The evening world. Newspaper, November 16, 1911, Page 4

THE EVENING WORLD, THUR Mother: Judge Dike Contronted by a Problem Demanding Wis- dom Like That of Solomon to Decide Claims to ‘Possession of Two-Year-Old John Joseph Livingston. Young Mother, Who Seeks to Pay Arrears of Little One's; Board, Finds Him Legally Adoptea by Mrs. Hyman, > Who Refuses to Surrender Charge She Says Was Abandoned. Swige Norman 8. Dike will need the wisdom of Solomon to decide the claims of two rival mothers wh the Kings County Court to-morrow. ich will be presented before him in The child of contention is John Joseph—his ‘other name is yet to The other woman, Mrs. Sarah Hyman, declares that she has taken alt e I Love Baby, So He’s Mine, Mine Because He’s My Son, Asserts Mother w Baby tor Whom Saijs Fostér- a Ee at. te ie Rival Mothers “War SDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 1911. saying he was Mrs, Livingston's brother, {He asked about the child, but said she was In Toronto and couldn't send any money now. When he left my house he was followed. and ho met Mra. Living: | stone herscif just around the block ‘That looks as if she were very anxlous | to come and see her baby, doesn’t It? I want to keep Joseph cause I love him, but by J can bring him up to b happy boy. eeciligacinsans HOLD-UP MAN STICKS TO PROFITABLE ZONE. FOR OWL WAGON SHOOTING. les Kuhn Admits Killing Foster in Jersey City, But Pleads Self-Defense. Charles Kuhn, twenty-five years old, was held without bail in the First Criminal Court, Jersey City, to-day' on a charge of shooting and killing Louls Foster, twenty-six years ofd, of No. 10 Ty. place, Jersey City, in Enoch Abel's lunch wagon at Garfield and |Communtpaw avenues. not only be- use IT know good and | Foster, but declared that he had shot {in defense. Shortly before the killing Enoch Abel put several young men out of his owl wagon, They threatened him and he volver out the window to attention of the police. Terring came along and ar- He Shoots at a Man and Gets $52. WINSTED, Conn., Nov. 16.—The third! hold-up within a month in the section |» between New Hartford and Collinsville took place it night. A young man, w: F. WH. Howard, a ¢ el. a friend of the lunch wagon man, was {n the neighborhood, and he at the farmhouse of Ei volunteered té look after the wagon on the outskirts of Collins: | witle Abel was in the Police Court. re hards is employed by the Col-| erring and his prisoner had been lins Manufacturing Company and lives gone only a few minutes when three alone. He drew his pay yesterday. young men entered the wagon and be decided, He wae two years old yesterday, and one woman, Mrs, | After Howard had inspected the cattle | bought sandwiches and open, Acoord- a & oo tate | and had offered a fa 1 yo\ ing to Kuhn, they? refused to pay. Myrtle Livingston, asserts that he is and always has been her baby. feentered the house,” Richarda, wag i There wax a row and a fight. Kuhn : he face with a coffee drawing up papers of sale, when How-| S29 Struck In the £ Rt lant the care of John Joseph since Re was five months old, and that Mrs ard shot at htm from behind, the bullet |fesen tor his hip pocket and feared ine Livingeton deliberately abandoned him. Mrs. Hyman holds adoption Fe eeerey t aee | Beward seized | wat going to shoot $8 Down on $50 ttl heh ; him, snarling, “What I want Ix tie; Kuhn took a revolver fi helt papers made owt last summer, Mra. Livingston says they are invalid, money you got at the ehop to-day.”" baad irl Phe wallet plerecet doctors $5 “ « 9% Decumae her conaent wee never obteined, | In the struggle the robber felled Rioh-!heart and he dropped dead, His com- | $7.50 « $100 The bitter contest between the two women is emphasized by the difference mw their types. Yesterday Mrs. Hyman's pleasant gray eyes were red-rimmed with weeping. 4s still spare and erect, her face keen and intelligent fa a young woman, still in her ¢ cheeked- and pretty. Here is the story told by cach: BY MRS. LIVINGSTON. Joseph is my son. He was born here (@ Brooklyn two yeare ago, and I have Never resigned my claims to him. 1 never abandoned my baby! 1 would be fneapable of doing such an utterly swioked and heartless thing, and besides I love him too dearly. Ho is my baby, and it nearly broke my heart when | heard that he had been adopted by the Hymene, 1 iad merely, given him to them to bard because T could not take care of him any other way just then end I had to think of his welfare first. b vith sweet oll and ale There was nothing secret or underhand Hia father left _me before he waelto the house, she was passing throuuh| make nim strong and well, “Now hers a | about It ra ie with each of these seasonable offers: Dora, and when he was « few the hall and I met her. poor little | > . . looking ye Along in the middle of the summer, “eer 5 old I realised that I could get no Work | thing wax crying his eyes out. It had|Sreat bigs healthy looking a year | Peerles Cocoa, perfect liquid food; can..... L'Te eo long aa T kept him with me. I took She is a grandmother, but her figure Mrs. Livingston arly thirties, tall, blue-eyed, rosy- BY MRS. HYMAN. If Joseph had been my own could not have done more for hin I have done since he was five old. I have four children, but they are all grown, and Joseph is my bavy! 1 have fed him, clothed him, petted him and developed him from @ sickly little thing to a fine, splendid boy. Both I and my husband love hin as if he be longed to us, and we want to bring him up and educate him to the very best advantage. I remember the first day I saw him, when Mrs. Livingston brought him here older than he is, and # nothing in the | ards, Getting the pay envelope, contains | panions fled, Herring got back on post Ing $62, from his victim's pocket the fai [Just in time to arrest Kuhn, who was low fled, Richards went to Collinsville |jeaving the Innch wagon with the re- | and reported the robbery. His descrip-|yoiver In his hand. | tlon of the robber tallies exactly with that of the man who robbed L. 8. Ma-| Magasine Writer Weds, Misa Reatrice Lawrence, son, a neighbor of Richards, on Monday | night of last week and on'a preceding ughter of Mr. and Mrs, Seabury Law- rence of No. 905 West Fifty-fifth street, Saturday waylaid three Collinsville women. ey | | | A NY LAO hide winaind a8 coer caunsive AOGMMITEED WIRHOUT BAIL | [se giivind inst wait Toons 2) Biteetive Home REMCOy jam Sul + in St. Stephen's Episcopal Church at Broad- way and Sixty-ninth street by the Rev. Dr. Beagle —— PASTOR TO SUE FOR LIBEL. Dida’t Write to M Wife, but to) ter, He Snya, Nov. 16,—Egidius ter Pres: byterian Church of Chester, Pa, came here to-day with two mombere of his congregation to deny charges made by William F. Van Arsdale of Titusviile, " Pt ge} Pa. Van Arsdale alleged that there hid titected, sand cannot praise ee pane, Prisoner admitted to Jee | been wecret meetings between the min- |iekual', Alt i In Third Robbery Within a Month ' ister and his wife, and that the minister | mendel it had written Mrs. Van Arsdale a love letter. | In his statement the minister says | |that the letter was not intended for Mrs. Van Arsdale at all, jdaughter, He adds that he proposes to prosecute Van Arsdale for libel. Mrs. | Van Aredale is suing her husband in| }the ‘Trenton courts, { but for her |} for Tuberculosis * Tt is a serfous matter when the trees affected, “A tri: away or to a ganatoritim 6 nut gly tromehdously exvensive, but it \donfield, Nv “ ven told ine At this time Twas terative, 1 stayed a it fhe last Wee! ‘gained . “having Ith Tt te tow five Alterative, is y Rever, Throat and Hie system, 1 habit-forming Hiker drug stores and other k for booklet of, peat. Bekman Laboratory, Philadel MICHIGAN FURNITURE CO ing, oF between f oon} Just have your maid or butler serve yor a cup of a |BEHREND’S BOUILLO Easy to make: One Behrend’s Bouillon Cuve in n with otling 9 F ip the an nent postpaid Free Henrenay 3 "ront Attractive Offers This Week at All the 200 James Butier Inc. Stores 3s Granulated Sugar 22° 102 Stamps FREE runs free; OPEN EVENINGS UNTIL ©. been raining outside, and his clothes | Wworia but my care that’ responsible Blue Ribbon Salt, ES ein AOS him along when I visited a friend Who) werg and wretched anyway. Tete tha: Seas. year he waa @1ehothe | A carton, had a goer lat Mra, Hyman’, ands] "T'fugt held out my_arme to him and| yi mother hid cons wo roe him. nat ane || OW TO Keep Hair Blue Ribbon Farina, °“ meeting Mrs. Hyman in the hall, | h®P | he snuggied his little head closo down| never showed the slightest sign of af- Soft and Beautiful 9 large packa, pened to mention that I wae looking for « pi to board my baby. She agreed to take care of the child for $10 @ month, and I ‘was to furnish hie clothes. This arrangement began May on my warm shoulder and stopped cry- ing right off. Mrs. Livingston suggested that I board | him, as @he said she had to work and | couldn't kvep a child with her. She hax fection for him, If he had been playing | and got himself m the way every i} healthy baby will, she'd call hm a “dirty | “Too much moisture saps the life of | little animal.” } scalp tissues and hair-roo! T had not agen her since the end of |an excessively oily conditio! Celery Salt, Pecricss, trcs grated; br ttle Prepared Mustard, [3.00.1 ™ style; bettle....eee- (ane Tyrel, on Beayty) CHOICE GROCERIES @ 1910, when Joseph was five and a half months old. 1 kept up my payments for a year, and om May 6, 1911, 1 paid Mre, Hyman the Balance due her for the month ending om that date. For alx weeks after that 1 wae not working and had no attaes money she owed me. The rstand- | summer. joughly reliable preparation can be A ore keep e pa: ing Was that sh id clot him, | Finail, a city of dvised ii i A sey. Ghocetore t could not Keep ud the DAY: ing wes that she should clothes him, | Finally, in Bae charities oe, | nue, at Uttle: cost. b _iniring either Sclected 1 ~ in cartons 27 Oran es Large, juicy, new fruit 25¢ quarter to buy him some little thing. |Partment, as it was evidently aba eae tharos. One teil ful 1g —dozen... 9 from Porto Rico; dozen But for over a year I have pald for; doned. didn't want to do that, be ¢ y je tablespoontal > ED earn 1 went to work on July 10 last, month later, with, my first month's pi I came to Brooklyn and went straight to see my child. Mrs, Hyman said the child was rot in. She refused to tell where he was, She asked me if I hi come to take the child away, but said nothing about having adopted him. 1 had the money to pay her what I owed her for the boy's board, but I decided net to pay her because she refused to Jet mo see him. I called several times davery Poin oI \oro'my baay, eo sian, New Daies, Eweet, clean, nutritious, Ib,..... 10°] Seedeu Raisins, tech rew fruit, package 10° Pid on, charity: IMLEL - Pulled Figs, in bee-hive baskets, each 19°| Cleaned Currants, -rie importation, pkge. 12 wien thy, and he told eet pele: a 7 Regular 10c¢ I a ee ral aa 5 JAC Stamps FREE) aus ay baby since the end of last April | 6th Ave 18th serve all mite ci ey re aa ena i Corner Street queky can of,... Belle Brook Saltines, made a practice of paying Joseph two or thron visits a week. Every time | ‘went to Mra, Hyman’s in June no one anawered the bell. | # that ahe Dought ‘Cap na ap| Thick as cream; Cc Baby c Liberty c regular tall 10c size Wafers:na Brand, 9 can this week. . can : her the privilege of buying th r ‘when I could not come to Brooklyn, but I paid for it. The reason I-refused to tell Mrs. Hy- man where I lived last spring was be- | cause she has made untrue statements | About me in the past to my employers, and has on several occasions been the | cause of my losing positions, I believe 4 has been Mrs, Hyman's intention for | & long time past to get my child away | from me. Tam ready to made up any artears of | ‘board to Mrs. Hyman, and a good friend has opened her heart and house to Joseph and me, so that we may ve to- | gether. I am well fitted to take care of him and give him the right sort of bringing up, and he 's my baby ond 1 ‘Won't let any one take him away! co Bethe lon a TWO CHANGES IN MAKE-UP OF YALE VARSITY ELEVEN. _ Phone Audubon 4701 14th st hone. Flats WEW HAVEN 16—The time te y ‘ : Wintamabei ge 233, Ave Matbasn ats °S “A: over for changes on the Yale) Vv outh ni OF im oe Yonkers 412 ° bush 165%, Seratty Two shifts Wine made yestor- Moust V Re MOkh Verase ERO: Ls fi "hone Hempstead 223, @ay which are likely to be permanent for the greater part of the champion- ship games. ‘The changes were the substitution of Gallauer for Paul at right tackle the suLstitution of Spalding for oman, * changes would the team, but bec Wiha dat Bias" stnn ond ||| Suits that 7 5 ‘7 ©6«| Suits 7 5 Old. Crow Rye, tic tt, 80° Irish Whiskey, Scie ta?’ $1.15 Pestle Me rortne'ss ||| | Were yee 08D] Neo [Shae ° Kingussie Scotch, in'ucr"" '79°| French Brandy, isc $1.25 y in the game, Paul ha S : . ¥ vay . Goua 4" ore! e Pace ieee || [eens fo otis | reatesa’ to Guinness’s Stout, bin, *1- fir $1-| Bass. Ale, ban, §1% Bae oy 10 Judges Lacombe, the United States Circuit Court, denied the motion of the Tobacco associations for permiasion to intervene in the Tobace Trust case, The Court also denier the application of the Independents to be made parties to the sult and have the decision of the Circuit Court approving the Trust's plan for dis- solution reviewed. When he filed his petition Felix Levy said that, if it w pei nts would appe: Soprome Sut Would aot be doue, ay Independent awyer ented, to the ——————— i COURT BARS INDEPENDENTS. joyes and Ward, in always refused to tell me where she lived or where the child's father was, @he brought him back the next day, and | I began to be his mother. From the first she only paid on the installment pian, and I never got all the Practically all his clothing out of my own pocket. He was weak and thin when he came |] petitioned to adopt it, all made out in to me. I spent hours and hours rub- \|GRE weeks come ti her all made m | thing w \ were Women’s & Misses’ last April of money for his I didn’t know who would get it, and it |} until she appeared ago to claim Joseph. She didn’t | ‘stringy, 0 see him in May or in any of| and she owed a lot | abl rd. I tried to find | through the early part of the 5 ne feel bad to think that the little | this a would not receive good care, So | healthy con d the papers Every i thtee | harsh, dandruff. can be obt h ugh for « shampoo. i few times the scalp is put in a ition and the hair takes | on a soft fluffines regular form, | luster and natural co “The most delightful results imagin- ed, if w dry shampoo | 1 ‘through the hair| Sale Starts SUIT CLEARANCE Adhering to our former policy of not carrying over suiis from one season to another, we tnaugurate this drastic clearance, offering 2,300 Suits at the Lowcs! Prices on Record. D. PRICE & CO., Gth Ave., Cor. 18th St. After | ‘The best Sweet Potatoes, 0"'"” 3 vs. 10¢ Red Onions, (.i3"-"o"" 3 bs. 10¢ Cooking Apples, 2... 6 os. 15¢ Rice, As nourishing as the highest priced, 3 Ibs. ] qe Rolled Oats, Fresh from the mill, 3 Ibs. 12¢ 3 lbs. BSe N ew Prunes, Meaty and full of Rich and Pure Butler Brand, can. - Jams Blue Ribbon Violet Ammonia, to: tu- ban; bottte 4, Evapcrated Mik Also with each can of the FAMOUS Baker’s Cocoa... Huyler’s, Purest and best, 7° Regular 22c can, Codfish Threads, Yeerless, large pkg+ sc Pancake Flour, Blue Ribbon Syrup, Buckwheat Fiour, Prepared Flour, sunt Nanna’s, large par kage... Large COD. ceeee eeriess prepared, large package Leerless, large package..... . los 1oc 13¢ 13¢ Nabisco Baronets from nal Biscuit Company, Condensed Milk 10° froém pure, rich whole milk, this week...... traits lve AZ 60 ZH glass jar... with 1 lb. of Best Teas Your choice of Formosa-Oolong, India-Ceylon, English Breakfast and Mixed, for.......+.+++- package... +. Stamps FREE} |Special 2-4 Stamp Premiums 2O Stamps with 1 Ib. Very Best Coffee.... 35¢ 50¢ 10 Stamps with 1 1b. Choice Coffee....... 30e 10 Stamps with 1 |b. Ideal Blend......... 23e Brooklyn—Phone Legs of Spring Lamb...........lb.14c Corned Beef, Pie, N ivek of Brisket ...Lb. 7@ Fresh Jersey Hams, Selected.....Lb. 14c} Short Forequarters of Mutton, Lb. 6c WEG EET AGT SER! SNE er ee BU BORE FS 2 ela eer Veen le eae Oe On ene W SRe High-Grade Wines & Liquors at All the 117 James Butler Inc. Licensed Stores Pili tai acca eat Aa A OE 50 gv’ Stamps FREE + with each of the following purchases: O'd Monogram Rye Whiskey, botte.....'75e | Imported Port, Castillo Cabinet, bottle... 75e Old Cabinet Whiskey, ? ui quent boe.. $1-° | Imported Sherry, Giralds Solera, bottle... T5e Princeton Cocktails, mMooiattan and Martini, bot, THC Donyel Kummmel, double grain, bottle... 7 5e Tryseme Brandy, exceptional value, bottle... 7§e | California Claret, pure grape, half gallon, 50c Superior Gin, 0 Tom or Holland, bottle... 75¢ | Lager Beer, teasing tlome vrews, case of 24 bottles, G00 Including Sugar, « Stamps FREE with All Purchases, tis 50 ZA Stamps FREE with each of the following purchases: