The evening world. Newspaper, March 21, 1907, Page 2

‘3 Ala hed as soon as we reached the point in: the testimony 1 could under my oath make the suggestion that proceedings be an Inquiry into the defendant's, sanity. capped at the outset by reason of the fact that the prisoner (would not eulimit to a personal examination at the hands of the allenists (retained by the State. Accordingly, they were compelled to be gulded only bots thelr: ‘observations ‘of the prisoner in court. ‘After the defense put into evidence the letters xritten by Harry Thaw, ‘given photographic copien of those letters and 1 turned them orer to DraXFitnt, McDonald and Mabon. On the, following day—Feb. 18—Dr. Flint came") me and told me that in his opinion Thaw. was suffering from an “thourable form of paranoia ‘and that be was incapable of properly confer- aring with his counsel. “OTHER DOCTORS “r) McDonald‘and Dr, was handi AGREE HE IS CRAZY. Mabon were-at-that-time undecided, but later ‘they, together with all the other alienists whom I had/retained in the meantime, agreed that Thaw was sane. They ajso united in saying that bo was a paranolac and that he knew the ndture and quality of his act and ‘knew'the act Was wrong. 3 They told me, howe’ "thom od the stand it they belleved: Thaw Ta Che affirmative. Vet the defense asked no such questions, and not until Dr. Hamilton ‘tesx the stand was I tn a position to act. "“T ysed to meet Dr. Hainilton last summer when he was , travelling on the same train with me. ‘At that time be had been retained by Black, Ol- x cot, Gruber @ Bonynge to examine this defendant, and in that capacity he gepentediy <onged me to have 1 comm! mmission in Junacy appointed, aince he = Orly that Thaw was incurably insane. At that time f djd not be- §-Thaw to -beinsene: it wns-Inter-thet changed-my-mind2 Wg Justice Fitegeraid started to mpenk Mr. Hartridge rose up. fegour Honor’—— he began. | Bang? Down came the Justice's gavel. REBUSE FOR HARTRIDGE, -" ‘qyhen 1 Watt to hear from yon in these proceedings I will call on you,” said His ‘Honor sharply. Yico \Fitagerald started all oyer. again. He sald that he held ‘Attorney's course at the outact to have been a perfectly proper and perfectly egal ‘ont, since the Inguiry ju the tria} had for ‘aqhile been directed to the Gefendant's sanity on Tune’ 28, 1906, ard not once to the present condition wer, that should the lawyers for the defense ask to be insane, they would have to “¥eur Honor,~“sald Delmys, “Mr. Jerome contends that my client is 4ncapable of conferring with me. How then is he capable of walving a). “professional ‘privilege and permitting Dr. Hamilton to testify?” "insisted that. the privilege had in effect been watved pen the put Dr. Hamilton on the stand yesterday. Fitzgerald sold he would pass on the matter ot Dr, Hamiiton’ 5 p iater. He also sald he would give the defense ample time to pre- ter_affidavits and counter evidence, yr I have made my mind up,” he added, “f will notify ‘the side which 1 have-decited-and-altow that side an opportunity to present proof that may be pertinent to the subject. LE CHANCE FOR EACH SIDE. hearing until Saturday afternoon at 2 o'clook, by! ‘shall expect the defense to have their counter affidavits feady 40 me at the office of Clerk Carroll, of this court. If, in lon, either side has failed to submit ‘the proper amount of proof in of its position, I will give them an opportunity to do so, Court desires to say that these proceedings are taking place in ‘of the Court outside of the statute. An appes! b=> been made ich the 1 As Hartridge sank baok into, his chair, Jus-/ * (From sketches made i ncou éonsclence of the Court and that appeal is being Snewered under the son law and In the interests of justice and propriety.” Fitagerald announced that on the morrow when the pal as- he would dismiss. them until Monday and continue to dismiss : trom. Beet a rcacy bat orn settled -The-hearing then adjourned. SEVEN ALIENISTS SAY HE I8°CRAZY. t-Attorney Jerome's motion for the appointment of commission ybodied the affidavits of seven allenists meee the State e hewspaper man. oe ‘of the seven alienists state that when Thaw was suffering. from a | $orsa-ot paranoia he-shot Stanford White; that-he-shoul-not-bs alicharged = trom. custody; that if he should be disoharged he wauld be dangerous tp the qjublic peace and mfoty; that {t 1s rensonably certain to believe that ho " sill pot recover; that he is not competent to confer with his lawyerw: that ~eguiies Tromt tatted stock, AbY Chat be should be detained in some insti- ‘tuttan for the care and treatment. of the, insane. ‘The seventh allenist, Dr. William Hirsh, agrecs with his etteagaes at pe states positiyely that the “form of mental discase in the paid Thaw is such that ho cannot-poatbly-recover-troui Ihe same,” The aitidavit started with that of Irvin §. Cobb, a reporter on The Bvening World, in regard to a note which Thaw sent him on Feb. 8 during ‘the pedigree of the trial. Cobb's affidavit set forth simply the facta in the: cident, without any inferences as to Thaw's sanity or insanity, Then followed in order the affidavits of Drs. Flint, Mabon, McDonald, eres Ferris, Hirsch and Diefendorf. The affidavit makes silty: ted p ‘Au he entered the court Mr. Hartridge sald to an Evehing World re- am authorized to say for Mrs. William Thaw that she had-ab- Sp aolutely x nothing to do with the calling of Dr. Hamilton to the witness stand yesterday, that she never advised it and never knew {t was to be done.” ) HARTRIDGE SEES HOPE AHEAD. i “Then, speaking for himeelf, Mr.'Hartridge sald: “I do not bellevé that "pny commission in lunacy will ever he appointed, although I am tn no way ts should such a gommisston -be formed. —Nor-ia there r Owit-convict-my cnet, as Mr. Jerome has already admitted ‘fo » reasonable doubt of Thaw’s sanity, and certainly he cannot now tell a jury that they are not entitled to have the same doubt. 1 don't wish to criticise any one connected with the case, but It was | BPparent that Mr, Gleason was the only man who showed surprise at Dr. Hamilton's-answers yesterday. I knew what Dr. Hamilton would ray it} Mr. Gleason asked him certain questions, mnt Fy Hamitton spot ton— ta an nast- one, dozen different ways. Originally he was retained by Thaw's: former coun-! —Phep-heowrent away aavhite: and whet We chime back he was in touch with the prosecution's side of tha case. Then he lined up with the defense cap -duy to tay until the matter of the appointment of a commis | tasth-tn_thetr_tehks,—thelr bankers amt YWehay been quoted aj FSH TALKS OF THE ROTTENNESS, ~ OF LOADS Will Last:Some Time— ~~ Defends Roosevelt, PHILADELPHIA, . Pa., © March. 21.—- Stuyvesant Fish. of New. York,) until prosKMnt Or” the Tilhioin Cen- tral Railroad, ‘delivered an address to- day bofore the #tidents of the Wharton Bchoo) of Finknéte of the Untverstty of Ponnaytvenia., He‘took for hie-mubject: “Fulth the Basis ‘of Minahee." Mr, Fish aid In’ fart: . ‘Tiere can bo no good final in the eretem ‘world unieds the ptople ‘have thelr seourtt ly. heya by. which tmoney \la lost; is no) reason for the people thinking: “thatthe: finanelal conditions are wrong, but merely: that these things are bound to occur from time ¢o time. : “The fict thatthe Lata, of the allroad ry > ident ae had fe more to dolWHE the ‘recent “decline In rallroad stocks jn Wall street than you or.T. 94 i “It in quite ‘trie that the! frivesttra- tion did unearth home conditions that | jeould only e characterized | by ‘the tse) | of extremely bad language That there lhave been natteh £68dtttas th railroad: ctreles Ia known tp all those who have! had tp deal with'the mannkenient of yart railroad Jateresta, The rtault of | these conditions Nas just been felt and “apparently. Such in the confidence that his law-| In tity matter,” r- | he sald, almost tear- have in tho ability of Marry K./ fully. “1 am being blamed for the Thaw to satiaty any commission in| Whole thing, when, as a matter df fact, Tunacy shat he ix rane that they will put| the rerponalbiitty really rests with Mr. him on the stand for examination and | Delmas for conceding shat Dr. Hamul- study, This step was agreed upon to-|ton could go @hoad and answer day after a conference between Thaw | questions régardiess of the ord! AOd (MIA lawyers, O'Rellly!:and Hart-| rules of cross-examination,” ridge. Thaw, in ordinary circumstances,| When tne statement waa carried to ¢onverses intelligently enough, and his colinael think he wilt be nble to prove that he |s able to consult and advise with’ his vounsel, which ja all that ts 4 a graye smile: "I aim perfectly willing to assume all) the respansibility,’* meggens oP render 0 commission wn- us Seed, com uo Cea r may ave a miguificance In view of a © e Thaw Takes It Easily. roport that the wily Delmas, knowing O'Reilly. and Peabody accompanted | Jerome meant to ask for a commission UMreS William Thaw to Thaw's cell to-}.as s00n qa Delmas had summed up for | daly! For a young man who Js never} the defense, decided to fore the issue ey found him falriy ¢ gi-]and save his oratory and therefore Ley ade an holt or mor on} jammed Dr, Hamilton tuto the trial at ow In earnest conyetsa- arenetsiets Peehelnsiprmone athe WONiec ni cee ee ‘aistired num that tn any conting- Mother of Thaw Is Pleased. She wan bound to profit by the| Mra. William Thaw, the mother of! atid evelopment. They pointed out| the -acouned, 1s maid to have becom} Phat imi any event Jerome must los | Meconciled to’ the turn affairs havo pvily in tho popular estimation by! take There !s a fixed ef that Ww will not be put on trial again fo: Will confession that tie has been axtriy~ Am With all his might to send to the Hectric chair a man whom he admits ja believed to be Insane from the be- ect Prospect of hiw: com insane Aaylur a Mew of he case ty also i maid to be aiared bY the Countess of Id It Have Been a Coup? | Yarmouth, Thay's F. She agreex] Glendon = was ‘meshed in gioom| WH) her motive: that any fate for oer Feborjereaw tim on his way tolcrminal, ee ne, : —~__—_ RY OWN wake. but for Mey COUEM, hoarsenge and sure throat re 1 “i * Meved) by awn’s Ttonehlal ‘Troches.” s sot 4 iy family Teak to be put right No opiates, So Soc and $iad i 4 the Imperturbable Delmas he sald, with | | will be felt to q greater ‘or Iosg extent until hey kre entirely corrected, “Our myotem Sot! Jocking up public money {n the nat}iral treawury and 40. taking gold or} its ,equivalent out :at |ctreulation ia & relfe of barbarism, "It haw of tate be n Very much the fration to blame, Président. Roosevelt for whut happens! an the Stodk , Bx change, put I canjasgure you that it ta not right. The legislation, ‘nat he has dictated argely) benefited The po- called Hepburn blll, J¢ constitutional, 1s In’ my) opinion, etonomboally: unsound | and tas affectéa “and will affect ud- the gone fal commercial inter- the country: more severely than od bn terewtn."” thew | yersdly | the | BLINDED.BY PARTISAN PASSION, SAYS POPE. ROME, March, 2.—The didoussion in the French Chagnber of Daputles yéater- ay of the motion of M. Jaures, the | Hoctalist leader,’ to publis\ the contenta of (he documents selzed ‘at the Papal | Nunctature in Paris at the thne of the Jexputslon from France of Mgr. Montax- j nin and the. milbdequent, adoption of | the “motion caused a painful impreaston at the Vatioan. It) is reported that | claimed, when Informed that had Seen agreed: to: ier violation of internation. ther representictlyie of | \ tie F would net have committed” It the majority werde riot blinded by: partl- J erome. at imerank Effect Now ee “Felt | rt for The rier biee-i-eertieict- ‘Husband Is Out of Town, " fanid-Her Friends Are r Unknown. Mray Zan, Goodby, forty years old, of No, UB NWpst Aixty-fourth street, was rowntd in a bathtub to-day while sut- ~|tertngsthom van epiteptic: Mra. Goodby, whose ferret John B. third ‘in. the. Bixty-fourth Street House .Mra Robert D..McKay, Periods of Thaw Trial; First— Demanding Déath Penalty, Now Moved by Pity vening World by ARTIST PERLEY. ttorney, -bitter and unrelenting, fighting for conviction; the other as he appeared yesterday, tearfully protesting agzinst-the brutality-of-sendihig m dman to the electric chair.) see leieileeiedeteieleteietelob ieee i-t One shows the Dis- Ss os ts to a Os oe tS 2 Depenamegen SEES (EES BROKER TELLS OF BEAR ‘AND IN“ MET.” Quickly Covered When the District - Attorney Failed to Respond. It developed from the testimony. of James Ro Keene's sou-tn-lnw, J. Talbot ‘Taytor, given in7Col, Willlam -N. Am- ory’a $00,060 flbel sult against President Vreeland, ofthe Metropolitan Street Railway Company, In the Supreme Court to-da; that the financier was eaoght. short. on ‘Metropolitan tmme- dintely following Amoty‘s placing of his avcountant's-enalyeie-of-the. companies’ report to the Raljroad Commisston (n the hana of the. Diatrict-Attorney- ‘John ¢.) Hertie, of No. 28 Broadway, tarexpert arceyntaht ipon whose -re- ports Amary testiNid he based nia at teck on the Metfopolitan, which let to} President Vresland’a referring to him in| the manner complained of, wan the first |. witnébs jcalled by De Lancey Nicoll, tor the defense. Hertle saht he conimenced Ala analycls at the public papers of ine Metropolitan system at Col. Amory'a requeat In 192 He bad never seen the book: of the company- denies ever Having ‘seen Taibot J. Taylor, Jacea Ko Weene's son in-law, but sdcitted writing « letter ‘cing for $002 compensation for biq ork in going over the reports of the Metropolitan, Bubsequently he received KELSEY CLAIMS FIRST SKIRMISH IN HUGHES FIGHT| = Raines! Leaves vegves Sick Bed and Forces Action for Insurance Chief. ALBANY, March £1.—Senator Ralnes, Republican leader. in the. upper house, left a sick bed to-day to, apyear in the Senate chatnbder at the hearing-of Insur- ance Superintendent Kelsey, who ts fighting Goy. Hughes to retain his office. Mr, Raines, had hot been out in. two weeks before; preceded Kelsey when with his counsel, former) Supreme Court Justica- Hatoh, former Attorney General Mayer, and former Deputy Attorney Qerrerat-Atmaworth; he predented himselt before the Benate Judiciary Committee, which 1m hearing the arguments on the chief. No-sconer—hed—the hearing —opstigt who, lives. on the fourth floor, heard gtoana Coming from below at 9 o'clock torYaryana hurried down .tol-the Geog. by Mat. The-\qpoans--werebetoming fainter wh¢h: Mrs) McKay climbed out on an extengion.In the rear of the house and r ‘the bathroom. Forcing open the ovindow, she reached the bathroom, where she-Tound irs. Goodby In the tub ‘with hér head under the water. The water wes tume on full trom-both faus i! Mrs, “Goodvy was aiuve when Mra. Mokay atagged her from the bathroom andvalthed her op “nar bed. | She died, ‘ore the arrival of @ phyal- ‘he ahs o had only recently moved 2. Gia Bouse ca hee, fellow-ten- ta pig Buy 0 her friends, nor her Wane business address. Hie left town One| business “Wrip_saverdt_ days —$—.—_—_ | Scared’ Half .a Dozen Women by His Barking—-and Show H -Went-on. ro, the almost human seal, walked to. the. footitghta of the. Hippodrome Biage thls: afternoon, Ucked his “chope, Mtted fits silken bod: lege.) ang’ with a pluyful bark dove into the: audience, Herr Bohmit's bald pate was aticking out pt the ofchestra like an jeland and Nero wtruck # with a splash, The dig- nifed Horr tmmodiately blew a discord and “collapeell and the surprised Nero ynel toward the feet of half a dozen women and children who worm SMbbux if the first row, Fanlbine screams and the apne, of che latest hued in hostery followed. pirigntened."; cried Capt, Derk h eeal never bites, + 9t4 up on Ais rear) {tian the tall Senator * from " Ontario, pale and showing signs of having of Passed through a sivere iliness, pro-| same tested that the committee had not the autnorty to follow out ‘its programme of putting Kelewy on the witness ptend ‘and allow him to. be cross-examined, nor the right to swear witnesses and take documentary eyvidénce. He asked that the oa mittee go into]. executive session “determine its powers in Seca ‘This Hiove waa atrenyously opposed by Senator Arm- strong. who $# leading the forcea -be- hind Gov. Hvshet—— He -sala-the com- mittee had sufficient barra to swear witreapes- and ‘take eviden. ve motion for ki ekeciitive saarion of the committee to determine the com mittec’a Fights was pasood. by a Sola fio 3 inman, MoCarren, Page, Raines and Bmith—s! ‘ohalan, Armstrong and Tay! [restore The Kelsey men regarded this vote faa-e-victory, for the for ther | BRITISH H STEAMER “HITS FLOATING MINE| 7. HAKODATE, Japan, :March_21—The | Britian steamer Fernley,’from Tacoma, Feb, 10, for Taku, hai beon beached near here after having: sustained ex- ing her carga before proc NICARAGUANS DEFEAT. | JOINT ARMY: OF 5,000. PARIS, Mareh 2—The following des- patoh was received today by the Nio- Nera almply” rolled over and piaytully jaraguan Legation from Senor Gomer. the Minjater of Forelgn ‘Affairs of Nie- Teo thousand Hordurans haye b gi fo the ce Continued. The Fin atage | | ing Powder. san-pagaton,"* | sweet pure & wholesome. cI fented Portiflor de Namasiq est Cake Is made with Royal Bak- Alwayslight, for U mount. S eeanicol’ was‘ vory insistent ‘on get- ting Hertle to Geclare that of the three reports he made ndt one was even out of his posséisign. | Asked to explain by what process he arrived the atatement, that the ty ae ounten telah ed “Incranta ‘rls 4 020,000, Locks the reported. bab “met” Had Big Deficit. He ‘said. that tnd eleven, elaven company’s COURT AIDS PLAN TO ROUT PICKPOCKETS MRS, WORRALL Judge Contirms Decision that They Can Be Santenced for Dis- z is Conduct: Se “The contention of Me Toantoct City Magistrates that men knowg to. be pickpockéts’ can be Om street a cars and committed ; > sone even (Mongh tin de / ao. direct Hence contesting t ® specific theft, was cupljehl tora Announces It by Adver- udgo Komilaky) siting Jn an a tisement--Husband Well |(n7s 0 ee tet or Mate Known on the Exchange, An advertisement published In a morn- ing newspaper to-day ‘announces that Amelia _R. Worrall waa_grahted_yester- Gay an interlocutory decree in her suit for: abaoliite divorce from Richard. P: Worrall. of the New York Stock Ex- change. The advertisement states fur- ther that the hearings were held before a referee and the papers, were scaled. Mra. Worrall inserted the advertise- ment. | Her object In a matter of con- Blderable apeculation, although it ts paid in the social circles inv which she WOVER” (ial ae Might have wished to keep ter husband froin contracting an- other martiage before news of the di- vorce should become public. Richard P. Worrdil ts a well-known Stock, Exchange broker and senior part- ner in the firm of Worrall & Jotinson, No. 3% Broad atreet. Me ta sald to be Cohen at tel Megistrate, We in. Jefferson M Court. sen! to! months on Teeth withor interfere with husband's, mansion at No, 135 East Fit- ty-seventh. aireet. The ‘service of the —papere inthe divorce sult upon Mir, SVorrall was spec- tacular. Process servers had been un- able to find iilm outalde of businces hours or to guin access to his office. One of them feceed past the doorkeeper he. Stock E ge, rushed out on floor. and the papera into Mr. Worrall's hands Just as he was jn, theymidstro€ gibi trading, traneac- jon. detection. serted by a Patented process at reas rates. with a contract to Resptinecnliaizepaliclensrean’ ew YORK PAINLESS DENTAL CO. (NC) ESTABLISHED 17 YEARS, ————__. WOMAN SEEKS DEATH. Mrs. Boberts Found Unconactona by Son With Gas Turned On, Mra.-Ellen_Roberts..of No.4 Hamitton et, the police of the Madison Street Biation locked herself’ In her room ina fiat on the thin’ floor of the butiding lastnight, closed the windows, shut the transom and “then_turned—on Fas ardp hi bee fiber jeri! een, 418, ¥74, 000 etc Bac Th ae me pony? C4 rs ate. bes aed for any other purpose,’ Putateered. Talhot J. Taylor. w ness suinioned “Pte broker. with 0! street, Col. mala = tes wae oy Besehiset arity 0 land's legal fotces, took Tay fo tin ha risa dapper-ap | lor Tin hand. | 76: ot middle-age, Very cari that ligne brown. sprita S Se tnarbedty Ene hort of Detropolitan. took ere You i the. dier d= at the cm Seaen Oia T he eras une zo ahort ‘on—Metro- about 2,500 vont 308 were yow-short your- Pa your: other customers?” 6.0m. altogether.:* Senate resolution to oust’ the insurance | tH ¥ “whew T heard” thé" D1 wouldn't back up ~Col. ta je wanted ‘to know If ine i Keune haa instigated | a heer! Faia: letropo! in. Taylor repile vers port tively. in thé newative: Mr. ‘Taylor Was. Amused. “Did you'make any money on Metro: ten, 2" bat shoul may not, he replied with a Amory, wad Hot @ good int savieer ie ald “the ‘witness, stilt highly Burr,’ broker, and James wr SOannfoghatn a broker, closed, the sare ae, dlesalecal of the complaint ie on the freon that+no libel, heer GALE: $ S ITALY, - VESSELS ARE -WRE ECKED ROME, March 2.-A violent hurri- cane, which has cased serious damage, swept over Italy, Several vessels reported to Haye been’ wricked. Association Prectt-a-triend soe ae aged f ae (Dear tise) of rbd teria oe Ka Panpeiast Feb gienp egeeciated with rae ee ath the next wits’ - ‘and Norton’s| || the gas from two Jets in.phe room.. Her son Themaa found the woman un- conscious, aad) Patrolman Parnson tele- {phoned for Anambulance. Dr. Burchell, ospital, found she Js not. ex- motive Is Coffee Sale park &Tiford 18407 Teas ‘of equal worth can- not be bought outside of | Park & Tilford's Stores at | | 28c te $1.50 if Mall and Telephone Orders Filled. ¢ soft taste found Inno other 23 Ita, 100° mill TEA™ 50c Best Mocha and des ava. \ “Sold elsewhere from 40c to coffee, Our reputation of 67 years is back of it. nglish Breakfast, or Cey- Jon, Elsewhere 60c. Single Vounds: DelvgreL WIe Coftes COFFEE. 45c., guaranteed tobethe tine:t SAMPLE SENT ON REQUEST. Gili es Company } fea} Arablan Mochaandrichest (Gls Java, Hasthatexquis. 3 Ibe, (bean or around) dellvered) Maa! wlym and Meena: 10 ibe. a mult 233, 235, 237 and 239 Washington St. Bet. Park place & Barclay St. Estab, 1840, in rheumation and are ‘conclymion tt Ary ere found great rell iat atk esti hi roptical So ie one-half. pare Our Price with fitness: Piane-C; Oat ‘eae Compounds (for complicated cases), ya ARE. NOW AS POPULAR “a ‘AS. XMAS > PRESENTS. YW The ‘most valuable and» sensible gift Is A DIAMOND It-Inereases in value. It’ makes you LOOK PROSPEROUS, and it Is ‘ap everlasting REMEMBRANCE of the GIVER. We have but one price. CashorCredit No employer's reference required, | > Send for Illustrated Catalogue 22. e 2 j UNITED. “AMERICAN OPTiCtAls, pene ‘ PIANOS [LW SWEET CO.| aul shi0 SALOSANTOL HELP. WANTED—FEMAL. INDRIESE wanted to Arsiat with, shane herwork. Ho with reference [2 Sth av. Brooklyn. z , “LAUNDRY WANTS—FEMALE. iMvantucd eumatism|-;: OUND MIX LLINGLA, me OF "ARCHIE ~~ Bxperienced shirt marcher ~ ’ ST Med cA ply AGeIbn team Vaunary, aie 237 De Kalb ay.. Mrook) (o The Business enterprises old’ through Sunday World Want; are}, ugually “Bargains? In every sense, ;