The evening world. Newspaper, May 3, 1905, Page 1

" i A y\ | he ‘ Di ‘te ie spoke calmly and with great do- Weare nate, warmer Thursiny skewert NAL I RESULTS EDITION | _ PRICE ONE CEN CE LW YORK, “WEDN They Laugh and Joke at Luncheon Like Men Relieved of Grave Responsibility — Rumor that They Reached Favorable Verdict on First Informal Ballot. 8 TO 4 TO SET HER FREE WAS THE ‘Confident, Actress Declared She Would Be at Lib- erty in Time to Take a Night Train | to Return to Her Old Home in FIRST REPORT. | Washington. | | | The Nan Patterson jury resumed their deliberations after Tuncheon | th Hann’s restaurant, in the Park Row Building. Throughout the meal | they laughed and joked with each oher and generally conducted them- selves as men who had been relieved of a responsbility, A crowd of | 3,000 persons followed them up Centre street. | The apparent jubilation of the That they reached a verdict on the first informal ballot, jurors gave rise to the impression This impression ‘was heightened by the fact that the reporters and attorneys were sum- moned to the court-room at 2 o’clock In accordance with the instructions | of Recorder Goff that they should be called when a verdict was reached, But the Recorder had gone to luncheon and the jury followed suit. | NOT A VERDICT OF GUILTY. If a verdict was reached on the first ballot it was favorable to Nan Patterson. Had the jurors found her guilty they could not have enjoyed their meal as they did. Within an hour after the retirement of the Nan Patterson jury this afternoon an informal ballot was taken. Of course there is no means of Knowing the exact result of thie ballot, but rumor about the Criminal Wourte Building in quarters that are usually reliable had it that the yote was eight for acquittal and four for conviction on a minor charge of homicide. Following the informal ballot the jurors wont to luncheon, They wero in oharge of six court oficers under ‘om Kearney, Recorder Goff's per- eonal attendant. The jury and guards boarded a oar in front of the Tombs ‘and rode down to the Post-Otfice, whence thoy went to Haan’s restaurant tn the Park Row Building, A private dining-room in the rathe- | keller. had been engaged by telephone, | Whe news that the Putterson jury was fn the restaurant caused the gathering of a crowd thet filled the plaga In front | @€ the Post-Office, Street-car trafiic was blocked and the reserves of the Oak | was a mere gi Btreet Station were called to olear tho/ Theref tracks, Record Murder Trial Crowd, Phe concluston of Reconer remarkable gathering about the Crim- nai Courts Building. Never before hua Guich a crowd assembled at a murder | Us position of this woman you should trial in this city. Mounted pollcemen managed to the cars moving pn the Centre street + gide of the building, but Franklin atrect| titled to the same legal rig) ani Him street were blocked, Fully 5,000 persons jammed themselves into morrow Frank‘in sireot In the hope of ‘catching @ glimpse of the defendant oe e crossed the Bridge of Sighs. Padked in the throng were scores of trucks, which had been seizod upon.as points of vantage, The drivers were unable #o force their horves through the erush, Y's Tho prisoner Jid not glence out of, the open windows as she crossed the ridge of Bighs, “Had she done ao, ahe would have seen thousands of upturned faces—an audience auch as she never beheld in her days on the stage, he ate a Mght luncheon and then ‘ay down on 0 oot, Her sister, Mra, Bmith, eat beside her caressing her hand, Lawyer Dan O'Reilly called for @ few minutes with the rumor about Gort'e | you to be excited or distracted by, decide the clroumstances withow @harge to the jury and the retirement | must t Gf thet body to deliberate upon a ver-/@ny thought of atmosphere, calmly and filet at 1.03 o'clock was the signal for a | With ® quiet mind, keop | one in a more exalted vosition in no- the deceased, @ man of the name of Young, @ race-track man, had this de- fendant to live with him as his mis- tress, The man's death, because of his personality, hi your passio: nothing in it to excite or your prejudice. Hoe bler, a race-track man, you should be able to con- sider the facts calmly, without preju- dice or passion, ‘“Dhere ls no artificial atmosphere for You “Of counse, gentlemen, I do not mean because of the humble and itnoonspicu- not give ber the same consideration as Whatever hem porition, ciety, as the mest prominont and most conspicuous, "Every person, high or low, good or ‘bad, is entitled to the protection of the | or law, and if that peraon is dentived of Ife unjustly the law has been outraged, Nevertheless, the law must punish with- out regard to person or sex, No Question of Sentiment. “You are judges solely of the facts @nd must deolde with unprejudiced ininds—minds, | free from lon, minda free from sentiment and ire; tain rule: the reeult of the first ballot. He says that the girl is strong and composed, @eady for any verdict, ‘Before Recorder Goff began hie charge @o the Nan Patterson jury to-day Dia- trict-Attorney Jerome made the positive @nnouncement that in event of another Gisagreemont of the jury the actress (would Not be put on trial again, si fand In due time the indictment against fher would be quashed, Promptly at 10,30 o'clock the Re- @erder arrived on the bench, an 0.4) he began hie charge to tho ‘fee ration, and his charge was con- adored eminently unbiased, the (rivolous darling af the footlignts ty the. apnenrance of Nan. Patterson swhon ale entered Part IIL, of Goneral Siiecay The dread of death had e@hanged’ her over night, Her compos- ure Had vanished and there was only the trembling, Pee woman left, When Recorder Goff began her hat shook violently, and it was ap- ferent 80, every one that there was a of her nerve reserve left, “Gentlemen of the jury," began the Roocorder, it te proper that 1 shoulda exprean my appreciation of the manner » 29 which thie trial haa been conduoced. “Pho frit] has not been #o long that! ore ‘to: distract your’ ntlon ftom) the “aot. tanieing |?! the or on the evidence, this doubt must be thrown into the bal- ance tur the defends "You must accept the instructions I give you''on all questions of the law, Mould be admitted to bail, it was eaid,|and you must apply these inatructions |to unite tha other ofro os I give toa to you, You must not depart from these Instructions by #0 much as @ ingle letter, Questions to Determine. these questions for your eear Young die on the Iya tanerare ia he div by vios defendant ‘These Tore questivis Kesolve -thumselven 1 the one | “Did the defendant Caenuar Younw ' Wither whother ftw y and wr ai “he Babseot of tr sider, sate bid pia the defendant fire the fatal a Gonfine re adtention to this one uestion and do not get lost In specity- | 6, jon, ‘Shere is no peat mony of eye-wil- essen, You must URN. a iaeretoryy For Bead Mig dea and ide truth from a ohain: of areal i tha beet of, FOU, von+ Th mable doubt is ‘Now LAR must 208 lose aight of this ci Inference, jana oy 1SD Y, MAY 3, 1906. “ Ciroulation Books Open to All,’ ds : -NAN’S JURY STILL IS DELIBERATING NAN PATTERSON Mes REFURNING TO COURT, @ROM A SNAPSHOT PHOTOGRAPH TAKEN THIS APCuRNOON FOR THD BVONIN! '@ WORLD.) RESULTS EDITION t Dla’ ONE CENTS , OPEGIAL EXTRA ¢ JURORS IN FAVOR OF MANSLAUGHTER AT 11 O'CLOCK THE JURY WERE REPORTED TO STAND SEVEN FOR MANSLAUGHTER IN THE FIRST OR SECOND DE- GREE AND FIVE FOR ACQUITTAL. The impression is general that no verdict will be reached to-night, but that the jury will be locked up. Recorder Goff sent word that if a verdict were reached be- fore 1 o'clock he would be accessible and could reach the court within twenty minutes. iso; caeanacbebhdied 3 NAN PATTERSON REGAINED HOPE AFTER COURT’S CHARGE PLAY THIRD ‘While Recorder Goft wan chersing the Jury tc-day Nan Patterson's at- tltude ohanged from one of oomplete deepair to renewed hope. ‘ “When 1 went into court,” she said to an Evening World reporter, I hadn't recovered from the effect of Mr, Rand's abuse yesterday. I was weak and ner vous and afratd I would collapse, “But as soon as the Recorder began his: charge I felt a great sense of calm- ness and re! I felt encouraged. “T) seems me that the change was 1 suppose I think so be-~ instructed on «0 dn my. favor. cause the Recorder of definitions of Siete at evidence from_ several authorities. While the Recorder hy ye peaking the defend- ant carried herself Ret with singular Haidity, Bhe seemed to be holding on grimly with contracted muscles, fearing utter collapse. “The evidence,’ continued the Re- fer, ‘you A tad before you Is Be '~ oumstantial indirect, You it ae * erding. to your Sonolence and your judgme! “There are two en atruatto ns you can it cat the eroametgadal evidenee In this ‘You oan decide that Caesar Young Re mot himself, or that the de- fendant shot him, i] there any grain of donbt, e i¢ to the defendant at your construction ence Tr “nerivln of the evi ‘Phe. Recorder devoted some time to tine Aiscussion of the expert evidence fn the cane, It je urged that the enray af RAG be- ae tive tl refusal "As for meaven defendant was oause he cast her o} to divorce his Need Not Prove Motive, Bute gentlemen, in @ criminal oase it Ip not necessary do prove motive, Mo- tive ts merely o with which t clroumstantial ey! for you to determin Tage OF anger, and it sucl yas thes I spate oa "te the nt Ky there wee any oF anger mee te Tike eo com~ migaion of a Bue in ca St circumstantial eyl- dence motive is often not only ‘impor- tang, but controlling. It must be proved umstantial facts in 16 Case, “Concerning the facts in this case I Y tit mye es com) atin 8, wre! Ca phe these facts, 't The Fatal Cab Ride. The Court told of the various soctdents of the drive in the hansom cab up to the moment of the tragedy and the Ne | Rteoor omplinals on th e on the fact that the defendant had | pHSF Po peasion, that morning A handbay nine Inches He revap.. Uinta the tele Ro of "the peticemen Ce) VOR tg Na on ter the Bhaoting, “ely chulmeds'* id the Court, “that the dofendant met euee that morning; he carried a } earourery that lover iia it id ey himself with It, © prosecution contends that there reons in that cab; et ‘was shot Se Benet aues Stoned, contentions tala the ranoye must deolde for i tie ia Aave laid scat a bart befora, you me a is at tf there A these conte! At tn lad bs oshuth ft | committed you must, brini many points that Mr, Levy tnetructed him to, When the jurors went out I felt, of course, a sickening anxiety, but I moon gained confidence and hope.” Bo confident did Nan feel of acquittal that #he had all her effects packed and a programme of her movements map- ped out in case the’ verdict should be in accord with her hopes, She said that whe would go direct from the court- room to the Hotel St. Paul at Sixtioth atreet and Columbus avenue and re- main there until time to take the 6.10 train for Washington, She was living at the St Paul at the time of the tragedy: by the counsel for the defendant. ‘There Were sixty-elght of theso requests to ier would not charge, as y the defense, the jury to hh tewtimony concerning 16 le purchase of the revolver by | Morgan Smith, The Court algo. ré-| fused to change that ay} aun’ y mould not consider the faflur: Mor- gan Smith to the mand. “You must ‘oonsider this fact,” ruled the Recorder, “A reasonable doubt must not be the bare possibility of the defendant's in- nocence, it necd not be an mere ety, jocture ‘or vague supposition; it must be a well defined and reasonable doubt, and if you enteriain such a doubt you must find the defendant Innocent, “But {f the evidence convinces you to @ moral certainty that a orime was igh int Verdict guilty, prove that the dershauni 3 killed Gaosar Unk and that Shans come by hie death by any ne 1 Beller this Ef aheenasit . aa, i Ae th intent ee i aot apn ee; bring ln e Verdiet ith ee we nat mn, shot wit t deliberet one but, (rea Mie in- tent fly you must bring in @ ver- dict of. mumier in the second degree, In the two degrves 0: manslnventer there not be the intent t pall a final ‘caution to the fur be feat Sonseauencne of their verdict, befor ¢ oF the Court delivered ra" delode into Ite hands at ——_—. RESULTS AT. UNION PARK. RACE TRACK, UNION PARK, 8T. LOUIS, May 4.—The following are the Bernt of to-day'’s maces here: You must PARTE nour: furlongs.—Dr. wingell @ to 2 sat L amar (16 ) Marimbo aa ), Time—9,60 35. BECON: P RAC oie fturlonge,—Nell! Russell (6 tof) 1, John Garner, @ to 5 Repaolens Minstrel (15 to 1) & ‘Time— THIRD RACE—Six La ee 4 morer (8 to a 1, Hardcastle (7 to 1) 2, Rossonia (6 to 1) 8. Time—1,16 4-5, —— FAIR GROUNDS WINNERS, RACE TRACK, FAIR GROUNDS, ST, LOUIS, May 8,—The races here to- day resulted as follows: FIRST RACE-Four tution 4 Gel tod) t, Lopay Robinany ) 8, Marvel P.' (2 tol) 8. SECOND RACH—Vive and a halt ‘tuniongs, Ben Lear (3 ito 1) 1, dialtter ‘3 to Paes * Goan dae Graham (? to 8 LAY TAR hom aroun Birlongy. ©) Bee Kies ‘Bitter: Brown & fo) 4 4 Nmeroes 2" "Twont out, {HIGHLANDERS WITH BOSTON BATTING ORD ORDER, Highlanders. Dougherty, 1, Bunvere if. Keolor, rf, Parent, ‘es. Wiberfeld, ss. Stahl, of. Wiltams, 2. . Collins, Sb, Conroy, 3b Freaman, rf, Bulta, of, Grimehaw, ib. Qhase, 1, Ferris, 2b, Kleindn, 6, ger, 0. Chesbro, p. Tanah, p. UmplreO'Longntin BY ALLEN SANGREE. ' (Special to The Evening World.) AMBRICAN LEAGUE PARK, NEW YORK, May 8%—Whvopeo! Di was the first real genu-t-n-e ball weather we hove had and maybe the fans didn't @ppreciate it, Hundreds of women who had been saving up thelr Waster hats for second appearance frescoed the Grand stand with color, First Inning. It looke<! bad for New York at the siart when Conroy missed am «uy grounder from Burkett, sending him to second, He took third on Parent's suc- rite, Conroy to Chase, Stahi tried to hes the ball but encountored a saliva and was out, Chesbro to Ohame. inital the ‘re @ slow bounce off Collins, NO RUNI Dougherty could Bot te beat out a rate to Ferrie, Keeler to finat on. p alverteld ps a rs mari wifi out idl fe ehratic 4! shan Keeler Conroy OND icone Inning. Freeman had the advantage of Ches- bro's wildness, He was forced on sec- ond by Grimeshaw, Conroy to Wiliams, Chesbro had poor control, also passing Terris. A wita pitch advanced botn runners, .Chesbro made a good stop from Criger, then threw wild home, let- thng Grimeshaw score. Williams's smart step and throw from ‘Dannelill nailed Perris at home, Tannehill was forced at second by Burkett, Elberfeld to Willams, ONE Fults was out on a oltp to Collins. Chase raised the roof with a beautiful triple to centrefield fence, Kielncw Parent to first, Chase being held at thir, Chesbro was thrown out by Collins, NO RUN@& —r LEXINGTON RACES. Special to The Evening World, (UBXINGTON, Ky. May 38.—Racing was resumed over Kentuoky Associa- tion course this afternoon alter seven years cessation. The attendance was jargo and the track fast, but the weather threatening, Six races wero of which the Ashland in- for three-year-olds was firs;, Brown, owner of the traok ts {ll Capt. attend the open: The first pave, the Ast was easy for U. % Dearnon's James V,, son of Faraldole, which won from at his home In La te and dia not}? thir | Deviin, GIANTS START BOSTON GAME LIKE WINNERS eocnconceee BATTING ORDER. Gants Bow Doniin, of, of. Tenney, 1b, Barclay, If, Dahlen harpe, Devimn, 8b, Raymer, 2b, Gilbert, 2b, ‘eedham, a, mes, ‘p. vol Umpire—Johnetone. BY BOZEMAN BULGER, (Bpecial to The Evening World.) SOU'NH BND GROUNDS, BOSTON, Mass,, May 8.—With Dan McGann back in the game, the Giants refused to con- sider any more ten-Inning propositions to-day and went in to make it a Water loo or get awamped. Firet Inning, Donlin walked, but waa out stealing second, Strang tecelved a bump on his left shoulder from one of Volx's curves and Umped first, Dan McGinn came up | Minus his prison stripes, and after re- colving thy giud hand‘ ehoc a sharp grounder, which Raymer kicked over the Jot and both runners were sate, Bresnahan carelessly slam the ball Against lett fleld for two bis Burang and McGann, Needham let a ball @lip through him and Bresnahan took third, Mertes sneaked a single Over second, while Batty waa posing in Tewintered. Mertes stole necond. ead on the next ball ‘swiped third. Dahlen struck out and Mert Pas out trying to teal home, TH. RE Cannell opened up witr a two-bas t ted ‘burner over aah irehney drew tee passage to first, phbatioohto trying to bunt, chur: he air times and sat down, an ich was th passing of Wolverton, ate rY @n euay one to McGann, UNS? iy Second tanner vin was hit by the first pitche: ball, Gudent punched of a nice’ rt single into left. Volz coldn't get one over for Ames and the hases were full, enh Med to aBrolay, but nopody ad- ming walked forcing in Dev- | “Vous ascension was a little too! strong to sult Tenney and Wilhelm re- Ueved him. McGann filed to Cannel and Gilbert ecored. Bresnahan rapped 4 sétngle over short and Amea scored, | Strang made a dash for the plate and tho thrown ball struck him on the shoulder bounding to the bleachers, While both he and Bresnahan scored Mertes fied to Cannell, FIVE RUD Sharpe filed to Mertes. Raymer was gut on @ grounder to ‘McGann, and Needham waa fe o Dahlen NO RT mM a greunder to Third ‘Inning. Dahlen Devin singled to right. struck out.” Gibert singed’ birt Patten had to stop at third. fn a mix up Gi- bert took second, Bey made a wild ohuok of Amoes's grounder and Dalien Reored, Gilbert folne to ithird. Donkin fled to Cannell, seorine Gilbert a Sttans fouled to Tenney. "TWO RUN: Wilhelm singed, but he ‘warout at feoond on Cannella grounder to Dah- ifored a similar fate on tor, Batty cut a elein field fonce ¢ reo and ONT RUN Fourth Inning, was Wood Ciay's Memorles in an interesting a Aion Rite Meee eae 8 jeraniium, Buténsle eaten ni comes one MoGann grounded out to short anit in) mad There is no indication, however, that a verdict will be reached. irfsugi Cemre street and Park Row was the occasion of the vent aut to dinner at 8 o'clock, and their progress most remarkable night demonstration ever seen in New York. Thousands of people followed the jurors to Haan’s restau- rant, where there was a rusn to get into the place. The police with difficulty kept back the crowd, who were crying “Set Nan free!” “Turn the girl loose!” “Let her go!” and other phrases of the same bearing. a PUN analy i BASEBALL RESULTS. At Boston—Giants, 16; Boston, 3.) At Brooklyn—Brooklyn, 13} Philadviphia 3. At American League Park—Boston, 2; Highlanders 2. SPECIAL LICENSE IS STAKE WINNER BY FRANK W. THORP. (Bpecial to The Evening World.) WINNERS AT JAMAICA. 2G, RACE EPMO Szat|_rinet RACE—Arabo (7 to 8) . eo areeee ge et or i ls and True (4 to 4) & Ghinwey rest ee Pa aet iftened’ from (a winter winds and olot ered aque SECOND RACE—Unole Urigh one, ¥ er she ef, tag ope | (even) 1, Incubator (18 to 6) 2, Com Bent, sideration 3 faym aye mitatinding winner ‘and this rater killed preliminary, interest in the event, It las beon @ disastrods meeting (ot the players, and aside from the eager- ness to be on to Belmont Pank, race- goers were glad to got away trom Ja: matca, with {ts form-upsetting turns and alc eilaualy. a snare aerate THIRD RACE—Phyilla A. (8 to 2) 1, Panic (16 to 6) 2, Bolden & FOURTH RACE—Speclai License vinet R welling; for | (8 to 1) 1, Veribest (30 to 1) & syear-ol i longs, St wee Teeeheaae aint Were ieee, Leonard Joo Hayman 3 Starters, Jocks, Wes, SL Hie Tin, ; eR Ravana’ true Bra 108 2 Hi ge 4 FIFTH RACE—New York (6 to 1) Ch, SOR eh lfrorent ato 1, Red Knight (11 to’5) 2, Grenades. Ifxcrent® sorte: Caria noihié and Lochinvar, tn SIXTH RACE—Jetsam (8 to 5). 1, Phoebus 3 to 1) 2, uate “Ori tnt, High) Brushy Libertinus, Maly ator... Baird owan and Sir Yowsut, Fibra 102 IURTH RACIE-Tho Sutfolk Stakes, Also ran, yoar-olds; $1,000 added; four and a v $700 added; selling; two- nga. Start fal, Won driving, ‘Time yen oI five furlongs Stare "bad. Won | Oct 4%. me Me AN ie lap Stanters. Jocks Wha, state. cy Sta Jocks We, St Hite spi Toonea Mint phyla Baird 040 Diggin ny + we Patio Belden sieelor fos, Red ‘Ataste 45% ob “Al ‘Aso ran—sthel Havinan, Cambridge, Bhiy wu ainda, Rapid Tran METROPOLITAN ENTRIES Bresnahan ale tne on a bunt to Wil- in-curve ) CANEE Mertes in je took frst gt under AND FULL STORY OF TO-DAY’S GALLOPS ON Soca