The evening world. Newspaper, September 22, 1911, Page 3

LAWYERS SURE CONVICT WHITES REALLY KINIMEL James A. Mcintosh of New York Life Criticises Mother Who Denies Identity. ATTACKS HER ATTORNEY =f Declares He Does Not Believe Claim for $25,000 Insur- ance Will Be Pushed. Deciaring his absolute conviction that (he released convict who is now seeking to establish himself in Niles, Mich. as George -A. Kimmel! ie really that per-| @oa, James A. Molntosh, genoral counsel | for the New York Lite Insurance Com- pany, who has personally indestisatet the case, denounced to-day the man’ mother and sister and their lawyer. “I am as firmly convinced that the man ‘Who was released a few days ago from Auburn prison ts George A. Kimmel! as Tam thet you are sitting opposite me at this moment,” said Mr. McIntosh to en Evening World reporter. ‘The case, to my mind, 1s absolutely clear and I really can't belleve that the sult against this company to recover the $25,000 tn- @urance on his life will be further pressed. “When we had established ground work for the theory that the man in Auburn prison was really Kimmel, I ook personal charge of the oase and began to pile up evidence to prove his identity. The more I investigated the more I became convinced that Kim- mell's relatives were conspiring. “They are charging that this company has paid witneases to perjure themselves in this case, That is false. This com- pany has not paid out @ penny except for the purpose of defraying the neces- @ary eapenses of witnesses when they were catia wpon to leave thelr home towns. RELATES THE INC:DENT THAT CLINCHED HIS BELIEF. “The incident which absolutely elinched my belief in the identity of Kimmell occurred tn the chaplatn's of- fice of the Aubufn Penitentiary a year exo. I had sent to Niles for Mr. and Mrs. Harry Fox, Mr. Fox ts a promi- ment merchant in the Michigan town and Mrs. Fox is Kimmell'’s first cousin, I did not tell Kimmel! that they were coming, nor did I tell the chaplain who they were. “We all ant in the office and when Kiminell came tn he !mmediately threw his arms around Mra, Fox's neck and Kissed her affectionately. She returned | his kisses and her husband took his hand and shook ft heartily. Both of them calred him ‘George.’ Ktmmell @tood for several minutes with his arm | @round Mrs. Fox and then, at my sug- gestion, he Introduced them both to the chaplain, giving thelr names cor- rectly. It is not reasonable to suppose that @ decent man would have permitted his | wife to be embraced by a convict in| his presence if he was not convinced | that the convict was what he claimed to be~a first cousin of hers. “When the case was Inst tried In St Louls we produced etght witnesses! who positively Identified the convict | White as Kimmel, but the jury agreed because of the attitude of the mother and elster, I suppose. If the ense comes up acain we expect to put Kimme!l hi f upon the stand, I am sure he will be willing to testif; though I don’t think it will be neces- fary, because I cannot belleve th the ease will be pressed.” 8AYS NO PROOF WAS OFFERED OF THE CEATH OF KIMMELL, Mr. Mcintosh said that no proof of had ever been of- fered, The claim was made simply unon the ground of seven years’ disappear ance which, the common law, considered to death, While the New York Life Insurance Company re- fused to pay the pol fn favor of Mre. lett, the sister, th pany dia pay a policy for $2,000, “You see," sald Mr. McIntosh, are not only eager for t they don't like to face the re having to pay back that § they have already collected, And jet me ask just one question, If this fan't George Kimmell who ts he? does he know the intimate facts 9 Georze Kimmell's early life and how is he able to ans\ that no one | Sut George Kimmel! himself could answer?” ‘ —— TOWN IS TURNING AGAINST MAN WHO SAYS HES KIMMET.| NILPS. ; ~ Greoting many old residents of Niles by their first names and recalling Incidents of , George | * of Auburn | prison, spent another day vainly try-| ing to prove that he {9 the man he rep-| resents himself to be Hig mother again declined to acknow! edge him as her son, and a bank who took a straw yote among the ness men of the town declared t} one in five belies Public sentiment in that seems to be changing, and to-day opinion is growing that the visitor is| Andrew White, the convict tenced from New York, and not Kimme! at all The town learned to-day the by which John M. Shetland, Berdllon expert at Auburn penitentiary, who has myorn in court that scientific measure ments prove Kimmel and White ident!- cal, reached his conclusions, This was by taking photographs of hin niel and White, reducing them to ide! we and drawing a series of hort | J nes from different points in the photograph to the same p inte 1 ner, as Well as meas oe we saowe » lhedeed Mr, Shetiend's remembered | process | 4 THE EVENING WORLD, FRIDAY, SEPTEMBE yg ees R 22, 3 1917. TCI By Tenor and Engagement, Long Kept Secret TOPROTECT HONOR Flowers and Bonbons and Calle Three Times a Week With Moonlight Strolls by the Seashore, Near Rimini. “He Isn’t Naughty, but a Charming Big Boy With the Heart of a Child,” and She “Is Very, Very Happy. By Ethel Lloyd Patterson. Mme. Emma ‘Trentini ts going to marry Caruso. 8he 8 80, and she ld know. Yo: terday the most fetching and tan- talising little prima donna on the comic opera etage §=announced her engagement to to the most highly paid tenor = in natightier Caruso—it aounds like the setting for a crime. “But Monsieur Oaruso is not naughty. Nol” exclaimed Mme. ‘Trentini. {e charming, me makes the calls on me one, two, maybo three times the week. Wed- N PEKWA® Resdays and Saturdays it is. Me mein: SANDE, brings me many bonbons and flow- ©. MISHKIN ere and says kind things. Stup10% “But he ts charming! Not naughty at all when one knows him and I him. But how we have fooled you!” rippled Trentin!, and pointed a plump, square finger derisively, “We love—eh, how we have t loved—for over « year. Long time get thinner, particularly the an- ago—sixteen, eighteen months- Behold, then, I get thinner, par- ticularly ar (yes, she did). do for this Monsieur Hammer his contract. If I wish to love and to | ¥, I shall do so. Yes, I, Trentint, shall marry one, two, three, four, five| times if I lik: | “And what do you think will be the! dest way to hold Monsieur Caruso's love after you have married him asked. What would be your advice to other wives?” “Moe, Trentini, hold this Monsieur Caruso's love? almost shrieked the little prima donna. “But it Monsieur Carnso who must holt my love, Mine, do you sec? I, ‘Trentini, can get many other hus. bands. ut @ oan Monsieur Caruso get him another Tr Pah! 1X sing to him by the shore, I foar not the salt air. I Birt with him, I laugh at him, I eat his bonbons on the Wedn day evenings. In short, this Monsieur Caruso much we say to each other we marry. And this sammer, near Rimini we you call onr courting. y and Saturday evenings, moonlight by the seashore, ah! Sometimes I sing to him very low, very sweet. Caruso, never. Ke fears the salt air on the throat.” “HAPPIER THAN | HAVE EVER} BEEN,” SHE SAYS. | Mme. Trentini is thinner than last | season, but she looks well. I had en- tred the Victoria Theatre, where Mme. ‘Trentint was rehearsing, just as ashe, in the centre of the stage, poured forth one long delicious note. I could see her small body throb with it. Separated from her by the entire orchestra, I yet saw the real, warm color in her face beneath the flaming red of her hat. “Ts It love?” I asked later, when we sat together in @ box. “it is confirmed Mme. Tren- tint, trying to look sertous a mine u “It makes me 80 happy—happler T have ever been. LA ROSH love,” Syr lagogue tha |BUT LOVE DOESN'T TAKE THE “Do I fear that Monsieur Caruso raat s after I marry him? But that {9 PLACE OF BEEFSTEAK. bration ense. Who flirts if Trentint mar- you, are you happy T asked, s him? Monsieur Caruso has had nodded Madame | what you call his flirts. What do you|tini. “Why ‘To-mor say ys must be boys? Now, my ‘love, and algo charming. | calendar, wh: flance settles down, Besides, the things , Some day we si nall marry and be happy | from Creatic thay eh mare not true, He Is | all our lives, But now Ihave a Bune in. Jpwisn ¢ boy—un enfant. ee ne th art of a child, I agreed, “When one e ings that he does people do {feels an you do, st must be quite dread this separated from the object of gues to celebrite ny tranked that between the Gi c eo how he means them. But by and) Pah! It is not that,” sald Madame = por the past few days carriers! two teams were playing in Brooklyn, by we shall marry—this | Monsieur |eppentini, “It is the beefsteak I want jy. wroahing under ¢ extra with Gomminaioner poled ‘and Canimle> Naeubh and’ Evie: ‘ ’ abena,' h Cot S r 4 Commis- Caruso and myself. Then you shall now for my luncheon, {Weight of mall-sacks filled with cards| 4 “4 . | see. After some time—maybe three > New Year's greeting. City stoner Johnson “rooting against one ears—I go M | spd edith inother, 2 I go to the Metropolitan Opera | QEEICIALS AT WAR OVER t departments will work GENE House with him. We sing together— A, Pepe aia i aha The score stood seven to seven, It Caruso-Trentint-and ia the home we! SUPPOSED MURDER CASE. noreoW, “while, Je | wae ‘the ninth inning. The Polite, Des are always together. We have mucn Aika von tne | Partment was at bat, with a man on to laugh at togethe: Richmond Prosecutor Orders Sec-| bay vt ck Mona {bese and two out. ‘The two Commts- WHAT 18 A CONTRACT WHEN EMMA TRENTINI IN MILLION OBSERVE YEARSB72BECINS. vices for Two Day IN NAUGHTY | MARIETIA aT GETTING HIT MAKES DONAHUE IECINE AGAIN Jaldo S &. ave a Boron; vi BOHEME, HASHONA AS wav sew ae veto for Police Team ever Fire Aggregation. Thomas es Plan Special Ser- | « Cele- Starting Sundown force, along with a lot of other ptives whose names appeared In to- police orders, Just by Itself t wouldn't be news, y Donahue has been in and out of tive vanka so frequently that he at s? ment us Is used to moving, But there ts @ touch of sporting interest in his change this according to the Hybraic time. ich begins its tions’ Not long ago Tommy was sent to the n, Will be the first day of We hth street station to pa- year 6672, end at aundown|t t in uniform, The Polloe De- one and @ quart 1 partnent and Fire Department became w ved In a baseball controversy that Vipera ie f rei early lost their great love for CUPID COMES IN! ond Autopsy After Coroner | abstained trom| ach other. | “But your contract with Mr. Ham- Vindicates Prisoner. sare espectaily| Oh Dee ng eates forbids you to marry for! Coroner William HH. Jackson of Ric | fr the bench asa pinch hitter Now nree years more,” I reminded the ant’ mond County 1s indignant over the a V eve, T2*) tommy was once SOME ball player, muha Srialh Arsen Beale me len of Diatiets Asiarney: Albert the Orthor | ana shortly after he had wiped his bs = it Vc vho, says, ales ands o1 ous: nd faced he with Mr. Hammerstein that saya Pach who: he sa Ml Jews to{ Rade on trousers and faced th should not marry!" declared Mme, {Courteous cnough & i tang! mire Dep nts her a Ii hit wren tint "ordering a second - P : nt over first and bre n X olga the contract for the [Of Meniy Colling, tl Owing to calendar no official connection voice, for the costume, but not for | West Brisiton, ; have d vince Fa Dnine ha dua the heart, Mol What do X care for 48¥ has resultel In twa sien Nel tein 9 Tews, e Aalentamrin Mr. Kammerstein's contraote tf x, | under $00 bail on suspicion c ni : bettas ‘Trentini, desire to marry? deen implicated in m fasuonn season this Monsieur Hammer-|ing died after being carr ariel t to me: ‘You are too fat; you home by four men who said they found |‘ him lying tn th Castle:on | ¢ lavenue not for from his home on Rich 1 wn photograph was used for compari: | mond re He had an to | eon, | Kimmel ov Wht ng ins! _ Hoe arrested four men and tm terviews to-day, fro ch he] cum Ravine arrented Caue ir ; ed to retire in discomfture, Were held on Biorye RE Ene y his and the otier, two that the men hed had a Nght with Anirew J t, of Arkansas Colling and exchanged blows in whose house real Kimmel of which Colling fil. Coroner's P for move than a year, Just piluy: ejay M t the d ‘ mysterious disappearance th a : teen years age. ‘ “po conse 1 who used { nh ten notifying Jack Daniei he had no recolle P. Hunt's daug'ter, bat \d, "I femempber your v with the mother the home of a cousin, o has acknowledged ‘ehe is iving, When - nan, with arms out: | ime hee UN'S you know your voy?! JAIL FOR “PO 0R- BOX THIE; any longer, You know ohn Jaqul Sentenced for Atay er son the mother tn at, Mrs Kinimel drey a Yeor and Pined tothe f ot ‘th on | geen ‘ before ber walle those standing oy / might hay nted ten On she sald ve rest “ET don't see in you t pias) Amel tity on account | uwenty-nine « 1 but would be, the Cour red to ner, It; of £20 w A , with her own! J tol ke which she would fir cut at K'mmel's first meal at home if i he ahoul@resavince ber he is bur aoa, | visied before of @ ahinlar crim any post yew ce many nan Donahue ta back on the de- often remained at the McCrea home as | Trentini, Bride-to-Be of Caruso, Tells of Wooing \X\\\FD SARL ¥ NS MRS. MIS. HTCREA ,| Declares Her Shooting of Con- gressman Dupree’s Cousin | ‘ Was Justified { {OCCURRED IN HER HOME, Fewer Scandals if Every W. ome| an Would Do the Same Wheit | Insulted, She Asserts. | OPELOUSAS, La, Sept. 2%. — After spending a night In jatl, where she was } kept company by her ioyai husband, | who refused to leave her side, Mra. J. P. McCrea, wife of the division superin- | tendent of the Frisco Railroad, who yea | terday shot and killed Allen Gariand, | cousin of Congressman Garland Dupree of Loutstana, again asserted that the | killing was justifled, She sald the kill: ing was done to protect the honor of | her home. Mrs. McCrea ts forty years old. is @ beautiful woman and prominent soclatly in this section of the State, Her victim was twenty-three years old and connected with some of the best families in the South. Just why Mra, MoCrea shot and killed Garland tas not been told. She simply says it wi the | result of an insult and in yenalea en of the purity of the home. ihe # “Yes, 1 killea nim, ang if every woman who is insulted by a man would do the same thing there would be more virtue aud fewer scandals in this country, As any od woman would be sorry to take a human life, Z am sorry. Naturally, I regret Killing this young man. £ regret it im the rr he forced me to it. Thi was justifial how regrettable it ts, Mrs. MeCrea was placed under arrest and @ deputy Sheriff stationed at her no matter home, Later she was removed to the | parish prison, where she is held upon [ser roner’a warrant. » young man had always been rec- ovaleanyes @ quiet and unoffending cltl- zen. He tarely mixed with people, and | emained at home most of the Ume, The tragedy occurred In the western part of the city, at the home of Mra McCrea, and only @ short distance | from the home of young Garland. The | jtwo familtes were close neighbors, and | it {4 said that up to yesterday the | young man had been a frequent visitor |to the home of Mr. and Mrs. MoCrea Mr. MoCrea, on account of his work with the railroad company, ts frequently | away from home, and it 1s underatood | }that in his absence young Garland a protector for the family. Mrs, McCrea telephoned to the Gar- land residence yesterday and asked the andmother of the young man for a| spool of thread. Young Garland took It to Mrs, McCrea, who was alone in the | house. Witnesses before the Coroner's jury sald the tragedy occurred within ten minutes after the young man reached the house. Young land was ahc three times, the first shot striking him | in the back of the head, shattering the | skull and producing instant death. Ho | seems to have been sitting 4a a rocking chair, from which he fell. Hesides Mrs, McCrea and Garland the only persons about the place were two es, the cook, who was on the bac! porch, and the yard boy, who was in the, xr. MoCrea, who was in the part of the city when the sho , haw joined his wife in that he will stand by » end. The exact nature of the Insult has not been disclosed, and probably will not come out until the preliminary hearing, | for which no date has bi et. A pipe | hea from which bu the carpet, | dicated that young Garland was | s Just before he was shot. Mrs. . if her story i# borne out, acted | businoss his wife Metre with remarkable self-possession, She went imo the yard and told the yard boy what had then telephoned } toh she sat down bs af officers: \ GULDEN’S MUSTARD Makes Cold Meats Tasty, Third Ave and Overcoats. and English models not be well posted on Fall Styles till you see our stocks—so come and do it. Suits $18 to $50. The New Twincote To-morrow, Saturday Actual $18 Value $72: 98 Like Picture Just arrived and here to stay. Two coats in one, Jaunty, swagger and Lecoming to all types. Made of Double Faced Coating Broad Cape Collar Raglan Sleeves Either side worn outermost. Oxford gray on one side, phlox purple on the other, or leather brown and tan combination. Collars and cufls of inner side. Decidedly the coat of the hour and only $12.98 to-morrow. Alterations FREE SALE AT ALL THREE STORES 14 & 16 West [dth Street—New York 460 & 462 Fulton Street—Brooklyn 645-651 Broad Street—Newark, N. J. Afford 926 Mea Why All Foods Should be Free From Chemical Preservatives, Flavors and Colorings The Domestic Science Clubs, under the auspices of the National Food Magazine, will meet in congress from September 23d to October 4th at Madison Square Garden You Will Find the Premier Reasons There Wallach Bros. Cor, Latd St. 1195 Broadway, 246-248 W. 125th St, nings) Just below 29th St. (Open Evenings) The Home of Hart, Schaffner & Marx Clothes, Come and See. OME in and look at our Hart, Schaffner & Marx Fall Suits We have American both—You'll (Open Overcoats $15 to $65 some Summer Suits left—mostly big Well worth making a special trip here, find your y size at $12.50. TILL for you pa a ve may Ane fo rew , Alexander ‘ated Dressing by adting Heatessen. vinegar fl Get Wise! _ | Mere is the dandiest kind of appetizer ever set out for a feast, Get busy and fa A y Siew 10¢, Men’s Shoes et $ 5 fA great line, stylish, comfortable, \ durable, good to look at All \ sizes and widths in tan C, and black calfskin, patent leather and kidskin with competent men to fit them, Made by E. Pritchard, 331 Springot..N.¥ ' NTH StREE I IT MAKES LITTLI FERENCE WHAT YOU NEED— A WORLD “WANT” WILL GO GET IT, gj val ae 4.388 ainda om ort 290m 18 wed na