The New York Herald Newspaper, May 13, 1875, Page 4

4 MECKLENBURG. | ibis Authorities Diseuss the Declarations of May 20 and 31. Ex-Governor Z. B. Vance Be- lieves in the First Date. Daniel R. Goodloe Accepts the Resolves of the 31st. LETTER OF DANIEL R. GOODLOE. Ratetou, N. C., May 4, 1875. Vo rue Epiror oF THE HzRaLD:— Allow me to say that the bypothesis on which the HERALD would explain away the fact that the “Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence” was ever published prior to April 30, 1819, tbougn plausidie, will not stand the test of examination, Yhe same suggestion was made by Dr. Francis L, Hawks in a lecture before the New York Historical Society in December, 1852; but in offering it he ook issue with all his friends, who stoutly main- toin it was printed in the Cape Fear Mercury, and that it wassentin that form by the royal Gov- ernor, Josian Martin, to Earl Dartmouth, the | Britism Secretary of State, it {9 stated that this | paper was entrusted, in 1837 or 1838, to the care of the late Andrew stevenson, of Virginia, then the American Minister Plenipotentiary at the Court | of St. James, and that tnat gentleman failed Jo returnit to the keeper of the coiontal records. It 18 atill hoped by the friends of the “Declaration” Shavit mar be found among the effects of Mr. | Stevenson, which are said to be in the possession Of hisaon, the present Senator from Kentucky, and they expect it to furnish demonstration of tne genuineness of the 20th of May proceedings. Bat, on the contrary, ifthe Mercury should be found te contain the resolves of May $1 your nypothe. sis and that of Dr. Mawks would be to tne thampicns of the ‘Declaration’ like a plank bhrown to drowning men, Suli it would not save them. The theory of the suppression of the “Declaration,” because of its rasbness, by the cooler heads that met in council on the $ist of May 13 incongruous with all the contemporaneous and well kaoown facts, It pre- supposes, in the frat place, taat the oMiclal report of the proceedings on May 19 and 20, which bears date Mav 2, and is signed by Jonn McKnite Alexander, as Secretary, is utterly untrastwortny; jor that report deciares that the “Declaration”? was sent by @ special messenger to the Representatives in Congress at Poiladelphia; that it was universally received by the people, and, in tact, that it was the work of the identical County Committee of Safety, which We know dia put forth the resolves of May 31. There is abundant evidence of the spurionsness of the pretended report; it shows on its face that It was written long after the event, because It refers to subsequent even's, and, Indeed, we have the certificate, lonr suppressed, of Joun McKautt Alexaader that he wrote t', from ‘‘nis best recol- | jection and belief,” in September, 1800, the original Papers, as he says, having deen destroyed with his Bouse by fire in the preceding April. All tois is irae, but it cannot be allered or admitted by the advocates of the 20th of May Deciaration without surrendering their cau-c. The as-umed theory of the suppression of the “Declaration” is inconsistent with the postuve averments of the report and of the witnesses that 8 was prociaimed at ‘he Court House amid the plaudits of tue peovie, aud toat many topies were taken so that the peopie knew it by AMeart. Can it be believed that nobody in Meck- venbarg would be imprutest epoaga to pabisn the proceedings of a iarge puolic meeting because afew wiseacres shook their neads? Is it at all porsible tat no tory would get hold of it and burry with it to the nearest British commander? And would whigs and ‘orles coaspire to keep the secret? Each and aii of these utterly tmprobavie suppositions must be taken for true if we admit she theory of suppression to be true. In addition to these considerations there is the statement of Captain James Jack, the messenger Who bore the “Declaration,” ur proceeuings of the meeting, whatever they were, to Pailadeiphia, tha: on bia way, at Salisbury, which 3 im the adjoiming counrr, forty miles distant, they were read before “the Court’ or Committee of Safety and highly approved. Tals statement, which is Goubtiess true, is utterly inconsistent with the supposition that ne bore the «Declaration of in- dependence,” while it mignt well be if we suppose Dim to have been the bearer of the resolves of May 31. For it appears trom the recorda of the Rowan county committee, to be found in Wheeler's Distory, that on June 1, 1775, that body sent an earnest letter of sympathy anda of exhortation Ww patrietic effort to the sister committee of Mecklenbarg, in which, nevertheless, it de- ciared fra allegiance “to tne present House ot Hanover.” Can it be believed that this tame letter would have been sens to Charlotte twelve days after Mecklenburg county had declared irre- vucable independence? The thing is imeredipie. But supposing that Captain Jack bore the resolves of May 31, and that be left Charlotte early in Jane, s he and the report concur in stating, the difi- culty at once vanienes. For, in the Grst place, the Rowan committee coni! not know June 1, in that day of rough roads, what the Mecklenburg committee resolved in the afternoon of the pre- ceding Cay; and we may well suppose tnat the More elevated and devermined spirit of the re- Solves at Charlotte on the iast day of May would ewaken sympathy and tuspire a spirit of patriotic emulation in Salisbury, when they reached there, “early in June.” might, if i had time, notice some arguments presented by rour correspondent from this place, butI believe shat most of them were anticipated and answered in the loager article of mine whica is im your hands. I will, however, notice whatis Said about the spirit of tne Regulators, who had scruples, after their recent oatis of allegiance, teen ag the price of avchesty and pardon, about again embarking in rebellion. It has been well said by Dr. Charles Phillips that the existence of this eeling among the Regulators made it neces sary to respect their scrupies by keeping opea the floor of reconciliation with the mother country. Hence, while the patriots of Mecklenburg did set | Ops govermment on the Jist of May entirely in- dependent of Great Britain, they decmed it wise | to say that tuey might return to allegiance % the British government would recede ftom its ar itrary policy toward America. fs desire to conciliaie the Regulators vas manifested in the Provincial Congress, whicn ‘ent men of character and induence among them with assurances of provection. The troable with the Regulators was tuat their rebeilion in 1771 against tne detestable carpet-bag tyranny im- posed by the Crown was suppressed by the very men who, in 1775, became the leaders of the whigs. | Tryon, the Governor, with bis accomprished wife and wife's sister, had fascinated the gentry of the iow country with his courtly style of living at New- vero, and made them his instruments im tmpos- ing @ gailing tyrauny upon the piaim people wuo mohabited the hill regions. Martin, a wiser and | verter Man, succeeded Tryon, and seizec the op- portunity of conciliating the Regulators by Kind- ness, and at tie same aaa ed their weil- grounded prejudices again genry. Ia DANIEL R. GOODLOE. Very respectfuily, EX-GOVERNOR VANCE’S LETTER. CHARLOTTE, N. C,, April 20, 1876, fo THE Epiton or re Henany:— Your letter of a recent date nas reached me. I regret exceedingly that a pressare of busin engagements will not permit my taking aqvan- tage of opportunity you offer me to discuss the vallaity of ihe Meckienburg Deciaration of May 20, 1776, in your widely circulated journal, I enciose you an adaress on thas subject receutiy delivered {A summary of tois was present letter | it you can | or from New Jersey. gress, | ting way for | circumstances ——— SO NEW YORK HERALD, THURSDAY, MAY 13, 1875.—TRIPLE SHEET. here, We beliewe the validity of the 20th of May, because— | Pirst—It 1s asserted by tradition unbroken by a | single contradiction, Second—Because it ts proven by the positive testi- mony of eye-wituesses, men of more than ordl- | nary intellect and of most eXaited personal char. | acter, Who say they saw and heard the transac- | ton, | Third—To this it 1s objected that they intended | to speak of the action of the 3lst May instead of | toat of the 20th, Fourth—That they may have been mistaken in | reproducing from memory the precise words of the “Declaration” on the 20th is probanle, and is a fair subject of critical inference; but that they snould have mistaken absolutely tts substance aud purport is not fairly to be supposed, and to de- mand belief in ita spurious character on such frail grounds ia an absurdity such as the tutegrity of bistory does not require. ‘This 1s about the substance of the issue. Iregret exceedingly that I cannot now elaborate it. Re- spectiully yours, Z, B. VANOB, OUR HEROES’ SONS. ‘TRIENNIAL MEETING OF THE GENERAL SOCIETY OF THE CINCINNATI YESTERDAY. Just ninety-two years ago to-day, while the Revolutionary Army was in cantonment on the Endson River eagerly waiting for the final deciara- | tlon of that happy wora, “Peace,” its oflcers, at the suggestion of General Washington, formed a society on the following basis :— ing pleased the Supreme Governor of the | in the disposition of human affairs, to cause the separation of the colonies of North America irom the domination of Great britain and, after a bloody confict of eight years, to es- tablish them free, Independent and sovereign States, connecred, by alliances founded on reci- procal advantages, with some of the greatest princes and Powers of tne earth, “To perpetuate, therefore, as well the remem- brance of taois vast event as the matual /riend- ships which have been furmed under the pressure ofcommon danger, and in many instances ce- mented by the blood of the parties, the oMcers of the American army do bereby, and im the most solemn manner, associate, constitute aud com- bine themselves into one soctety of friends, to en- dure as long as they shall endure, or any of their eldest male posterity, and in faliure thereo! the collateral branches Who may be juoged wortay of becomiag its supporters and members. “Che follomimg principie# snall oe immutable and fourm the basis of tue Society of the Cincin- An incessant attention to preserve inviolate | the eXaited rights and liberties of haman nacure, | for which they have fought and vied, and without which the high rank of @ rationai beiug 18 a curse Instead Of a olessing. “An unalterable determination to promote and — cherish between the respective States that union and nations] honor so esseniiatiy necessary to their Happiness and the Juture digaity of the | American Empire, ‘fo render permanent the cordial affection sub- | sisting among the officers, This spirit will dictace brotherly kingnegs in ali things, and particulariy | extend to the Most subsiantial acts of beneficence, according to :he ability of the sociecy, toward | those officers and their tamilies Who, uaosortun- uteiy, may be auder the necesaity of receiving it.’? ‘The arst Piestdent of the General Society—wotch ts composed of delegat trom tne Stace societies — was General Wasnington. YESTERDAY'S SRS8ION OF THE SOCIETY. Yesterday m raing the Tricanial Convention of the General society, composeu o: the descendants 01 the Revolutionary heroes, vegan at Deimonico’s. Baen State society sends five delegates to ths ‘trieanial Convention, aud yesterday ail tne seveu State sociecies of Massachusetts, New Yor Ww Jersey, Pennsyivabia, Maryland and souti Caro- lina Were represented. | Amoug those preseut were Admirul Heory K. fhatener and Mayor Covd lion, (of Boston), of Massuchu Hamiiton Fish aud Alexander Hamil ex-Judge Lucius Quiatius, Cio United States Judge Jono f sey, aud Hon. James Simons and v. Pinckney Lowndes, of South Oarooa. The meeting was opened at eleven o'clock by Hor, Hai ton Fish, the resident General. Mr. George w. Harris, of Pennsyivania, Secretary General, acted as secre- tary. THK PROCEEDINGS. Afver prayer by Kev. Dr. Hutton the minutes of Inenbial session, helt in Boston, were approved. ihe treasurers of the various Wwiies made repurts on their finaucial 1d More expecially on the funus at the hior aiding destitute widows aod Orphans Ol members. fne Mussachusetts society, according to these reporis, hus a fund of $65 v00 for that purpose and spends avout 32,000 a year; the New York society nas $25,000, tne New Jersey $16,009, the Pennsrivania $55,000, the Maryiaud $5,000, While the South Carolina society is as yet adeot upon individual efforts in that regard fund is now being es abiisned. Tye aa- nounvemients of deaths of memoers were then made, amoog others that of General Tigulman, of disposal 0: @ Marylaod, ana a committee was appointed 10 re- pore obituary reso.utions. The As: ant irevs- urer General, Mr. Wiiham B. Daytou, reported that the late Treasurer General, Geueral Tignie mau, Lad jeit a Geficiency of $3,000 or $4,000, aud Was authorized to prosecate tis estate for toat amvoust. The seciery theu adjourned ull this moruing, at eleven o'clock, when the general officers for the next three years will be elected, LAST EVENINGS BANQUET. The New York 8 ociety of the Cincionat gave 4 sumptaous Danquet vesterday to tne de ga'es at (oe Union Cluv. The toasts were as 1 lows — ‘a “The Memory of Washington, earth’s greatest legacy to me the Founders of Our Society; dear sons of memory, at heirs of taine.”” “fhe Memory of those who felion the battle flelds of 1 wud i the secoud war of Independence; dive aiter them.” “The Presigent cinnat ” ‘Our Sister State Societies. * “The school House and the Church; it is that iorms, but rahteousness that exaitetb a nation. The Society of the Cincranatl—On Huason's River h day of May. 177%, our tathers founded it; River now, the 13:h day of May, 1575, wir children look upon their work and pronounce it good,” “The Army ahd Navy of the Uaiied otates” To-night the New York State Society and the Generai Society wiil be entertatued at a great ban- qcet tobe given at Delmeaico’s. Hou. Hamilton Fish will preside, In tue aiternoon the delegates Will be driven to the Park and to the varivas ins tations, They are in charge of General John rane, Alexander Hamutoo, Jr., and Johu W, mimittee or Arrangemenss of tue New York ety. General Cocurane & boa Gescencasrol Dr. Jonn Vochrane, Surgeon Geu: raiaod Director General of the hospitals of the Army of the Revolution. education ates.” THE NATIONAL CENTENNIAL. ADDR&SS OF GOV. BIGLER BEFORE THE NEWARK BOARD OF TRADE. Pursuant to special invitation, a small but select representation of the solid men of Newark, the leading members of the Board of Trade, gatnered last evening at the rooms of the Newark Board of Trade and stened to a short bat interesting ad- dress by ex-Gov. Bigier on the subject of te Phila deipoia National Ventenuial Exntoition, GOVERNOR BIGLER'S ADDRESS, The Governor, who is a man of pleasing features and addr and of imposing presence, advanced &t once to tne President's ciair and in an easy, earnest, Of-hand and at times eloquent manner, Spoke substantially a8 follows:—It was not at al singular, he suld, that somebody should have sug. gested that tne close of the aret century of our Hational existence should be commemorated by some fitting national ceremonies. It was picasing for bim to say that the idea of @ na tional Centennial Exhibition originated in To a citizen of New Jersey, Dasiey 5. Gregory, he believed, they were in- debied jor the Mrst suggestion on the subject. it Was prowptly brougut 10 the attention of Con- dit Was thought to be an emine. tly fc- ation to eXpress its confidence in the government estabdlisued 100 years ago, and of doing houor to tue wreat men to Whom we were indebted for \'# foundation oa @ grand aud benen. cent basis of seli-goverument. It wus cousidered that the ceievration svould be natioaal, bot con- fined to locailty. Congresa taen provided fur the apyotatmen: of Comuustioners for ail the state: and Terr’ories. it was soon discovered tha! A SERIOUS DEFECT nization. here Were 20 means of rais- ing the Becessary capital. A board of Hoance was then appointed, Witu power to raise $10,000,000 on Capita: stock, This Was apportioned tu the Fari- ous States and Territories, Ailer a hundred days it Was sound there Was 4b @>undance Oo} stock left And that it Wus necessary to take other steps to PUsh the project. But ior the pavic of 1872 ail the capital would long avo have Leen raised. Instead of 8 (she Governor) Spending three months in New York raising $175,000, he woud, he beileved, have been abie to raise $1,000,000 In one month, | Ls Question HOW was NOt an to the propriety of tae Tnose who the saggestion of the Centenniai Exnibition was vroacued tne people Would readily lave sudscrined ali the stock, and Ware su Would even now do Exhioition, out ag vo its success, existing when 80, a8, indeed, it was very suitable and proper they ould. conciusion Governor Bigier sald that he hoped the national Centennial aid prove to be & bond Of fraterbal alection Bi | the pubue | the Chief Mag istr: | than diseouraye bration | ' | ad woald be a corrector of misunderstanddings. Ke concinied with an jnteresting P Oi the Very encouraging repuris he b been intrnsted With the Work by Congress have proceeded as jar ns it was possiole. Under tue remarkabie (nierest taken oy England, Norway, Sweden, France, Vurkey, Germany and vearly al) the hatiols €Xcept Kussia, and wound up with an eloquen! appeal to New Jersey to come quickly and generously to the help oi the Keystone state. Tue Governor Was Warmuy a plauded at the close, and receives. quite an ovation, Among the more prominent genuemen pre-eut were Messrs. Orestes Cleveland, Henry T. Duryea, J. President of the Council of Newark; P. I. Quinn, Secretary of the state Centennial Commission; Jeremian O'Rourke and others, THE WARRANT WAR. COMPTROLLER GREEN HAS TO KNUCKLE DOWN TIGHT—HE GETS UP ANOTHER BOTHEB AND WRITES A LONG LETTER ABOUT ‘‘MY POL- t0.”” The Comptrolier came to his senses yesterday and sent over to the Mayor the warrants for the pay of the flremen for the month of April, made | out in company payrolls, payable to the order of | One of Mr. Green’s | the Mayor just about ten minutes to sign these | warrants, which, vad the Comptroiler veen less | obstinate than he is, might have been made out | properiy by him nearly two weeks ago and the firemen paid promptly on the Ist of the month. Mr. Green wis fogced to do as he did, not because he cared about the poor firemen, but he got wind of the fact that they were going to bring the matter before the courts, where he felt certain he would be beaten, Late yesterdar, as if to get even with the Mayor for having made bim come down trom nis high horse, he refused vo send 4 messenger to the Mayor's office tocarry the warrants tor the pay of the emplosés of the Department of Puoiic Works to the Finance De- partment, although te had be n notified that the Mayor had signed tuem. The employés were toid, wWueu they applied for their money at the Comptroller's office, that although the Mayor had signed the warrants he refused to send them to the Finance Department. The fact ts that the Comptroller wanted the Mayor to do his bidding. The Mayor finally sent the Comptroller @ letter stating that he (the Mayor) had no mes- senger on woom he felt inclined to place the re- sponsibility of carrying the warrants to the Fi- fiance Department, and he desired that they Should ve carried by & messenger who would be subject (oO the regulation of the Finance Depart- meut, This i¢it Mr.Green no ground to stana on, 80 & Messenver from nis Office Nnaily culled at Wwe Mayor's omice and took the warrants to the Finance Department, where the laoorers and others in General Porter’s department will get their pay to-day. in Mr, Green's note, in which he notified the Mayor that be had drawn out the warrant for the firemen by company payrolls, he sticks to the idea that the men ought to be paid oy individual rrants, aod expresses tne hope that the Mayor “will find it agreeavie to adopt tae plan.” In (his note be inclosed @ copy of the following letter:— Pixance Derartwent, Comprronen’s Orrice. city ew Yous, May 12,1875. Hon. Josrru L. Penury, President of the Fire Depart. ment. My Dear Stm—More than a week ago, on the 4th of the month, the customary day of payiug ‘the firemen, the money Was provided, the Warrants were signed by me, and ail things on m t were ready for their payinent, The Mayor, however, refused to sign the Warrants, and tor this reason alone the firemen are still unpaid. By the charter ic is the duty o1 the Finance Department “to pre he forms of keoping and rendering all city a * and the manger by which all salar and the mode by which ail creditors, of (ne corporation shall be pati.” it was und Haveu ever that this charter Was passed, and its provi- sions, many of them quite new, Were thé subject of {re- quent discussion between us." In complance with my. uty, ani with my official diseretou, the methods of of the various classes of emploves oi the city exerived as my julgment indicated were best t pudlic interests. Ne always where practic- rrant to the order ot the | e the money. In the case of a | ‘or IMsiance, it Is not practicaoie to Warrant drawn to cach of uy of the able, as the saiest, to person entitled to ‘ree large roll of laborers, ny them: 1 « be ver 1 one polnt to nuother. a aulariy appointed pas hieen Years’ € +1 have no the saie and ¢ nt drawn direct!) sheré are by this plan no intermediates reasury andthe person so entitled, and % but & forgéry Can prevent the money going | » him. between firemen and | unuiag | They become ceupation, and are to be found 10 . which are generally in the la’ od of banks and stores, and th eadily and without inconvenience. vor Havemeyer, Who Was amen of large and public affairs, acquiesced in ded itselt to his exelent judg- nt and sate method of dealing be ened the warrants tor the ympiess and regularity, and lithe forces of your de- regularity they since, made t & subjec: of complaint because it required too macn labor om his part aud Was irksome to Lun He desired that the mode of baymeutin use up to bis tn ould be changed. 'y to ny knowle: Yielding to his wishes, thougd contri of what was 0 vi pent tothe tre ser- vested in the nged and the | and in the ¢ aniee Vepartment, the d of drawing one war! AOU atto the order « 1 waster tor each company im gross. The Day: | got tu#moner t to each compan: , and there pa i rees as were ina att | time, selecting th: hich is most cone | venlent to the exie | shite plan bas been tried as an experiment, antill am | intormed by your Irtier that it inverferes with the daties aud diseipline of the force under your charge, and that | plan previously im ‘force, or | ligent observa- | ry ne to persist in | > ve jatertere with the | win of & depariment having the responsibility of pro- | tecung the city tron tire, as! have the anques- tioned jawful right, tod it was under the cir- cumstances my plain dat arected tor the May pa: ments a return to the old abd better system Ihe wi rants were signed for the flremen’s pay on the 4th of the | oath and sent to the Mayor and although a couple of | hours ouly would be required, he has et signed them. He proposes having @ warrant drawn to the order of each of saxty f mount due to lis company, thus | th foremen of the | 4 ‘ae paymaster tor ihe company. | 5) annot consent, Here would o@ sixty men constituted fe difterent duc counts or to the distinguishing between good iving no security for thesaiety of the mone: ands, to woom the Finance Department wou! have continually t look’ to keep their accounts and re- turas accurately. Itivurare thing that some one cr members of the company 1s not absent at pay , einer from illness or some o: ber contingency, and the foreman would be obliged to carry this money about Without sales or other provision for its satekeeping till the absentees appeared. The money of dit- | ferent months would become constant contusion would ariae in ‘he accounts MXtY Uopractised paymasters. This p readily see, would not work well, and your departme: would pot think it wise to occupy the attention of your men with this sort of duty. 1 am quite sure not be willing to adopt such a loose method of i ¥ of which ‘he Comptrol | onsibie. If these moneys were | This was thoroughly tried under the were most uusatisinctory. arcely necessary (or me at this time, when each 8 up to the light irreguiarities, frauds and rs, to dwell upon f the most caretul methods ot wonevs. One would aturally sa of the city wow b a course. ado} rant and the pr wi of me at least three mes ™. hers impos @ labor that itdoes upon 1am not unwilling to relieve the Mayor of what he is lease’ to call “trudgery.” but which seems to me to be etter described as the most responsible dut out large sums of public moneys wherever erly do #0, but i cannot consent to loose method: aeaiing with pabile moneys. idid not make the law whiel requires his signature oday ve hetore me an application to ercentage on muneys deposited in 1870 by partments and officers of this city ina bi subsequentiy broken to relieve this ins sockhoiders from turtner tasied I regard as of paying can prop: a small che loxs the unwise polic: allowing numerous chstosians of public moneys. While I am convinced that payment by individual Warrant 1s the best and safest plan tor the éity, Lam un- Willing that the firemen under the direction of your di pariment shail be longer delayed in getting the! The Finance Deparuneat has a discreti mode of payment of the men. If the m paid in the mode that I deem the cise this discretion so far a all be permitted to y« , I shall today draw another set of warrants that will be irksome to the Mayor to be abie to pay you even today. This wever, buts temporary expedient, to reneve the men who afe waiting for their pay, agopted in the ho that His Honor wiil come to think’ it wirer to throw the weight of hig official influence in favor of encour: rather than censuring and discountenancing, the methods that are practicable in disehaccing’ the gr moneyed traste with the responsivility of whieh the Finance Department is charged. - Very Fvspeotfull NDREW H, GR thelr payaen THE RAILROAD STRIKE The laborers at the Delaware and Lackawanna tunnel in Jersey City, who struck for an increase of wages two Weeks ago, returned to work yester- day, having failed to aitain their object. The leaders of the strike have been redncea ten cents a day, and were notified that iftney did not sup- mit t6 (his reduction other men would pe at on employed in their places. Contractor Mcandr iniormed the men that rather than yield to the de. mands of atrisers he Woula suspend work for an | entire year. The number of men who bave re sumed Work is avout 400. A large ti jest t Yai rather thad Work for bay low rate ae udiow, ex- | ailed paymasters, I took | the administration ot the late Mayor | | that led Mr. | Counsel at this juncture were | Ui pursed his lips and peered at Victorias in an | with General Tracy. stioula | THe BROOKLYN AGONY. Eighty-seventh Day of “the Great Scandal Trial. a ANOTHER GENUINE SURPRISE. Victoria Woodhull Summoned by the Defence. Frank Moulton, Mrs. Ovington and James Freeland Denying. | The proceedings in the Brookiyn trial opened | with an extraordinary scene yesterday morning. | It was half-pasc eleven before the business began, The court room was just comfortably filled. About | twenty ladies, including Mrs. Beecher, were in | attendance, several gentlemen, among the rest | Mr, Robert Mackenzie, a great shipbuilder of | Dundee, Scotland, Were seated beside His Honor | on the bench. During the idle -half houra low gossipy hum pervaded the court room. When it | Was nalf-past eleven a smartly dressed lady, wear- | ing a red and yellow flower on her bosom, a black | hat enveloped ina biue gauze veil and a sutt of | gray surmounted by a blue velvet jacket, entered | and walked briskly into the middle of the chamber. | All eyes were turned on her. It was Victoria Woodhull, whose name has been s0 woven into the warp and woof of this Brooklyn scandal. She Was looking well; herage might be thirty; ber | eye was bright and radiant, and the occasion was evidently one of great joy to her. Floor manager Caldwell provided her with a seat, and speculation was rife as to the things she would be asked to tell. Mrs, Beecher took natur- ally some interest in THE APPEARANCE OP MRS. WOODHULL, whom she had never seen before. Tilton did not at first pretend to be aware of ner presence. The | foreign gentleman sitting beside His Honor on the bench was, perhaps, the most curious of all. To him Mrs, Woodhull was @ greater phenomenon than any other personage in the case. From his position he had a good look | at her, It was not long before Mrs. Woodhull op tained a chance of being heard. The object in | subp@naing her was to ovtain from her letters in her possession written to her by the plaintiq. Evarts, Beach and Fallerton took part in the debate. Finally, Mr. Shearman asked for the letters, As Mrs, Woodhull rose from her seat in rear of Mrs. Beecher and stepped into the charmed circle occupied by the opposing counsel every eye in the room except Judge Nelison’s was fixed on her movements, She was very pale and her lips trembled with suppressed emotion, but ste | marched forward bravely, yet with an air of defl- | ance, such as might be expected of a prisoner who came to be arraigned. When she reached the piace where Mr. Evarts and Mr, Shearman were stand- ing the latter gentleman put out his band | and again demanded tne letters, a3 did Mr. | Evarts. A whispered conference ensued and the three held a sharp debate, and then Mrs. Wood- duil addressed the Court, and though her voice trembled, she managed to say that tne letters ae- manded were not injurious to her and could not harm her, so she was willing to give them up, But she wanted it understood that she had been | arrested for publishing the scandal and bad suf- fered the rigor of the law. Then she opened ber reticuie and gave up one by one six or eignt short letters, which were eagerly seized and perused by the couns 1 for Beecher. So enerossea were they that Mrs, Woodhull was saffered to stand, a fact Beach to say politely, “You will please sit down, Mrs. Woodnall,”” and she at once sank intoacvair, The features of Tilton and his tudy. The plitn- inquiring way as toough be was puzzled to see her in the court room at all, and on the side of the defendant, even though unwillingly. His counsel were evidently surprised at the unexpected appearance of Mrs, Woodhull, and they conversed eagerly as to the | probable contents of tne letters and the use to be made of them. Mra. Woodhull glanced at Tilton, and, meeting his eye in @ moment, they looked steadiastly at each other tor nearly a tinute, and | Victoria's face Mushed slowly but vividly as her | own eyes fell, Mrs, Beecher had all this time been | gazing fixedly at the “publisher” of the scandal, | and a look of mingled scorn and pity seemed to | linger on her face. insensibiy her thoutn closed firmly as she surveyed the woman who had just j spoken to the Court, and then her lips curied and | a bright glitter grew in her eyes. Mrs. Woodhall | was apparently unaware of the steadtast gaze of | Mrs. Beecher, though her eyes were catching, as it were, the glance of every eye within her range of vision, Then the counsel made room for her on one side, and she became @ part of the audience, though tne object of attention to all curious eyes, PRANK MOULTON’S LAST APPEARANCE. For the third time Frauk Moulton has filled the witness chair. Yescerday be toid again the in- teresting story of how he wrote Beecuer’s famous jetier of contrition, He wrote it word for word &s Beecher dictated it. W be had finished it he read it over to Beecher and got bim to put bis Dame to it, Moulton has appeared for the last um | | { MRS, OVINGTON | was again a witness. This lady was brongut to contradict @ Mr. Martin as to the length of time Bessie Turner spent at her house in company Mrs. Ovington, wno is the | Guardian of Mrs. Tilton, isa pleasant faced lady of | @ very precisa address; an enthusiast the Beecher great emphasis the question, “Isit true Mr. Mar- Vin spent two hours on the piazza of your house in conversation with Geuerai Tracy?’ “It is false.” Severai other questions were answered in the same language and same tone, that caused @ titter to pass around the chamber. Mr. Fuller- ton remarked, ‘That is very ladylike, Oan’t you way itagain f and the lady fusned as the words. NEARING THE END, The defence expect to end sur-rebuatial to- | day. General Tracy speaks of having some six or | seven witnesses to examine. There is also talk | Of having an adjournment for a wi before a] | the summing up addres: are mad The | jury are feeling cheerful at the near ap- proach of their release irom attendance on this most tedious of trials. Judge Nelison 1s Ot Opposed to an adjournment o1 @ few days pre- paratory tosumming up. He has spoken of a re- cess being necessary to digest and arrange tne matier to ve laid before the jary. The witn yet in reserve will testify to no facts of import, ance. THE EVIDENCE. | Judge Netison took his seat on the bench promptiy at eieven o'clock. A long a ensued, | which Was explained by Mr. Evarts ing that he Was expecting some payers in regard to which rt. Tilton a question oF he might have to ask 3 two. Shortiy before tweive o'clock Mrs, Victoria Woodnull came into court, whereupon Mr. Shear- man said that the delence had subp@naed Mrs, Woodhull to produce certain letters in court, She Was now in attendance, but deciined to produc Mr. Fullerton ooserved that be did not think the | Court wouid so instruct her. Judge Neilson said that Mr. Tilton mignt o t | them. Q | calied, out he svouid decliue to give any 1 c+ | tions as to the production of levters or papers. The Witnoss isnot compelled to produce the pa- pers. Mr. Pulierton—If they want the papers they must | pUt her on the stand and put her uoder oa | Judge Nelison—i cannot give any directiuns, Mr. Evarts—:t 18 not necessary that any other Process than the subpana duces tecum siouid applied for, and the possession of the papers do | Rot make @ person a witness in the action; then the question is whether the sabpena is a proper exercise of the authority of the Court; that is Whether the papers sour lt for properly come in as evidence, Now ihe subpwna 18 “ali the corre spondence between Theodore Tilton and yoursell, @nd ai, books, pit and cocaments between + said Theodore Tilton ang Henry Ward Beecner,”? Judge Newsou—\Vell, the suop@na compels tae . side, who answered with | beard | Wiuess to attend and bring papers. That is the | | authority whieh the Court exercis in reference | to the papers. | Mr. Fullerton—She has been suppenaed as a witness, Not as an expressman, aud 4s & withess | sue is here, | Ph aie Neilson—I can’t give any direction about | Mr. Evarts cited several authorities in support of his argument. Judge Neiison—I am quite aware tie witness | neea not be examined, aad tt dows not amply & right to cros#examine, The only question 1s whether you can attuch the witness jor bot de livering over the pavers on your request, being here. Mr. Fullerton—Your Honor will perceive ® fea- ture im this case entirely different from that in | the authorities read, ‘This subpoena does not de- | scribe any particular paper so as to enable us to | identity it; toere 18 an omnibus clause t» produce ali papers, without specifying any, and hence it | does not bring this case witnin the rules as laid | down in the element: because in those cases the particular paper was described in @ Way $0 that it could oe identified when it was pro- a . But | don’t think a witness was ever brought imco Court and compelled to produce all co: respondence between A aud B, Judge Nelison—You tave no interest In those letvers; you cannot croas-examine the witness. Mr, Fullerson—Not unless she is put on the nd. Judge Netlson—They may identify the papers by another witness, Alter some further discussion Mr. Evarts sub- Mitted that it was for the Court to say to the lady IM question that the law entitled the defence to the correspondence, Judge Neilson—It entitles you undoubtedly, un- | less there is Some personal objection on her part, in whion case it is to Le tested by another pro- | ceeding, stood up, and, addressing | she | Mr, Shearman her Mrs, Woodaull, said—‘drs, Woudhull, we call lor the letters of Mr, Tiiton.” | Mrs. Woodhull then stepped forward and con- versed briefly with Messrs, Kvartsand Shearman. Mr. Fullerton—We think 1¢ due to the witness lo gay that she is not called upon by the Court to produce these papers. Judge Nelison—I have Dot given any directions. | Mr. Evarts—she has been advised that the writ | entities us to the produc ion of the papers. MRS, WOODLULL'S ADDRESS. Mrs. Woodhull, turning toward the Bench, spoke | as follows:—‘l have a few unimportant letters in | my possession, and [ feel in bringing tuem | into the case at tuis stage of the proceedings that some explanation is due, They are letters en- urely creditable to myself as well as to the gentle- man Who wrote them. Perhaps you may remei- per that! wave been iniprisoned several tumes during this scandai, ana during that time my | private ofice was ransacked, Some of the papers are in the nands ol the detence, It may not be go, | | but itis an idea t have formed from the fact that my office has been ransa Some oj them were very important, and wit explanation I am wuiing t» give them up." She theu handed thew to Mr. Evarts. Judge Neilson inquired whetner tne examina- tion of Mr. Moulton was to be concinaed, | Mr. Fullerton suggesied that the cross-examt- | Mation should be proceeded with, After Some further discussion on this subject, Judge Neilson intimated tnat if atany fucure | time the deience desired to cross-examine air. Tilton on the basis of these levters the witness | furoisning them must be in court, THE EVIDE John Napoleon Longii was then examined as to | the measurement of tue Broad street piemises occupied by Mr. Sehedler, near Deimonico’s | restaucant, In rebuttal of previous testimony for the defence, Francis D. Moulton was then recalled, and pro- ceeded to deny many Of the statements made by | Mr, Beecher touching the interviews he had with | Mr. Moulton, wheu the jetter of contrition was — tu writien. Judge Morris went over Mr, Beecner’s | id where he @ from | Mr. Moulton’s testimony asked iv the language | given by the defeadant had been used, tue wit- Bess on rebuttal denying all of th Several | sharp debates occurred between counsel, but the jaintif’s side got in all tueir contradictions, Mr. oulton being still om the stand wen the bouc of recess arrived, APTER THE RECESS. The court was slow in reassembling, Mrs. Beecher sat alone in the afiervoon, pule, wan and weary, the great.st object of sympathy identified with the cause, Her son was with her in the morning. It was almost half-past two o’clock be- fore an oficial word was spoken, and then Mr. Beach stood up and announced that Mrs. Moulton was ill and could not atvend us a witness, but her | evidence denying a certain conversation with Mr, Beecher would be taken all the same as if sue testified on the witness stand. Mr. Evarts agreed to this arrangement. Mr. Moulton then resumed the stand and was dismissed in a few moments, He was followed by Stephen Pearl Andrews, who was recalied to testify as to the occupation of the office No. 48 Broad street by Colonel Blood and Mrs. Woodhull and as to the latter being married tc the former. When Andrews left the stund there was along pause, and finally Mr. Freeland was called and examined by Mr. Shearman. He denieda statement of Bowen’s point biank, and people turned to each other and asked, ‘Who is telling the truth in this trial?’ Mr, Freeland supplemented bis denial by | the remark “Mr, Bowen mace a mistake.” Mr. | Beach moved to strike out the observation. “On!” said Shearman, “it was only acharitable remark.” Mr. Fullerton stirred up the irritability of the witness on cross-eXumination by pushing him closely for an explanation of bow he determined the date of a certain interview between Bowen and Beecher at his house, “I'd answer your questions, Mr, Fullerton, but you put them in such @ way that | can’t answer them.’ He was | asked if in December, 1%0, he received a note from Bowen and sent him back an answer to the eMect, “Yes, that will be attended to.” Tnis ap- peared a simple question enough, but though it was put haifa dozen times the witness, with an unaccountable ovstinacy avoided a definite an- ewer. Fullerton appealed to the Judge ana said :— “I think Your Honor will have to take this witness | in hand.” The Judge, however, took no action in the matter, and the counsel proceeded to make the best hand he coulda of the witness, “Pure cussedness,” as artemus Ward calis a certain perversity of disposition, wonid apply to Mr. Fri land’s manner as a w.tness, There were four lawyers on their legs together in the course of Freeland’s re«cross-examination. The matter appeared to be of a trivial character and only acquired its importance from the peculiar crookedness of the witness’ replies, When the afternoon proceediags were formally opened Mr. Beacn announced taat Mrs. Moulton | was too ill to attend and deny Om oath the aile- | gation of Mr. Beecher that she said to him, Beecher, | don't believe the stories they ar» teil- (oy about you; [ believe you are @ good man.” — y consent of counsel it was agreed that the de- nial of Mrs, Moniton should go on (he record as | made, Frank Moulton then resumed the chair, and alter denying the assertion of Mr. Beecher that he (Moui‘on) had asked tne defendant to pay Bes- me Turner's school vil, retired for good. Stephen Pear: Andrews was recul'ed to prove the signature of James H, blood, reputed husband of Victoria Woodsuli, to & iease Of the premises James Frecland recailed, contradicted the as- sertion of Henry ©. Bowen that the interview of Decemver 26, 1870, occurred at tis (Free.and’s) | house, The cross-examinauion was a very amu-- ing one, and the witness finally escaped from the sand quite angry at Mr. Fullerton, who evidently took aelignt in tormenting him. Mrs. Maria M. Ovington recalled, was examined at leogtu regarding the duration of tne interview ather house vetween Bessie Turser and Geveral Tracy, When she pronounced the statements made by Aibert P, Marcin as ialse, She was very ew: phatic in these assertions, and her answers were | given deliberately and while she was looking | directiy in tue face of Martin, Her testimony was | | as foliows:— | Examined by Mr, Shearman—Are yon ac. quainted witn Mr. Alpert 2. Martin, Who gave tes | ha im this case? a, | was acquainted with | him. 4% Was he in the habit of visiting at your house in tae summer of 1874? A. He visited irequentiy | st my house aiter Mra, Tilton came there in July, Q Do you recollect, Mrs, Ovington, ons hens when he visited your nouse when Miss Tarner and | | General Tracy were there t A, Yes, sit; be wag there July 24, 1874, )' Mr. Maitin testified that he came to your house at ball-past two o'clock, and ne found Gen eral ifacy and Miss Turoer in the back parior. Where Was Miss turner at bali-past two on tue alternoon of the day of Mr, Martin's visit? A. At hail-past two o’ciock Miss Turner was in the back parior playing the piauo, in company With Mrs, Uvington, Mrs. Tilton and myself; General Tracy Was HOt in the house at that tin | .Q@ Are you positive that it was B past two | o'clock When Miss Turner was with you and Mrs, Tilton tm (he back parior, and that Mr. Martin and | Geveral Tracy were not there thea? A. I can | swear tratmally that they were m Q Mr. Martin testities that Gener! trae? A. Itts iaise. | Q Mr. Martin testified that Miss Tarner and General Tracy were seated in the back piazza of | your house for two hour Is toat trae? A, itis jalse, Q. Mr. Martin testifes that after General Tracy leit the Whole conversation or discussion ween Miss Turner aud some other person no’ Was the testimony which she oing to giv before the \uvestigativg Committee. Je that irae A. It la tise, Tracy went | away from your house about five o'clock. Is that SS LAP. | expected this furniture would be sent, | ton. | auction woud be expensive, And be saya that no other topic was talked of oot that eutjcet aiter General Tracy lefty A. 1s not true; there was no discussion after Goneral Traey iaitt Word was said on ibe subieat: we isa Turner weat went to the tea tavie, sna belore the commitice vomedciately after tea, THAT PIAZZ& INTERVIEW, Q. Mr. Martin says your piazza in the rear of tae house is not cool enough to sit upon until half past two or threw o'clock Im ihe afternoon, He Nays there ts some protection (rout the projection of the house next door, Which rons back. (Coun- sel read that section of Murtin’s evidence.) that so? Mr. Fullerton claimed this Was au collateral and shouid hot be received. Wis, OVingLOD, is Dot the piazza the hot 4 tween hall-past two and four o'clock! A. We have always regarded 1€ 80. Q. Does the uext house on eltuer side of ie | oui house project beyond the rear of your house? A r side, Q. Is your piazza exposed to the sun im the a(ternoon ¥ A, It ts directly exposed to the sua, Q. Have you recently taken pains to observe when the sun shines on your piaaz A. Yes: from two tll! nearly balt-past five; im the summe 1 tink longer, : Q. Mr. Martin testified that he sawa clock ts the room up stairs and by it learned the time; te there a clock there? A, I think there is, but i has not been runuing for two or three ye . When did General Tracy leave? A. lt war before dusk, a littie aiter six o'clock, Q. Do you remember a conversation In whien Mr, Tilton said you toid him “Mrs, Tilton loves you and would lie for you; did you have such @ conversation with him? A, No, ir. Q. Do you remember the conversation to which Mr. ‘ilton testified in regard to the piazza being better than ts, because of seclusion and comfurt combined ? A, No. sir, Cross-examined by Mr, Fullerton—Q. Was ue Scandal (ne Sudject of conversation that evening | A. Not oue word, Q. flow long was the conversation between General Tracy aud Miss Turner? A, Little teas than an hour—apout fifty minutes, Q. When did Miss Turner leave the house to ga beiore the comunttec ? A. LT think a littie before seven o’cluck ; It Was davight. “That's ail,” sald Mr. Fudierton, and the witnest was escorted from the chair by her son, Judge Neilson— Weill, this is the case on botk sides, Mr. Evarts—No, Your Honor, we have several witnesses, but they won't be long. Mr. Eggleston was recalled, vut the jury rose, and, the Judge cousenting, the Court was ad- journed till eleven o’clock this forenoon, COLUMBIA COLLEGE. SIXTEENTH’ ANNUAL COMMENCEMENT OF THB LAW SCHOOL—DIPLOMAS CONFERRED ON TWO HUNDRED AND TEN GRADUATES. ‘The Columbia College Law School held its six- teenth annual commencement last evening at the Academy of Music, in presence of an andience highly fashionable and deeply interested im the exercises, Boxes, orchestra chairs, parquet, dress circle and galleries were all illed, especially the upper gallery, in which tere was scarcely standing room. On the sage were @ number oj prominent citizens, smong them being Peter Cooper, Judge Llatenford, S, P. Nash, Edward Patterson, Hamilton Odell, Professor John Or- donuux, Professor Chase, Heury W. Johnson, John M, Nox and some twenty others, Shortiy detore eight o'clock Graiulla’s orchestra Opened Wito Aitlle.’s “fwo Leaves.’ which Was followed by selections from “Giroté-Girofla,”? aud during tne performance of the latter President F, Barnard, with Proiessor DWight and me Rey. Dr. Dufile gn either side, and folowed by the Board of Trastees of tae Coilege, came upon the platiorin apd Were received with applause. Presi: dent Barnard wore his acudemic robes—the col: lege Cap and the scariet gowu. ‘Ine graduates, 210 In nuimber, tI led iu and were escorted to seats by Grand Marshal Allen and his aids, Imme- diately in iront of the stage. The appearance of the house when all were s2atea aud the venerable President rose to introduce Professor Dwigot, Who Was lo deliver an address, was brill- jantand lurposiug, Professor Dwight's adaresa was eloquent and attimes afectiny. Tue vaie- dictory aderess Was delivered by Frederick W, Henrich, A. 8., and was botn well written aod well deciaimed, Mr. Henrich received deserved applause. ‘The alumni oration was given by James A, Bianchard, A. B., LL. BL Professor Dwignt reaa the report of the Commiftee on Award of Prizes, pretactng by saying that the test of merit had been made by essay and by written answers to printed qu tons. ‘The followmg were the vad~ uates wio received the honors:—First, prize, $250, Sutherland Tenney, or New York city; second prize, $160, William §, Tales, 01 Brookiya; third prize, $100, Rovert Vickey, of Chicago, The first two prize men are graduates of Colamoia College and the third is s graduate of Harvard Voilege, Monoradle Mention was made o1 Taomas ‘Thacher, George N. Hale, John P, Sweeney, Wilk jam 8. Hornblower and Jonn ©. Gulick. The diplomas were Conierred by the President, f graduates comimg upon the platform in group €avn separate group Lumbering as many a8 came under the imitial letter of tue names in alpna. betical order. ‘ne music curing the evening w: exceilent, among the selections bvelug Balie’s aliaman,’ Strauss’ hte age “Da Du” and Autograph,” and parts o: Meyerbeer’s “Pro- pete. AN AWKWARD AUCTION. HOW & LADY PAID FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS FOR FURNITURE AND HOW SHE WAS LEFT WITH s& EMPTY HOUSE. ‘Tne Mayor's First Marshal, Mr. John Tyler Kelly, yesterday brougat up a furniture dealer with & sharp turo. The man’s name is William R. Romain, AMrs, Haghes compiained that she had bougn® ‘from Romain, some months ago, $1,000 worth af | furnicure, on which she had pa’a very nearly $500 in instalments, A few days ago, desirous of giving up@er house, she tuf rmed Romain tnat coure not afford to continue ths piymencs, whereupom an arrangement was made by which the goods were tobe sold at auction. Mrs. Hughes stated that she had in the house about $200 worth of tur- niture other than that boashs from Romain, aod She whtch by agreement was to be old in for her. claimed that ali the furniture ane oat the furoiture which she vad not bougnt from Romain was carted away and she had nos been aole to recover uny portion of it, Besides, ia THE GENERAL ACCOUNT sent to her after the saic, Romain made her out hus debtor to the extent of $18. A Mr. McUlellan, who had bid in tor her a large portion of the tur- miture, which nad never belonged in any way to Romain, stated that C eppege ss) was given toe Keys of the nonse @r flat to whica Mrs. Hagh nd walted Mra, there jor its coming, but It never Hughes added to this statement that s| nt to the turniture establishment of Mr. Havens, 1D Toird avenue, and there identified a lounge and some other things waich beiouged to toat por ion of ner icrniture on which Romain bad no claim. Mr. McClellan Weut there also, lie said; and Mr. Havens, when spoken to by him # out the furniture, saia he did not know anything about it, only “that it wad oeen sent tuere by Ro- main.” Mrs, Hugnes staved to the Marshal taat ail she wantea Ro main cented tha’ not of the los ne had “eased,” as he put it, to M Hughes, had been in the nouse at his suggestion auring sale, and he claimed that he had om dered bis cartmen to take it to Mrs, Hughes’ place, What had becowe of it since be did not kKoow, It turned out during the hearing that some of the turnisure “leased”? to mrs. Hughes by Romaii was second baad, and that he was, in point o! @ dealer tu a certain extent in secondhand : No, 48 Broad street, from May, 1872, to May, 1873, © ure, Inasmuch as he had disposed of tneiun Then the rebuttal closed, | nitare he haa “jeased” after the gaie in Mrs SURREBUTTAL | Hughes’ how ‘Tne M inquired if he had a | license jer in secondiand turaiture. replied he had not, whereapon ti Li bim $25. Mr. Romain patd $20 down, and prom. ised to COME DOWN AND PAY the remainder of the fine to-day, and as it wit require $25 more to get out a license bis visit t¢ the Marsha: will bave cost him when be gets through just $50. The Marshal informed Mm! if she believed she a Mr, retson, who who was, Mrs, Hugn main, Was present Mra. ~=Hughes her when she stated, obtained by Ro during tie imvest stated that asked him “Oh, no; I ke & running account with nim (the auctiol it will be about $10, and the printing of the told ns list of the furniture will be about $10, whicn you caa ay. " in looking over the manifest (and the papers hes rela’ og to the Sale) of the Kelly discovered that t per cent commission, alt pi yo! ou wi heid by Mrs. furniture soid, Marshal auctio: r had charged ten whereas jaw only allows two and cent, aod at once took him before th Colef Clerk to show cause Why his lice not be revoked, The trial of the auctioneer take place to-day. THE TAMMANY SOCIETY. The Tammany Soctety held a special meeting last evening at the Wigwam in Fourteenth street, for the purpose of installing the newly elected Sachems, There was a very large crowd of big and little Injun boys present and the best of feels ing prevailed, although at one time quite a seri ous row Was threatened by the report that Lig Inyun Bernard Keilly intended to deliver a eulogy on the late Mr. Kicking Bird, wao took too much poison for his ow good « few weeks MZoy and who some Of tue short-haired Infans of tne Tammany Order believe to have been & swallow: tail member of the tribe, There was nothing Lew in the ceremonies, which, of ciuree, Were held within © doo ihe following are the Suchems who are to hola office jor the ensulig year:—Jonn Kelly, fhomas ugiap, kKdwaro by Dponneily, William h. Wickham, Acram 3, Hewilit Bernard Reilly, Nathaniel Jarvis, Jr; Mies Be Andras, William Waish, William ©. Oom pl ad Smyto, Heary le Clinton ana George