The evening world. Newspaper, January 15, 1906, Page 4

Dustice Devel Says that Doctor | ‘\Céivicted Did Not Prac--« tise Medicine. _ €©ASE TO BE APPEALED. A Diagnosis and the Prescribing of Simple Remedies Does Not Violate the Law. The medical fraternity of th ‘will be interested in an un ®enting opinion fled to-day by Joseph M. Devel of the Court of Sessions, in the case of “ ton Alleutt, who was recently fined 0 fn thut court for praccising medicine Without a license. Justice Devel s opinion will be made the busis of an appeal by “Dr. All- eutt’s counsel, Black, Olcott, Gruber & Bonynge, acting on behalf of the Osteo- | Pathic societies of the country, who be- Seve the conviction of * alloutt was iliexal and unjust, “Dre” Allcutt advertised as @ “Demon- | sirator of Mechanic Neural Therapy.” | He ives at N West Ninety-eighth ftreet, and has an office at No. 27 East Twenty-second street. At his crial it was shown that he diagnosed cases and then gave advice and treatment. A County Medical Society detective testi- | fied that che “Doctor advised salt and water for stomach trouble, and warned | im against eating potatoes, pork or sweets. His treatment consisted of manipulating wish his hands the parts of ihe body where the pain was sup- posed to exist. Justice Deuel’s Conclusions. Afier vevlewing the evilence given at the trist at some lengtn, Justice Devel Writes as follows: “It 1s agreed by both parties to ex- elude from yoaslderation the title of uh a Ts by un of *doctnr’ because of the very great public i importance of securing an authoritative ta adjitication whather what the defend- |” did comes within the stat- niuor of ‘practising medicine.’ Mr. with canoy ease, from a huge e ee TOHERS® “Beef And” Meehan Decides to Accept the Invitation of the President. Meehan, “Reet-and” P: Row, canvasman the was busier than day, taking in John: ne of ons the other. Almost be inside (he door all the ut orders with re they got Invited to the President's recep: was going, wearlng the official John Mcehan dress suit, and accompanied Mrs. Meehan TI waiters told em. the waiters being at the point blowing vith pride, ao everybody counter just Ineide the tendered oongra tula- up door, and Doesn't Disturb Johnny. | Meehan was taking the honor ame portraits of “ «l those ~wo princes of the turf, Do- nc ami “Meebanus.” vencering a und of raeat and dishing baked beans k with a spoon as biz AS a scoop shovel. Midway between |i obes petal pdt let li ad the bottom hem of his whiskers and See nant can remedies A | ttt yoke of hie white apron a huge Fee pe rentes Hains et sontata of | 2amomI leamed in his shirt front. Balt and water are harmless and that | o¢ absancnoe from pork. potatues and) carved out of “beef and.” You'd never | founded the bua ness forty-one years eth sale paltiiren Hf know, seeing him there. that #6 was | eo Ci soehn aa: ‘i eeenee inherited “He examined tte patient by asking | worth half a million dollars, owner ofa {t from him. In all the sap. deci E years questions, looking at her tongue, feeling | house in Madison avenue, had been a toast por een al eed: pues eee of her pulle, Ustening to ber heart and | Sgnool Commissioner under 3 Van beans, “‘sinkers" and coffee, ‘ople | lungs and then made a dlagoosis. He seid she had ‘stomach trouble’, If he had stopped there, ne one could claim he Was practising medicire. Diagnost 4a the preliminary step of all physicians to deiermine what medicine is indicated, But dinguosis is simply to ascertain the seat of disturbance; it is not infallible @s to cause or remedy: the healing ager cles employed after diagnosig must determine whether or not the prescriber violates what the Legislature had {n mind by using the term ‘practising medicine.’ Defuniant enjoined the com- nt from eating certain things. eltns do the same. Not Practising Medicine. doing nothing but making a diagnosis and regulating the diet is not ‘practising medicme.’ He went further and did sometning to the person ae complainant fur an hour that prib according to her evidence. “a Toucking fans ordinarily “But Dot uo ils; the the duagnoas rarely, it 8 all counbined, Micpiten: regulation ureatment. make out a aggociates answer " istration of drugs and lotions is what the statute aims to suppress, nof tn doing of thi y mind know die cbs lucely rest injury, remote consequences. ant did was as harmless as if, follow: ing diagnosis, he had sald: “You have @ cold; go home, soak your feet in hot water and go to bed.’ Infinitely less arratul then the tons aad tune) of £0; aRelant medicines’ glaringly and seen y adverdsed as specifics for all manner of human ailments, and yearly taken into the systems of the credulous, Outside the Heating Art. “Suppose after making the examina- tian or dlagncsix the defendant had id: ‘Abstain from alcohol and tobacco nd go out each morning barefooted to walk'in the dewy grase? We would then have diagnosis and remedy buc not practising medicine. What the de- fendant actually did ves him outside the healing art by medicines as much does the supposititious case me one, possibly one in a thowsana, might be deceived to bie injury, but the statutes are intended to protect the ordinarily prudent, and ought not to be stretched to cover every remote conse- quence that a fertile brain can invent. (Smith ys, Lane, 4 Hun.. 682.) “The defendant stonld be acquitte shasta BAR ON BALLOT REFORM. to Talk Before Lawyers" of State. ALHANY, Jon. 15—The State ar Association, which will hold its twenty- ninth annual meeting this weet, will /@iscuss bullot reform. William M, Iving, who has been called the “Father of Ballot Reform,” will speak to the subject, Joneph H. Choate will be elected Sp ident of the axsociation, 33 Rbpente, eee ot a Ae le officers and Susticen of the Supreme Cours, SY What the detend- Ivins and Cho ALL KINDS PE ~peritions are, af. Earns | Sunday World Help Wants, More offers of york T the wealth which Mr. Meehan has The Only Fireproof, Clean, Up-to-Date Store on 14th Street. an | known man who turned Wyck and ‘helped to ‘run things at the} Wigwam at Fourteenth street. “Yes,” he said, “I got an tnvitation yesterday saying Mr. and Mrs. Roose-/| velt requested the pleasure of your | :ompany—meaning me and Mrs. Mce-{ han—at the reception at the White Hous: Thursday evening, Jan, 18, 7 ¢ 9.30 o'clock. We a ‘Thursday afternoon and attend the re- ceptiop, and I guess we'll sta: Frid best wisies with one hand and passing!" Washington. “Well, I've entertained the President often enough. When he was Police Commissioner he used to drop in on me regular patrons heard that the boss hal 1 he happened to be down this way been fon on Thursday evening, and that le take ‘beef-and’ or ‘sinkers and We go: to be gocd friends. He'll Take a Day Off. “T Invited him to the last annual bal! and reception of the John T. Merhan elation, He couldn’t come. But I'm going to take my first day off in thirtr- three years and go to his reception.” and coffer,” have been as.an oasis in a desert of |stern-fhced ‘tightwads to many a news- {paper man, broke and needing cash. wiih payday three daye off. He has loaned money to nearly every well- in copy on Park Row during the last three decades. “Yes, I knew ‘em all.” he sald. lot of fellows who used to come in here as cub reporters are managing editors now. And a lot of others are down and out—boore got ‘emn—ut they were good | fellows at that.” Mr. Meehan is proud of being the ut there was no other visible evidence | proprietor of the original quick lunch establishment. His uncle, “Pat" Dolan, S Second Annual January Drug Sale WONDERFULLY ee inasive sale, comprising in astonishing variety Patent Medicines, Toilet Goods, Perfumes, Soaps, Rubber Goods, Manicure articles, Powders, Creams, Brushes, sfirrors, etc. Everything is of the best and most reliable description. z cles are among the most widely known in the world, and are constantly receiving the broadest possible publicity. Mail orders promptly filled, except on articles otherwise specified, A who come, no matter how large the crowds. The Prices Are the Lowest That Have Yet Been Quoted for Such Reliable Rubber §7c oe, quar, Mystic Fountain 47c (fa Myatt: “Fountain 78c for 2 quart Hot Water Bottle— muaranteed two yea Bc (%3, UE Fountain Syringe 1 year guaran 65c 5,7 Guart, Hot Water Botte. good quality. a for fom quality ¢-quert Hot T2C Ware Boos 78c {20,2 Quility No, 26 Bulb Syringe. for No, 902 Bulb Syringe. for durable Complexion Bulb, R024 make, $1.98 peak She, inteliine © 3.00 «Wil $2.3 for $3.50 Turning Spray Per- 15c Sin Beringe, Red Rubber Complexion 25c Gc (cr totes tno boxes: Brushes and Mirrors 4c tor a real good Hand Scrub, 100 for good Japanese Nall Brushes. 1c for an all bristle Shaving Brush, Mo for en “Ydeal!’ Shaving Brush, 20c " ® rf Shed" Shaving rus a “Kant Kum Out’ 25c {te Brun Bho for We Halr Brush, 0 for “Vanity Mirrora—for 10¢ ic. for Brustes for doren of Pure Gym Nipples for your baby. Shay- 1Oe 135, Breer Combe. reguins value, 45c for 2. Bees Set—comb and brush— Value 750. 10 for a good Tooth Brush. BZ eh PMT EE € exceptional val 5c for Nall Files, Mexible or hard. Brushes— Be for pint 1ac, for quart of Btrongeat Housenold Ammonia. 100. a cone for ae Cocoa Buites or m4, ound, “aide. for BSC Bie. ee poamd’ Peroxtte Yysoneo. Je. for Pound of Suxar of Mik. We. for 100 Z-xrain Quinine for box of fresh and Vie Pawders (tytt olen, for 30°, size, and 42 yite of Eeaonice of Pepein. ounce Lotte of elther AGC Rhcture ‘arn ca, Parosoric, Caine gion enee ‘of Rhuarb, syrup of Saws, und, De for one-half and Bo one-quarter pound of Pure apt of pure Seld- for To, 12c er” “od Wlaud’s Iron PY Is 1) Cascara Tab ets, ARE for toy wentnltis Tab ern 100 938 285, f%, Beech erie Taniete— © S00 in baste, fh: for a bottle of Boda Mint Tablets, Ce nt Chioride of Potash tee a pink oC, best, pelined Wood Risohol 08 Der coms ‘Bo for pint at Chafing Diab Aleohal. grain, for % quart Hot Water Dottle— 1 year guaramer. | Pure DrugsaChemicals~ 20c § for 44 pint and BBe for a uint of Pures: Norwerian Cod Liver iz for a pound of Soda Phosphate, fo 4 of medicinally pure Ep- Se iin Brite oe’ Bicarbonate of Soa 12¢ & tor 4 pasos of Rose Water and Glycerine. 17c i4c § 15¢ singen. for one 8 pint and fate @ quart of pure Standard Wito. Hazel. 100 Fie Compound Cathartte poun: Etterves- Sazpound, bottle of Ettersee: Ade for cent Salts of ecther Soda Phosphate or Litht pound 1c for pound of Violet Sea Salt, io tor bint of Vieiet Ammonia. 5c | ze and OTe. for $1.00 i. St awamp BR zit or soe, site and @Fe._ £0 B5cC Gs. Oo westpnal’s Ausiteator, ‘ae ale and, Oe, for. $1.00 | BZC hee of pater John's Medicine. | «So Malt Orders filled on above items.) 49e or 8. weet Be Zeller’ Emulsion of Norway Liver Ol| with Hypophosphices WO size of Felion’s DZC be uhyvpnoepites Compooad. Bc. for Best, Belmgonna, or, Beladonna © ahu Capsicum Porous | ate tor 30c. sixe of sagen : nt and 8Dc. for quart 0 | 28 Bea ia Wine Boge 1.00 size, ine MDC Ph .P Si Sertecty tat very nutritious. | Ade fe Se aeetate Brad Wwhte | Pine or "Tar. aad Wild Che motsa'for thelr auisk ad aview bee restgratlve. for $1.00 stem of fr Baris Sar 47c eapariiia Conn VW 127 Livorice ey Spears A pieasant and mild that works on ¥ Ac (5,02, Farl'a Headache Powders, yery” eftective anid pastopty harm- Teas. Ne for Sulpio Napthol; 25c. size, $38 aly x) Pinkham Compound, or ‘utfoura Salve, 33c for Sve, and: Ge, for $1.00 Perfumes $1, 2.9 ver ounce for Hubigant’s Ideal + Perfume. 59c per ounce for Piver's Sarramee. Le Trifle. +20 per ounce for Pingude ne 8 (on. Imported French Tc bt, Flora) Perfumes, fa ounce 45C fit Pertames, ” batty 75c for 2 ounces Iéuiim laeting: Rertumen, ) qnaitties, going to run down | over | Ive got a good many friends | Fahey & 06i, 1 (Ghd grin brokers, | announced y that, ‘fem_will go nto lqnidation fies Fel from bual- ness. owing to the peculations of a trusted employee andthe contunied ml. health of the senlor member, P. R. Fahey. ‘The New York correspondent of, Fahey & Co, ‘was’ the National Bank of Com- mere, - An, oMietdl of: ‘that Mstitution statid to-day that the firm of Fahey & | Co. had & dmallbalante with the bank, but that“ thé account had practically bern closéd fom some time. the amount of business and the nature of It could not be learned. ~ P. R. Fahey & Co., Brokers, of Cleveland, Say Trusted Em- pleyee Robbed, Them. Quarter Sizes, w! jcloop 15 CENTS. at 2 YOR /A QUARTER PEABODY & co. CLEVELAND, 0,, Jan. 14-—P. R. Housekeepers’ Guide For Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday. Prices at 160 James Butler Grocery Stores. Nowhere else will housekeepers find the same high quality at such low prices, the same purity, or the same fresh wholesomeness, because no other retailer buys so latgely or sells so quickly and economically as we do, One of our stores must be convenient to your home. You are saving money when you buy there. j who don't know any better call ‘“‘sink-; never fell Into such an error, Mr. | ers’ dougnniits. President Roosevelt | Meehan says. Hams Delicious little sugar cured pic- nics, lean and tender, ii $to7 abe the lowest price of the winter; a lb Me Bacon. Swift’s famous Eagle Brand Boneless Bacon, best cured, with a streak of lean Having become impressed with the beauties of the climate, scenery and products of. Colorado, Utah, California, Oregon and Washington, thousands of Americans will visit the West during the Winter for the first time, and we are glad to inform them that the best service possible on American railways will be found on THE NEW YORK CENTRAL .LINES Which connect directly; with all the great Trane-continental Lines, _ Prunes. Highest grade of fresh sun-dried Santa Clara truit, sweet and full flavored; 85 to the Ibs Alb eseeeeee DE Rice. Fine fancy clean Carolina rice equal in food vatus to the highest priced; this wezk, and a streak of fat; a Ib.. At 160 JAMES BUTLER Grocery Stores Double °°." Stamps Green' With all purehases of 10 cents or mote, except C. O. D. groceries, Extra stamp Specials offered below are given in flace of Double Stamps. Onions. Hest white and red Connecticute, mediantrize.gt. qc Ticket Office 1216 Broadway. ina. Blue Ribbon, made Fomtisnen eres? | Stag Specials with Teas a Coffees Housekeeper's be. 50 Stamps Free with Very Best Teas, a Ib..... Special, 25 Stamps Fre: with Best Mo. 1 Teas, a Ib. TOMATORS. : Tapioca. 15 Stamps Free with Choice No. 2 Teas, 2 Ib. ra arn G coat 5 ae 15 Stamps Free with Old Government Java Coffee, unsurpassed in A hear art nen is guality alb.. cae Sse bad Aualisd, tmported= t= Be | 10 Stamps Free with Best Mocha-and J » ald.. qos eartgn «1 JC 10 Stamps Free with Best Maracaibo retebetaiel 3 ie ui 5c Prepared : Bucilateat Unald Mixed Tea. | Butler's Golden Tips. | wtish.© re 50 Stamps Free With Every Lb. This ts a prime favor iy package . Condensed Milk. Watch Our OS TP Adver- Rant Ranna's ee span = Llberew, risk mQe@ lisements. Pancase Flour. pap Ten parte Butler's, pure and There Are Bo tenes ean “Some Big pont: archan ‘hich ree Surprises in 1b. parchment ned eartens Hey ness ana Ser Store for You arenes Mocd avtna: ame ete: sees HS) Ea bright, Ju ainaasss extra te Extra Special Fees Stamp Offers. Stamps Free with Idtge 4-ounce bottle of Peerless Y; 2 Lemon Extracts for «+. ee = 25¢ 1Q Stamps Free with 2-ounce bottle Qur Own Extracts for. 15 GREEN STAMPS =~ FED with | 10 one orces! tersitire 15c¢ |w Dried Fruits bon brand 1-1b, carton, Peaches, Blue itib BN STAMPS Halt-pine dott moth Guseps, Finest from Spain: 20-08, hot Yalue 456 The proprietary arti- — with Bxtra salespeople. Every effort has been made to supply the wants of all iti eraren 14c wel ir Medium, Quice t : BEN STAM 35 : + Main Floor 10 ° TAMPS FREE with | JQ GKKE: SPAMPS RE with | ia 208 Black. or White Bin v pore Spices, for» rd—Dutler's 2 AO | AER Mee Mm 10 Weli-Known Grades ‘Stamps | Free v w h jar Extract of Beef, East View Brand, con- STC fence et Tie Aaceat = | 95 c Sa. Fe cM, Betas: 20: centrated essence of beef, for « -25¢ Plum Pudding. : 23c {3% rint of Slay Ram: 45c. per 5Ge DB aprees or Shettierre tale < 5 Standard, for 8 fo eg us iar. 2 ears; 2-ti oan, ce rg Si LMG California Fruits. yi" 91e Be ae Mlag e of Kalseritia Farina alge of uneven Hair Tonic. 29c tee trial sine of Kalserina Farina | SBG S%, Mpagtltts, Oe, or $1.00 Essie Brand. East View Brand. Sardines. 20 2 ene. = © Tonte. irate “prpsetyed. Ib” pares 204 papas Choice gaetity Ais Catiiormia aor pes aa Matne Cunge ot French tmportet | BOC. 2? mer | prenerved in toh: heavy eyrug: equal a a oe Pyeeam Stora rie | SF, rae ‘Ot gael Bee ae oulting “THM arate ose syrup, Aothing “nher” ta packed. | to the ‘best grade of inoat retailers. Ry teen om a ‘an. few Cherties, large vanes: save ‘a We. Rattle” of juadruple ite. jp « © strength French ext cnctslin nese | SOC) Mant 8" eh Haya Hale Suse Corn. yy cut bottie. ar hithest pis oe x i Toilet Cream, Face |||BAn°=" Dentifrices | WTZe_ tor 23, eine and GOc. for 3 uize Dentiseptine. 17c for, | 28, of fing erregert! goth Powder. ideal Antiarptic Preparation for the Mouth and Teeth. , Handsome Lithographed Calendar Free to Every Cu&S’tomer. Powders and Manicure Goods 1c. for Rose Nall Bleach, best of all. ot Eodust, pil atid of ' Limterated Tooth et me. _ Charies'e Piesh Food; Set Kats sins ai se : 18 ie coe | She Bet Tm, mean: am. HS See {Wine and Liquor Specials| : te we Gee oe | ee eee At 70 JAMES ety LICENSED ponte Te ee tte ome ron sons | ENE Bens RE a Canadian Club WhisKey, 3 otic, 98c| 2Vc. for Hornish Nat! Enamel. ASc, for Woodbury’s Face Powder, Sie to2 Hinds Money and Almond Cream, 10c. for Onkley's Face Powder. 48c, for Pompean Creain—barber’s sine, Bc. for Swansdowa Face Powder. B avec ape. SIE ide Hunter Whiskey, J.8. botting, a bottle, 79 Cabinet WhisKey, private stock, gt. bot. 1.00 ae! eae value, bot.45¢ A good selection of Toilet and Bath Soaps 25c wo pt Coke's White Tar o, 7 Par Footm sw meone Ci 8c tine’ Boar. t ty carry i PSR eee u id Inedicinal effec: ro kes of Bee Yolk Sham) % for Jeat Bouse. handy to carry tn tere — at " B. Chai Ca rs durav) | éue etna ¢ for ine of Dog! 2: foe cakes 0 19¢ Sif fie ge —Buotce: aM 25¢ eS frien: eallo a iien Gulls Re sate run eo WK BE 00 aaa one-quarte: Preserves. eapeeiaily TWeeticial for women aml | BSc, Bhatne Ee. CAD Arne 7c wr ay oy ‘toc! Sir sone Bound oe Liberty Pre Nett | Paste tt anette; : Triuarh es t So Cream. quperion 75 for $1.00 size of Dr. Bar's for 6 cakes of Gem Foner Sotho Salata has oye choicest whole | ——————— me roreign qublitve | Prime eten Cécki * a: | c And system Bullder. The ZECr oes neo aie " fruit, dob, Coes White PO a bi i fat metiine Cf thle ae for rewtoring 4” | ZC Soap, 19c 4, Ror dment of Wien Base me. 55 | fase: ‘aso, sna 25 ‘i ' i "Spode Nervous MIAO gS AOC. {2t,box, canoe, Brent of Rove pp ah : iz } = ; | keane = ° Make bf Oriental Tr ‘Soap. Be for “i Corn’ Starch. with bottle Whiskey, 10-year old; for, | for Ban eve of Little Liver Pills Ae orn un (a cakes) Sweet Seenied | Geo top, 14ehs Xickt, Mace, Powder XIAK Brand, pop- ie ven bottle ie Scotch Whiske er | 10c tor poe, aiee ot | BC. Giscerine Sonn. f cone ai a teftoea Wook wige ong enone 3a Stamps Fret ith battle Power" Irish One pees tar vax (3 cakes) Bau de the okin aay eal; bald. 5c | 30 Stam Ww tle F Frepch : known or golds or chills. 1Oc 6% 'sdao 8c % So gu of Mes. Henton'a - Garton + «a « 30 Stamps Free with bot ra ‘rope n Sognac | rants, SC for, 81.00 sine. of Conon Wine for box (8 cakes) White Glycerine 4a — 12c 1Be for ter, Persian Violet Fuca Powder, Tag SM: Ne = Se sau = a ate "Gttilng, - 33 tae nds) tee Greta So. PR Sed Hy Zic Crue's BSc Bench wack Powbe Bis Fes at Whale, baa aca "gs | saa (2 Pounda Pure White Boratea finan i-th. " td x oh ZIC (lahe"Foar.”” Se “ni pertanea ia Jara ae Amoatl a cake for *Rachor Brand Castile < can ot Pertut Violer en ote AC th 0c Rtepsel st ven ke for Pure Italian Olive Oil, 2c % Casthe Soap. ‘ae a cakg for Wiiams's Shaving Boas, fof Manyon'a Witch Haze Soap. Satin (ons or BUTEER’S best ellan Misc: apc 'Botay So ap, 20¢ for good quality. WDial. 39e % ‘eemak pigeon nig made Bove oaks for Woodbury's Facial Boa, 8c & cake for Dr, Baris Suchur or 8c carroll carl ays 31.5y for Chamnaie Vest—none better. Cakes far Cazollon Ter Soap; acter nex of 8 cakes or ir of strong, Kood anal: ; F set Seaiee Oe Pexhones | AMC LF hl yas phe Ua ys i tore _votile of Bastman'a Sapbrt Hl AE EEKe fr tints, xaphtbe! Roap.. | gle fore sx¥09, Bealece avin Het Washing Powder, . cake fie Wook Bowe. ere Soicce having Bot, Champign Glothes Cleans eh Saves, Rubbing —Saves ‘the Clothes Hair Tonies and Dyes 2B Hi tte Mowe Hair