The evening world. Newspaper, January 8, 1909, Page 1

aha tN oe A pennant A AOR OOSEVELT IN OWN ANANIAS DEFENSE RESTS IN THE HAINS TRIAL WUATHE Mitr tonight and oaturday, FINAL] @be e RES | LTS F DITI ON a Circulation Books Open to All.” i “Circulation Books Open to All." | PRICE ONE CENT, NEW TORE FRIDAY, JANUARY 8, 1909. PRICE ONE CENT. RL as en ar yg CANS ALENST DEALS HM HARD Wang le Vigorously Betore ls stice OE ‘rlanger, One In- }, \ BY CONGRESS Viting the Other to “Repeat Remark Outside,” a | a nimdae urea engl tiats i «atk ; _ Unique Bill of Particulars Viled | cage Perna Te) ste ae we eat in Woman's $50,000 ae ~~} a _ vice Slur Deckired i. vate Washi Wilh We Damage Suit Choir Singer Who Prefers Art Secret Service Slur Declared p+ Hate in Washington ei a Dama in Re lies Made b Dr Man- Without Basis of Fact amd jor winian neo) Ron to Husband Who Forbids Career ging Nepi y Ur. . a Breach of Privilege. He a SNES son to Cross-Questions of Darrin mi and the Judge Stun Pris- ip : : ; poration to Prince of Swindlers” Is Now TO TABLE HIS MESSAC Nftornesct i mee ; en | 2 . i TG in Europe With His Fair oner and Counsel. ‘Members of the House Send 6 wer a Stenagrapher, the President to His Own aM Aninias Club, STATE STARTS IN WITH TESTIMONY IN REBUTTAL ‘Begins by Calling Witnesses to Contradict Thornton Hains’s Statemeat That He Did Not Talk With Policeman Fallon at Inquest. vGVvx——————- 7 ilow Miss Magher ute Won the Love of Alfred 4¢. Goslin, fn full fighting trim got buck {dent Roose charges to jammed ¢ tiie She ate with him and she drank SeenTTAG hot pee Q 81h him. she smiled at tim, she vugge tim, she pushed hh she Kissed him, she looked at him, she J i — Powinked at hin and she admired him Jt rowed fnto the corr ” to admire hin. she | House and 03 0 i the Capitol, applauded tne 5 fooked al him longingly and ebal- dors) OF PS eee enged hinv to embrace her. She told Secbelcrippttig and, lashing him she loved and admired tim and Most of the Congressinen who odo anything in the world tor Afler one alienist had given it-a blow that jarred il all over, and sanother had gone through a cross-examination that did more harm than red ge in a At Mr, Roosevelt PIR she UAGgRIA, a Oven ined tinned and is ministering still.—rrom those why difter with him Crees Asie etn ee ) Report Opens the Fray. The fray was opened with the prese tation of the report of the spe. Gold Class Pin and a Pair of Gloves Also Reported as Having ——————$———— Hor aiding his brother Capt. Peter Hains, U. A., to kill William E. The most remar able bill of purtic- Ay ROE AG e rhe Drea ' Been Taken at Different Times From ; a fac aisat| j Annis, rested this afternoon. Gent's further views regarding the § Wardrobe of Same Class, Tvs presented! today by Mie) Algred Following the alienisis the State started to further tear down the t Servi lin his message ay h } hits 6 AUnerieuan 6 ntatives: Jast — Goslin, whose husband, known as the is ric of the ugle ensé with it Febultal, Monday: loprince Swindlers,” fled to Europe De. 1. Samuel Manson handed Hains bs lad Miss lore Moyers, daughter of; ed a gold class pin, whieh paonatell | ia " Accompanying ¢ PY a Myers, a druggist, at No. tached to atl t marnite j with his stenographer, Irene Magher, | | 8 y saying that on the day ae Sentra vee aut ted to| Numerous othor thefts, the loot rang in wus convicted in General Ses-| i © fthe murder Capt, Hains's mental con+ I deat Oe ti rey sine V High ing from handkerchiefs and gloves toj stuns, and jumped hs ball while the dition was such as to render him ia- Sein i ea eae Fourteenth | cloaks and silver-handled umbrellas, |case was on appeal. Mrs. Goslin sued | 2 of recognizing the face of his that the language of the message con. street and Seventh avenue, and to Misé have been reported within the last six| Miss Magher for $60,000 damages for or even bis name, if he heard Leshe ts, set w Ks, and , whose | without basis of {J ® authorities of the|alienation of her husband's affections stituted a breach {of furs had been stolen from her rack! school are much exercised over the|’The case was cal of the House the school wardrobe, matter I Justice Brady a dation was made that, A month ago Miss Myers had occasion! In the case of the theft of Miss|preme Court te sidered unjustified an fact. Alsv of the priv The reco at It ex for trial before | da jury in the Su- Here {8 the bi Fenemy, or F ts it spoken, allowing the possible infor- ence that, being incapable of deduction of initlative, it must have been Thorne tha objectionable portion to compiain of the theft of @ pair of) Meyers's furs the thief left a cheap}of particulars furnished by Mrs. Gi ton alia Who practically committed the i dent's annual message be Inid on | gloves, and a week before that she miss-, set of catskins in their place Jin after ex-dudge Olcott had secured Purge, een though the Captain held + ie tomatic gun. the table and that similar action be) - eee a court order 7 ; Hl taken with respect to the message of “From the nature of the action the ss «to pateh this rent in the last Monday because of its being “un- Knowledge of the facts is more with enses Dr. Manson made it more glaring | Teaponsive to the inquiry of the House,” Miss Magher than with me, and as she it ning his mind and saying that as to what the President meant when Jis now . and as I-am informed | Magistrate ey Guilty on}! ete dulnss mind awakened when he said, referring to the limitation and bell Paris, France, and ts) i Re rd the word Annis, and that he placed upon the fleld of operations of [not very apt to comply with a request Charges Presented by Bar Knew what he was doing when he the Secret Service, that the “chief }to state tle details of how she allenated ia, i started down the runway to shoot, and. avor of the provision ' the affections of my husband, how oft- De See Sen; Association. that his Impulsive manta’ probably argument in f the provi | was that the Congressmen did not them: od Oe es jen, when and where, and the manner- recurred witle filling bis vetim with nelves wish to be investigated jism and loving looks, sweet words, em- | publteation 1 do not care ta alr my | batters All Show: Reasatment. Failing to Do So, They Are Ordered to Pay the Owner $2,000, | aces and endearments used by her, erences with Mr Kellogs I the} City Magistrate Otto 1. Droege was en came the other alienist, De, Ly When Chairman Perkins, of New| ~ 8 Arad Maen te - pata) )/and as my husband, as 1 am informed, pwapapers. a lto-day found guilty by the Appellate) Plerce.(lark, who, afier deciaring that Maviior the Special Committe. arose and in Addition Are Assessed $240 Damages— is now with her, aud not Ikely to make sty friends tn the churen know very |Diviston of the Supreme Court of the | Peter Hains was insane in November, ope anor HOTTA Coda i PGR . . a statement, La on information and 1 y ve Men this steps” Sh) gharges presented against hint some Whereas Dr. Manson insisted that he Bernese: si Tener|, esau ars Tae Carroll Beckwith a Witne ‘ belief as follows on tinued it wus inevitable, It} inonthe ago by the Ii asociation, bad recovercd in October, became woe full membership, while the galleries tte cs Kar Association . “PIRST-HOW SHE DID IT. A LOUDESUS ONG IIMAY, BAY. NOW HAC and was ordered removed fron - | fully mixed u cross-exanilna ah. Were packed With interested spectators = if tA ESE PRe RECN 1 removed from his po Both the exseutive and diplomatic gal- | “Annie Irene Magher looked at the sition as Magistrate, | Being cal mm to give from mem- | plaintiff's husband lovingly, longingly, From Mrs. Kellogg's frends tt was that there is ay present an of making the separation | t sweetly and invitingly, and by looks learne 8 ;and motions and by. what she did Bey detint p aki i and mann. she ahalienged his love, they Hold any naued ofar lories, usually deserted, were filled, their! Fleming ‘Tuckerman won lis suit) Mr Beckwith sald Le had exam occupants, some of whom were com- | against the Calumet Club this afters] the portrait in dispute many times Pelled to sit in the aisles, displaying then Calumet Club, and with great i Two charges were preferred by the | O!Y some of the things stated in the Bar Association; One that Droege had |!) Pothetioal question, Dr Clark floun- attemr to Uribe a representative of “ered badly. He couldn't remember any onsent one in Keenest interest In the proceedings, It jury in Justice Lehman's court | terest, and from his knowledge ¢ e World to withhold from publicae [Of the eetly. He Analy was not observed that any member of) was out only a fow minutes, ‘helt style of Benjamin Wi Belleved i Sad ena Reale meen acetone see |tlon an article that teflected on the Saured Ont to hts own satlutaction that h r 2 y t th o BTEC OU BN eSE Oe e eiUeraces lel eky a i 0 eter Malis was insane because he had the President's Immediate family was verdict 1 that the club return to be from his brush S : | | Magistrate's methods of procedure in Present. The corridors were densely to Mr. Tuckerman the famous Benjamin, "Is it a painting of high merit? act words used by the defendant the oa SAVANNAH F RESULTS. j the co and the second that he had ‘Wie Overcome an Impulse to kill Annis, plulntlff is unable to state, not having crowded, the doorways were jammed West portrait of Benjamin Franklin, “It is a painting of merit," replied and equally insane because, on the third en junlawfully released prisoners comnitt- em the} Mrs, Kellogg, Brooklyn Con- and long lines of people waited an op-! which he says he loaned and the club ) guardedly, adding: “As Cet ne he Hasuena el hei Nee PIRST Purse; fo ° by him to the Workhouse Bs Pan ra to the tm- portunity to get even a view into the says he gave to them In 194 ling le degree would depend upon |i, he present eal ‘ tralto, Sacrifices Home to!" e charges made by the Bar Asso- | P Le aS chamber. to do this; they must’ pay Mr. Tucker-|each person's opinion," ii HOW BESHELLE DID ‘ t KO. ciation against Droege were the ont | Changes His Mind, Congressmen Tawney, Smith, of Towa; may § the pleture's value. In ad+| Fleming Tuckerman, who says he iM Meant 4 Musical Career ii a ome of an invest of the duit! Ne 2 re : 4 Mts REKIS fosayshere-) «she enused plaintiff's husband to Musical Career, nny a Sy After insisting stoutly for upward ef Sherley and Fitzgerald were on the aitton, the club is assessed $240 da ceived the Franklin as a bequest from Tae SUBREE WIUHES ekvarlowd est rei Court by the ¢ ib of Ac an hour that Peter Mains had “im. floor, prepared to resent what they age Is father, who in turn received it” PP Otel, uy counts, instituted by Mayor Me¢ sive insanity,” Dr. Clark finally des celled that he had been wrong all the time and that it was “compulsive in- re Feat tg. | sanity non he awiteted back and Piel) 44) Limes jn a state of high, a usion, juggling the words ‘compulsive’ and npulsive’’ until the One found him= Piper picked # sanity the and to invite to wine suppers, dur- T which she threw flery, longing and} Mra, Nella Brown Kellogy, the hand- ¢ loving Jooks at him, and used all the | some contralto of the Tompkins Ave- on the Mayor received the ri «| port from the Commisstoners he sent | a copy of It to the Bar Assoe! A long opin ay by Just deemed (to be the insinuations of the Carrol) Beckwith, introduced by co from an uncle, who was an artist and sai President upon them, as members of atest artist in America.” an art collect the Committee on Appropriations, witness for the plaintiff trait from t They were not alone in their indigna- toh. Indeed, for some time past the feelings of the members had been grow- ing more and more intense, and some sel as “the y and bough was the sta » West family in Ph wiles and lovers’ arts and modes of to-day, delphia, and demands the return of the | engearment, su ax tu cause him to love Mr. Beckwith confessed that he was} painting or a judgment of $4,000, half! jer, and consider ler the ne plus ultra an artist and was graduated from the of whic As recalled |o¢ woman, anid that she regarded him| her husband, a tea merchant. | of thom have been giving way to their | Ecole des Beaux Arts, Paris, In 1878, to the stand for further eros#-examina-|ay possessed of all the qualities she | cerned, and {9 living without Mr. Kel xentiments in language which fully tes and to the next question said he was tion by Mr, Brown, . | admired and a fored In mane a8 AN ogg, at No, 223 Bainbridge street, brunt ted to thelr wounded pride more or less familiar with the works | TR werent you posted? demand- | Aden! UNestled Up Lovingly. Brooklyn, with her two brothers, Mr HIRD RACK A Breach of Privilege. of Benjamin West ed Mr Brows e p gly. TT ale ED IE Pec ReL DOLE Mri Perkins addres: He was a Quaker and one of the | I might have been; it's quite pos- “She ind ed Lime Hatten Ne! out | Kellogg ts taking Me Us, eat follows: first artists of our country—a ploneer, I but there's nothing serious in peal his ehia cand. Rut i HAR in his store at No. 283 Washlogte “TO your committee were reterred cape | Miaht say. He was also a distinguished | Uf there had been I would have the pe nue (Brooklyn) Congregational Church, | i has Joined the choir invisth 80 far as ts for don audience be nd to allow s-exaMinas ff conduet ‘ requitin office. A copy of tt. Was served upon the Mag d the House as him and talked lovingly street, Manhattan Just What an Illusion Is, ter tolonial days," sald the | been haled bet joard of Cove aused [iim to visit and stop a , i s tered a swer | tain passages contained in the annual character In Colonial days nme ne 5; tee i H Aine 2 oY with nt Ane SOD UC) Phe tea merchant's wife has been 4 68 Anna e entered an answe Have you exanined patients whe message of the President. We were to, Witness uns Buse e ues | rca > live with ler as} singer for twelve years and jas sung, WEIR , . {s answer ; does directly! have bad illusions?" asked the Prose: Sart ith a —-—-----—-— -- i as amea't POUR BACT ths Igsue any allegation of fact in! care ation pecre am lietherr | PCD ECs i aan it In the chotrs of half a dozen fash \ ‘ esha p utor, “Yes, nit, maiiyy"" replied Dr, Mansoy The witness defied on usion as a s out that within portions of the message were couched jand ived with h Gian wraokivarehurchees (Siac teas alea| Wen oo aoO! Gritten t title erase mero gar l for aR ROSSTOWN TRANSFER ORDER i Gave Her Many Presents. done much concert «nd drawing-ro is Bl Ged uid Tt he dignity of a gislative body sshe caused lint to give her presenta | work, as well aa lending her voice for! ond) s Dale), 9 to disch, distu ytion—"the pa- smhould forbid their reception. ewe and finery a: wl Toto e Sixteen ent’s rhed by Ain “we are of the opinion that the por: | 9 SUBROFE Ren 0 rea ae ee nein Deane \ ant ‘ im vuid Dr. Manson, bd CU UL COC Ey | ay Gosiin relied various elttes in| withdrew for a time from professiona! | ‘ i : Parner nite se 8 enon of the privileges of this Ronse . 1 Burepe where she alleged Rah atdiaillaiil tau to. spr t would be singing. She declared then th t fd that therefore following the prec- typewrt er courted her edent set in similar ca: the Hou. . SoS Gr ee ni va a “thus alienated hit affecs nieial Ue A or hey nuaeene a ” \ tness not should decline to consider them, . . a tise owns (WO. holises Inllcsmestace and. form (be Buses ¢ his iitustra personal “With the merits of the question re-| ‘The Publle Service Commission, | content Drooklyt Goslin has seenred | 2" ; taking to define deiustons Dr. farring to the of the seovet servive | through its counsel, to-day recelved per- ry a lis pe the property can. | exhibition even ve ee u \\1 e iN} resting state. men this com has nu ) do {mission from the Appellate Division of; rari, The Pu ‘ * Commis t @ Judgment| mosphere aa (that | Vo \ 1 ea de We fully rec the tha the Supreme Court to carry to the an took the ground that _ chureh | y h these!” sire Kell admlitedto a | ee ays President to express hts disapproval of | Court of Appeals {ts appeal agatnat tie i ? ar <6, i JOSE Sait: | * lon adopte » © Col *, 1 re tour n 1 she, ork) reporier ‘ y ay . y , epee Adopted by the y {| allngs of the supreme Court wid of th iv Fy Ie er ates ATES tops P" Last Two Pays of Big Sale. a Ah, ves so. salt M a defects aid to ask Cat) Appellate Division that its decision Int heel 3 aie ction ' ? > fe ena t tate { ! AM n ‘ lue to e Werecilae a ater t 1 nen i —— the Fifty-minth street « awn car | s » y ee ay $10 Men's Winter 0'c ats $4.95 1 ‘ x that he (Continued on Second Page) transfer matter is subject to review ¢ He 5 an off ‘ for a nen When the Public Servier Commission ve «| THE PUB CLOTHING CORNER, ita ate ‘ ; ‘ ih guard a ots ne New Tarkiah Haths A bacatheler ' t : Gow open at the Tae ee Gay (Ordered that the crosstown Ine siiowid with t BROADWAY, atl Ald Mre. Kellogg ‘ ats é Hania: exp laniallen nDe e rot-clans stow Modern [exchange transfere with the Metropol- if val eet Harel) st 908 pace ; Kdginiliesae, fewelied : Hie Atanas hares reli at aiisa Rasber ehons whee aa | tan lines the railroad companies took ines wou keane. (et | eae coats, to-| nestied in a mass of allky: brown hair, dovdie, blew é NUN new ap As tndergoings. Dre the case to the Supreme Court on the in carrying the case to tie higher court 1 Ae nat wish to talk about this for IPR nena, Broadaas (Continued on Second Page) Austin Flint, sitting just behind Dae \ . > \ | good, the defense in the case of Thornton Hains, on trial at Flushing‘ | ee