The evening world. Newspaper, February 5, 1907, Page 3

- Marvellous ja Love of Harry Thaw for His Young Wife ZHE EVENING WoRLD, 7U ESDAY> FEBRUARY 5, 19C : 3 Most Remarkable Feature of Tragedy Unfolded at His Trial ‘ + Audience Felt a Thrill When Lawyer Gleason in Latter Half of Address to Jury Told of Prisoner's ‘ Master Passion. By Nixola Greeley-Smith, T-took Assistant-Distriet-Atlarney eg he dimebag! heat ea na sm eannetantan fra ae a ee bs fate Rela eth Garvan exactly seven. minut to'state the case-of the prosecution -at the trial of! Harry Thaw for the Killing of Stanford White. It-was a simple, direct, bald state. ment, of facts brought out at the Coroner's inquest, Indeed, the open: «ing scene of the greatest day of-the trial seemed merely a Coroner's “quest, with>more—auditors—and—a more imposing: setting. Lawrence White, the son-of-the victim, -a-fire: man, a policeman, an engineer of the-Madison- Square Root and-sev, eral spectators testified to the man- ner of the killing on, the night of June 25.5 Their stories, taken all together, 4old of course nothing new, revealed but a single fact not contained in the circumstantial_newspaper counts of the tragedy the-day-after it occurred.e ;> appearance of Stanford White's son, a z ‘There ercatintor st n-the ; fresh-cheeked Harvard sophomore, faultlessly dressed, who gaye his testi ———nomy-fn-an-impasstve mannersiné-a-tull, coundent,_plensing_andsilghtly English voice. ‘This yout! nd iiluslons may be s nly-col ars Sara Ge THE freshest amt mozt-anspotiec ae appearalin_the.court-rcom, face the un ps9 far from WIXOLA GRELLLY-aTA person-that Looking at him-and see Sar —thip—withthe—lead_man_who bad wa ae {eon represents to-dsiy, 1 wor page than that whereon the peda very! rent his | MU Anes: ot | tauford White was written, T hoped so; andteven-Harry-Fha™ whose. fixed guze-suftened t6.pity at sight! of his victini’s son, must have hoped so, THINKS GARVAN ERRED. uk had referred touchingly to th nday before his death with his wife seven minutes’ uh Mr. Garvan in } fact that Stanford White ani family at on this fact. reader of n bare smiled in Ly Seven minutes ope filled entirely with the te: White-as-he-sat-at-a-t of June arrest, long imprisonnient atid (Mie present trial. ‘Phere-were smal -eoo- mony. The greatest contradiction, however, waa ddressing 1s confessediy a y one else In court, must of Uie Jury he ¥ e@ like ev d the procecution’s case, Two hours presented tt ae tradicions in thelr te fu_the pronunciation of the n. ire Champig sho, judged by the various renderings of her na by the engineer, firemen and policeman, must have been a lady of intinite varlety and several aliases. : mot MIR. GLEASON Mr. Gle SOPENING., son, of counse! for the defense, took possibly one hour and B half-to open the case tor Harry Thaw. He spoke-nt the beginning (o> yhostli 1 Soprowniweiare js sald to hay scorded scant courtesy | c.triviopenrd— and there were many At net—ansicus to-think particularly well of “his speech. “The first { lave pieised Mr. Gieason’s worst enem)+ but ir my opinipn the latter portion would have gratified his best friends. Hia Gea ¢ testa: beritéd psychoputhic temperament in whict nity was Induced by brooding and sorrow—was long and labored, [ Uiain fo i “giass of-water Urged by a dark veert ron rapectators: “Rede Hike he-dei witowhen-he-get-te-the-real-story-and-briefly,-une <Uvely_ told ts iu his casc—the wonderfu efiGus «Jove of Harry Ky Thaw for the litt) So A CW NGe Gemini “Stanford Whiie Was killed—the Jaten in ell of rs wae fired by the truth and, simplicity of hb ~en-antic: an scn Of id the-thbalds pat and mes(-ef ae His Com. thrill t words. fetakable stamp of kin-! nd home. It seemed to me a mistake to dwell) mony of men who toht how Harry Thaw killed + jn Madison Square Roo Garden on the nigit > , and then raising his revolver nildalr walked slowly toward ~ of the piece produced that night, *Made-1 4 We. f i pleasos, that the x is proper, operation was decided upon. Meantime she began to take;; NEW STUDY OF EVELYN THAW. JEROME TANGLES uP FIRST ‘INSANITY oa Sketched Especially for The Evening W orld by C. ALLAN GILBERT. SINS Heston Tere ho: was insane athe statutes of have Suat dire: e meaning of[ In iteelf to which 1] Miri Odo ‘A. OW On crogs-exaint witness defined (delusion rowhat you WhO nan Wrong prvi clusion may be all right, but Up may he wrone a-sOWAU On eX, As to. Delusions. Wee you re “ty rene Tieie he Romierg test?! (Do you “Uyin tha, man 9 } ; helfeve in Jt are pdicere andhoreat me Mics ( : > Hove qnany ty Pawo yor. Exe 9 1 think they x o Whethor they, ‘were, repeal are , ; r stein?” ACO, Ypres Kh Dae ree + t ott wrong, conclusionn fr 1 falee premiies? | ALT Know croohing About It tn GQ 1 tnd "Women Who Were: Chit ih tyro Ft tie Ges hyy One nal otto tpt vestie” didad aad } on Woiat ahd y A, Yor i sort erprerttibtest? 1 thought. th nelusions, did you? AL Appar 2 D Teommittine $00 ip depriving them. vy had, reacted | pos! i oD mi nevi eather, Hert ye T_Wtn't commit. Strey—reached— at Den: xa m erroneous and wion e| many after t ited. Yes, from) omy knowl ivy non wh (| O. And stor deter: “whether they!” ff: : \ ; i : them” Somp ,men might con He defendant tit th jould be relensed ftom confinement. oF, } Y E : : R 5 st them right. Ry. noth ss 3 eamarily. | ‘ y \ A 2 F : re nlor ia} nd them Rane you-were net ee ~ them In a lunatio naviuin? AL No, air, z oO. i * were Insane frenees of that'nt “tee n you were examining Mientere ty deteemine wen rf Ay . sane. wasn't Ite fnine-| oxpert-um-ta_whetier Ne waa wah P NEUC EA eR BLYe ESR UH in AO, back to. Ahly. cone Ie all you had inown about Y cane, thattAcL dont We wan what lus appor? c Mey pouty the oucurrannestomethoen ‘ioment ago? A.T + x La eel h don't know sal did. Pou} f-0% fhe “atand hiave” tea I pplied eved Taery = “hint sald ~~ sane eat son wert is Tig only other Tacks em Inthe hypothetical queation-wa you have addict bad “us Taclig : [in the sumemr of at night In Letrectoetet att btaanosraer? Q opinion that Thaw tafterward is reached (ie accurrence an. the [night of th hoof June Us row with : ' tor-orma: motorman in A Pitts: Big aste sian In yoursopinion? AL{RUTK, street-cur a year before, iy It? Yew Niet Tents tis charac-|..Q. Now, did vou reach the conclusion (Co EO REET HEALS j that thix defendant wax suffering under IG AST Chin Niwa ee eat ne deluston? A, Itght after the idently trying to tangte tae | ; ae = me in (hen hypothettes Tangling an Expert. EAD COLD "5 Baty ing Dro Wylie . are milan ow ¢ jealiny aera : fs cfanntine withthe | fae a TIS sthergit Cea nad heel the i tsente abe Tal form tn opinion “as a he r o 1 Baud, -igaret tee Ul wordia wHie ruining tiiy WHO Viet by wlenincs, are yaw motto a peatorscLarae. tuoc toe. Trt : ae RA TRIACKUHAUAVETYNOGY, symploms of path- |e eae 00., 1047 Broadway, Taha face’ ad by. Se y_ sa of un- | sound mind = Q.—he-vou_consiler that aman who! In inflamed by th sion of aout and slays anot 1 consider ar) Tore STAN e TAS Not necessary se butttmey by an Insane delustor Miss-Coulbourn, of Bast Market, Dorchester Coit aty, “Mar yland,o « ry) Ou pat? G youy p = i wv ‘ : eSuaicees - Gil penlizninernectii leauclanawarstahall had what was supposed to be a large tumor caused by Kidney © { Nell J [not be cr enOnALVe Tiana Se ane ORY trouble. After a consultation of several physicians an ce Wi have aright tu-squallty + . ins aN weve auieeeenenauiees and was cured by ao ard How many times have you nerved | ax an expert?” A. A number of times; 3 {i could not may Re neutraxtor Gunes? A. ADO @ raep Ah MAP To herved an an ACTUAL HOTTIE OF Tine WoNtts CENTEST ICIDNIY CUitE SENT Add - sever eyes e trial, Gest In-j B Pr 0 THE NEW YORK WORLD WHO S an oxpertiin the Nut tri Bene BRAM HInS Pores AONER OR BLOOD Disease. Did 1 ou_that? A, You askea a Sho. writes of this” wonderful cure: “T | thought that it~ ah you ie what cus 0 at Te was my duty—to Tet Q. Did T ask you what the charge ¥ aie know what your wonderful Safe Cure has Was’ A; No: Steere ‘ done for me. as there may be somebody Q. Why do you, yolunteer that? A. e eufforing ax I Thad a tumor, and:my 1 Tieause’ Tothought. the question re Heck eek: doctor told me that 1 would have to-go ta |” : 4: . Cambridge Morpltal_to. be operated. 5 Se ha anata Mure Me-a permilt to Ihe hospital at Cane : : : bridge. The doctor examined me, and he - est 5 53 Bg] said tt_waw too dangerous a place to tack! ntine Expert, will p i feet in the warm © n of th I uid» ry your answ not tothe Injection walt until the Inst of October, and he would ror Bo} 9 oeslerevelanegmaltors Sout t seanee : xend to Baltimore after the doctors to come 3 tlona?. Will_you endeavor to do down and assist him about cutting ALT think T have. : tumor out. It was about 6 Q. You do not then conslder that the : ntvervadannerearartecss jeraing ian = A killing of a man. becaure of jealousy : 3 - “Q. Do you consider that Kill “ TEC TRIG tt uman being for neg ruin and before I tad ured that bottle the tumc: ne~of ‘ was nearly..gune, and 1 got another bottl = BE EE aa a : é Cate ein The tert of Auguxt tate witieut : ; red-when the 1st of AUgUat CATS : : wets ant “Ba iE un : g Leing operated on. If you wish to use my Mr. Gleason, desplt® bis white hafr and 2 markedly fzappeed manner what-b-hove-feh-frony-the-besinning—that-the- mes: iirkable fatre ofthe ease he statea~was not the waurder. of Stanfort ssianteie Tar Ty Tse, illionare spend nade aihere opening” plea far his ite; stoi DID MURDER FOR LOVE. ~ Wheto Mr, Glearon told -the-jury that Harry Thaw-from:h{s ‘first-meet— {ng with Evelyn Nesolt bad joved ber-with as pure a love us any one o them, orcany other wan, might feel fer tac woman he sought to make hj wife, he told the truth, but only the emallest fraction of the truth, Eact min may “kt! the thing he joves,"”-but-very-few mep-kill for it: Harry-Thaw-dld. a Vory-ten-meh- in Harry. Thaw's position would have: married Evelyn Nesbit, ‘Thaw amarried her—married her, despite her refusal of him on reasons. connected with Stanford White, which she {sto tell us herself, ac. cording. to. Mr. Gleason's promise, and then brooded over her story ti)!" ~ ho was persuaded that to kill White would be an act of Providence and not wrong. Ta The avernge man does not buy with his Iite's devotion what a tiara and an automobile may purchase. He docs not meet a girl with no money | {, 4 no protecting guardians, expose almost from babyhood to ravening wolves | ayd ask her to be his wite and face family displeasure and possible disin-| * heritance, Moreover, if the avernge man‘ dld this, would he do more, when a brouding sense of her wrong came to him, than to upbrald ner with then: and then go out and get drunk? Harry Thaw probably did both these things, But he did- more, He- may have done wrong. Ills jury will tecide that. A woman's code of} ethien in tragedies*tnyolying love’ ts apt to bo peculnir, And I confess, my own eusceptibliities In the Thaw court-room ‘have been the best argu-; went aginst women jurles ever presented to me, But there ls not In history or romance, in ill love's happy idyls or Ils) sembre crimes, x story of greater feeling, of more enduring single-hearted devotion of one man to one woman than that of Harry Thaw to Fyelyn| \\ ébit, Abelard and Heloise, Aucassin and Nicolette, Tristan and Iseult,! § : / Fawcelot and Guinevere, Fxola and Francesca-—one may sound the gamut of omotion, inrpired from Eye to Evelyn, and find none greater tuan that ~< ylelded by the ordinury, dissipated, foolish boy oc triai for his lfs before H —Ndge Fitzgerald, to the™ big-eyed, wan-cheeked girl-inodel who could only He say to him when he killed the man who had wronged her; “Oh, Marry, Jook at the, fx you are inl") - non = Hit excinded as aw witness from-the-court-room > you nov know. tt your ‘expe! e % name -you are pertectly welcome todo. so~ ~) anity orn: defendant —tiinK inthe world, quest fh sclentitic expert, having t Tam know! Cambridge and in Dof- based upon t Wyncil ¢al -quesiion of your oplnton bi or seven times In bh + chester and teveral other countics. I reside (Continued from Second Prege.) put to you, and the frets you wholly and e meagre Unat alousy Is a common mo- 5 near Cabin Creek. Tone Onay = hare —stated—¥ dave obss has ficts th J here in ve for killing? A, Yea . ‘: . Fast Market. Re reference to unsoundness of | t and sh thoes) Gi Would: the mere palitee: of-a-man xk Does your. iback Lin what. direction proot of hereditary | mind. wi cal protession | {ac Observed in Pitts! who belleved hik wife ha: been wronke¢ Feta to ‘pass your» = ingant is" important Al “Hereditary | deems Thaantty: 4 Of VEC, day, ee Y * much Irritation ‘Are HS nervous? Do Trent tov tte “medica! mind, “impiier} Qe in rout vhen_ he kit y — i Fate 4 isnot oan rau za Mlacleei-ay Dias irwin wndeat the functions of use cal aapect at Yeh cimition:by-Mn- Gleason: MAY BE COFFEE : za saad ere bets nt once nnd. WHue prevent eee —— rT eBITe AR Sot ath WEE yy “ ST Sie zi M aaak arrow Ollie tions aad tatal-remltad =. -— Tara TEETH B mil ert —opinien the -dafondunt Ee the _Trontics fuer SATS Cure Ty Ia pleasant #BG MHL set-your-xiaieye-and welt ve tary ins rH G = 4 tus act knew EE AMES atone Wife Are yours Myriads have bn itary “insanity, “would |. ‘nd Yailr a eines ene When the house Is aire, Its tike Freee-ouce. right nea a eH Wee : ate “Sure eas Psy e! Oba tv be Sel a : > "i {dney an adder troubles, fer 33 ce SAN a Cee the neon aae Sa REIT DORAENED m3 Fine ee Insanity; a-body_when-disease begins to show; 1 Mf ma, ot ide necliversand: Mood ete a Telatives-who-irace: their Grevent {rom=which defendants connect ont The tess —hnadt started —io—qualify it'a no time to talk but time to act— hess ofrizhts Minnane all alee cal ir a en Me, Jerome. on {delay 18° dangerous—remove ¢tie CURES HIDNEY DISEASE. — 4 common ancestor of the defendant— jis hypothetical question, A, ¥ RNa Ory : ot ea ai = world You regard that as an impor any pAb AMAR lon took up point | cause of the trouble at one When the xidh the uric acid We mot Gar aoe Sails causes Gout factor-in-arrivin deolsion on the bs » qualification, and after i Luma, the feints _Khoymatiam of the les, Rheumatism of the Se Rtlater lintel = 1s-a- Modest Expert, waa al)! “For a number of years," anys a jj, is Queation-of insanity <A. I would eacMe B that emaremtent now? Teansaa lady, “l-telesure tint. coffee tte PALEY ten constipated and the Hyer torpid:— Wartterw — = what w on eo unbTe 7 ; : coffee tn: Briehtr Discare tie i, und no ii atter-etfect ix experienc Medical, Not Legal, Expert, { 9: And you as a clenting man. NA was wrond ‘ani be unable #99 | ag hurling me, and yet, T wha #0 Sate Mille auickty felleve the contin, wad no tll ten eAeck Wy experignce | 9. 1 ask you: to wtate, aa an Las not nit myself an’ ex = Amat cen Pater Theht peaatiae dm=/ fond of geet ea not a ett a J idireat, 1D $1.00. A BOTTLE. Refuse substitutes containing harmful drugs whether In the case of so-called’ -Q. Do you think you a expert on, Mpulae to do that wi! le paltered with my appetite and of a hereditary influence, -experia require oF |) Hy ?—AL-Tbelieve T-nua-fili ty cpm Q What you are trying to Kot at. T To convince every sufferer froin diseases of the * base ithelrsolpnion upon. the fact rof| petent-ta Jude mun fi hy enn Te tay diay thut Mun may know) course-ylelded tothe temptation to TRIAL BOTS LE CER Bees iver. badder aad blood tie sere meee thy —well the nature and quality drink more At Inat Igo Tisinity; Among relallVes Of Mis alleged Qo Then you ado nor mink -vou-nre an ett Ho bad pare CULE will cure tiem, @ Uial bottle will be s ABSOLUTELY FREE, postnaid, insane person, ort? A. believe. L ha had of bin act—that {js wrong and against 0 at. AnY-one who will wr EICS BATH CURE-CO: Rochester N.Y. and-mentton— Br. Jevome=-Thatte objected --to—as Helene experieren=to testify ag same eae £0 ai auouulty oe Lie ommupity \that T made up my mind’ L must saving seen "this liberal otter inthe New York World. The Renultencse of thle offer In without the Isau sreditary Influences | pert, nd that It js forbidden. by tww—and) Ctther quit-the use of-coffee- or-dle,~yuny: gaaranterd = Orrdoctors -wilt-aiee-vend-medtcal—bookiet-cantaluing ~deserl ptions-cf- have nothing to do with this case, Q. You belleve you are a man Yet bo swept away by an emottonal tn erything I ate distressed me, frpaane and treatuwent of each” dtsea: and many convincing testimonials tr jo eve The Court—I sustain the op, thoroughly competent to give an opinion Pulww which leayeshim-no control of! ang J.suffered severely almost all, the Mr. Gleason—We except, You muy ex-| {n° ense of ‘thin seriousness da Aan vin will At might be an Irrealetible | time with palpltatlon-of the heart. 1] amine (to Mr. Jerome), expert? A. Yer. fimpulac, independent of the will-and} The ‘crofs-examinauon began with| : } cal eatlyawokaniptinvthe ule Crith 3 RE * anith | Q. Now, we don't know whether you based on a delusion frequently up ao eee ae ee io cola ere: | ara: or not an: expert Ara yout” A. 1. Q. What evidences of delusion werw/ the feeling that I was almost gone— : nd-direct lines tn hereditary Insantiy- ¢| think Tam. I do notilike to make Ghat there in-‘tay hypothetical question Ini oy heart seemed so. wmothered anil the operation of the lawavof, this Biate| Kind of a'declar If,air I tile caso on which you based ri | Hd GLa tee he operation of the laws of this Suite] think It is too egotiatical Yor any mai ous an oplifon aa you have rendered?| Weak In {ts action eared It val xround of insanity? A. 1 am not. to state. Ao It was based on what L saw this would stop beating. My breath grew eae i ES Q As you ait. there: you would not] Q. Well, have you «reat knowledge: man do in tle wirect c totily dis-|short and the least exertion eet me a assume, then, In « case ax serious on the subject? A. Ihave not—sir. 1 “interested party, 1 did not know the this, where you are nimply testifying as | have knowledge eaual to tho’e who con- man to=panting,. “I< @lept" but) lttle and A sclentific man, vou would not assume | skier themmelvas experts, Q: Was that in the hypothetical ques: red from rheumatism, to speak as bene familiar with the{ Q. Haye you knowledge equal to that 4) MM HoniiionernattEseconat Two years ago I stopped using form of the statute on Insanity as pre- | which the profession aswumes in an ox pur abewer to defondan dob scribed by the laws of thin State as Ulo| pert? A. Tbelleve Lave expert knowl | cohn aie Soak, SUewGY to pds@ondanca’ ene old kind of coffee and began to maidens, laughing maid- ens, ‘heroic — Le defense tn homicide cases, A. Not on} edge. tirely upot the h use Postum Food Coffee, cnd from the legal end of It. - 1Q. Do the profemsion-wenerally con birt bse ideas y DISS D cers cmminn | ve Gnu ee ea PAPE thtieebs bu_the very Ast Deran t0 improve at all are pictured by Giby [Tone ‘niven’ Rere Upon the aswumed | thm 40 ~— i! We ytedon ny tha Worked a miract Aan e% : cantina thetest of” il} facta atuted to you and facts which | | Q, Well, do you agree with that ovin- ninlon Ww ) anything —and—digest—t—_without— on : ari you observed aoe tty your, opinion | ion of the profession? A. T have never sie : trouble, I aleep like a baby, and my “s here waa based entirely upon what ‘ct: | duwpited it ! UME ad Colt at Ave supplements now ‘being; ea na ara ra tlontasnaldertemobe pace ee Then’ you do belleve youreett an lecopinionstrom, th Mit heart beats full, strong: and easily. ; selves, an a part of the medical sci Cee . Genemilly, yes. | done, and) thea, after on My breathing has become steady and ence, Insanity? A, Not entirely. On my Do an consider that you are an | from the Court ta the withers to. pie : er qi 2} i ormal, and my rhejwnatism has left | Own’ obreevation “of ‘the’ acts ‘and. my Soe aap ruaataecees ee een ortorital Be tsa Rte feel ke another person, and | eof the Insane : ombodtes y hypothetical question, | Me. ; OM are a hare told ua yan dld| -Q. As an expert In mental and nervous Mie Gietson Asked over again amd ft is.all due to quitting. coffee and ¢ ise you are willing to give you oF ) i" ons o G v a “ of eo nol deratand the In ot mot ppinion as Bosh NA ead CCRC de fend into it also th tons of the KW! using Postum Food Coffee, for 1 given by the Sunda er oath, we othe forms ' 4 LT eect ae Javrasre iply) from: the simple observations you have leek tn tite aaron haven't’ used any medicine and none i rT 1. am mtifying # of the teat A to toa Hoe Fite dere ndant, inal es. ‘The msgs +s palaine: could. | would have done any good as long as is 4 fon. the street car in. the summ: as an expert, give his. opinion as. ta ot 3 nO" But Ceo NOL Know the’ partious| 1905, and the fasts embodled ind Thaw's condition when he killed Wiftts,| | kept drugging with coffee” Namo | ‘i World form of Insanity as defined by the | ants question. that on the nix based on the facts Included in the ques:| Blyen by Postum Co., Battle Creek, A Jawa @¢ our State 4x an excuse for ths sith day of dunes MHL, when he Killed WOM ate that opinion, A. pelieve| MICH: | Dhore’s a reason,” Read the ‘anford White, he Was insay} pinion, ALT believe a 7 Is goram}eaton; OLA crime, du your. Ay it} Bantord wy he AST vat RANT WARainaene: ttle book, "The Road to Wellville, prawn by Charlee Dana a + Gopaglent, Wo, Re ‘o Wiheretore, your ‘opinion as to the! Q. par see ja the moat immaterig Q. And ja it your opinion, air, that|in pkgs. All grocers. ny if $ = a 7 Pf og sme