The evening world. Newspaper, January 9, 1911, Page 1

hr « — WRATHER— ‘Tuesday; col E DITION | “ Circulation Books Open to All.”’ | to All.”' dd YORK, MONDAY, JANUARY 9, 1911. 16 PAGES PRICE ONE CENT. BOROUGH PRESIDENTS, OUR mS sh rs CARNEGE SAD TO HOLD. DOYOURECALLYQUR nassau ha =) $700,000 NITE OF anti — | Miss sing Chamberlain Is Ex- Dr. Louise Robinovitch in Cell -PLEDGES (IN N SUBWAYS? pected at Official Inquiry in Detault of Bail on Per- ~ CARNEGIE TRUST MEN CT] Into City Deposits. jury Charge. ——— o> & PRICE ONE ‘CENT. HOLD BACK PAY. GIVEN UP BY JEROM |CAN ‘he Evening World Sends These ‘Open Letters to Heads of City — Court Refuses Injunction in Accusation Is Based on Denial Government Who Will Act Taxpayer’s Suit—Mayor of Parents Made in Court on Grab To-Morrow Defers Inquiry. Action. Cummins Group Borrowed From | Ironmaster to Close Up Madison | Trust Co. Deal, the Report in Wall Street. || MORGAN CASH CHECKS RUNS ON THREE BANKS. According to or a ‘ . ¥ jen je, the mi The Board of Estimate and Appor ent will to-morrow receive | cnain ite #4 ods a Board, from its members as a committee of the whole, on oMice ; Hal! te subway g¢ ‘oposition o subway grab position of t rent requ then be in form for ptance of a monopol 1% Dr, Tanise Rankw ent from hl | 6 the 4 obtnovitch, sister of g City Cha Robin, was sent ‘om ate thie afternoon fh the City fault of $3,000 dteted on a cha of per in ¢ William ‘T._Jerome, after an indietin vad been filed base t Mr, and Mrs, Herman Rablnoviteh. are parents of the bj The chars made in) the after she had been n response to an om Comptroller William the Mayor is expected e Interb fompany. The matter he Board on the rejection or of transit facilities. The ‘ ; n to inquire | ee will be by the vote of each member as a unit, ‘The tinal ballot} tiat nave arisen as a result of Mr. Ofsthe Board will be under the 2pportionment provided by charter. Hyde's long continued absence from : . = . his desk and is duties. A new and alate aspect is put eH om the matier by the Tax Com-| Justice Gort Supre render ene the Munieipal Banking © the complications nal ballot of 9 con ird’s report as a | miss on | All Demands Met Promptly and Number of | Timid Depositors Falls Off—Other Con- ik wrecker and herself, enw statement rhe n Court this ffidavit wileh accompanied j ease fternoon denied tue app ication of the zs biog plats . sioner cert tony, shoving an increase in re esate assesment |S" Gg ee vo hee fast cerns May Absorb the Nineteenth Wh brings the city’s hore capacity to $150, C 5 pans, sulng as a taxpayer, for an ins iephcsanoait eg 2 bo BI hb hahies i c Ig capac 150,000,000, more ine junction. restraining Comptroller Pren-| Goff. in the Supreme Court, for the ap- and Twelfth Ward. ough to build the entire system proposed by the Interborough. Gergart trom paying to Hyde his salary Polntment of a committee of the person In the me ng Work writes these open letters to ter December, re and property of Robin, In which she set - oom A is these open letters t seems bighly probable that for sev.) forth that she and’ a brother were the a s - , 4 é Borough Presidents: era! days past Mr. Hyde haw been |i) only next of kin y With all danger of a bank panic following the failure of the Carnegie . “ the immediate vicinity of > York, Hers Rabin. y id Elka Ravine Dr OUISE . . 5: Hveatina j i ‘ he Hon. Alfred E. ‘steers, Mile. friends) and’ Aly oftice. Atal were |viten, the saiediacet Hoslni and of. On | RABLNOVITCH : ‘Trust Company apparently dissipated by the prompt intervention of the re) oe ng that he mus: stili be off Rovinovitch, appeared before the Grand + ‘ van interests, financial circles were alive to-ds fi ssi President of the Borough of Brookiyn: the Hlorlal: coset: on &vduok huntiigloarys WhICh NOMA beeplal aan reel ee Coie | Morgan interests, financial circles were alive to-day with gossip about Pete sir—By reason of a 1c sveer of integrity a# a citizen in private life|expedition and while the legisiative day to consider the charges brought Venta note for $2,000,000, said to be held by Mr. Carnegie and executed Magistrate in priviic lite . of your borough elected you to the grafting-hunting commission was pa-/against Dr. Rovinovitch oy the Dk ich ine hest position in t ss gift a year st November. You have now held the | tiently awaiting {ts chance to question | attorney. « by members of the so called Cummins group, which was in control of the office to whi mu elected for fifty-three weak: him regarding his alleged share in the — | i k ies The people of Brooklyn elected you on a platforia which | raising of the half-million dollar cor- dward Robinson Calied. institution that bears the iron master’s name. ontained this plank ruption fund that 1s sald to have been| award Robinson, another son, was rite when William Al-7 ‘The Madison ‘Trust Company will be ‘All future subways shall be Wuilt and owned by — used to. defeat the anti-race-track bills nec ged scares wees Eee | ten Butler, counset for Mr. Carnegie, | Nquldated by the Rauttable Trust Cone . the city and either operated b; 4 r pares . Gas a witness. | - Ka A Press it 7, Recent A ater fiGodah ceoeead in the in. in 1908, ‘ julred to remain in ante- | gave out through the Associated Prea#/ pany. The Nineteenth Ward Bank and under terms | Comptroller Urges Deliberation. } | n statement rehearsing the objection Mr.|Twelfth Ward Bank will probably be : room until the twenty-three jurors filed | | yh Soe ce eee ee troller Urger Deliberation. [room ust the | Carneule made at the titme of the for-| consolidated with other banking inter- TErOY T: ‘EE: ” The C y to Part 1. to present | | . ay Fl aetaamene Y iy 1d ee eal preside ae hic salon senger to-day the following communtca- | the indictment to Judge Swann, mation of the Carnogie Trust Company | eats an 90 nas their affairs are atraleht- rere hae io Whe: Bvakion op to the elecYon of tion to Mayor Gaynor A dramatic scene occurred as Mrs to the use of hia name, The story out. Both banks and thetr branches CIRGTG. the LATLOATIONC CUETO thee ek ene voure |) In Haw recent occurrences Rabinoviteh, who saya she is Robi passed around that Mr. Carnegie, whtle| are tdeally located for business, the — self to the T avenue loop and the Flatbush ex: = P tin the trust (Twelfth Ward n p and atbt Sie Daarvine dries tucier Es - he may have had no tnterest In rust ‘Twelfth Ward Bank In One Hundred and temsion in Brooklyn, and you sald specific tain banking Institut moth aught sight of Robinson, 1 interest in| Twenty-fifth street having exceptional Ny in that tions the city Is inte: old wor * & pronounce an ran up to him and threw —— company, 1 ae 1 an ih favor ¢ faa ipal ownership of the naitor, I consi it very im- | nM around hit, men who controlled tt | advant sat the closing of the subways and hearti!y subscribe to the provisions in th ; ai ey ee fs ty s Cte CG ast Ss 4 dle wy) a : Northern Bank, its neighbor, Somos wiattorn cunt une AS) Ne! porta there should be a me fy boy, Bddie, my bey. te ot United States Circuit Court of Shonis and Hedley Confer! — Result of Medison Trust Deal. rinaee: el It aaieies aa. You: will recall tha sidered your pledge tw Ti ing of jhe Banking Commission | woman sobbed. Th: she turned to the i | Th the pantie of 1907 Mr. Carnesie went |.) it ee pp SM cet pegs Feo, Sot CAN il achemcal Sone our pledge to The) mediately. May 1 sus Grand Jurore and Distriet-Atiorney aie ae rh ith Chie iy lin the reacte of the Carn Trost} edison ‘Trust Company.” seid: Align Livening World of enough importance to mendit to the ofe| Mets eas Whltnanant Asuitant minim | Appeals Reverses Finding | With Chief Official Oppo- [to the rescue of the carn wun, |W. Keech, President of the Equitable tice of this newspaper by a relative, specially delegated to| ferconal convenience, such | tiey Clarke and oxclaimed wt} . ; H * | Be elaine 15 tl uctian to pre- | Trust Company, this afternoon, “wii comm ) the hands of the editor. Undoubtedly at that Personal convent nes | ae UTR Getaee in ane of Lower Tribunal. nents of Subway Grab, | ventempt ecaniters trom naming the [NOt be fully consummated for @bout time 9 emed the exploitation of your stand on the sub-| “T aisa suggest the Acti where | ls, vigor afte: tain, It ia reported now |*Xt¥ days, ‘Thin period will give ample fAvestion of weight in ry te feellngs of the voters of your borough. | Chamberlain, Mr. y J, Walsh, | Old man Rabinoviten echoed: “Yes, | ) that when Cummins and hie associates time for stockholders’ ineetings and to remind you that at the tne you signed The Hvenin | wig in also secretary of the Banking | that's Hadle. That's Kudve.” | The United States Ciroult Court of} ‘Theodore P. Shonts, Pretident, and | eee een soa ce nent trom the Van {other legal formalities. Our part in the a Shad plate atest aya felis WBN ictal ppm Manip bat! Commission, be requested to produce Robinson, who 1s undersized and has) Appeals this afternoon reversed ¢ Trank Hedley, Vice-President and Gen-| Norden’s they did not have mo | Regotiations has been arranged by our Proposition thu Spans and woaduiynrtin euetencahae ne She: Ae for the consideration of the Commis: | geraggly xray locks, was taken entirely | judgment of Judge Hough's Court in @fal Manager of the Interborough| gnough to awing the deal and were com- | lawyer, John Quinn, We nave pledged p of Munhattan, the m that has now come) sign at ita meeting a certain guaran- | unaware by hia parents, He had been| >. 8 % § Transit Company, calted on| pejied to put up thelr Madison Trunt | oursel first, to guarantee the de bake known as the Triborough system and for which bids were opened on Oct.| fen ohtained by me last July, cover- Kent in Atterdgnorahce of thele presence | Shar, oF the. Walden) Motor’ Compan: c ndergast at his, ofice|Gonpeny holdings as collateral for loans |Poslts, second, to Mauidate the eom- i by the unio Rarvice Gomisiasion. a ah rs sete + the Pup.| Ime the depostes made by the city in |in'the jury. room. He nally recovered sash ine Panhard, Ford and other Rr BE ny itn | earnraniy OLA aN OF RE Sony and eiviae the geeste emanate ¢ Interborough had no offer to bu oper. bway befe > the Pub-| ihe Carnegie Trust Company, which : | automobile manufacturers, sued by Mr. | oanip | stockholde’ Mee The amarborouah Thess Te monepiea teat reeeetes eons uarantes was delivered to the alsin trons Mis derome'e anise queen? Gelden for aeged infringement of the Mime rondergusta otite poh thik teabelbenan te cali on the| “Tt is likely thet we shall continue e that the Interbore woule © monopolize the underground trans-| ‘ aad : . ‘ Mr. Prenderm ‘ kgs j 7 tation system of the city, ‘The people elected you and your associates on| Chamberlain, Mr. Charles H. Hyde, | a group of reporters, [Selden patent in the motors used bY | President of ihe Board of Aldermen| Cummins group for money. ‘Then, tt lajthe operation of the branch of | the Roerd of Estimate with the single purpose of securing as *00n ag posaible| 4st October. Is Not Sure. | them in their automobiles was called Into the conference. | reported, Cumming and his aanoctates | Madison Trust Company on the Bowery. Independent suvway line to relieve the intolerable conditions prevailing in There are other questions that I. | «Are those your parents?” he was| The opinion of the Court was written| The visit of Mr, Shonts and Mr. Hed-| borrowed $2,000,000 from Mr, Carnegie, |But it is a question If we shoul ire ‘existing subway of the Interborough, would like to submit to the Commis- | agyed by an Evening World reporter. | py Judge Noyes, who holds that th ed considerable excitement| giving a note and a lot of collateral, \to operate our own Fifth avenue branch Do you Welieve that in voting to consider the proposition of the rm. sion, and TF trust it will be con- “Of that Iam not ure," came the| otto improved machine ised by the y Hall, Mr, Prendergast| The note is sald to bear the signatures at Fiftieth street and the newly Cugh vou are adhe~ing to your campaign pledges? Are you not aware =| Venlent to have the meeting to-day, | jaiting reply. “I know these people and | gory company and othore le the eauly el are, as ts knows, |of William J. Cummins, J, B, Reich-/dulred main banking house of the Mad:- t the énterborougl ‘fer cuts out the Broadway end of the Lafayette as sugested know them weil. We came to this coun. | FOd company & ! record pposed to grauthag| mann, Martin J. Condon, Samuel H, Trust Company at Sixtieth street Maen \nep? } Believe me, yours very truly, try with them, As a Younsater 1 al.| lent of the Seldon engine, hut udde th it ties mperel See eee ay ke Macrant Fifth avenue. One of these witi Is there any reas¢ why yon should vote to consider a monopoly of | ‘S/sned) WM. A. PRENDERGAST Ways thought they v my father and | the defendant companies do not infringe | qunway extensions to te yrougi| lowing Ia the text of a letter given Prebdably be closed when we get around ubway transportation when you pledged yourself to ‘definitely and posi- Mayor Defers Till To-Morrow. Wut of late years things fap. | by employing it as an element of the the form of contract submitted by | out by Mr, Butler thin morning and ree 0 It eee tively protect the inti ests of the citizens?” ‘To which the Mayor replied that made us think differentiy, | motor vehicles. t teoretion report} ny him fre rhegie move The Madison ‘Trust Company as an — Deur Mr. Prenlergast—L came over | In fact, both my brother and I believe "While the concluston of the non-in- 34 nats Dtast Uraeaeee|t mir yea ee ae ete pissy ; 7 = Jate to-day, after being In bed yes- | they are not our Here ne fringement which we have reached r k oon th Dorboch, She Lnaielaineia tana cae e Hon. George McAneny, | terday with an apparent attack of | paused a moment, as {f hesitating to) leaves the patentes em unded with | Intesburo that been tnade aM, Aug. 19, 1008 ne hades se yy ident of the Borough of Manhattan: | the grippe, and found your note | speak. nm suddenly: “In fa espect to his patent for the # ume | nw of the fs hat the Board of} William Allen | to us as an institutto coed oaniret: : : here. 1 have to leave early to-day. | evidence which proves that t aso run,” sald Judge No it Hatimate may tuke action to-morrow, Sir ne ago I re Ss Hiplacgedpelipar teins ati ear Sir—In the election of 14) you were chosen by the people of the Bor-| 1 should not have come over at all | our parents.” annot be regarded as depriving him onts and Mr. Hedley ved a) fT would ob- | iese banks. Our transaction was close! j of Manhattan to represent them tn the city government with particular! and am doing only those things | “lave you seen them lately?” he wa»| through any technicality of eH ken critics $8] Sect to the y name for m | bY acquiring the stock of the Madison ence to affairs directly affocting their borough. At that time the p: which have to be done to-day. I hope | next asked. reward for his labors, He undoubted " the) fnancial institution, I wrote to the | ‘Trust Company. We do not control the mount tssue before the people was relief from the disgrace-| 1 shall be better to-morrow, and “Yes, I saw them once a month for| appreciated the possibilities of the mo- |. - sbWwa Song, "| effect that I preferred that It should | Nineteenth Ward or the Twelfth Ward ful conditions attending the transportation of passengers) wien I cone over J shall try to ar ea }tor at @ time when his ideas w igi chel and} Rot be used: that It wasa great mis- | Banks, the deposits of which are being through the subway within the borough mits, range a meeting of the Banking Com- | (Continued on Second Page.) |arded as chimerical. Had he been Prendergast declared noth«| take to name anything after a man | cared for by J. P, Morgan & Co.” You ran fer office on a platform which committed you ————- | si zm able to see fav enough he might have! int had occurred during the intery eit living, Knowing that € was Banking Situation Cleared. to vote for future subways to be built by the elty and (Continued on ma Aisons Page) | faker Guha af ab taxcrenching anit 1 attitude powerless in the matter I did not Through the action of the Morgan in- ‘either operated by th Aty in the Interest of the Cire G r . one way tivel vefuse, because that would | tere: taken after a consultation last he citizens | 7s the Circult Court held this one was shied ; se Undeentena t “Be 4 . or ite leased under toma that will Griitly a pal 900,000,000 Hak ike another tnve ule ; er eof no avail, ae T nderstand tha all of Saturday night, through Sun ts of the citizens." You a) ADDED TO CITY’ and in framing that platform, T certain wted that T e banking situation, which looked very ammveds he went In che WOME PACKERS MUST STAND TRIAL,| "a And, in addition, prior to election you willingly TAXING VALUES.) (ction , ne uaadh A ave | squalls: on Saturda ae been cleared ned o to the peoples + n The Even - = o ‘Braston engine ni teal " rn i “ Jup. The withdrawals of to-day were Somntlltign Yoursst to ibe LUGMhGERAEe ee ee ee | aanien actvatore ne nto, cs Woiker|{| Whe Sas Comimissionees’repertea'|| The Branien, soning wes ihe. leading COURT DENIES APPEAL, 000 oof ine e NiUeawal of system then in the public mind an independent) gtreet, a workman on the tracks of the || t? Mayor Gaynor that nparly $900- } oi wiy dey to its supposed MMCAGO. Jan. 9—Judgo Qvorgo a. | ahi ee Acco , « custom, there ubway. In ‘hat pledge you gatd Metropolitan eet” Hallway, was | 000,000 had been added to the vantages that type. Tn the | carpenter, in the t Btates Iiatrict | Ranks SAV eH From Ryle ages brie haiedbyiih doc “The city should be kept in @ position to bulld | aught between a south-bound cay and |'sewsed value of real estate in this} ich: of ans nl int toeda tthe Motlon ot iie| ‘The action of the J. 1, Morgan bank: | to ¢ ing the morning, when for itself and to control the use of its own proper- ja trick at West Broadway Kuane |] ity, ‘This 2dds more than $80,000,- | reciat« en { it packers that. criminay |S house and Mr. Morgan's Eqult ala vd sified nto the main banks and I can see no contingency at present under streets this afternoon and knocked un- | 000 to the borrowing capacity of the | x! ‘ nine | prosecution againat them be forbidde: rust Company in guaranteeing the | Ins house of the Nineteenth Ward Bank it would or should be required to do differ. the car * city, Including the present margin, the modern a nou a plea wa ade on t nive Poss of the Nineteenth Ward Hank, the! at Pifty-seventh street and Third aver Oo MCANENY A tremendous crowd gathered that!] tue city may borrow nearly $160,- Ho made the wrong voice andy whe te of ‘twelfth Ward Hank and the Madison| nue, customers were pald off at the rate Have your viens changed since you panned thie senti-| plocked all traMe in West Broadway |] (69.900 after July 2 5 peed a RP Race ul A Ea ADD: auved thowe Institutions ar a aut {ou an ae The odtedra we t had a great deal to do with your election? Are nd watehed an ambulance surgeon and|} 7 is spon Y ait J a 1p n from disastrous runs to-ds ured he old depositor at the in- rae i bees egg a “contingency” has arisen? vey ee ee or @aivatore out, He et The total assessed velue of real} ips ‘ Py | a Ars Ago agalNeL BUCK prace Phere were many withdrawals of ac-| atitution was sound. A majority of those It was on your motion that the Interborough proposition, which had no om: | taken to Hudson Street Hospital with|] estate this year te 97,941,241,357; |) oj oice for t tice, Contempt proceadings, argued ¢ jounte, but as the Gay wore on and the] who drew out money were women and ela) life at the time of your election, was referred last Thursday to the Board of | serious internal injuries, last year it was §7,064,192,7. defendant it wer Bch ise) method oj understanding that the deposits were se-| they were mostly patrons of the savings Fatimate as a Committee of the Whole for “deliberation,” Included tn the ——>.— Details of the ssments will || morally owe him anything. | Pee Gut enter eat ihe packera ten{ eure by the strongest flgancial institu | departments. proposition of the Interborough is the plan to third-track the Third and Second World Building Turkish Bathe ne found on Page 16 of today’s || “The decree of the Clroult Court 1" | gays for any furthe pinay ine. | tions of the elty became generally din- Rur. Soon Lets Up, Fvening World. revoked with costs and the cause re-| tions they might des! co make before! seminated the crowds at the banks and| Bradley Martin jr, President of the (Continued on Second Page.) manded with inetructions to dismiss," pleading to the indictments, their branches dwindled away, neteenth Ward Bank, to whose efforts ‘ # ‘ \ ! ow Peat SEL: AE aa SEL Ste ee ESHER He