The New York Herald Newspaper, May 8, 1857, Page 3

| ao ~_ iain Tint NEW YORK HERALD, FRIDAY, MAY 8, 1867.~TRIPLR SHEET. ——— that this was an adjourned court~ | eah other? A. | ead before that ] did not think ar % ; , on 8 hen wo | himself bo callnl upon % epesk 0 any % tho on, 9 A, Y looked at ber alesely, Dut did not ob- ‘ai contended Sera fen. . Mey were hoor yes, sane sev-Hinainer, rae i thin: The And Joh seathemes, WA gp aly db aay & - a+ jedgmant 0 .@ Toews ot you say, came from the parson ‘adhered to tte dediston, and 9 recess was | Q. Weru they not bowtie? A. Ab times they wore, and a ae ont al a erin anon dt en Ses be awigned to the dofendam, ip write oo oe te coat 3 you do ak Wey come taken enti! twe ocock. ' ha oc oye eer, babe just read 10 you {‘oumsol oad cinchision of ex. 4 and wiib bie own wiInesoos—whes dei he ony in your bear, | might yrorecate HK for hime, ab as ma Or At, i rom Dr. Burdol? A. Tdo OW Wom they came fram Dr. | wpopnmony oF SENSAMIN Y, MAGUIAE. acne Beene ool tadgment 0° PPward Prarpont | ivack}) ero, gentlemen, there. wo a many whe conad | ing? He obipcied to the Watimany ami ran, “This 8 | Doe nos Bee te nary taal i prefer & ee dais ali pepeng: >. 1. ‘ager te rocees tho District Attorney called Bonjomin | Think | heard Mr. Plerpomt speak of tives 9°? oe ee ee ee rah | part of tho Tacos of the defen to Dut ce ‘do We our | ob fabe charge @talart tik defen wi ay 90 for, the whesbor bo waked aibeed thers eter bia wounds yon ¥, Maguire, who tertifed an followe-— Wels ton tes eee cee Wo, sir. | evidence of the defence, if] am oh ¥ ‘There | chiens i be bok by H; and yot when wo at | purpore of ridof ber. Bhe, ut once fee enc knew? A. No, sir; the spots appeared to be of the @. You are ® dentist by profession, i boticve, sir) A. aiean Swern Harvey pang was coreen, J. Sie howe Some reer, Twill not ag he gl tg says “tei, . me ode pied women SO ee ile * ame charactor. c w Harvey? A. Maver the partionlare, vo tha’ to the e'¢kdence ta riadlose, delence, p proba! ‘on = hesasion, ‘ser @ In reference to these woinds having been iniiiclod | Yea, sir. glance whatever; I nover bad an bour’a gonvorsation With | sConnsol again reverred vo tho same tictuu,) Now, goa | +00 rexpect ar contideration. » fe told you th 4h intocont woman do oes? id, amma pad Q. Did you know Dr, Bardell? A. Vos, cir. my Hemen, I ave quoted thosa ret of la +, oot thas {wap | preparations wore malo for that morder by my, elenky thet have outatacion, Dr. Binds Demived to wade HA ‘ax bis intended wife; \t was known smoug their ma- i | f uw i E i 7) f E dispected tho wound? Doctor did nob have blow was etruck a3 ¥ : ts F re ' wo blow. 8 @ And that when he put out bis band: he could nos havo berm erping ay obec ‘A, Toanpot say that to could mat havo grarping apy object. @ It would not Dag papa 4 ed sweali have been near? A. As 1 aald before, it war Bay when bo held hia band np, judging frou the cirou- _ The Gourt—Tho general appearance? A. Yes, sir, * _@ You think that there must have been a atruggin with | @e who did this murder, and that the murderor ‘ hale raceived personal violence y would depend rem ee eee, the Decaer's bolas a? A. Fos, Yi that a man of his physical strength weit as ae rseaoet A. {think 80. @ BW he did takto hold of aperson? A. Ho woukt havo Given violence. By a Juror—With regard’ to those scattering drops of ‘hood, you saki there was one on the teaf of tho table? A. ‘There was several Hite drops of bleod. f .cedegetelyoeeaghd ‘A Saror—Did mregzic ‘Tho Court—There Gall your next Tho District swhech I will Br. Burdell, Say de sumer ber di teas har amity —to ry : ©, and to Feat ‘Ge house No. 31 Bond etreet at $400 a year rent. ‘The Court—What is the date of tt? Mr. Ea}—Thero is no date to it, sir; we will dx the date wy Another subject. Ie Mr. MoGuire in Court?” [No ‘enewer. a witness by whom I havo but thres or testimony will be very short. exception of Mr. MoGuire wo iH gF xfale i Hi ef lf if " i g i g Ee f Hi in FE lf in eR ia : { 2 8 Fe ‘Who opens the case on the part of the de- . Cui Af the Court please, we wi ws that this prosesution bo Tf the Court please, before argument 16 made tobeheard. aA ‘The Court—It is a most onosual ding. Mr. will state, before my feat, the law Figen he where two defendants are indicted togothor, présecntion having concluded, a motion may be made, ‘md the Conrt may instruct the jury then and there, st tho termination of tho direct evidence for the prosecution, that ‘tm the judgment of the Court no care has been out Freooeent, tho pany euay be put upon tho y'tnces sland, it upon the witness 4 ena mado a wiunecs of. "But where. UT rest—the jury must pass upon it. Tho lo- testimony, or they may go to motion of ; it E 5 E F Hi sir, under the fms ig okber a @ Did you ever #00 Dr. Burdel) write? A. Very onan, } yt, sro7U,m gol terms with Wadham? A. T always | jose thore was say Tent Doparmity for it, bus because the J HRI no’ mordor was ever moro defiberately pl al dim. ~m a iho fare Deen, and since the death of e Awe @ You are then acquainted with hie handwriting? A. ‘ iarvty ave enshen ® |, Coarinet Ravied the power, 9a Teey secu Ree cae a ily your thal the defendana re. | waa sequatotance, nb she waa loncod . the cago as they havo ip similar cases, it had »| Yoo, stv. Q. What other relattves did Op, Burdel have in this leave thea. q owt red Hannah to go to bad early tho night in questi. | Mrs. Harvey Burdetl. beup wb hed ye E! Fin'yon dove tho gontoen 10 ak at shone papers | i? ,A. 140% Kuow” bat Yay had any adore oxoept | pyyet ih but we prefor that ot sours should Boake, | ABO Here the yet met wehin tho sraridwrearad | thc fer we omierae sm amd en th mentioned abd ¥ g- My . : nto evidence inthe chain of damaing qui would | was ’ , and vee if any of them are iw bis handwriting; and ifso, | <Q. Thubis iho husband of Mire fenaiem, who has been | Stes os Te pele ne ae manne Mess werer conan Dofore, aWhing fikets v9 oocur | and rhe did invoke the aid of the jaw in Der pe which, or if any of thor have bis handwriting apon them? | ® Witnem? A. No, alr, but 4 Draiher of coal Mr. Dennivon; | Gare for this reason. Wo with not yng , @ardol | every Dight when this servant wad in sho hoes. 1 don’t | Very soon after rhe prefervet awnlt against bon (or sane reaps are ioe Gnceanense whieh ory retanen eae | Soh husband and BS Brow" ey ure boi cousins of Dr. Bur: | should bewcquitied, but that cho showml ba Kyo cba ih wan chown that del not oooure Sho cays it | der, and one fur breach of promise w marry, in wbieb be apn) A Bonet wf Noy 1 inp band writing; ~ oie oe one Now with your kind permicncion, V will take the ‘of | oply occurred that night; and yot Ma y Donoho, when tt = ee) pac eerie ad Pecos fog han | nature of No. . band i to prove s i Ai c 0 g a ink the #iz . wast net pas in Mrs, Denninan living separate aod | eailing your attention to some of ike statements ta the Dis- | ts Deoensary to prove somothing crimmab which oconrrod focgo, Mie te name tall 9 the Msye enocel @ evitence}; Non. 4.and 5 are not tp ‘bh handwriting; Nord | SPart from her? A. Two nde know. y's opening, whieh he not aaly faed tagprovo, | a few days dafore, says shat Mra, Bardell roquested ber trict in bis handwriting; Nos. 7,8. 9, }0 and 1) are in his Q. You know Bim , thus den’ mow where ho lives? A. | hut cit not aitempt vo 1 Hanna to go to ded a wodk before this, and 8 prove, witch statomonts were the | aD: » ; nd but for @ subsequent matier, stone of his case,” Had ho prowed everything | tbat that waa tho only tima when ane ag aR EIR ae bay fs another Riteriine, You, or. oe (ir, Busiolph then prodaoad a pistol fram tha Judge's | @ 0 you know; whore Airs, Dennison Svos? A. Ithink | ash herald be wok, a vary insulllelemwasgol circanm- | quert WAS iade—ono wHtnes oantra , lan have rendered a verdict af jee in 810 drawer.) she bvev in Brow ‘stati ROD ahd mada or upon such a point ay thai, ffere ? a. Wore Zon ever present when Dy, Burdell purchased Ctnee. e paler Dr, Bardelt ‘and wan tm the habit | gid ce eae ie fpr ns on 7 tie circumstance: He iz mt thera was I bare Crap or groin ml revit of Dolor ‘8 pinto! . Twos, A. She said he was, rian, that itr, Bh i rable, | that door—a mynter Abo Hike of whiet prosecute there 4 yh pe Dy ‘ 2. In respect to the nn Purchased, how ja that? pon ed I 4 rd ‘fio relations hetwoom Der and Dr. nen, os hctiacal oe = Deag . ay he — he | made since pees created tho workd de Baraat ‘* nom geae sens Dare. ee ver " meh abowing him the pistol.) A. That by exaotly Wen it fe 4 ‘Doh, sly to do it, bat ‘J i ; time—dhat my client hiel would have » Eaey oy Ghbateg 4, Hom Sane 24 nee bo parshased PA, Hl Wi Des fod om tbe a7ck patna of Mtr, Foor, she hus Tee serial Mie abing ging vena ag fm er ay ater ag, Rhs bal nore thare of Iii property ws Hi iis wt bom 0, Tome eiween fonr and five yeara ago, ‘band «1 js Hoban? A. not, called was tbat venorabm umn, Dr. Francis. é tink in Guat amour es | suite wens as gp Seay P oa te p : ls . 4 3 m, Dr. ny pat 4 x twhich hoe had dora, He then agresd io and did Q. Did you afterwards 600 Kim his ponsosston? A. 1 | Oo ua kus w whore ha was at the ting of the bons ‘cowmtenanco Samed at bosomven of the Loe ae ened han ite wore discontinued, it being exprons Devo? Jaunary? A. domed; Thave not nee } wich imciiigence—a man of very high stand! fishows you bow # may be ke! wart her Te avon themeelver, thal. wilia & carta aia, Q. At 81 Bond airoet? A. Tsaw it quite often in his pos: | BD as yer, 3s you how in this omamuntiy—and erect pashing agéinat the door will open it; session In Bond street, aud saw bim fire at a mark in the Gy ‘Wear spar profecsion? A, Tam 9 dentist, oot "hay te hig cea oo yon who ‘amesed bee ah Me ieman, 8 tho District Attorney dase noraber of days (some six oF ton) Kae on ee pi country with it eA Del yout arn your profession with Dr. Bardel par. | these wounds had’ yom deat of anatomical Snowpoige. | Min “bonoraby” aga inst whom wothilng oan be sald-—tella | ried. | the sul or ts at a tere aetaiet whowd $0 SP tue tana Sean ate mene Ran tigt neh Bret comenemen to sinty I commenced | You heart tho Wietmony of ir. Ubl, another witwenn for | yom that a cinare wirc, in, Bis SAE eet places it | baits. Now. sentemen, Tack yo whether ¢har itm of Harvey Burdoll, and was velit dim fora year BGd @ | thy proresutiony tekd ba twit joo—t think ha cant-echat it | Olent to open ttafter it had bew ow Unad che perpetrated the marder?” Gan- Q Where did ha parohavo a pistol? &. To Chaiham t cary Koy would not | procf goes te street, afew doors from the corner of the first binwk. dalf; in! nj have na deen with Bina. wos a AAS thing, & go. WiMcult that tho me is Q Which sido nt Chatham atrect “AL a tho Wf Rand Q'Do7F know Alvab BlniteN” A. To. | cura a Sea tama Mnomlak wo Sues AMT | open its rey when altered,” & peuikl’a would open | pct you pndorsiad het luring 4a claret fm year or aida golag up. |. Do'fon know him well? -A, Not vory wel J P th 4 thee oe P st blow. it open; and yot the manu y parties may hay io a do ging wp. Y That will be weered by asitno for tbe deforms, Well, | it; you eetid almost, Blow it, Sheas Mis Ye sey great | anything serious in regard to theta — with bin; about'a ‘year ago waa the fmt time T | contiomen, (Rit ends UM part of the I ARarney ' “ Eager Ho mechs told you thet hs hae OF thw" awardeced | allectige for ityan 4 think Wt to de a very superior a Beer snok "abr ume ‘tite. ertous Mm AulNg ‘Bh.c9 the homickte ava you boen froquent in your | nan was whut npda a> floor of his woo Ryda assas | me in fis connection chow out @ sagest wl the ‘as there any mark om tha dy which yom | eemven fnew i? A, No, nothing exeops on pen pt i whl ‘war’ it. { Ch Q. Did you notiee et the: time what kind “of a look ef Visit'to 31 Bond sarcet, dud paid great attention to this sin; that Dowdy “Wress Hot f DaPNon h | not the District Attorney examine the py of partios Sts ? A. 1 donot remember, J eare? A. Lwax thava nearty every day during the Oore | py. Tell, Tak cant eke Dashoem in witch | tho fad tho keys to that house? Why wai not thoeo om hy eh gc ae. 0. Did you notiee who the wiaker wast/ A. did no, P Bor’ ins ortigation, from #lYah ho dedued an inforonca of gH against my | Premises oxamicedyand why was not ecrutiny directed to | heart Wiha, ents it was natural for atthe pereon who sokt hima the pital toid him it waa . Before that you hol Kept away from your dousin? | cient, AWrai in bisproof upon that poms? fia witnessea, | them. ‘There were other partion who had keys to that view on ae Mg apt ecin ion bn ages ove of tho best. / A. "Ves, Fir, Dre. Mawrand Ubi, isl yon that this body remained there | hoaso. Tdon’t wish to tast annessseary wuspicion he co een Fr ae ho woukl invoke th paticietion, which bo subse “Q. For how many momiha prior to that time have your | ag it habdealways, ‘hers was no evidenoe, #9 show that it | sxyboly; but there sera ocher parties. He has Ca "fect beep in tho Bouse sf Dr, Budell? A. Ym April was the | had been disturbed at all. Amether elvenmetance which | even to call them as witnesses upon tho otand. The ry Q. You dons snow whether it was O89 sor someberty 8. aaportant to bo | Obes, A. It sas not Colt’, ' Q. How did you come to de wita Wim whon he beughs! } Fat time I was there provinus to tho murder, ‘ the ey clothed ¥ timony waa before the Geroner, and if it is ms : thet pictol? A. He invited mo to ge wth bin, YQ. How fur wad you roviled trom it? A. Thad resided | rhevepte was talsz dle nard. that Yar duneneane Ge | proven here it will ba, thet goo two or Uareo persons hat | point Warwo or throe altercaitons ip the | ours nf» Year oF ou were with him in bust seseas thes time? A, Noy ta Union equare, vorrior of Fourteenth sutet. pears the next day with a Yer cape on, by | aeys w that houne. Ydon't choose to tention their names | two. Mary Donoho — rh ayn thas. thaso "| Q, When bare insyeen Demis Hubbardcr Nemia Voors? | Whioh ha cought to hilo lew neck’ but’ that | ki present. Why was it chat no sttontion was directed to | cho trad been there about » week | le Tie’ ie, “pip, Wore you amocisted with ttm in any way? @. No A. lsaw hor here yesterday, in Oours; when she went} shecrld riot eo hido it aste prowert a boing dis. | s2y one cle? Was it becawee tho official, whose namo } patties Ol ean ery onl toid bor that t waa ip rela- out of the dvr, | row her pass. covered ugion it corresponting with the mark upon the 8 become a byo-werd of reproach, know mot how to con dell caino out of the room and tol that te cay barga the ig own ¢ man} w ‘ami } Althis time they were aucried, . on to iicybard, Now if thas be true Q Issheheronow? A. I don't know, newt of Uae decensed—a mark whie& Phe Di«wict Attorney an inquest? Wa it Deo sn the wane eer ee we) ‘An to the character of Aro you 8 blood relative wrpr. Bardell? A. Fos, sir, ; fl ha J Q She ia-reviding in the city, isshometi A. Tthinksbeis. | sna! had Been given in the deatta gripe. “Yon recoliget, | time or attention, ho thwght a Jort state what relat @ . His mothor andmy mo- thor were sisters, Q How troqueky have you eam "hor during tho lust | fyatememscho rhetorks wht w ro een ae aie Ge” wees Ie tetore ee , 1 boon sincoyou-wers | three mow?” A. {may have seen Mer threo ines; per- | Fa a Udet, gentlemen whas letee prentenar incre | cease further inquiry in. any her di Doral Hubbard, perhape you have beard euough arady. in hie honse? 2 Poem Iesench April test, haps net more them twice. fo ached his Witvers, Pr, Maia, Dit saa observ: . | Let tho presecntion answor. Another aociasatie pst You have heard that she was ay 9 Proves pa Q. East A. Yor, wir, Q. Where have you soon her? A,“T saw bor once 909 | ding bert her neck,” gointing’¥e this particular cir Tho District Attorwey says nt stolo the key of Yr, | mistress of her own bie meet oy ee Q. On business? A. Tc ddoththara on bisinens. or 910 Wreatwoy , at Mra, Beulen’s, #mpce, “Wy. Main eald, “No, there was tothing.” ur. | Bi seal y atid upon that bio socks } let ue prove it, but if allowed wa coubl prove We, Q. Wero you on frien: ty or unfaiendly terms withihim? | Q You wentthero? A. 1 did, ther Uw that, gentiomen, bo 'tdlis:-yeu that it was aosid | to prodica With roference to this, 1} from tho papers of Tir. Burdell, coat ne poms Le A Wo wordnm on frie aity worm e Vaid om ace bite eeen | a, When bed you laet been there before? A. Idon't | gay-caiet a.fur cane was a wry dowabio artiche of cloth | &aY, Keath nis ower cuored by mortal | divorce frean her iwwfo) busbamd, paid ube 4 Yeallod; 1 thonght aft wares that Tbad beter havo the | tink hatbeen thero befura; Uttwmic not, iogesViatday. Trero wasmefhing woonual in the iwiy's | maa more ‘abe in fect Woon that, T do not insinuate that | ond afterwards kept ber a8 bie, oam Resets Oo Q That-ya since the homickie? “A. Sine tho homieke. || Grew,@nd a0 tho wext mam Ciremmeaten cea ‘ct | the District JAttorney dit not boliewe wh @ Were zsa precont when ehy-waa oxamined ata wR | Qrgmae hip eiensant Again, the Deetice Aueacy saya, | fact wever weal so, He says it wae found Near poss befors tho Coroner? A. Twas. ‘ OPhie wooman—this fend—tes weman tlend-—told tho do’ | TLat key wos found in an upper atte, among a b was Ler maklep name, Her married seme was Vourst, Q. I with you wor@ea mtodo, vir, the reletives: that Dr. Q. You favo attonded here during this entire Uisl, | masttes imthe hover to liston to tha uRoreations between bor | pets, Where it had been thrown probably by Br. # b 7 sho bocame divorced # er ye A. Burdel) had “in thisserty-at tha time of his death ? @, Se | Dave pornos? A. I was subpetand. and Bectos Harvey Burdoll.” They Aidli-toa, fle told you, | himeelf, hohaving het it, Ataltevents, thore ky not one | namo. Gentlemen, cannes you understand why a oma vera}. @ Wimi was the cause of Mh ditfioulty betwoen yom | nydwne words of loathing-were moh that tboy shrank back | particle of provf, not any well Gunde olen showing | tight feel indignant et the \lee of having » Blow) cous Q. Just name team? A, Ho bad e ‘half sistor—-Mrs, Se A. Weil, he spoke rathor ‘owas | abated; a bosutiful semtence—beautiful: language. it | uF pretending to show ons the prisoner at the bar over | © ome back to ber ‘busband’e ows, hve Ngee ep a friend of mine, Mi eh . . \ . had possession of that key. . Burdoll lott his key; | Foo! nav0c! daughtare, @ Tero was ® 1 focting —that ie all T want toqgot | G2, One Se eee Dut | whether te lost up there or whers be lost it dan: not so” | ine bis Kopt miatres? ¢ ould you blaine » woman if be fap hn you or yay aonb A. Yos, sit. |. yom raat no such facta existed. Away goos, then, this | pear, andthe District ARorney youl inalanete that with ramen Fag orp tiphonsnp tryed oh oH ovd-exatmined by Mr. Hat. ‘mw canstancc. 4 sir, | bis Kost key the safe of Dr. Burde!] wo. oponod and ransack 1 ere to live come » aleboug Obs quertion—she day en'whieb you purchased that | Sip’ eamstanon. Another, endone Of Ae a foniant war, | ed bytiis defendant;and yet, gentlemcn, ws though tuero | she came often there to visit Dr. Burdell, (an you bamne Kitiehcees Os day oF aay, ime, 089 7a use it at Dr. Bor- | tied ‘eho abernded ‘wervel’ upon Dr. Thompson, rawts | were & Providence In al thes things, it eypears by tho | her that abo ished thie woman But» to come there afer Nae A. V did. 1 is r ‘enli tectisnony of the prorocution hat even time, when | cho discovered a IR lade a lie aah catia! So Tuer cto up hor bantes against De. Burdeil | isallegod tho particular paper abovt which you lave | Burdell Teey proved. yo ot tne Sontecesan aa yer-tied myself. 3 on hered Dr. Thomxwen testify t, and so | Heard so much was missing, anotber key bad Deen got. | evide bard. K F ee hog ° of Ju ie ; Dr. | Demis Hubbard did ot come back—that the defendant c comes mark? A) Shooting at a candle. far Trova that, he 1@i5 you that exactly the omtrary was | it was obtained upon tho 28th of Juno, which key Dr. far tareen ate mg Prost = lerparatyzod. Burde® always thoreafter bat in his poosession down to Nov hei to take The District Attorney here announved that his direct te might prove the character of thie Demin Hubbard, That business done by an r @erpey ated went out, Q. Did yon ap Jewrons htypation about "that tine? A, You, about that timo, owen, igen Wat i the manve of her husbaad? A. George D. Q. Where did thoy re ide at the taref hin demh ? They resided in "Thireys.ixth street. re Boyett oth © retatves had he? A. A brother, Lawia Q. Whero 4 he redo? A. In Brondway. ¢ In what yumber? A. Ido not remember. } No. 910 ,is it nor? A. T think ao, Q. Was th g brother deranged? a. He Q. What @ you mean by that? A. caro of bir olf. Q Don’t bo govent sometimes? A. Re~ies out, but not often. Q. Did] somistinbbard or Mrs. Veewset. scrthere? A. Ibdelieve’ be dit'toard with Miss Granent; tho siter-in- law of Le wig Burdoll, Q Int pesamo sourr? A. You, Wh e@ was Pemis Hubbard or Voorst? ~ A. 1 think her crim—that Dr, Baréell applied'to hiro in the matter—that n = ye trdefl cali: 4 tho timo of hir-death, ‘Tho papors were lovtin Beptomber, | mast havo been satisfied in regard wo tbat point, 60 far a@ Simemy was through. va andl umid thet he hint nothing to do in | tho ene OF Ie vow Kee eiel suppiiod the ck a: % | Demis Hubbard coming tw ive under ber roof.” Again, & the mvotter, that ‘facre was no reason why ho should bo y: . . pants bl Gragg ed aot. Boctor Thempsan thon waid he had no- | Was a8 enrly as tho 2th of Juno. Mr. Horring told yoa | conversation at the fant table ia trumped up. iia THE CASK FOR THE DEFENCE. thine “to'do shh il, end eo next day wroto a noto | that that lost key, after tho 2&b of June, would not open | said that Eokel—as innocent and harmless mab a to {pat eect, AncAher circumstance put by. the | the safeatall. ‘Then what becomes of this circumstance? | ever appeared in buman form—made the remari, “ enaeen rar tec be Disti bot Attorney with dramatic power, was thi. | “But,” says tho gentleman, “we will prove to you that Jingo, T would like w be there when he waantrong up, if @pcning Speech of"Bir. Clinton on ohe Peat | 1 wi snot say of bim,eshorald of my'cliont, that he bad the | there wana mysterious smell of burnt garments in the | did not bave w pail too hard at the cord.” Now, of Mrs.“Cunningham. dra patie, ‘That eiroutaxtance was that Mr. Thompson | prewises there,” intending to insinuate, no doubt, that | the girls are mistaken. The facts aro than:—A few pighte hey .rd the defendant ask Pr. Burdeli upon tho Friday pre- | Wecever perpetrated that murder burnt up his bloody ae ty thie Dr. Buriell came home very late, Ho ‘Mr. Cinton then reso,erid profound silopee, and "Pre- | oo" Moy tho homicides ina very famniviar manner, “when | Clothes that night in the honso, HM iad his pars key but could not get in; wan, porbape, at Baise Wm fornieriy Hubbard. @ Ww aho Yolated to Dr. Berdel? Aho was his | eocded to address the jury in behalf of the defendant)ia | he would retun,” and thutthue sbe know the oxacbhour of | who eapzrienced an unpleasant se the time when the tock was no © open BO ono cousin. || bo following language»— DS g retwm, so that sho- might plan hia death, Ho tells you | Smeiiag burnt woollen op that evens could get in except with difficulty. Ho the hall with Q. Be ownrticod cousin, was sho not? - A; fhe was, t at she saki¢o-bimyin a very affectionato way, “Harvey, | Iwill not take up your time in reference to that. violence apd woke up Hannah. She axeked Mr. Yoodgrase @ ¥ fas shoe married of a single woman? A, Bho had | OXNTuanc ov Ta Jowr—Although not attageiber "NCC | y ihere arc you going?” of “when aro you going tore. | ebuugh to say that otbers who hat quile as good or Holter | te Ge ‘and let him in, Young rans did no Deen? parried. vexstomed to addressing a Jury in capital oases, Pave | { orn?” justinthe same manner that one would address | ohportun'ty rmelt nething of the k: Mr. Ullman, when | of Jandpess to Haavah and the Doctor, He want down Q. } do yourkenow, slr, whether or non divorce had beom «never riven to addres a jury undor circumstances’ tke | another dsavingtho house. There, gentlemen, are tho vo bo went into the house, smelt nothing of the vort,andthore | and let him in, and the Doctor immedi oly began to abuso Progu ged ny hor her husband, throng) tho instra- » Joading cironmstanees upon whicb the District Attorney | 1 D0 preof or anything to suspect Uaet b poor Snodgrass abd raid to bim, “Twill knodk your Yraias in, ent Bey wd ok ho expense of Dr. Burda? A. 1 do not, (Mw? Dow surroawding this case. I havo never before |” Lis ven to canvictithis woman: of the crime of murder. aro very deiicient.. You know very wall 1 Tw. cach your head in, God damn you. Why w thiadoor prosesnition « s i from fc on ed in t nse night, we Hod? od 4 rather qurprived at che ‘tieen to address a jery where the mn hed 80} His owm testimony taker se Bees dp ion all en burned in i ey, it for a tay | of Dr. Burdell; instead of thanking him for isting him 4 igcented the whole house not only *or a nigt nat ber. 1 ouly | or two afterwards. Xe! rmething of Uo kind) existed there, | Dr. Burdeil treated Snodgrass very rudely on this oocwe matee, who lived | elon, and yet Bnodxracy Dever rovemted it, so fur am I come Mickeriug | leard. Rothe remarks were probably ma‘io in regard % wod that | (hisattable, The language ved by Burdeli wo ‘oodgraw of guilt, |b age the very best criterion of tho faot fs reats Wero guiirely meaningless. You « go tat the Doctor intended to. kw at ee ee ‘or soparcte from hime - 1. believ woro both stopping- at’ Dr. Bardeli’s thew be in Bona etrset, g €) Io lastdeauary? A. J do netanow whet timo. « & Don’t you know tho fact thet hey-havo not tived to.” " er for more than a year? A. I never-knew abort the ¢ peer een Claw ees , Rurtell’s scrap book, since bis mth. Q, Wher dit you last see the husband cf Mrs, Demig Babbart? Mr. Hall, the Mstrict Attorney, sald -be-eould not see the 1 @levanoy of (his testimony. Jotge “e8-—-] suppose we cannot try this divorce qnee- Connsl for tho nocurad—T has been urged that a me- closed their evidence, end we ail felt mot only thet tho | Mo, ciroumstancee-whish he alle lot against ber Prosecution bad utterly failod to point even tho iogor of fowl bin hayes bore fae savage uack oe as But, gays tho gentleman, Boctor P. well grounded suspigicn towards tho prisoner at tho bar, |) Upon thir unprotected and defenesiess womyn? There ison- | acFass the way, discovered aboot that tito ‘but where the proseoudon bad proved not onty-that the \y one jrineipto upon which Toan uaderstand t You heard es bens ooh bot FB oy or Lage Bsa mney om % ire, tho of feels I. ent " lufere opening of the District Atorney was unjust end-ungouo- Tr rete teeween the diferent muembors of tee Bardell | KONE) as he supposes, 10 show thas coon wore rous, but where the progecution had proven'boyend perad- famiy. You heard-enough from bim to draw tho jafe- | burned in tho promisoa that night, Now it {3 @ | not venture that as dhe eese stood it was tho bounden duty of | rence thet Br. Bordoll was generally on bad terms with hix | Carou® colncitenco that two gantiemey, lust evening, | ib ress? Drains when he said #0, la bora guy the jury at onoe tomequit the defendant, Tho-District At family—quarrelied and made up with thom by turns, but | (sad I Lope my friend Mr. Oliver will not blame me for | parses you do rot bear parues aay, in reiere® 9 1) v4 “ At-| gat they peeresaone pocaliarity which is very apparent | meutiouing bis namo,) he was ono of the twe who were | enother, “I will knock his head inv? “I will KRY oq 4¢ torney, in opeaing this caze to you, gentlemen, fos thoug h | upon this triel. ‘The moment tho Lifeless remains of Har- ing, in Pond etreet, last might ebout oleren o'clock, | you do It!” or euch idle words as that? Not a Any he supposed that woman who, éinoo Use Gletof Janum wy | vey Rurdell arc consigned tothe cold and silent tomy, or | Dr. Parmalec’s window, and they <liscovered just such a | but words of that kind are used, when DO meaus® /“yhas. bi corer te attached to them; and yet if taolgras © ) heep crac before, geullomon, commences tho ‘scrambling for | aidkering light ay the District AWornoy alludas to. Now, tant bad been Gagged and hnented ao Ghenghahe ware)e » Woknow whh what avidity his holes his | God forbid that wo should bring up De. Parmatco, and | kilted, bad been way laid, or garrotad Counse! for Mrs. Cunsingham—No, cir, I do notrnean ‘abe Leutwer caro. My motion is this: teat your Hosor ci geet the die-nissa) of abis prosecution ex {t now stands, un- fees the pat !ic prese eutor call as witnesses Mr. Bnodsracs, «ctor; who wore capable of committing it, who were wit- merses defers the Ccener, culled by tho pubic prosecutor. A motion-<l this kind wan made in a case before tevost aright to q@womoel the jon 0 pat those | ‘The Court—Ifgou will show me any right to compa p J nem proves.tor'to produst any winewes, i csould to seo it. ‘Coonac] for Mra. Cv bawingham—Tde cane of Austin. <@ation 08; of the bend 1af the pabho hall ‘mot do it uulere {ts on enthority of oarawa courts of our Maeto. Jn my it would bean bi moe with tho prevcou ler in the diseharco of his cuts. ‘Gann will. Rot be aqrrernedt7 theautiorit ¥ of the Geurt of Oyor oud: Tur ig Bh ee existe abo, wad eee Teas “a Court—dPhere the intictnsents areeonduriyd by pri e—The MMicrEny tora! wilt not hear ® mation as to my right totwlt oma 20 tho Inrindiction must he | wwe Mr. Sal ee your Bonar to all whe law on vt enw 7 have & recon? ‘The Court-uo, vir; we will and @&) up iho Umea Fe Car odalre mnt be exam? ‘The Court-—Yen, oir, when he cet co an’ the croc ememipation of Mr. Metvuire Se betn ap important witness. £ wobmil Ciot it i fair a pa cont oon ips Supereat ruw. 1 sat’ copecially tet cane of this charar ue , at, Wis doe. Court— ntl the winsenes fe brosigtht. 4 tA rocoldert Cab! 4 the A torney Genors’, 1 was ahew te ous p ts to my prefer: Bien brethren. “4 The Court—I (nist het, tee — who we een shat will wai Mote nae iad hae'cmas ab ealcer aftar him. Wo bind bat recess. ‘The Court—We will wait unt he comes. To the » Fou may, if you chooro, rouiro for moments. Mr. Chinton—J will ont nnd confor with the District , In a short thine the counsel for Mre, Cunninghun ro turned, and stated to the Court that hie ground of ob jes Bon to the Jnriediction of the Court war that {twas not commtit Wed, mud that tn apite of ail charters there Sermen iting with the Judge in order constitute a = . 4 his property. ° a five exiated on the part of the prisoner to-oommit this act, | wild beast, when she eamo into a court of Justice, bef #o | blood grelatives, bave sooght to divide sod snatch | Cbargo him with murder on that soconmt. J don’t’sap- | according to the theory of the prosecution, ti inpoas =) “ne who could have a motive t | twelve honest men,-weuld fMnally have somo show of do- | and divide up amoug whatever property | Pore that he was burning woollen, bovts or clothing, tet Pr. Burdell, that he would knock bis DeNO8 out woukt it, | Now, the fuct that I desire to prove by this witness ceney in bor bebatf;) with a wiew to prevent you from «giv- leit. “Wo know how they have pursued and Might. It is no cnusuel ciroumstance to veo alight at | bave been convinein poet ces bedid OF yy my Ki hunted this wafortmate woman, find I know, alvo, that tho | dows, and thero was nothing in the jor of this | the fact tuat Dr. Burde I, notwithstanding D® ncwsoseed & with- ‘first plaeoy bo had thin lady, Mra. Demis Voorst and has | pervade the broat of .every honest man, saw? Who appeared before-tho Surrogate’ Court to render, tf | lated to impress ‘apon bis nvind sack an idea, even if tho | out mich difficulty. We bavethe thet that they lived to. Dand ty! 7 % , mw) and void the marriage, in order that | thing had occurred. But Dr. Purtaalco, in spite of our | gotber, as a ans thing, tm pence and haw sony, diawret. 2 tags 9p On Groat Ge eas ‘Bnd at the ‘expense of Doctor Burdell, » divereo wapoptalved. Inte | ing uttorunce ta, tho fvelin gs of manly empathy wieich | yory counre)-of that family or ie mowbors of that family | oUNe that pight, as spoken of by btm, which was cyicu- | peculiar disposition, got along, he and We dF srdans, | | throvgh his own inetrumentality ho eaused in advance of word of teutli ony todenouncemy clie ates | thio 'tvighs got “tho property-—that tho yory | Temon-tranco would bring im hero that favorito dog of ‘his, | ing the idea that thoro was any contemplal’ joy, be taken In tho Supreme Court of the Stato of New tho worst woman tha: God ¢ ver croated—as a-waman, (a | counsel, Ncnean a very earned aud ‘big | and it was made to epeaie trumpe: tongued pera ben hua | crim, Does not that speak more loudy ip sera all tho papers of which aro on Bie. it wen ty A eae of hor) by tho vory | Lawyer, appears lero to prosecute thet woman, and, | tstimeny, that “King Qharles.”” Woll, gentlemen, that | than the frivolous quarrels mentioned ew 4 syains ber? 3 Judge Dav!os—The witness says be dos. Bot know any- | waren ss Diecself as bis & it a gontiomen, why? You all recollect that upon the Goro. | dog of his, lehoukd J wea ® great pot; he rsyu ko | will not take up your thme in going over = the periiculare of tng about !. } Pea : 0 oftew Lxtonod rwith pleasuto te tay leemned | ner’n. inquest with what unmingled foolings of di<gust wag | Dever went in pursuit thar dey of his to another Louse; | these alleged iutzeeations, every ttle 89 | having boon tor Connsel-for the accused-—I want to prove a fact by bir ) as be addressed juries tn capital and-other criminal | viewed the conduct of x corwin lawyer who appeared | Yet a gentleman living woxt doer to him informed mo that | tured by the District AWoraey to try am, ehow » cases;'and what was my ev rpriso, when leaw that bo-- | thoro.as tho counsel for the blood relatives of the de- | it Was no uncommon incident for Dr. Parmaled’s dog to | pouting towarda guilt, Let 08 8@ 9 what iho | which will bo a link in the chain ef olreurmstances whiet : usually ao fair, eo-ec2did, 0 cautions, 69 Just—had over- | eonred and took ® part in that inquest. If you have | Com? to his house, amd for Dr. Parmaleo to cores after it, | i. The District Attorney renertet 9 pm the cirenmetanoe will eetablixh it, (Tho question was overruled and exoap- tion taken.) rtepped al] the beands of mc Ceration; vet eententing: him. mingled indus city, talked wah your uaintance and w experieuoo greet diffi sult: fn it} ae a on the of tha defenda Q, Whea wore they theroto your knowiodgo? A. Ido | self with ating tho ‘ucts of the care which bo oxkwctet | Feller ad red Oo te you bave heard wows, | «way. 1 euppteo ‘bet gontienmn wi APCS io | Te stom BOs ber tne dorensed Weve 0 teen bonses ane hob knew. Bs ‘ - prove, at, a: m7 exsor! we said, ho raneacki xt tho | mingied condemnation of ihe course pursued by that j cowrt. Ho |s @ morebant of good etanding. | romarked thst it was srelief ta ber to know that he bad Q Havo you no personal kmowiedgs ef your relatives, | elassice—he Wavelled over « I bistery, sacred and mo- | man, thoindelicy and indecouey of aj as a public | J will not, gontiemen, step <o digouss the etrango manner | notcome totic death by vielent and foul means, Why. where they reeide? A. I don’ know abouttione. dorn—with a view toeslect fr male fiends, inercor tist bo | character and ax the counsel of the blood relatives inter. Of Dr. Parmaioe or Ris peceliar mental compecttion. I with | eaye the Dinrict Attorney, dad the speak of murder, ax” ; of might tyoify by means of t! wm the charsoter of mg un- | ested pecuntarily im the death ef m te iy cons ziown fa peer 4 y client, and Tcan un- fay nothing ukind of «ay man, andthe reason why I | cept from guilt? Ho forgets that tho servant { abcrap bone . oe het seem Mand wg derstand wby this trial has been conducted as no other _ Pat the question as to his pecu Bar mowtal mmpasition was | Hsonah,who conveyed the intelligence of tho Doctor's Staines aietenen ber ph cen es = phage oe pi tee ny hg deen neat. Upon postr he: po Bonar iene wid wees wai same < - eer one that she — that the Doctor had been : 5 pilered bi 2 a r ple Chan asthe work, the handiwork, citable ind, ‘who notions in his head | murdered. n says the District Attorney, } since you saw her at bin house? {Objectod to.} f Almighty could, autil you @ rrive at ¢ho end of your | of tao-blood relatives of Dr. Burdcll, who bare an ianorest which bo could aot aesount'Tor, Yea sew onongh of his | cush into the pe apr trhe aig Ifehe MerGlectarae Counsel forthe nocused-—Iy is in proot that the leativ- | duties tn ew cave, Deny it hw proneerees sure, Dewbase, | to tho amount of, perhaps, €0,000 or $35,000 in | SPPearanco on the #tand to cearrant yon t that conctusion. | teom immediately he would have found fault with hor oon ing porvon tat waa neon with Tir, Burdall was this vory | notwtibatanding the pre‘udice « thich Ban gurroubdet this | tho deat! of my cliout, Thon ‘interosied jn | His own nephow ead to mo Kuma if wecemsary ho will be | <iuct there, and sald (t was feigned. Taek you if bore wan woman, bis mistress, and that wo Intand to prove, caso, and with which the comp tuatty, to@cextain exfent, | hor death can pend their counsel here, and | om tho poe ps Dr. Parr tord bi iit this smoll of | anything unnatural in her conduct, the frat piase there Judge Device 1 do not reoollest the tostimeny to bo tat havo been inbued, I eseume that you will decide this | pay « you .werk wp the case, Cosh for the toutimony, | Durned woollen was porce! ved by wim fn the evening, and | wore her daugl Lbave tt on my minutes 1 Dr. Thompeon wns tho last | case upon tho evidence, and th at yoo will.act upon the | perew.up witnerves aa though they were upon the ruck, | be failed to mention enytht og as wemoliing of burned wool. | the otber daughter by: Porson sean wii Dr. B fi Jaw—ih oher words;tumt you will act asmen. In tho | uo everything toiuduce a jury of tweive men to send the | ‘8 afterwards. Iviow it in this way: that ut that time | viclont excitemon Counsel for Bho accused —I eay that the evidence ef Mr, | bri-f opening which ft 1s my | stentton to make % youl | defeudantto a folon'’s grave, 60 thet they upon the death | Dr. Parmalee supposed th ¢ murder waa committed in the | end herae Q. Did yeu never eoe thom st 01 Bond sweet? AT never did. Q Nono ofthem? A. I think I saw Mre. Voorst there, Q. How Jeny a time prior to the death of Dr. Burdol! it. ch grief and agony, could che eit down io Plunebury ie thin:—-When obo ieft the room in which Dr. | sball not go over all the ovidenc tin thieess. Iehall not | of that womms.csn take upd divide among thomea carly part of the ovening,, and it wa ta refarence to this | und eooliy 5 Pardell was actually foun’! mardered, abe left this ire. pw ed the counsel evrporcd t would, todepict the an- | the share of tho erty which aust fall to her as his | idea that his dnorderod | ‘nsesnation oacceled the autters ‘been best oy he ovens. fs if being” pet oy tn | Denuis Voorst,-bis biood cousin, in the room.with him at | Ruish and sorrow wy oiirnt han, wired. i eball not stop | lawful widow. understand op no other principle, | He told you that the bow so was dark—that where wero no | Can you moppors who would do otherwio (haa ag to the timo, #ho not particular about it. Tho cook | togive you any account of that, although the abuse hoap- ewears she saw julm at § o'clock, but the laet woman found | 6d upon her by tho Ditriet A Wormey—tho oviragoous in the room with him wae his mustrest, Demis Voorst. i | abuse—would render mo anwo ‘thy tho name cf man aay, therefore, abe t# on trial Were I not to say a fow.words in her defence, which are durige Dayies—< ct try any iaeoe of that kind here. called forth by remarks of the Ihetrict Auasney bimn- Conneol fer tho. eccused-—I want to sbow the relations tion Lo painfe! enough Yad dest. Fle wid you that oxisted betwotn other parties and the deoeaxod, as ou “a veiled. picture of sorrow, a well natho prigonor and the decsaned, and show @ motive | miserable hypocrite ; that all the @ufferiag sho coum bas experieRon: fairs souting counse) about travel beyond the | hte except the om int hoatue windew; and yet,inre- | ature dictated? Thera aro f circumstance "snd meek to bo tho chesue? of tlander 3) | See to ono of van ory, inated that be | which aro. too tivial ip “nate cbaracier Wb sh af ever fesued from scortal lips, calndera, | Sid not observe wh her ero wos 6 light iu | @iluto to, although dwelt on by the District sttoroey, Ui or falsity of which aro wet to be tried in this | the sound oF third mor 7 windows—ahes showing Ust be | ‘Tho text dalng with rogard to which Phave an ovpiauyion because yon wre sitting 0 ty Uo indictment in | PAld-Do attention tothe matter whatever. ‘Tho discrimiaa- | tw toake te, that this defoodant refused to testify — chat sho © gontioman told you 4'9 lady lived wt $1 | 0D of do joror broug! st out that fast, that bo pad no at- | would nct come in without advising with conasel, 1 had thet she kept there in effect'a house of | “ntioa to the mater; and yet bute moment before bo * seen her at that time, and did not unt!! tho mart day. ile $614 you and with anoagerness, he sald | S8orethat there wes No light tere excopt thin syzterious the us , opt nn seoniyen San eee that ehe het boon on the part of oer. entirely feirsod.” | ft that tere he would cmroof that hecee. He atte Hiokeriag light havent eared in tho aki. You Lo Q. When did yourse Mr. Voorst, the huoband of this Picture of sorrow, | to wil you tuet.sbe bad forsaken one fenton ovidenes ihe kied ef omohe was. Byon on this ke taken pany oll & my a x been a year since: I pover eaw whe ceanee hanseryes sath awesds we — ae awent on {0 that ewain, describing ter | pono coe bis perres excited, on seang two le in the that t oarings tee im four times f F a uct for yesra sa that of the most infamous | Street whove ap.pearante denoted w brigandish, dat | net been @ Did Dr. Monded Layee brother named Joba? ..d10 Vibe fet time that | wernan tet was over Roflured to eo at Large ih this som, | DO tuRGed off ihe widowabl ; and whepantisd en creune eet santertmets OS the Separtar Fete {een br bende re aid. ‘ to depiwre tbe lees of her bus. | qunity; exd yet, genclomen, he knew tuat that would not | i thelr appasraseewae wdspicious, be coult not teil. The | to go t-Eurcpe)—she, knowing that uho had boop taken Q Where aint he reside? A. No. 2 Union aquarn So depict toymr | be the eubject of evidence.’ He knew, .o6 he must have | Only reason he eaakl fi waa thot they were not very | (nto custody, and that her marriage fad fc md 3 pe buses eas a = po ee known, tha’ no each. ee cule have Roon offered in thia | Wel Greased, eoheaney Copy in their move- | keyé seoret—mightshe not w thout ir; pity aliow ’ E did.” three e + wan whelly foreign to the isaues be: | ments; yet when aalle§ upon to dewiribe what in thoir | consult with coun ; & Where does sho suside? A, J think tn Laanoca be od. Bul, gentlemen, ‘when sho 2y yer 00 ot PAGO MOE Fok be Coan ten tote | rmovetatons wae’ Git btrack him with horror, be coud | Cereeed tee alti ono oc of ru be stroet, in thie ity, Ded of ciekaser b weelf, and.aashowud- | come the ahonel Wt which this donl-and ebilish | Only say that theire-walk frightened bier ell he'conid not | was treated without rogerd tar tcc eo mauat sho Q Has she chiidren? A She has. wan of oternity, 669 | giandor is © bo dismogninated thy hows this community | tell whether theytwalked fast or slos, bus Snally stated | treated in w way po ‘aan would treet. Bie’ Mg Q. Was sho divorced fro ber husband before bis dems? youth had departed this | ‘sir: scattered over the elvilined world. Tank jeu, gentic. | Att was 6 wodagan walk, neither Curt nor clow;thatthis | scarcely "his “dug.” Howe his sor ant, nad | Aci do not know Kife—shat his apirit had found ti Wa, #9 amother.end we men, whetuer, as honert men, your very hearts did not | witost Crighvened dim out of hia eenses. 't allude | that it Go immetiniely, and oe oe, wet @. Id Harvey Purdei! and his breather John have daw | trust,a better world. Yet, gesdeme ao peices trast ficken within you ns yon heard thie icfamour wbuso | % this merely te <how the peculiar mental compo- | testimony in | A » and did give her faite prior to tho death of Joke? [Objectet to.) in the widow's God, Sho has: faced afl! , Sho d heaped spon the dot head Of the prance cries | sition of tho mam. Now, goatlomon, if tho jury | and teey met One oe jhe ce Heaney | Mir. Clinton aaid they hed a kkcki to alow that thetwegn | bas co:ne through it unscathed, Sineo deat tmoctownn) tar? Hind tay friend boon an amateur who loved | SX | to bo G0 roeiver of ‘tho dicased | withthe temmony of Manuel oy ie, Harvey Burdoll and b's relatives, eo far aa he had business | rapidly an cmnsethly borne demndhe ch ancl Sine, stl wo Words, to tear and 1) Gheracter, ings of & man Who W frightevsd borause be moew be sorry to ebiak thas an: ww i woale end eorial connections with thers he eonctanty quarrelied | unfortums ely for her, abe wae desbed up.eean opochin bi mere sport ef it, he hot. have that walks amkiber fash or sow—i/ the jury box | these women in Looe gh of with them and fenlnge provailed emoug them all. | Liletory of fearfulmoment Rudderiy thet hat ekene out an the! ute to be made the rec ppiaclo of euch foare, Ido not know Atorney, abe wo wiper Mi Bus Fare the Dietriot Teo chjeetinn of Dutt Agoruey eave with edad | from the horizon Uf her future, not. tant sh wot Bedbiebem, | Oris ‘mors tan Ye “eeureo bee , abfScich | what is to become of parties wihowo rights Sopond on their | prinsmonloetalineed trace he ciel, wat, Xept there @ |. geo when hey ough! to the proof from his een erane and hallowed had iumine heraliiietion. | gy knew {t was no’ case!and Tony | setion. Let CT 4 alittle further iu thie care. The | eel, ‘unt! the right to eco her ‘lenda, nor to eee her coun- ianosses, Ye afirened Git the qcomion war proper aad | Tee grave-tas oloped over hor husband «wad herawmbly | qv net true ie fact. mi he Knew that becerould nce | District Adorney Jold' you he wonlt preva tet thoes | she Court of Oominets Pees tae reat ay af order from ~ 4 thought thin wns @ case whero cansderatio | bepes are al! entombed. Dat at laetthe «wr of Be allowed provait, or evidence t gon abe mubject, lived together v@ivery ill terme. Sle aaye the do- | upon hi imaself to contine her with = Dogburry took, ‘ - ty that one fact would | fendant mottered covumgo against the doceass!, and be | slew w enforce her aw, wih © & ty | hee up theworvast girls—thovo who hare been | bar rights, my ant ihe rights of the ps the re oc dict woman fas it @ pleasurato him.| vader foréhraw long months in hia cuntoty—ae to-kave an tarervoow wis Ber eat ad hi sand up here ‘before you, and, while the inponcat | Witnesses. As you mr drag their manter, they aro bee. | rights. 1 then asked the Coroner wiotee, Cone! W@ hor deurhiers of that womam sat within’ @ few feet of him, | © I thom having boen ciwcharred | @ witness or a party. Tress wim an, ee her as wos te pleacant taak to him to travel beyond de record, | for drunkenmess, and @ho @ther, ® good cook perhoye, bat erty to examine her as mach as ho , then be was at Lib. id 19 Cielr presenoe.and to desertbe thet matiior, | 70m causes which tte unasce-aary to option, devidedty | bor as @ party, 1 Pleasod; but if he hekt wiae Undervers to dem haa cxvmaded trom war | e2friendly te her. Teas parties’ aro produced us wit | be examined "eg wines ip, O% iow | her te birt & tho preeent me, in the torms be did? Was it a | Eeexes. after bewing boew into the casioty of the ro | @ dhing—ahe community forbids MY Sorts wiepaure & tlm to tale, acoures like that-—on cnneseesery, | BowDed Coroner Convery, drilet by flim, a‘drowed fa | ex ebe oneupied the don 4 vindictive, I hy & Sendich course? Gen- eter Ge eee 2 forced, to ewear | pecially befure that mau a ventas, sanded ; tomen, 1 wou! © thought thst cae = ir foraser empiay'or; 3 proceed |] Qu ho dit bot adit cr rejeat orkienoe upon We bars of | ot haunt aot dog itm aboct, but dat abe wns over | wocst ir bi whoro velow Bosred 50 drop of the make Daring been tn custody sor ¢ ovbes bet tis cranttaice,”” eeemaep—t would Bob sabat counwe! aald tn thetr To éi4 pe regard the | ready to inrotuce bm to her ecquaimieaces of bugwn kinder, woall hero been retreimed | being almost fri thoir | party, nee enoral thing te eee ost woud Bet allow any in hia opening, | ehe erlsked to etand croll; to introdace tuimn.toy by bamenity, by @ eamse of decency, from une. | COumryinan, at 7 vet i thle ~ 4, ing, to bo examinad ad a witvem: as anything ous | minet repeinbio erquainiances that Lo comary 601 uncalled fur abuso of tho me | oaiybeen ebabled to Letify 4 & y. ‘ativan | Koowing Uat dhe soca 5 emrwing my aliont’s isnoesaee, elloved was their duty, | These are theeo who know chat te wat | ther of theo? lumocent Geughtors, Vet, the gentiemag | "2.as would be likely to cour with we et Totaled to the "torr ave Bo ubjection to bo oxamin: exes upon tha evi. | best pleased when ke was bearing, at be mup- | sonlé acwi to iniuence your minds hy euch ciroumedniong, | SO? Sytao house with Harvey Burcoll. Exproaaions ero | het be bro eny magierrate aerrey Mt he would take of counsgl. Ho dis- fy upon her. Why did she District At | sic thvug!it chat they wore a mutable topic to deacant up- | Fepeated, some of tiem mot tran, and would Inter; van tan examine ber a+ a witness I jet ey said mak shat catapsont? Did ho p that he oo, aittevugh 80% Coming within the line of hie duty at all, Aggerated by three witaesses. Now, bear in rlud tho | dhe char, pro Bo obstacle. Even after being eid on owas pon | evula Tid beweppoo thatit was Go of | and if be hadgained anything by a course Kiko tat, i | Set that with the axeeption of thoso few altorcations urder, 1 told my learned friend that he wag to prove the handwriice of Dr. Burdel, and to provo the % Wo; bo did pot ogpect within tho rubes feuch riatake aay reading of couslenances, or my | Se¥° pariien wero oxtromoly friendly; anf all the alter. def we the Grand Jory or ‘ ber to amewer any and wehnee of the pistol. They were aot wory eigaiteant or | It etriker mae, to prove anjshing of that sort. ¥: impertant farts in oay view that he mew saw, and he did | men, why hoe, usualy eo fair, make @ Bo Kee tho nonewlty of cocupying the disse of the court to | emblitered with akun‘lor Hike that? Was ‘t, how the etaln ef. foaling in retorance wy these two fits, he supposed dhat you woull-bo influensad by deabamnation Mr. Clinton wail te only two facts dhe witness proved | to dieregard Iqna hordiy think thet. Why was the has twrit om Beeo paper’, abd Gio Cast that | was i? Let ju equent remarke, if he chow: Surnaa nature, Again be you that fi etion that Flannah tella you of i, thal on one oocan) Me a. Wiibowt onemmlon and wissen’ fore, that no | Mm. Burdeli caid to the Deter shal sho would have sour Or 0 wilocer co iat might be fat to hor. I tomdered ber g bat my client was an emmsay of hie, that’ no one | eaten, or ko rovenge?. About tw samo timo officer | tay ral Van ie ot was lof ber innooenee, againet nave G.S0tive t commit that deol of horror | Dawe Faye toe: ho wai called in, and that the expeonsion cane to tent tam P~ Bose. na were personal iD ber wish sre Could havo boca eparet (rm alluding | Wad by Mrs. Burdoll that Aho would ave gatiauc- | @ decent dog te dn ng I wouk! not subject but Wie unauthorized atetement of tho Metrict heart's bloed, of words to tat | gentlemen, for thi: party requiring « re el, aod iodmene would havo bi De. Bordall parchas=! a pirtol Uke thie. addregs you, iaform you upox that point Befwe pro. npelind ea, as far an we gonid fron 3 est. | CMeot. Now, with reference to thie laaguage ar} Jago Duviro—in Kt tocranary to show Ge erate of fexl- | cending in reference 4e the facts.of th’ cao, gontimaen, I witness Magaire, $0 go tuto tat prof. It fil, you havo tm ovidench already that to ane! Cott | fe much about her not being examined as a witnoas, Thin, lng of Cie withows tewards Dr, Burdell it eeferenoe to | will the liherty of calling your nuon to ane oF me now ¢o rake the ‘counter etat which ig | Commenced immodiatoly after that poriot. Thi en, fk tetimony for osgeution. Now, thay purchasing @ Aric! . two rules of law whist tho Court » jown for your Dr. Harvey Gurdol! had that bo | then, had reference to the eatistretion to bo had tit only have pet pr ac Mr. CHavm—1 wish to como strictly withia dae law, and | guidance, I refer so attention of the Court tn tie (ret of Shad | thee two emits whoard tho charge muis by L Dut, * I have | proven the ianccon wo have the Ingal right te -rom-examino a whincer iv an} ireenleaf on Evidence, seeuon 18>~ r al etolen a nets, manner we Giink proper. ‘Tho latitude of the eroec-exars!- | — n eivi) ennwe It lo wedBielept, If the aa br whol tt ‘ ‘ wiod i @ pol . nation doce not nt aii depond upon your Honar’s or the | pgrece wih and euppeesn the Sy> | ‘ " ¢ i 1 aa District Attorvey'* cow on the imp smtance of the testi. | to prove, but ie erimiass 9 fh mast orm withe shatow \c mony given by him on tuo direct examination. Polheais but thet of dhe gulls of the part had quarrets @ o ’ take & chmrge’ OF ie tind, ee Gent dwige Davieo—-You may (Cragin him on the point for | —n other wordegontiem: suv governing gor ania who we i wh rhy Prosonge tt at th jot Attorney has loft off the which bo han boon called, butk is vory difforent frou | tathie caro te sieaply shie~ ne the clroums'ances | trict Atorm +a comsiderable ti Bg Kowl a at LS one eaten belaie okt Gee Harvey Bar’ Suits wer fo of ao end bi reaher Willi tween thom. At thy rohan Rardelb Y called mot. for thie tur ied ho wad (and that f it frogs his «pooch ) yoothee|s than golag into a divoros wait. Proved in thir case exched ry Q. What were your rolations wb Dr. Burdell prior to | thet af guilt, it is your beunden duty to 9 his death, friendly or nnfriondiy? A. We wore noton | is beet eta od tn “Rest, on Prevomptions,”’ p visting terme Woke thostberty of reading fram that hook ‘apon this pein xt the whole Dou Before the Coroner Soodgrase wan evasatoen, this lady wore examined: ayo, and her and ten youre OF age, werd wade wit. Wore you on epraking terms whee you mot im the | “The evidonos agvinet tin aerured sho y ne to Bae 9 yey frou steely AT did B08 aponk to him exclude toe morn certainty, every hy puthects I hs fe eve Uke boys preet ot ake weer Q. Was thare a litigation between Wm. Ryrdol! and his | hie guilt of tho offence imputed to him ¥ | f- Why sted ty Late cone rr ordiner Harvey Bardoll, the deceased, in wesob you took | If ell tho ctreametences proved cout! be tres ant fot ths | came to pay him Wil s witnomes Were evar oulfeuted Op ee meniane part against Hisevey? party innocent, you uurt acquit. Ii tho cirvumetances aro | Mr. Porrepout sued him, and o mn. ee Ganguinrs were 4 + pdt eo pa vr} betwen. Harvey Burge | seyeite a with’ enilt or innosonce meantime cone raits hetirar ¢ not In accordance with the roles e ne laa bot Wat ware the rolations eon Harvey Burd Aoquit. Abd upon jhie point I w gone againot ¢ fot the vole purpowe of extracting frm them ovitesse at ments wht the asked Mr. Fs againet William; and uham | paved, Mr. Pier and bis brother Wiliam, friendly or anfriemily? A. I | ing yor attention, gentlemen should think they wore not very friendly, he wont 1@ see | fow illurtrations of th pri him about three times im the apace of four youre; Wilkitsn | prerently, if the prosecution lial prove't tonty fol! my. Hived In Colombne, Ohie, arkd Gecastonally came to the city, | than they bare, that it gould not avail thom wit Bir their mother’s guilt, T recellect weil, in reading that evi 1 a the peculiar nature of the questions pat te these artiees boys ="My little son, what timo wat i that us beard the noo Inet Friday night?’ What time when he called to eee him. thie rale of law. [ sow fond from Judges i eres & od owe a , Sve nee bnew, iat of the diatanca which wo- | Bimonde’ chargs ts the Jary in a capital ca | i’, = yy at Sr. te se ae ren Nae oe reer. wae Oe porated thom, what the rolaaions of these Drotharg were w ' roportet i the fowth yolome of the New Yor’ Lo | crime iP ay je come ia vy ) vee Ae 4 , WI und wate And ia