ried @ilt De CPry Berend, ard wilt atiow Pr} te reserve the 'mi'e* amount of mony wt hia command (or clker MecrmmArieR Of the exDediy stores One @rticlke most weeded sre four. tee oof. Dark (68, Paper. moinenes, DULtET, OMB. AFI. Doane and Pees one @re (rut, preearved motte and veg tables, FOrk, Were JB om sed pickle, mar, Mi@eul! fohRC cope, ined and gout, whale oF ; Dapke's, beflaio rooee, ‘ur and onl The crew wil com fet cf there wrt, they must be proviweed for three | ere of erenhebneute where either o” Manwlartared OF 464 WM) Fem Coe rt | Donen ef fuck stoner, ther will Co ae lEyOrten: service . President, thie argumeut © vow dlosed. larcon | t ihm wod.e 004 uations! undertaking os apoe the detivs Before thelr © Pn only aiterward, for, in te adernce of & Territorial go Yerdmeot, there can be po ‘positive’ iow in words w he a et eee ee mn fT 5 yt om 108 tet of Her Husband. the dear 867 tor the purpose ; ane tor bie Bioces, thee living ett te towks mong the g otir ; be ever untd the time heremafier APPLICATION FOR CHANGE OF VENUE, | 0:2 :me spe now recoiiects of Alleged Overshadowing Influence of Senera"bateees, tert are Fue sm i EF i i i I ; : i its tf i 4 t 88a7 it z Swart was ope. and that ‘ioper et Mr. end Mire. tor giv by Mr ena Mes Hogn T. of Japuery, 1867, eb wbich stuart, Mrs Mir. Burch in © © Weay friend of Mrs Fare : at ure manines day there- : Stoare if to Little Falls. She came to bie don acd desire, abe gave that afternooa Woes * Ssaccetacte | scnenbevtieus atx or ee, un aie | fens aner moo Se bereupon M ber. ‘sot bie whea se 2 ‘Scme weeks age we publabed the compluat mado by |, at Ube Bugg-etioe be moota op Gentes, Me bens Sag, PORE of an unpleaseat as- ‘Mrs. Fervem, ‘Stuart, thes toe famity | ture trevepirea between busband asd bere ectll {ansc HL Burch, tho well known baaker of Oulosgo, is the | Pty” 1g hy op ber bow. ve o'clock P. ML. at wbich time he retaracd from Ciroust Court of Cook County, IL, charging Bis wife with gested Me jam, Mre Faroe, the cefeacaat aad her visit to Caf- | the Sunday school, of whick he was the Superintendent, Aber tes ares ted prea wr nf ae returned togetber in subject of Souris beans inten the Inoteg tt < inquired, a Give our resders the anewer of Mrs Burok to the com-| O6 ‘sicish ‘The next time ehe sew Swart was ie ‘usband, | ber if she woew :bat some ladics oa toe ‘aide, two plait, im which she denice all the allegations mise by ber | wires Farvam’s parlor st the fremont House, im eh: eugpectes ilve ove mo that time, wore going to busband. The answer was Gied ia the Curcei: Court ef | in Cbicego, in the month of Feoruary, 1867. fhe | winter , Dut ber basbacd tasted aoe Qcquamtance om sccoumt of her tatumaocy Cook Couaty, Mllinoie, om Friday, the let of June. We Cefendact, ber brother, daughter, avd a young lacy | the young lady’s returning to Cdicago, aed Mrs. Burch | Stuart; et which inquiry she expressed some sar- y uJ J then pteyrg with her, weet to epead the evretag of that | very revuctaatly eubmittea thereto. A‘ter the retura of | prise, and replied im the mogative She then have divested it of i's legal techmicalities, im order that it Mir aud Mrs Farnem, and while there Stuart | the young lecy to Chicago, tn the month of Debember, saned who tbe lacie referred to were, but Be would might ap car in the form of a narrative. Upon taet og | 1658, Mr Burck contiouce Bis marko1 atwentwas to ner, | give ber po information. He thea of ber ta re- Ceeion Stuast met UvDod to the Gefeadent thai ocfore coll- | to the appoyance of his etfe, end by numerous actscx. | gerd to what bat transpired betwoen os b ragstaipat ing vpoo Mie Farnew that eveolog, be Bad been down to | binted more pertialny and elfsotion for we young lady poly ey la oy Bane My Mrs Buroh, reserving unto nerseif all benefit of excep. | ber Dovee to cal! acd bed left bwoard. The aefraieet | than or hws wife, among which was bis ny ed fected. Upon that occasion he of ber tf che had lion that may bo taken to the many errors, wacerteiatin | Fecolcer Us Shans Me py hp SF Re 2, be Reeun: tien Lien wereorsee tr onneieen cat ee ry excepting mae 0a New ‘2 every 7 ond imper‘eotios contained im the amended bit of coot- | Year's cay, belore mentioned. The Geleadant wae ac- | such maska of alleclon Tore” net as Uatfermiy | est ber such questias. as thes Hane abe wed een aA plant, makes answer Co ft as follows: — someres ‘to ber bome 0a the evenieg of ber visit to Mr. | tcewowed upom bis wile. Mrs. Burch, with her ee ea a oh late ca alt te hae ‘The udenits het he was la m toMr. Buren | °° Fervam, by ter brother, aad caughter aad tae | nurse and cbridres teft Chicago for the East oa ibe 21 4 ber, “Get up! (Bet @ Bo for youl” He ta- At A:deny, New York. om the 2518 day of Mey, 1848, aod young lady apo by no other person. aad from thaterea | of quired of her why ste received atieatioss from Chat ete 00d ber busbend bay: lived togeiber Crom baat Le Gemen otber chan bimeell; and abe told him al Be ‘ispe until the 16th cay of January, 1860, She aino 64 } wa in era sr Tarra ean EC i Moved to Chicago, where ber busband thea resides, ant shat they Dave evce sive bern and were at the wickeoss always been very courteous sad to ber, whiok as. botn inbabitants of the State of Detroit, woere she thea resiied, to tentions she never ebould beve received had hor cusbend with him she bas bad tev bat been kino to and tot eegiected her, That she was satis- 0 ae soonmtee Pr ig gee eh te tiarret Corntwg Burch, bo was bora on 867, aed bind and attentive to ber es he once was, it wes becaess see Gey 0! April, 1857. O« be had bece #0 much cagrvesed ta busiarss Tne coaver- on aan the compiaiaaat tovited Seton was thee suepcoced, and noihieg farther upoe te Fn the aefendact thas that ebe was gratified that she fed tod him of voorsi ond epcrriain Ge cha ‘cummaes ge’ on" cogegement every, thirg, a8 hed relieved er mit of tub ed 10 meet and dis; otter. 3 would be, bed the allegetlvos deca wade one we Pre eceeptance room ae cortemty as to the time or times whee, place or where, ac (be yerrom Or persone wita whom (be sau: tery therciv ol) ged 18 claimed to Dave bers committed; and obe tnsiets inet shy is entitled to Baye Before trial ©} 2°, Novgias, enc introduce the complainant aa the ce. mere particuiss epecifi my ha fon ga dy Ud sllegations | ‘egoant to ber. After meking this call, Stuart returned to epable ber to cuepre cumstances @hich (he Ceucy to enteb'ish the same She posiively and ui quivocelly dros that eha bes ever commiiied scultery © bed crimivai iviercourse with David Stuart or eh eoy other person at the city of Corcage. fo the Stet of Titaows, oF at Guilford, im the Siete of Coopexicet, of sey other piace w Of Complaint or at avy other Ume w win ber baed) other persons to. tac eptireiy ent ebsolviels fottow soon efter: Upon the arrival of Mr. Barch and ‘emily ot Sechem's Heat, bis youngest child, thea oa'y spout fourteen years of age, wae very ill, aad 62 continued for e long time after, After’ Mr. Burch bad besa at Sa cbew's about ten days or two weeks, be said ¢o bis wife that be thought the sea air di pot agree with him, Do that he woud go to Saraioga, and bom he lett bis wite while ber child wes very unwell, for that piece. Mrs. Burch has since learned, aad velieves that she will be able to prove, that be young lady mot hor te pbepd by eppototarnt at “g8 Or 0a his way thither, where they remaipes for several cays, and that whils May, 1662, apom whicd occasion the complaimant iavited bim to celi witb b m eed the defeatant upea Mra Hoa ib toe complainant ama the cefepdamt to their hoare, eC Clips with them et the com iaioast requ The 3 i) iH Ff Uy ; g i 8 visit 'to Chicago. Before the guesis oa tbat ocoasws ve (iv reply to the one which stewor ac | Were IVI, he CoMp'esant ware out a vet of toe per. | there tbe Compinivant was partioaiarty’ atteatire to bor; | Boyd that moro ne et bc ume meclioued 0 Me Burchs amnaied bit | 0&8 wbom be daien to be tevited. und the vame of | enc smong the things waich were ai that tims obseryed | to bim two days belore); “It was not mo, bat asoiher, Toe severe: | StHert ens tvclucea among them Withio & short time | s0 incioatupg the Dature of the atioations aed ihe tatim: that emtionc your wie trom the pai of virtue to that ef 0's amend: il! of complet, after the occasion last weutioned, she saw Stuart ac a | >-twees them, Mr. Burch was seen kissing her and ex! sbame and dishooor'’—and be then charged her with 1g COM mitted ROullery and b: » | «miler eotertaioment, given ber sister by friends of ber | dite other marked evisenors of foaémess. Ahout the | crimtpal cenduct, pot osly since but before their mar- “ Peete ete eg waS | buekaed and bersets, whither ebe was accompanied vy | Int cay of Seyrmnder, 1869, Mr Burch jvmed his wife ss | riage, acd sppied to ber every vile, opprobrious ana ia- ate ak ike onan her busbavd, with woom she returned bore Upon tae | “scbem’s Head ane soxompsaied ber to Chicago, by the | sulting peme be cui think of Be seserted that he had 2 bext evening after We occasion Mast meutioved tar defen | way of Albany acd Lite Fails, aj enon of whion places | the evidence ano could prove her guilt, and that there opt raw Stuart at an even party given by Mr. aad | they stopped ‘or several Gays. after Mrs. Burch’s re- | wee D0 use in denying it, and said he snould send mer to bre Fervem for the cefencent’s ester, to which an+ was | turD to Chicago, ede was euror ised that +be tid not re | Aibepy immediate'y. Sane, im the mostsoomn man: 40 ghe bar good reason to beil manciovely mace aud ox pur poke Of obtawIg, WILAU cree of C1vOrce from ber apy contained just cause therefor, « for a more Ctrcum@etsniial soswer to, and devial of the said a log tons, enc ia explepatton of the causes have faduced the compiaiaantt» make the char, the wilegetwas and Cumstences vader whiob Wey were made, she sates, Laat Mr. Burch apout the pear $a iar cad | Mme Uno Chrietmss cay im the year 1857, Stuart . i wrivng Irtiors to ber and 08 she vow beliewns was re ceiving letters from ber in repiy Aboot this time Mra Bureb was to‘ormed that ber burbeod fad proposed 10 the young lady to muke bis Rouse et Chicagy ber perms pept bome Not \oog after this time Mra Burch war ia her #itb a beok, wbich she ied upoa the parior table, bere tt romaine? for several moatne. Mr. Burch : H i of bim to expan be charges bg Praga every tims for he bim wich the mors Deatah canoe & & s b’ck, and made go onjectous In the fall of the year 1867, stuart called at Mr. Baron's house, io the i t | York, where be-was | *fterbocm, just before tea time, and Mrs Burch came | tormed thet tbe young le'y bad in Jonvery, 668, while | opty ipformetion thet she could obtain irom tim was mus clerk in « baokiag house | 9°¥8 t0 tbe parlor to see bim. requesting the young at ber bovse, me ‘ee statement to Mr. Burrill, of Chicago, | repeated at ries thet sar bed seer guilty of crimimal he Tamally of hat anete, | 'a0K8 to come down us roe as the» were renty; before | relative 10 Btusrt and Mrs Burob, aod thereapoa sno | conduct with Devid Stuart—meationiag tho time when ; u resiood as | ‘CY Come Cown Stuart eon berseif became earnestly ca as at cohanena @ few) : jauner eged im couversation relative to trivia) matter, wy janes sae ee ak eas ae fon sana hg ym ‘ich abe bad beard to regard to perecos, ana he coon guilty cand Burch sureequectly aa por to the tae of bia marriave | ‘DANSed thet abe sbouid teil what . eat whe per omere with ber, removed 10 Chicago, snd there, wita very tat | SUDtIY dechwed doing fo; abe arose to go to another "ot we ona- ed meape, ¢ugaged wD rad berealter coplioue! to treasect vert of the room for eom-taivg that ehe wished, whea 20 . ‘ead @ benking Dustuces. That soe bes. cengbt bold of ber arm aod insmed t! —~) manor emenced dill of compiaot bim = As be ht boit of ber wetted wo) wormed, epi she vow } pa eptered = room and ? cr cent ot tbat Mr. Burch, previous to bis marriage 0 youpg lady area — ber, mace repeated ead particular 1D | Stoart” bed guse ste explatued ay regard w the re: cumatanee, wre Burot, reco tects umes ie uncle, Erertus Corning, with whom she was thea resid- bg oe cad. tm rogard to the probable emouns a Se sawsnn aeeans 4 OX amd acvantage wat would acovue to coupe pbe @ terwards beard that ear 4 4 Fy lag Der, @dicd Circamsiance, toge Ber with coresion bad deem grovsiy —_s pubrequent copcuct. fully develope to ber mind lest of January or the first oN sad mf yy danger my tives aud trelogs Cresed to visit the bouse of Mr. Burch, suepictons were unfounded, ene of Bim to send for ers ae ot) ber ocle, Mr. Ooraing, ania watt uo) be came, waca Se oe eee do eee she boped ene would be able to satiety him of her inae- ees, Se to cond, dh ane of enton bs cence, He esi to ber that if ene would ackseq- Mouey, euch prov be , Gt cue of © es iat, he wena Uirely datwfactery to Wr. Borch, ane ano cid thea and | {rOreh. ene o1oe, ater hie it ene is , fur several years, by hunself and vy ees year, M = oe rag 2 in, pores ‘should dene tone wih whom be was conescted tb D Fi0Wes, extend to | Selling at the Boure unat the cea t ae pidge ey (ase Wr. Burch large suc exteosive p cuaiary aid, acoommose. | **6 trom tbe seering studied Reying ma. } count, mene “ : som ors, WOuence and crecit, by means Of whic® aud the of ot the Dovse she frequen Dene, and be iewing that they woud be fauntully forte’ of Corning to promote the interest and welfare | UVbend apa ctbers | For a ae nee re - knpt, of Mr Burch, \arge sng pabstantia Deoefite end prote | ‘° Ft Burca's Bouse 10 arte poy. hem forever a by Aacceusc to bis busioeen and she further etutes, that ame te eee Boory4 while svcd sid, a commodetions, influence aed crecit Leg A Tg =| —_ ‘ze'atmed On, no, Tom wot so that Corp: re thus exteoceo, as be desired, and while Corning was unceasicg tm bis efforts om his bebaif, Mr Barco Ureates ber and ber ‘amuy ado frieace winsiy aod wie respect; but thet about the year IAS6 @ misuncerstantiog frcee Between Mr. Bovcb anc some of the persons con Berted With Corpwg tp reference to th+ pecuniary accom MeCations thai ebould thereafier De exten ied by them, i i F f i ledge thet ane hed bese guilty ve ere rted her taccease as « reason wieng: that abe had bece guilty then sais ‘Well, then, say you Reve E | end that ‘rom time to time thereafter, otner mieunder: cape ies byt — plane Speatnaa ons sasaennteiens aor Anan wbied abe bas Lot mentoned bere, were io doptomber be bed locked ‘tha freat Gor, from ano aiverthe your 1867 That immediately afer the | 150, When he called two or three times, whee Rer bus ae fig thek sihen be rasa i emrceesane fe yur le Garea ope | XS sreabeda' toon noe ad te sects and es si ae it bebe wren WW Graing cone to te , teat ber waking), and to ereak to ber on reads and family im for preseec im bared sud woking terms; and that, as the other moon | (© New Years ony, 1860, whem in company with other Cer stane og [rom Lime to me occurred, be trrate! Ger more ULk buly abd Was MOFC Aad More harsh aad se vere to ber 1b speaking to her and of ber seaily (rien ts | “T'S! ber frepda and scquaiptances be wns at her m ber presence, wat ebe was, by bis vegiect, iil treet BeUt ane cruelly, deprives oF si! Bapytorss and dowesic | APC COROmET? formal cali a ber house, eer tbe eater Com! rt, ano Was Ofte) Airaid to exp ees 8 wed im oat ’Ethebt given by ber, abs has now Bo reco lection tere where be bad expressed @ aidereat #isd of bi O8D OF err © ome = gm money t0 defray toe ores. we Bt Cved, UAL! tbe ous O August or September, 1667, ROO Urceneary- eT pense Of her Dousedold, ering o er — once thereafter, during the tame year— Toe next cay, Toeeday, Jani Mr, Bured banded bis #ifo a paper, # vertepe he mace @ forma. Cal, abd on the evening of the eat oay oF the Dext day bat Ove thereafer, when win douse She recouects that Stuart did pot make tbe usual 1 were ( 1ipg tbe morpiog Her busbanc theo rriated waecre she bad beep anc for wbat purpye .and whom she bad seen, Ot mentioning tbe peme of Boys, by accident, aed not by Oemyn. Her busbanc theo asked her if she had oo be crus ten With Ler busbeod aad ber, a: thew i otber persou; neuber wat or erg DUD st aay me, OMe Iban the twee ve‘ore wbe that sue might ibereny cippiraae bien ao? Bricg avee SUAInGdE eas tie testona Geonen or te en eereta Mr, Burch thew & exp. anatory of ge ie earch bes rr DG+y tere Wik Ruart, ard among other reatoee that pied, * Re od pny, —— treated her, #) 6 that, cot kn vet f 10 Hat concivMoc ebe ways Coat enous this time ‘mentioned welow, Attar Mr. ~ ¥ J ae wey he Cults. band Uansterres bis prof-esionsl busiaser to 3 ‘came ‘wife's reom: tae; ane senans, clmens, Brobee nearwss on Squeast Of be.) ccs creme ined One - tresestes ise eounn, be wupneaer oes eopicred cl bien to love ter as bh ia whew cacy were | 8G Carberally no eited there wo Go ube eae, aa ta var CS a8, worn he re/unve fret warth¢, eo bee reeetved (rom bim es the sole es OFDer Ways ured DS inf ence ang portim w secure ber to read it, remarking. ‘Neo sed Bly reply to fueh appesis, “stut ap, ans | Westhen che tee. Gitere the fan of Must not auiler,” aad ee sop pour @agety break joe oF that.” Aad ta fur | (867 Mr. Stuart's family visted Cdiesgo, an) apon their A lated w come property, mgeed ther explauerice of the manuer tu which be hae trestot | STIval Wr. Derch requemed bw wife to be civ aad p> . coming what ik contained, ber, ebe reve thet soe hae often, wih bis knowledge, | Me te them, aud Mrs. Burch Uheretors invisea Mee. su Din & short Wms deen for cay® witbout one penuy Of morey tor the ori! coies outa ane re @uert Farnam im tae Dary aod vecrttary expenses of Ber Dousebol!, aad har um Upow Mon Shier * was thers at the time frequeniiy wih bie Knowledge, eva obliged im order to | MF Stuart soa Ds family. be call'd at tee bougs oF oJ Cerny Puch Cxceners, to borrow on* Ld twe dollars ats time frome youne Iady guest of her femily, whom Br oppiiet ene o vpiformiy Beit quently aeked bim tor ten or tweuty dollars ia money, end be bar given her ope bail of tne gum for which she asked, well Knowing tbat abe could not cefray the ex | MS 00 <UPet recoliecton O ibe particular times wnen penees with the som thow given her; and at the sam: tme ard mber preeence, young lacy staying in the family at bis request, | | “ohne a2 follo af pocket movey. more tban the sum cesived by her | Sbe reonbeots tbut Stuart was at bor buebaad’s nouw She says tbat Mr arch bas from tims to tine cirecte® | (Re everibe in the moth of December, 1657, or in 3 A ; é H & 8 ~4 2 8s i wtber persont, wutil the mouth o Jannery or Fi Maes 0s, cating the borioen That sue bes tre be pearly or entirely Ceasec hie vinne Cant to be remind Irs. Burch frequen is eaw enii Stoart betwres be m: mibs Of Sepember, 1867, and February, 1868, sue : i i such @ queraboe? Teuteew | sever'keve tbe» reproacted ber in the must barah and severe aw scuage for wha’ she bad doe, and represented to her that by recery Dg the attentos, so had brought reproaca sbame and GwmdoDoT Upr® dim as well as bereeir, for the reas tba: much atentioot bad beea observed hy omers, be aw bim, er the ctroumatancrs atten ving tbe rorera ter oh were ior (be mt part Casual meetings, bas givem the ber jneie® RD® BDOUIO visit oF call pom aaa to | Jenvary IHGA; that «bie there tbe servant giri im APO eru'd be commented upon to the je; ary Gad dingrace yo whom the tread vate” the orsinary civintes of ite, | nrcogh the hall to anawer toe corr bell, eropped at tbe en, Seeeeet, Set Se een one Baty come | pana . and she sexed why he desired her o aud by ROrh citectoes hae compe'ed bor, io many Cer OF the parlor, where #b» was sitiog #.t0 Stuart, for Ap ed bere. leg) occasion he turther ssi | write euch » paper, to which be replied tast be wished «te siances, to relequinh the ecquaiatnnes of persone who | “Ireetions, ae was her cus ‘oa; thar ebe tod ibe gir) | © Der that be would drive Boys from tar city, sud woul! | Keep, He thom seid to bor that he bed writien w hem ua- were trek # of herkel! kad Of Der fumily, aod bas algo by \o ray ede wes exrgaged Upon ard ay Dim ap. bir business, end meo\) med the manuer mm ‘Bie wo come to Chicago, and that she had promised to com- POCD CireC ons ODNiged Der to cMMiVAIe tbe free worp o sot, Mre. Burch inquired of ber woo It «as at ths door. be sane, te Perrone WhO Were DOL Agreeable to Ber, IM order to pro- Od Was Diormes that ems Mr Farnam Mrs Bored tov » Dut he ead ae mote abd eubserve be burmese ana cther taieresm and | “rkrd ber why rhe did pot admit tlm, addiag, © You > per Wee, aoe Led wny be yews Bhe site saps ybat the complement one st Gmer | so0w | siways eee Mr. Farnam " The servant replied made vee of the oiost grees nod Ipearting inpqange ID You told me 10 rey yoo wan emerges, and I told bim so, peaking vo ber; aoa thet he bas also ‘rom tinw tome | “2d Wat you was up staire”’ dire Burch says Gat sur taken oerasien to speak of ber taqily frieods to euch | ‘eco! ees ibe cireumetaves, for the reason that whe beran 1po ge vers terwe es be kKorw world deeply ours | “*TDE 2 j Sbe expostaieved wth by ed tO appesso his anger, plorite to be tergiten, and u fexnoa! as De bao tm: i i i 3 3 Fy £ E & i 0004 Cowd pom Ibly arne Turk 80 lperene. hie determination. viotew-e i rom & member of ber family who hed sen Mr OF 800 Low paver, ead that acd lejare ber (eclings She seye that Mr Such hes re | sDd Mra Farvam oa the pext day, thai Mr. Farosm ‘it welatlon, that ane thougut it wiser t wabat, to | never speak of it 10 any person whatever. And there peatec!y, when tary were invited to the Rouses of thew | \Jured In Conmequence of the sur eRDL’'® refurel fo admit me im bLeDeS. upon he repented bie promise over and ovor again, that Teh BOR Bod aequaictanees, ane after they had accevted | | 'D, ABO Oe merung bim s90n afer, Bhe apoingiqws t) After Ube feepe adore Mentioned. nothing farther trang | btuing whatever sboold be dene autil her uncle came. such DVitatious, thawed fox! she should ge, bet refused | Mim lberefor, eiaticg to bim that rhe foppored be was ow | pirco upon Desebdject thatdey. Ou Tharsiay, heii | She then uncerswmod that nies she did to ncoompany ber Oumwelf and left her to go ern weer | Of tow”, and that she Mow: CMriaiMiy woud Mave Reed Lew | ORY Of JaauEry, 1560. ber DusoREG prevented wiv a | srite the paper ce would at conor snd Vant OF euch Other ercort ae might Be offered her, amt te 8€ Phe Keown be was at the door, aithongh soe dit noc | Cra’t of a pte wmed be desired ber w write to Boyd. sty | ber sway, end wood pot wait until mer fetare iy ike Maoner ; sa! at other temes oF te bee He 10 Fer general Company, Gdcing, ‘ You koow, Mr toe to bom that Mr Bored was cogmineot of @! toa had | oncle abouia come. She hed bad ad slesp whatever for ecrompankd het, be bas retoroed at an carly Dour, leer Ferpem, I am alwaye glad to eee you It wer aoe Watered bevmern Royu amo Berselt, aad requestrag bim | t#emty hours, sad but very ite fore weun, and hed (Dg he? 16 WO DOME Wikowt him de fartner gays | vOHED betwr, that be bas carefully seoght te conceal Baw ervety and di | Mr Farnam omc that be potiord bie bat ano shaw! to tae tremuneut of thie crfenoant from the patie so! for thas | oA! S0eD be war atthe door Partum theo expresses) porpoee bes ofter shown Dimenlf very atient ye sn Ret Teelf pavatiod, bot Mre. Burob thonght that he fen ia fo her whem Others were pret st, AMG ill tresind apr a | Sree Mm Bis fering aod B96 FeErntt-c tne cireumsuace them that Mr stuart was thove, ant to retorm 0 her to the cace of ber brwoand arne es tnat he bad avven Sy vO'Ts Last sbe Dad wridee to him, ond (urtber Fa wg Toes Der Hasand Mad thst be, Boyd breud are ibe U0 that cay she coptad the draft of the letter, Ru gre the copy to ber busband sad goth = a soon ne Uy Were oot Of eght and Dawe an of fear (oat might wtertore with ber busrans ¢ ou | ‘og further taomeired between bim aed ber on taat | Dim Of her imvosrmor, aed relying pou her treat she ine rnbdmiitd i eknee w wie pe eee relations with Mr Fernam—ae rhe hea betore that | Cay, bryckG general remarks reproaching +her | haed’s promise that no one should evar see the paper fleck, 10 terniment aod eracky, and emaraaored to one cee eXprested 1 Der HushANT G Cimike L980 close ae in. | Of | the Dare | of thom — bevore ast he would never mention ii 10 any ono, #89 Cousemted cen! ‘tan fay Pe PDC Coult from the public ao’ her own | “mecy Detwoom themselves aud Mr ant Mra Parnscs, | Un Frivey, toe ay following, pothiog wus sald relative to | 0 Wie Sued # paper as He desired He sien placed be family ane fr ence, abe whenever it bas been conmed by | #Oe0 the complainant informed her wat oe owed Mr. t ne | fore a On) Of (Dim she bas endemvored to make sowe eatefec | fet dato tor mech money to bere any hreak wits them, Ory © Score CF BPOLOEY fOr Ol CoM@OEL And 's exotson | *8¢ Tor Chat reason be desired ber to cultivate tnetr eo Jon of every Lot and rircometamer reletive (per ae | Vanibtence The clreumtancs aforerai) made as impres qowtntapor ®iMh Doorht Mtuart, ene e@pectally in vegers to | on O® Mra Boreh's mina from te fect that Farsam ony fote Wnvirg to Pow intimate OF frien ly etatione | oad before that time bern oartionteriy astentrs he Newt DORMe Hej aint d wi od Wel to ber, ane bet trom tue to tae. PRE him, she save to Biuari we ide month o Me ane Mee MO Welker at the Tremont fou in Ont ValnADle Roo Crery preerwtt, as Lokr ee Of Dis reward and wary, 1ESB, Bt & prt; geen by | +10 ‘be kLowierge aad ame ut of her Buaband, made her rorived A pickage from Mr. Boyd, 1 wotom he replies 10 (ue sfirmatte, after toelr arrival home Irom the ore be bowed ber @ book agi ® f inst be bad roseteed from aH of é ae mn Dersett OFRO, UPOT WOICh OOrarIOn he Was IbtrOduEE! 1. her by at his part amy aoe proven aber t epreneed grvat vatinfae foevter tha ine Se tthe Conraremien . the Ort revere and AbOFive lanpiage—a0d W Aporwne Dor husberd, #bowt thet tine expressed gooat ae Gree 0 with Pas Dim tah) to Dim, “Lett go am, 1 erie ht” Woe on im makiog ber Pequeipted wD te oe of me old [Vee Borch met Sue ton thee rece Neeing joat fete we frome the inte Pobert cauart, of Detroit, abe from ynatttme | Fe'hom. woe be eatkea home wie ber, wootung her tu the complainant became ‘tesatiefed #ith Sto tie Fe e ORL TH, Ae Dereles tor man rom sepreseed 6 Der the Se vaat re Svoart aod bi famity, coeanion WHER POET rey rte, ta o vert and ebaracter were v otonat fo bm y6 that be Kerare ‘her tres be m WED RORIAl * reNOTt® naterer If Soren ek to some be Durand sien Sword was a penile set, me Were WHO nny foundation # pianetin of her acqramiance wilh UeTrt Smart «be eye, xt Vme rhe pe # recilecte Of wreting Svar was Rout tbe mooth ietroducad to him, on beard of toe payer wae Completes, ant before the bad w gue ohe spaiu fad to fot, Dow au you Maks Ine ig paper when Mb vos trae, Ama Roe Agee Np artoted Dim of ber inpoceoc:, 8rd begged ant inplered Dit KOE to compel ber to when it, Hat be stern’y iarited, aud whe eipned tt As room as be hel sigaet tng suotber pansy and said morning.” te an) ard ber angb th warned aan 7 bone on ne she parti te Abe sUPAmEd 19 LDS Ot conte, beettiog that Mr. Berch war cbt, afd she withowt remaine for pay. rowing Hk 1 wae te AaMe Ane Dad Tr and that potntng hed heen so Tove dhe aes eteping the parr be opens + to her tore, ane wr. Valeotine, (Burch's partner ta bee nese), aad Barva's coeen, Faome Bureb, #ho treme to nave been in wat if, @eikeo tn ee Buron sae them sgn tholr acme he ra, Gnd her heerant tors inem dows #nen x Ro tPA They © ult ROL Feed thom, Veeution Bile band one sat Pow thing. Wat @rhak tne Mee, mre wae eed and (yWiened Hat 89 id wo mow, S0 PAPE Must Bike har Ae ~eqolentin of any iing f sigved f', wap. fim the moreing, formed ner why be tonaeely deformed bim tost fe was mistaken: thar be Bandkerchief wet a Common ope, and tot phe dit cot Gare aoptbing bout it, #t ehich he became very reve vareete, hd ster some more reproschte’ tenguage from him the scene gute Noibiog elative - matter transpired on thet der. rch Gepied on thet cay at Mr. aot Parram's wiih her compeny. Aboet tae o' voce © Saturday #r ouch presented to bis wife the drat: o eauther letter emich he cosired her to write to Boyd, ac her Domand cestro ber te to the meaihers of the oo © et foamy, Degen te yiat Mrs, Buron’s house fre