The evening world. Newspaper, October 24, 1914, Page 1

% es fi Bs ig 3 ‘ is Ls > -MRS. CARMAN’S CASE IN HANDS OF THE § . . La “ Cironlation Books Open to All.!’|___ paeelemenniaetes =e aeeercee . “Circntation Books Onen to All.’ \ PRICE ONE CENT. Conrntene, 188 Toa weag _NEW YORK, SATURDAY, OCTOBER 24, 1914, / a i ar , y | I —— io | A WIRS. CARMAN'S LAWYER [MUTNYOUTATSEA ‘SCORES OF BiG FOOTBALL GAMES/CQRAEI| SHANPS | ; ® | 14 @ - ” Qu - Re Qtr. 40h Qtr, ise | ABOARD RED CROSS, 20s o 9 6 77) BROWNIN GAME SAYS PERIURY INDICTED HER: [Se ee ee | SHIPNOWINPORT|xale..........¢ 3° 0 oa VERDIGT EXPECTED TO-NIGHT nasinis Canc sutlwernue sey tom . al Red-Handed Conflict Made| West Point....... 0 0 7 7 —- 14|Ithacans Roll Up Big Total Voyage a Terrible One for {Holy Cross.... 0 0 0 o— 0 Before Final Quarter Lawyers Agree to Speak Two Hours Be Pisenges, 0. of Penn... 0 3 0 7-7 senbe Each and Jury Will Probably [four men are IN iRoNs,| “Sls: -- ; ° © ©lscoRE IN EACH PERIOD. Get the Case for Considera- Princeton. . "0 16 0 an tion by §.30 o’Clock. Ship Might Have Been Seized| Dartmouth ........ | 0 6 0 \With Game Tucked Away by Mutineers but for Stern Harvard 0 6 | Early Ithacans Use Subs— rem e ert @ venin, ‘ol le er ee | . , MINEOLA, Oct 24--The (ral of Mrs. Plorence Carman for the] Master-atArms. | ony, State... 10 - 67000 See Battle, | murder of Mrs. Louise Bailey entered upon its final stage this afternoon, pm tka. ld. favuione a . ig \ when counsel for the defense began to sum up. The case will go to the Bae Baa anal Rutgers........... 0 3 = LINE-UP. ‘ f jury soon after sundown, and it Is the j eneral impression here that Mrs,} high .sene—stal'ed the deck of the Tufts............. 0 7 — i | Carman will be found either innocent or guilly before midnight. Seo ce a | Michigan 10 0 = sort i Mr. Graham began summing up for the defense at 1.47 o'clock.| nee mission of saree ateebe ova | Syracuse... nae “ : ; ; ‘ a plier He’ centered his attack on Celia Coleman. He said the jury would have to choose between the story of a confessed perjurer amd the story of little Elizabeth Carman, who said she “knew' she wouldn't go to heaven if she didn’t tell the truth.” : The defense opened to-day’s session with a very deaf witness named Rudolph Loewe, who said he saw a man running away from the Car- man home just after the shot that killed Mrs. Bailey was fired. The District-Attorney brought out that the description furnished by Loewe of the man he saw running fit Farrell, the tramp who said he saw Mrs. Carman fire the shot and then ran away to avoid getting ‘into trouble. Mr. Graham oyerran his time, finishing after 4 o'clock. District. Attorney Smith then started to round up the State’s case. The jury which took the fate of Mrs. Florence Carman in ‘ts hands to- day bad ringing in its ears a new analysis and arrangement of the evidence by Distclot-Attorney Smith, which requtred a new argument for the defense by Attornéy John J. Graham. Mr. Smith's new angle of attack took one | point from the evidence of Celia Coleman and two from the principal wit- messes of the defense, Mrs, Carman and her husband, the physicisn. As he had the significance of the facts arranged for the judgment of the jurors * they were as follows: : First-—Cella Coleman, the negro maid, confessed liar in defense of the Carman family, confused and terrified by the ible consequences of her Untruthfulness, fell back on the truth as her only way out of trouble. she aid, in her final narrative, the importance of which she showed no sign of realising, Mrs. Carman went out, there was a shot, she came in in a moment and said “I shot him,” and addg, “See,” and showed a revolver. SLAYER THOUGHT DR. CARMAN WAS SHOT. Second—Dr. Carman said that when he heard the glass in his ofce window break be turned and saw a revolver protruding into the room and @imultaneously ducked. He dropped behind the chair simultancously with the shot. Mrs. Bailey remained upright. but be had dropped as if shot. A parson outside must have thought he was shot. ‘Third—Mrs. Carman, denying that she went downstairs before the shot, admits that she went to the door of bis office and listened until she heard Dr. Carman’s voice, or as District-Attorney puts it, “Had not killed her husband,” and then went upstairs again and went to bed frightened, but contented. As against this it wae the intent of Law ‘er Graham to point out the general unreliability of Cella Coleman and to ‘isist that her testimony was jhe result of « long course of nagging by the District-Attorney and that the story took the course suggested to her vivid imagination by the constant urging of the District-Attorney along Ines which the District-At- torney actually belleved true. Garland Gaden, the is picti.. factor who was Dr, Car Carman house about the letter, fon @ few days after th turned in the driveway. I heard a ( the physician sald he was shot &@t/ shot,” ; from ambush, was ejected from ‘.>/ Q. what did you tee? A. I saw man about five feet from the fe: and ten feet from the house. to the fence and jumped o Q. What else did you 4. eoked fate the broken window and gaw Mr. Carman. Q. Mrs. Carman? A. No, Mr. Car- man, m Dr. Carman? A. Yoa, rman. He had a lady in his arma and he lald her over the other way from me on the foor. Q. Did you see anything else? A. Yes, two ladies on the steps of the Carman house. On cross-examination Mr. Smith court house before the trial began by order mn Justice Kelby. He bad w, '- ten @ letter to the Justice which equeei order: to De leoned to :'s court officers to talse him to the Jus- 9 Chambers at once. saw MAN RUNNING FROM WIN- DOW OF HOUSE. ‘The defense brought out @ brand ew witness to-day, Rudolph Loewe, a very deaf baker of Freeport. It was necessary for Mr. Levy to climb over the court rail and stand by th it ness box and shout into Loewe He answered with # marked Teutonic coent. iy “| got a letter from the Secretary ef State about a chauffour's license,” | Dont “baker who had been cee he fm ¢ halting wey !@ answer to uy. shoute, “Z wept te the . (Continued on Fours Pages.) learned that the witness was a Free-| the time the vessel cleared for Huro- | pean ports on Sept. 12 until an hour | last night when the Fire Island, Light signalled the approach to port Four of the Red Cross's crew Iay in {rons In the brig when the ship came to anchorage at Quarantine to-day. ‘They will be handed over to a United States Shipping Commissioner under the charge of mutiny pre ferred by Capt. Armistead Rust, V. 8. N., navigating officer of the ship. The cruise of the Red Cross was that of a veritable hell ship, accord- ing to many of the 155 passengers who returned aboard her from Rot- terdam. Irishmen in the stoke hold and West Indian negroes in the gal- ley kept up a continual warf; i which knives, revolvers, belaying pins and monkey wrenches played parts. Had it not been for the heavy! shoulders and quick right arm of ono man aboard the Red Cross some of the passengers believe the Red Cross would have been seized at sea by her mutinous crew. That man was Em!! Kovarik, the giant master-at-arms. A former body- | guard for William Sulzer and one who hesitates not at throwing « quick fist into @ mix-up, Kovurlk, single hand- | ed, stopped some of the bitter fights! between the races, and in one instance disarmed a big West India black wh. threatened him with a revolver, TROUBLE SHADOWED BEFORE SHE SAILED, ‘The riotous cryis> of the Red Cross! was a direct result of the troubles! precipitated just before she left New Yory by the British Consul’s com- plain againgt the shipping of a Ger- man crew. When the Germans were ousted frantic efforts were made to comb the waterfront for substitutes, and anything that looked like a sailor was grabbed by the shipping agents. Negroes from the Hudson River and ; Sound boats and heavy fisted Irish jollers and coal passers West street were drafied. An ‘ex-convict had social position in that crew, Before the Red Cross pad dropped Scotland Light behind her on her out- | ward cruise her navigating officer discovered that the Germans who had! been thrown out of their positions had left little mementoes behind them Every pump and bilge was atuffed so} 84 to be out of commission and the re- tri ng had been tampered with to ‘such ap extent that it would not | cperate properly for several days | Had @ fire occurred gn the Red ross any time in the first three | days at sea the ship would have been doomed, [MUTINY STARTED BY ONE OF THE NEGROES, | Two Austrian stowa’ from and one (Continued on Hecond Page) _ PEACE FOR WORLD SEEN BY WILSON IN ARBITRATION TREATIES: Agreements Such as U. S. Has Recently Signed Will Be a Check on Hasty Action, PITTSBURGH, Oct 24.—Peace commission treaties of the kind ne- @otlated between the United Staten and many foreign countries were spoken of by President Wileon bere to-day an the means for “shedding light” on disputes which will make the use of force unnecessary, The President predicted that after inter- national disputes bave been discussed for a year, as provided in these treaties, cannon will not be found necessary to settle them. The President addressed a maas- meeting in celebration of the sev- entieth anniversary of the Y.M.C. A. movement and dwelt on the lessons of Christianity, urging young men to be progressive and work for the pub- Ne welfare. In opening the President valid he felt that by his being away from Washington Congress could have ‘more leisure to adjourn.” He spoke particularly of the Ideals of young men, Most poopie, he declared, be- lNeved young men to be “arch radi- cals,” but that he had found them to be very conservative, “It would be good for men, both young and old,” Mr, Wilson said, “to detach themselves more from bustoess and think of higher things. I won- der how many of us think of Chria- tianity as an instrumentality for the jeal development of mankind? just concluded treaties of A great many nations pro- v we wall look for the light or a) My prediction i» that if after the light has shone on @ dispute for a year It not be necessary to 0 hing, that after we know what happened then we will know wh right and who Wan wrong. I that light 's the greatest sanitary fluence in ithe word: ——— SON BORN TO QUEEN OF SPAIN Mer Family Now Tw ahte MADRID, Oct. 24, via Paria —A son was born thls morning to Queen Vic- toria of Spain. The baby boy born to-day ix her sixth child, the others being three sons and ty o daughters. King Alfonso wes married on May mM, 1906, to Princess Victoria Buy nl of Battenburg. The first child, Crow ¥rince Alfonso, was born May petra {HOW THIRTY LOYAL MEN RUSSIA OFFERS TO FREE ALL ITALIANS CAPTURED FROM AUSTRIAN FORCES. 65; it was the only hig football —————- contest to be staged in New York, ee es Barre Or ane ete but thie fact didn't aeam to excite face ts han end to Italy |the football fans. They were very all the Austrian soldiers of Italian | slow in getting around. Half an hour ly those from the | before game time less than 3,000 of in°the Gaitetan | the rah-rah byos hed put in an ap- |pearance. It looked as if the big down at Prinoeton proved the real attraction. The Cornell team, abdut thirty strong, were out early for practice, | There was only a faint cheer. Indeed, ithere weren't enough Cornell rooters on hand at thie time to mak ‘The numbering of the pt @ change commented upon by every one in the stands At last the spec- POIO GROUNDS, Oct | Brown and Cornell football forcen | clashed to-day for the firat time since | “until the end of | rh to ee ‘eott! . me of the in for emer Wat these provinees will mo to Italy | for her maintenance of neutrality and refushi to fight on the alde of Ger- many and Austria. 24.~"The | 10 PAGES Arrocromos IN BATTLE ON COAST, «French Refuse German Request for q | are rumors that some warships have been disabled. Unesttied To-Night: Showers Probable Sunday, PRICE ONE OENT. GERMANS FORCED BACK: SAY LONDON OFFICIALS, German Army and Airships, Allied Armies and Fleets All Enga Warships Reported Disabled — 600,000 New Troops JoinGermans. NO LET UP IS ALLOWED ..- oe TO BURY THE GERMAN DEAD. | an Armisfice—Claim Gains East of Nieuport, Between Armentieres, and Lille, and Toward Metz. LONDON, Oct. 24 (United Press|.—The Dunkirk core fespondent of the Evening News wires that the Germans have been driven to a line twenty-two miles northeast ef Dunkirk. He adds that their retreat is becoming more “ © pronounced ag the lines of the allies are strengthened. At least one Zeppelin and several armored aeroplanes are aiding the Germans and are attempting to disable er sink vessels in the combined squadrons of monitors. There % The Gerfftan fleet is also showing signs of activity. i is reported that scout crulsers have been sighted operating ~~ tators had a chance to know who was who when a play was made. The numbers were sewed to the backs of PLAYED HIDE AND SEEK WITH MARITZ IN CAPE COLONY. CAPETOWN (via London), Oct (Associated Press).—The correspondent of the Cape Times at Carnarvon, Cape Colony, describing the recent revolt of Lieut.-Col. Solomon Gerhardus Martz, be rad from any part of the stands, The Brown squad raced across the fleld at 2.20. The crowd had increased to about three thousand but atill there was none of that real college enthusianm. FIRST QUARTER. When laritz came to Kakamas, In the Cape Province, in the capacity of ‘om' ant of th lense force, he 8 of the local ‘gar- t_ne needed them the Geld for twenty yards. rison, on the plea to arm @ force againat the Germans. Merits went away and the line, It was brought out to Cor- Then'the garrison luckily nell's twenty-yard line, Then Cor- approach. A party of thir -|nell showed the stuff that is making ing men from the garrison went to his cainp in the night and succceded in| her the mont feared team among the kotthng "a supply of rifles ‘emmunition | hig show. Successive gains by Coll- and horses. ari tht up with them thifty, miles ‘There wan ia three hours’ Aght before the men from | ball to Brown's fve-yard line. {Rey Miaved hide and eck for six'ders| wae a first down with a gain. On before they only one mi —_—__—— FRENCH TRANSPORT te GL, RecrecCorua TH Bisa WITH WOUNDED ABOARD Donovan went in al left end for Brown and Wode took Gottshall's IS REPORTED AGROUND, jince ot tet quard tor Brown | a When play continued thera wan an, Oct. 24 (United Press). /*xchange of punts that landed the| ball in| Brown's possession tn mid Lloyds’ jon on the Tele of Wight | iaty reports Marie)" ‘Three assaults in the line yielded Henrtett: re on! Brown fifteen yi Murphy carried whore off Cape Barfleur, alx-|the ball tu Cornell's thiry-yard line. Bt, Opervours: /On the next play Murphy got around } Cornell's left wing. He was downed jon the Ithacanas’ two-yard line. Mur- phy tried again, but was stopped one yard from tho line. On tho pext play ir whe penalised for offside play a clowe call for Cornell hy was on the Job again and through che line for about the woun hy of Wigh dangerous p eee STEAMER HEIMLAND LANDS CREW OF BRITISH oaition tn } Mury | broke STEAMER SUNK BY MINE,| "even yards, On a missed forward -—- } and Barrett kicked to Browns LONDON, Oct. %, 1.20 P.M Norwegian steamer Heimiand whi: been eeported from Amster probably by a mine, arrive The frown was forced to had | punt punted back — to nk | Browns 10-yard line, where Murphy tumbled but fet! on the ball in. time to save it for Brown, The ball was sweatora and were large enough to| in Wilhelmshaven and Kiel harbors. Cornell kicked off to Brown's 20-| flotilla fired on the German right, which they searched thoroughly en@es yard line and Murphy rushed it down! fectively in concert with the operations of the Belgian army. Brown] * then had to kick, ‘The ball went over| gone to the enemy by naval fire, | yer, Shuler and Barrett brought the| Marine, and torpedoes were fired without success at the Wildfire an@ ‘There | destroyer Myrmidoa. ped, with the lona of the next play Harrett was shoved| planes and balloons aided in directing the fire. lover the Hne for a touch down in| were fine and favorable. No loss wan sustained by the flotilla yest from Helgoland, while Holland points report that all of | the crews have been recalled to the big warships anchored 3 ae f German submarines are continuing their attacks the British-French fleet along the Prench-Belgian ceast from Dunkirk to Ostend. LONDON, Oot. 24 [Associated Press).—The Admiralty to-day issued the following announcement: “All of yesterday monitors and other vessels of the British “All German attacks on Nieuport were repulsed. Much demage wes “Fire also was opened in the afternoon on the German bat Ostend. Admiral Hood has now a fine flotilla of vessels very suitabl& for this work but at the same time not of great value. “During the day our ships were persistently attacked by an enemy “Other Britiah vessels again attacked the submarine, Naval The weather con Battle From La Bassee to Sea ; Called the Greatest of the War, PARIS, Oot. 24 [United Prees}.—There was no cessation in the fighting along the line from La Basses to the sea throughout last night eccor@img to the early reperte received at headquarters, This is now called @e Greatest battle of the war. At a number of potmts the allies cede ground in the face of the fupes. attack, but at no potat of strategic Importance were the Germans ante te gatn. yr The allied commanders, obeying the rule in progress throughout the campaiano, have refused uselessly to sacrifice men in holding exposed peak tions In the face of superior numbers, “y The German long fange artillery has been brought {nto action ena. the Nieuport-Dixmude-Ypres line and against the British and monitor flotills, but so far the advantage in the artillery duel bas ~ aa with the allies. a The heavy Britieh naval guns, and the French three-inch, have molished battery after battery of the Germans with enormous deen to-day bringing the crew of British steamer Cormorant which was destroyed ni a mine recently. Kicked back to the centre of feld (Continued on Miporting Page) \ ela rtneenmeermne Burgman deta among the gunners. ‘The Germans are aleo bending every effext to 8 wedge