The New York Herald Newspaper, April 13, 1867, Page 10

10 — WASAINGTON. CONTINUED FROM THIRD PAGE. constitutional Whore tes law; 2 a {nviolable, and that, | tovbived. it is wo long to detain the court with reading the United Staics. Se . sare cute any done ‘tho to use the word in its commor in legal language, asuit not fit nited States can for one moment si a8 amicus curia, or as | $Eions reretoes ing She Feseiaeat, Leere Salt Sao: 5/1. cong qteen ieee meee Weert Malice a anor e motion made @ this Dil attempt to from tis ‘receras of this | general reazon—one to preserve our peace with foreign | 00 appeal from the hte a Porqiore Slate tribuns K approbation, advice Souter which th ~~ ory’s ferred commen! federal courts to general fame act is President of Sent be r mm, aD allow a court Soe vith iad maaan is our President no tribat ie unt we doal with him. ‘im and remove him, and strip from a then take him and ‘and as be deserves, but not dent he is nota mmurdores oar President, and ay have done pun not from him the @ auitin {aot 18 ng a if it wore Urosehs ag rd, and for this Treter your honors now to the case or nrgis wa Juam Madras (1 Potara, 123), e up there in a suit ing the opinion Governor. The demand opon him is not made personal Tt seems the sult was against him 7 ‘Damn tion of these cases, in which origival jurisdiction fo Pr STE aS. india steee ming hit ig given ‘to this court, there 18 nono to which good man, and conferred countless blessings on his im {8 in big | the judicial power extends, from which the oriztaal | country and posterity, yot I belfeve he used to boast officially. ’” Andividuall®, same poor here against the President, not to execute | Preme Court of the United States, that in cases in w original jurisdiction is g.ven to tue Supreme Court that the laws, for the ndividual ee! BG power 10 exe. | int et cannot to axercised by an Inferior court, nor’ | the United Staten. Te wring refute fetara wich it have keep 60 Court. instruction of the President that make this objection. mako it on my own motion, as law officer of the | Affecting ambassadors, thing. ¢ Magistrate of Chie! lagistrate 8 name, but by his style of nee Maa the claim made upon | Court; that is exclusi' Liste itselt tay ba considered sea'pany'in the record* | stitution, and the constitution i'self’ has oon- | the opinion of Thomas Jelfersou with those of Chict may bo considered Justine Marshall ne “ * sented that in a great case in which a Siate is farshall and Justice Story and the Supreme Haare ney ne Our aay atic cones’ | a party, that State can mako an appeal by oriziqal Dill | Court of tho United States, aud of He 1s beyond the reach | to the Supreme Court, The Court will reculloct that in the recent publication of the fourth volume of his bie, _ natch Preset ot it {s not difficult toehow that ‘ainst the United States, against them by mame upon the of this court, (ue Guveruvr ur ibe question £55, 10 which the oplaion. was given, by Chiet Justice ay origin ia Sine, hak was meant by saying Abe, Governor ot #'| jurtadicton is gived to the Sapsome Coury the. Jad-cial | Thomas JefTorsoo tn reusing to obey that sub “The claim ee the Governor is Ho is sued pot by bis name but by at sppebere t6e Btate itself Again power derived from the constitution. " Tegard to the power by which this tribunal was created, of any ouher department except in the mode Prescribed | that such was the ro-pect that. was entertained for th | ahd Madison and Jay in the Federalist at the very time Deyo at department of the government, such was the | When the constitution was pending for its ratification be- “ iiroog control of | EPsolute necveslty of creating this department, as a | fore the people, setting out plainly before them that the Teached by | peaceful arbiter, to avoid the ciasning of arms and hos- constitution created one vested in tho by the constitution through There itis. As President other hing of the government. Only in that other you arraign bim for anythin; ile he 1 President, i seems to me unnecessary far as this dill seeks to make the from oe d@alous I mean in Therefore it is officer representing the scandalous a It is with ~ gn ine Wee | Wat decision, bat tnls precise eg og tg isnselt’ to, ceil lenny, 306 to 402 of 6 Wheaton, The same doctrine | much and so | justly respected = poles Sew es lg Bs a +e foun ine dentally im the case of Hunter’s Lea- | the whole country. I refer to those President, as I said of Sir President should i - dg aa to com! a ‘murder, he could not be tri first of ail, he is the the mation malas ont Lae A ¥ = see vs. Martin @ being 9 where the decision was given et himself im a moment of id, “appellate $i jae f. by tbe Please, the igh orime of | Tion'to ae Buprodus Court ia all’cases where it bas noi | even by the hands of the President, the pommenenve- of deal him before they him, Saaraan 9 Jong as this | Cannot tak appeliate a ‘shall touch him for | cam take When we deal with | Sreve had not Trom him the robes of | apd ce bat givin uuish him as you please, | the ee in the Inf I thea, While he is Presi- | that either be east rin ‘the eve of the law. He is | the party who was suing, had broug’ ~ Be nothing else. Whatever theindividual | 22¢ 8p) ish him for. it individaally, bas take inviolability o rT ‘although the argament it seems to fa crery ahiaeet Rated | the Court plea, “pon the ground that the suit bere is | ‘aU ty, ema asmuch have wa auth me power of the United States cannot be ox 18, Here the individ pamed as President, and the eult against Jurisdiction of the inferior courts is excluded by the official capacity, for his official eonduet, so tbat it and eset eante a the ene: Farge ze Officer, as it | bere we have four conseontive decisions of the Su- ia ay a Fig = where the impeaching ment power, For impeaching power? The misdemeanora, Thi he, Bynes to this, for the | of constituttonal law, that was the only clause in tutional law. What can highest crimes and misdemeanors, he is above, as Prosi. | the | constitution | wnicl be —s sag tell of Mr. Madison, that where two laws conilict with each unanimous vote of the convention wh.cl mi Gent, the power of any court or any other department | ‘strumeut, “But now suppose that iastead of being ex. | the law is to decide which shall prevail; that when you done or omitted to bo | Slasive the jurisdiction should be concurrent—that | take up an act of Congress on one page, and fay it please your Honors, | Would not take away tho original junsdiction. The oniy constitution on the other, if the act of Congress is in to paras this question. dent a party, I pect, not 10 oriticizo | Dring it hero, by original bill lao; bat as that would | liton; su Sao wih hich thi vi ve ara PM | The conclusion clear, ass shown byt ena oat gret de a shown by the debato;_ such was the pinion of the be brought, ‘and which | cisions, that the jurisdiction woul vent ory pe sees rd Prana pre pes arerin aT seine twenty-iien | t 4 HERALD, SATUR By 867.—TRIPLE SHEET NEW YORK , SATURDAY, AY RIL 13, 1867.—TRIP = - - me pee of om i a Nn eee nr EN All officers are placed On PF" sige! MISCELLANEOUS, SITUATIONS WANTED~fEMALES. are negative, ‘and that the ertinal jurisdiction is exclu- | Hike the President. him in thes, otsely ‘COLO! 1D; ust UM. UN- where a State | the samo footing with respoch, W'""a the sin- 101 RD.—-BUY YOUR FRENCH WES? “TH SECOND FLOO! FRONT ‘AXTED—A, COLORED SERN grb; MU ‘ues 90, Agi Porn “otra character of the — ope mit ease eg’ td the Chief linea pisten's 3, 134 PIECES, $90, % z 1. Foom=A Teaneck ie gatas spay teaet tat | Kate as So eee , not Se of its betng a State, but comes peached, e0es. . - “ a Pp like any biber person, under that clause of thecon- | the Prosideat cannot volute fr au offence until he i x doa ane NSD AND LBXING- TE COOK, stitution ond of te act of 1789 giving this court a right | out of oflice, rubject i officers of bong Plates, e ton ava. young girl as ‘seamstress, |- angraatg ets ofa family. ‘at No. ue to decicte, ‘not in consequence of the character of the par- | States who are 0 tm cannot be tri ey Cut ‘Goblne, no ob fon to of one eblas ‘has good re until they are out 6f office regret some rémarks, which I trust will turn out to be fa Adiga too hasty and inadvertent, that fell from the ae of Marshall | my learned and able who is ties, bt but in @ousequence of tho maintained and reaffirmed by Chief Justice Gesoaghort in whi he said that 1f this court, 1m fm the of its sworn performance In that case the learned Justice | duty, should pi dor its oath of office to defend we dopa 4 Justice | the onstitution of the. United. States from iolation, original juris jon, subject, however, to such regula- tions as Congress would not obey its order, and that there would "te "The Coury thea, | brought on a direct and fearful confict between th: fm acase in which it | President and this great tribunal has peastedes y more strongly aud with more ability than this very President of the United * in bis nda veto messages which | suppose had the approbation of his Cabmet, or at least a portion of them, for the finality of the decisions of the Supreme. Court of the United a cane, Rasenimelicaess inves prvcecprreorae Sh msgs rt Be punal to tho Suyesag | atitation? Who m time to time, wi ee Ply Sou egies jarisdiction aud mote ability and force this pare the great Juriadiction. scones the result wourd follow tbat joctrine that all the departments of ment ration, every county, every wre sworn to eapport the pom the United Boy aie zie ie Dain, oa bang | See ahosiod by, ths SOMMeam ha led te hoa _ the ver ates whic: (amy Ny rem coer the ont: partion that are | @ result, as my learned brother has referred to, for the forbids 19 pacsyvityio tos he government of | peaceful, and final and rade decision of all such States in ite own judicial tribu In ad- | questions aa this, What! the President of the United ae to the cases already cited, in the great cuse of | States not obey the mandato of this Court! If not, he U1 Wheaton, | disobeys the mandate of the constitution, vs, the Bank of the United States (9 Wheatot 09 pes a y pata Hhesejeotctist to say that the Pregident merely follows the example of the jud.ciai pena. ised ir its A WaLker—That was not cared a es fae appellate form, In every other case the power is tobe | become necostary to carry it out. ar the | would have poner bor eit existed ta pertectly its original or appellate form, as the tania Tron tho. dointon all Chil seapce weatalt Bor, although Mr. Je was a Very great and very Jurisdiction ia given to the Sapreme Cou wiadom of Congro:8 may direct,” With the excep that he was no lawyer, and he had no very favorable opinion of lawyers or ot judg nor Fa yer a of the Sapremo Court of the Uni the great ch |-man who presided there—Chief ‘estce during the period when Mr, Jefferson was President of Besides the authority of Judge Tuck ‘can the case como up by an appeal to the Supreme | would be well for hia reputation had they been ex] ne in casey ike tats, the jurisdiction | ftom his biography, Upon a judicial question like this it is vested directly by the con- | 1 would not waste time upon any attempt to couple’ in writings, carrying out the idea set forth by Hamilton ‘tribunal—the Supreme est crimes and | tile array in order to avoid all disputed questions | Court—for a peaceful decision of al queations of conn ‘be stronger than the lan; other, the tribunal which is to expound and interpret take up the 89 result would be that there mal ‘ht be asuit brought in | Conflict with the probibitions of the constitution, that the inferior judiclal tribunals, and brought up by appeal instrument declares it to be utterly null and void? to the Supreme Court, while sere would bea right to | Such was the opionion of Jay, of hiadiaon and of Ham- ich was the sense in which the people of all the the constitution when it was framed, of many of tho men who in which a State was not a pal ‘waa brought rede ee wer hegre sare in an ee here prema riba is original jurisdiction was I cases ie ; constitution, laws or treaties of the United even gave Goal jurediction to the construction of the powers, and the other to preserve between the dif- | there is anything that is definitely settled for three- ferent camponent members of this great Union. Tho | fourths of a century, by Repealed and manifest decisions proar hero 40 | original jurisdiction was given only is two cases—one | of this court, the opinions of the framors oi tne the other public ministers and | Constitution and the great statesmen of the day, 4: veroment, but this I must say in defence’ of the | consuls, decisions m regatd to whom might affect vitally | that ths is the tribunal, and the only tribunal Siantod resident, affecting am! ule, and those in which a Stato shail be a pai troyed, Sere the present case might be derived from the jurisdiction In the case of controversy nited States is a party. Biates be suod under that clause of the constivationt On | was the suit against the Govornor of Georgia, he most definite | my learned brother, and the Court well remarked in | lows:—My leamed taims and | that case that no process could issue unless against | calamities which would follow if the President of the with its.own consent with m; De suc ircct provision consent by an act pea of any juried yarn by suite before the inferior | the court will only select and m: ey Tt ig @ peia- SS dJurisdicti the Supreme construction of any oue or jon From the moment that they eonstitution of the United Stat for by his veto he admits it to be a moro, ministerial | works are used in duty which ho is compelled by law to do) la in fact a | tion when the constitution speaks of “controversi ¢.t» | ty ‘decline the exercise of | Jurisdicdem which Proceeding. against the government of tho United States, | two eases, when the meaning of the constitution 1s ¢x- and whether such a bill can be entertained by this tribn- | pressed in the same words, “Shall be a puaciy,” nal, These questions dopend upon the proper con: | Sball the words “Cases in which a State struction of the constitution of the United States, and | cases in which a State shall oc a party piainsJif M# therefore becomes necessary for me to read, althongh | as well as a party defendant? And shail precissiy | o¢ tuat great State, then composed of tho most Mt is so familiar to tne Court, that great clause creating | Similar words, ‘controversies to which the Uuited the judicial power. of original and appellate jurisdiction: baasadors, othor public ministers one con- | rious State conventions which ratified it, or in the great the | discussions in the Fed-ralis, will you find a single word seocaty chat may Supreme-Court sball have original jurisdiction,” ‘and it | going to show that that claieo of the constitution which was not confined as was the appellate jurisdiction to the eases ‘before mentioned”? in the that the Court had original Jurisdiction jn any case in wuich a State wasa party, unlesa expressly restrained | by what authori Dy other provisions of the constitution, In those cases | interpolate into oR where the Court had original jurisdiction by the consti. | si» to which the United Staces shall be sation it waa exclusive, Tt was vested dicactly by ae tiff,” any more than evnstitution, and could neitver be impay nor nor diminished, nor aflected in any way | taken in this supposition, and that wo cannot directly Seasea Greene va. Mumford (5 Buode Island); wr any St 6 Congress, Another source of jurisdiction | sue the government of the United States, the question the of 0 es is, is this a euit against the government of the United ‘that subject Congress bas oxpreseed tl opinions. It has constituted the Court of granted an appeal from it to the Suprome Court. The ATrORNKY-Gewenat—Alio® me to say, thst is by | named against whom any process to be sued atany | ask, is the President of the United states the The President cannot. | ment ef the United Staies? Is this asuit agai Inited States can be sued, I | United States of America? Does the President, in a suit | permits these military laws to go into eifoct, what then? man to an authority that I did not | like tht represent all the departments of the gov 288, where the courteay, | ment? The distinction 4s drawn in the clearest man: the case in the Circuit | by Chief Justi Court, as the government or hable to ve sued except | which he said , nor can a decree or | the case of tho king. Although hoe perhaps mav give | tem States are to be expelled from the Union; ten mil- vernment for costa ’ | testimony, it is said to e jucompatiblo with his dignity | lions of ow so are tobe deprived ot ail the benefits of I epti.ely concur s bn under ae of the couri, | the constitu learned brother thet the ‘government cannot mnt; but it may aes bya Baise the first magistrate ef England and the firat | to be tried out of their States for offeoces unknown and or it may | magi ‘Whon it comes to the | dignity conferred on them by sueir respective nations, | prived of the right of trial by jury and in time of pro- Upon the Mae whether the bea the read when I wea up, 2 iowa “There was no ju except A its conse oe oo con: rts, undoubtedly there must be an act of Congres; | ciple of the English constitution fat what 1 call ibe attention of the court to Is this, that | wrong; that no blame can be linputed to him; that be | in revellion; deprived of the the judicial power docs enibrace a case of a cuit against | cannot be named in debate, By the constitution of the spent cltizens, So far as ‘Constitutional the government of the United States. Congress may | United States the Preatdent, as well as any other officer Although the havo said that he has vetoed t! fantiomen, ix in thei ‘Congress constitutional, when the Presi After reading the various clauses of | q dijforent moaning sod as confined to cases 1a which | take Jurisdiction, article third of the constitution, he proceeded to puint | the United States shail bea party plaintif? By what | might be, whoever aight menance disebedience out the difference between the words used in the grant | authority of law or of any debate or proceodiugs in the | t the mandate of the court in a caso given ta hem, by ‘In all cases | convention which framed tho constitution, or ta_the va- pol ee et Jaw, would preceding clause, 80 Jurisdiction ir dill, | tho paco and happiness of the wholo nation; and the | by the constitution whose decision is final and couclu- ‘as un. | other cases in which a State should be a party, decisions | sive, upon the interpretation ef the constitution. If it t did that he did every | in relation to whom alco might be affected with most | Were Rot 80, as welt burn up tho sonstitution, If it thing that he intended to do in opposition to these laws, | disastrous rogults if there was not ono great | 18 to depend upon how Thomas Jefferson, President, one wero passed over bis veto | tribunal to which ‘they might hasten at ones, there was bat one duty, in his estimation, resting upon | Without delay or loss of dignity, on appearing before Dim, and that was fathtully to carry out and execute | Inferior tribunals and lay thelr case promptly betore tion shall be given by the various States the ‘mion, theso laws. He has instructed mo to sa that in making this objection it 18 not for the purpose of escaping from | 8 Commentary that is most siguificant upon the import- | essence ey responsibility either to perform or to refuse to per- | ace of conferring upon this cou fori day construed it, or howAudrew Repro Ereiceny shall construe it the noxt, or what conflictin; is court. Aro not the facts that it can baye Do possible uniformity, This 4s of the cou! TO no! at are now transpiring -e of ithe "doctrine pi uuilioaion ana immediately, with- | Secession. was with great rogrot outdelay, without a resort to inferior tribauuatsad the | that I heard these inadvertent remarks auade by long course of decisions there, and appeal hore the right | # gentleman who is so highly but Utbink this ARGUMENT OF MR. R. J, —— IN FAVOR OF THE PET- | 19 decide at once all cases in which a Xtate tsa party, or | Court will answer the wonace in which he bas indulged If the Court please, the discussion of the prelim!- mary objection presented by my learned and distin. | rocking on their bases, and it may be that of Errors and Appeals of guished brother, the Attorney General, divides itseif Properly into two parte:—First, whether under the | Perhaps it may well be that such a result can only be | Of Errora aud Appeals of the government of tho accompiisihed by the interposition of this court. Court of the United States considered a agure and the High Court forth io thetr opinion, when ai ichn, oaaniposal ot this goyernment is to be saved if it is not to become a a 10 101 was brought up mere mass of broken columns and mouidering rainy | for the flual aajudication = anaes thao ror gre would not obey the dual tine of the Supreme Court States—precisoly the same menace & controversy in which the United States is a party ? | #8 the Supreme Tue very foundations of the government are now j Similar menace from the T next a to call partioular attention te | of tne United United States can be sued in any tribunal, State or na: | ing meaning the worls ‘Statds” and | that is mad> here, Permit me oo read the tional; and, second, whether a bill to restrain the Pre- | ‘ parties,” Sue seem Broaly to strengthen this | auswer that was ident of the United States, by injunction issuing from | interpretation, Tho words that im att cases | teruugh Chief Ji this fr into of affectiag ambesradors, ner 9 Public ministers and | M8 oF court, from carrying into e‘Tect an act of Conzress | conau'a, Ne and those in which a State shal boa par.y wns | (Ov)2—°U) ‘ag tho legslative may, forbidden by the constitution, and therefore unconatitu- | Supremo a hal Nave original geetelaction Tt tit, by et be errs yr ete ry *prosshon e confines of tional and void, being a proceoding to enjoin the Preai- | been set! y court, in @ repeated socies of de. ry 01 cannt ‘because cinona, that the term “ pariy’? there-apptios as well wy | tedut ds. With wualever doubts or wbatever difficul- Gent from the porformance of a mere ministerial duty | g ray Plaintit ns to gh Sit utbabenea sie ence be attended we must decide it if tt be at betore um the preceding clause of the same sece We have no wore right xiveo thau te arurp thet whic is not Tne one of the otver would be treagon to the That wae the bp re ‘by tne Court in tht day to tho inenuce of the Legislature of the great ‘ a, ten all-powerful, and tothe unani- resoive of tue High Court of Errors axd Appeals which the United States shall bo party.?” Now, in ese shall be a party,” be construed to extend to guished jurists aud statesmen who adorned States shall bea party,” be constraed as having enurety | any court, that for this court to refuse whatever the consequence do trespass to the eonsiitu- say here, with s faut sense of all.the re- devolve upon me, for the wee, peers an opinion, I say shat ¥ oaks Of “controversies to which the United States | this —— _ isgue ite mandate pega | an 2 hail be a party” should have the restricted meaning, be unconstitutiony, and “shail bes party plaintiffand nota party defendantt’” Aud ete or pee, of Way, or any of the would ot army from the execution "But | pext commented in to tho ,cases of Kendall va, suppose, for the sake of argument, that I may bo mis- Stockton (12 Peters, 644); Ellis vs. Earl Gray ray (6 Si rR, arrol vs. Osborn States? This is not a chowing jait against whe President of the ); United | United States, only giving the name ot no individual, as | that no officer is above the Jaw, but that all functionaries cited’ by | are amenable and responsible to it, apd concluded as fol- jearned brotuer has drawn a picture ot United States should disobey the mandate of this court. Let us look at calamities that might follow on the » | other hand. If this court declines to exercise tho the | powor which J think is granted by the constitution, and the State, because there was no individual could issue. I According to the President's own opivion, the constita- | tion of the United States is subverted asd over- in the great case of Burr, in | thrown, According to his opinion a ilitary —“The single reservation alluded to is | despotism Js ‘rected wpon the ruins of the constitution; 2 jon, deprived of the right of trial by jury; many “og of difference wheh exist | cut up into Sve military districts, ins'ead of ten States; istrate of the United Statesin respect to the personal | undefined, merely at the will of a military offcer; de- found peace, when Congress itself admits that there is he king can do no | no rebeilion by sts latest acta, ‘ing of States lately ght and privilege of is concerned, they might as well bey undera Czar horus or the jurisdiction to an iodividual or corporation to sue | of the government, may bo impeached and may bo | ora Sultan wy the banks ef the Bosp! United States directly in the inferior courts of the | removed from rye niga crimes aad misde! ened Nive as in this free country. Life, 11 may States, oven even in one of the inierior courts, unless a State | people again. How essentially this difference of circum. | all the other privile; can sue the Esee by am original proceed art of the United Staica, what would bs | countries in reference to the porsonal dignity of tt the result? tt ow would be the consequence of such a | ecutive Cuief will be perceived by every person, Jn this | stitailon of Mississippi, and is recited and accepted as Take the case of | respect the frst magis: bonds of the government of the United States disputed, | moro properly be likened to the first magi like those issued to Texas, of en individual or corporation holdiog euch bonds may | confederation, and it |¢ ‘pot gue for the r.covery of thea in ‘ s ber of tials, hold num by, ore peo is DO taries, vol. 3, sec. 10TI-72, we ba show that, in the opinion of that i ¢ or, tne might provide for suits in the establish claims on contracts of the in @ note to section 1603 the ef a vera ment. 3 the learned commepiator, RaCt that im controversies dues ombrace ect sueing the United states in o if where is say Pine cided cases, as I = *f fa allsatte "in which ‘a Sta State wy, tee Juriatiction depoude, nor ca at ‘the charactor of the party, ae steven of this court is le exclusive, And Uy can neither be taken fro re ee a can it bo in (Wheaton, tod (1-Cranch.), and the constiLution? Accordiag to this doctrine any | be served wah a ube we a these bonds, ‘even quotes Mr. Tucker ae referring to the word “controversies” in the judicial clauso, as including such disputes as might arise betwee the United States and more States roepecting fiscal matters, or between their debtors, United States and | jon was never recwled, or cha we contractors and agents is © ) any respect whatsoever. Of cours, if the Court had a any tribu Nery bigh authority elted, apparently with appro- | right to issue a sc bation by coveriag | of the United Sta that clause giving jurtediction | other peraon it would foliow, as a necossary consequence, Geveral has confived bis argument, and I un States is & party | that the Court bad‘a right to follow ou a disobedience | the court t bave confined us to the preliminary, oe home te if 80, the | w that sadpena by the pi esti ether bioh gives to thie'e, 4 bogey of the constitution fd es Tue distinction de Jariadiction in ali cases ta" write ah in which the United States as well as individuala, rocecd Ng, States is a] in that caso, The King o' eflvct | He ie the fountain of jas ig 3 State In this Court asan | the King’s courts, © In the cause of an individual | government, aro the King’s officers fhe King | toreply? oue of th debattely vo inferior tribunals, Union; but it cannot give such a power fora Slate | By the constitution of Great Britain the Crow | may be taken from them without due to sue, Decause in all cases iu which a State is a | is hereditary, and the monarch can never be jon is conferred exclusively to this | By that of an original bill, If, then, an individual or | from the massof the people and on tue expiration of the gue the coverument of the United | time for when ue 18 elected raturns to the maas of the @ United States the President so coool of =Missiest; are to go back to a territorial Siate let them ihe right of trial by jury, and habeas corpus and secured by that com This upheld the validity the ord!- Ex. ance of 1787. That ordinance js madea art of the con- in | stances must vary the policy of the laws of the two | Court “795"4 ate of the Uni & part ot if in the very act of Congress admitting Missiseippi as a State into tue Union. If they have gone the back to serettoezal privileges, not only are they still en- own over to have beoa | titled tee eabrg a of freemen i the territory, but State migut | thoy are, by direct compact, which has the force ‘of a tetfcandum. 1 ia any | tandamenial fs entitled to all the privileges and bene- sit hag over beon decided that | file of the ordinance of 175%, of which they are de- the President, that decision | prived by this Miltary Reconstraction — bill, I Triat of Aaron Burr, by | want to know it the subvereion of the constitution of the the a s cor.sequences | United states, which the President admtis ig accom. quently Dy iy learn. | plehed by this act, ic the ereciion of mili ibe ir dent of ‘the United | 0a the ruins of a federai constitution are not greater "33 of attachment to | evile and greater calamities than any of Bn which 1 before Chief Jus ica | bave been pictured with so much ei \d power It was owing ep- | by the learned Atiora jeneral of ‘the Cal United States ? that it became | 1 would gladly have prOeeded to discuss the other great but this opin. | questions which ure involved tn this case, presenting 4, or modified in | the most momentous is#ues that wero ever considered DY i, fraught for weal or woe with the aud welfare, perhaps the vory existence of ment. Yet inasmuch as the learned Attorney @ State, at any, rate, of | doubted that the chiot a Marshal extrageous — cause to carr it ont ef na, duces tecuno, to the President in the same manger as to aay of attachment for con- | ment as to the mere filing of this bill, T shail, with tho President and tho | permission of the court, reserve the consideration King of Groat Britain is wel! known by the Chief Justice | discussion of all these momentous questions toe England can do no wrong. | later period when the court shall have given us leave to ad of office, the courte, or | file thie bIL all the ofticers ubder tuat ‘Tite Omer Jusmor—Does the Attorney Genoral desire cannot be impeached, The succession is hereditary, Me O'CoNon-aI have permission to Saterpose a bled in oe There is no resemblance Whatever betwoen tho President | gestion at this point. I have reasca to belt itisthat | of the United States, who ts but one co-ordinate depart. | common right of @ party to file bis bill im, that, the | Soretenee in which | mout of this goverment, the Executive Department, on involved, | He does not even have ibe whole of the executive | affected iu tho cage of the State of Georgia by the @x- original juris: at jurisdiotion hor can it be im- | country; and the Senate may perpen d the officers he nom. conferred on any lod to quote | Again, tI Continued:-Tho, den’ fa, | but i cam Far Weettt will | thirds of the Senate. But the jeaton thi bo tried Wh 0 attompted to give ph pg Tr) Which the court has cognizance as io the ies is not power, because it is part of tho executive power to ap- | ception that has prosenied jiself t pore ine officers who are to execdte the jaws of the | gentleman—I even include io lado ind therefore, there can be and is no odjection to the fling of that, hg ‘no impertinonce, or irrelevance, en gt bee executive power, | or indecorum, or di in tho rules of order in without the consent of two- vara of foun file that bill’ and d take our sub- cg Jomnce—The Court will consider that - be Afrowent Gexmrat—Your honor asked if I inates, hs we have experienced at not exercise it moment, clause in regard to bis fro! Prigo it in civil casos, members of Con- | wished to to the argument _— it. Tess. are. exempt from. afrest or. impneonment | willl to rebuatt the imatior without further ety pian Court to exercise BE print pw On oy A He As to the other Ido not think the objection lies to the character of the ibs, batt they thorfre neg being irtod in |. att, O'Gonee-=l. would, soguiras om mabe that decision, | the courte ct wee”, ‘and panisbed, iknow | ‘cours wil vetsin thes questist cy hd the ag the Sa 8 Pen be one tah eae un coe remap ir, O'CoNOR—At a future time. At present to decide it. bi: a The Court held the matter under advisement, , q r dozen Silver Plated Ware, Fable Cui frigeratore and Housekeeping Articles ot ens Sieseer tanent in thecity, at ey ee ably less than an} A BASBEORD'3, BASSFORD’S, COOPER INSTITUTE AND ASTOR PLACE, commer store. Positively no conection with any other. Ll PARIS APPLIED TO THE SKIN A. Before wassng wil prevent 1 freekling oF tanning Ac USMAED DE DE PARIS. 3 will smooth out the marks of manit pox, snd closely Xen the akin like tvary. SURMAIL DE PARTS imps B imparts brilitant sia soft w oa in. Hol by iSABEAN, Sis! droadiway, and all the Dost i einera, el D3 P. P, 00.8 KAST INDIA Aw Coffee aye ses nd for 16 cents. New itn depote—Faterson, Palain treet; Newark, wi Jomey’ city arith an Gor e areola and Sedcker fh Genbral dee ponies Chambers street. JOS. dottogon sel Gs Proprietor, =I SITING WASHINGTON MAR- A Breas get the ee a East India Coffee, 8 pounds, sew, i tacnwin ieet we) jgunchard & Ge 765 New Aer eee ated eater &, BEACHAM, pam NO, 1!—VANILI ya NANTLLA, V. ‘ANI. Ne by a&TY Lee Vanilla. ion for sale ane Secu ‘a importers of Drugs, Eesential Olle and 'VORCHS OBTAINED—IN NEW YORK Stay ie cone aaa bane pub M, ows 5, Attorney, 78 78 Nassau sireot. TARRH.—PAIN AND NOISES IN THE HEAD-— RORTON'S New for Catarrh and mode of treui- ment acts like a charm. It breaks up thia terrible disease at irs fountain head, removes at ouce in in temples, offen- fire deen ee ia ets ioniusame eatiady ‘forever, ¥ by Ge fend stamp ‘for ‘bamphiet to GARRET Se et ONS Reeth —, BUNIONS, ENLARGED JOINTS AND ALL Cebit ses of the Feet cured by Dr, ZACHARIE, No. 78) roadway. IVORCES onan FROM THE COURTS OF THIS and other States, with as little reac ie recy as tyne lenny poe ibe [ein ine pepe or desertior rs ‘i Wt RING, Gounselion at Law, 212 Broadway. R, CUNNINGHAM’S ston soi My — NEVER DRSer aan sgt et, BRE Sos etreet, Nortoix. ion = faterre Oy Mt . MARCOU, ‘Aiorney, 2% Duane street. Di- faliy attended to, Cousittations free. LASS LETTERS FOR SIGNS—HOUSE NUMBERS, ,Pchly gilded, slvered, embmured and shaded. Surpass Rr aie Mink MhSweatdn Be. 107 Falton siroe Ors DRAWINGS OF THE GEORGIA STATE ries for the benefit of the ged on han Home. GEORGIA STATE, KETRA—CLASS 80. le RSS Ae wee Bs, fe ge tre a a SUPPLE relegated o to st 76, 20, 10, 15, 41, 48, 18, 17, Cen ob. nseerapersrate aia att. 12, WiWe nox UR MOTTO—“DO NO Har) .' Before you do otherwise when you feel sick, cold fect and it te eral Out OF gore FAKE “SRANDRETH’S PILLS. ‘Time, betta ‘and money thus a Full directions accompany 5 ench box of RANDRETH'S PILLS, Hon, Demas pares saya" ‘I sek more of BRAND- RETH’S PILLS than all other ther Kinds pe rane.” Oniee, Brandreth House, New York. Sold by druggists. See B. Brandreth is printed’ le govern- ment samp. HE GREATEST PAIN RELIEVER IN THE WORLD— Warranted superior to any-ether, or no pay, fer the cure of cbronic rhe old sores, eth pains Desk, Lunds ual chests sore thvoats, Ac.; slvo to inter- wally for cholic, ysentery, cron} at is soe’ Jnnooeet, aa norerfails ifused __ SITUATIONS WAN eases Seen a8. WASHINGTO! sa BATTERY PLACE, THIRD Zee orm an wet niet, say about WEST S7TH ST.—A Pants heen YOUSG WOMAN An nurse with a fnamiby going lo av. Rie RoveE—a cuauant ¢ GIRL 48 WET 7 WEST 21ST ST—A RESPECTABLE cou AS WAIT- Teas and chambermaid, Apply from 9 revved oto sera ly to Hurepe as warset it with sieeatog Inquire atthe use of her 1 EAST 18TH ST.—A LADY OF 10 ¥YBARS' EXPE- rience, aa housekeeper in this city. She would take charge ‘of the house during the absouce of the famally. ‘or address, with references, Housekeeper. 173 po ae pet 8T., ey THE Poten Meat Ma oro mended G réll recon jorman gil Lowe's Ger- nan foes 17 ne peed a tampa in’ se way been employed ia a Feepestal sora for Q EAST Uta, #t.. REAR, BUILDING—4 RESPRO- table colored woman wishes-todake im plain sewing; good reference given, Gall for two days on Mrs, Seheak. Lae S8T., peed msentin wine» REAR—A ope Call for two days. Fa HAMILTON " ST—A-” RESP! YOUNG wala Tike to io ctaraping ei ‘with Say et ant ies 00 sower and Can be ition, Fors weak at her own retidence, Sitza O'NEIL. i Spaunats sjomr et country; would travel; et fou Years’ references. ° 37, FAST ISTH STA MIDDLE AGED MAN, A NA- ive of Paris and weil acquainted with the soon npaay as nr cor aud atimnde ni gone Qrimore Paris for the woxt W ee for information and refereassars sn” Aree 37 STANTON St, In REAR—& YOUNG GIRiy Ag Shilaren: Call for two days. Sa a BTN PITT 8T., SOUTH YOUNG WOMAN, who oi underetan de, sootling tat tts breaehee both meats and fon fo hotel er board Buses prefers to ge short distsuee'in Ue vonstry ORCHARD Sf., BECUND FLOOR, FRONT ROOM— So cbjenion to ge nekert distatorin he pouty nn 5B EAT Danuah eet tn a private feuadys le wing Yo ‘help with the washing an. ele ° LST. AT HER PRESEXT ENPLOY. willing to seetoa bt wiih the waiddns aadireatigs ys 61. WEST 12TH &ST.—A YOUNG WOMAN AS COOK I soabe wash nad roms nantes solemiog Wo'sd as ti wummer with ‘the family. nent ci countty for 62 ora AN FOURTH FLOOR. HALL ROOM—A WEST ere pin YOUNG WOMAN, AS CHAM. 9 waitress, or or chember and 4 bermaid a1 hive no obj iGo Fb ee ad tho best of city reference Mic? ure. Ay) dh nin bog tne AND 7111 te to assist with the washing and ‘iroalngs "good ci aty y retorence LOG tnd noteis oh wang gad norman rma re for vity or coun ‘Suited immediately at Ploymsat Asvoctalion, ne 106 = BETWEEN 6TH AND 9TH ST3.—A oy a wang ad situation, city or country; aleo, +h Bom wash and iron; also, two smart, capable young (Q) SRST, NEAR IST AVE, IN FANCY STORR—A ‘wishes take i103 oiable girl, @ situation to ALLEN Sf,<A8 MONTHLY NORSB, BY AN lady, a iw An A eng attend an favalids, beat oot oo. Call on ea can be seen Saturday londay. seieione; cat beeen baurny and Monga ne a Bae tirer ace eae 9 fame sor coun oul take aire ‘at ber own, 31 Site a Ear OF do chataberwork abd suwine’'s bakery—A respectable young & = hea | 160. Ba oF ok caldron nd to do Chamberwork " Toure me W NO. 287) WEST 19TH ST.—A RESPECT: nae eas oe Coty = from My Te che ca anh Beat of ae est between. 19: 7TH AV., NEAR 23D 8T.—A_ SITUATION aes peak and. D wanted. by with good reference, as | thoroughly up idgaf seteefear® diana tarteniog & | muah ining i wham touareg wif aa lass millinery estai ‘o- 556 "atteromes tor 8: Heat in Fup TS BRADEM, Importers, SITUATIONS WANT! YORK he RE- 2 8T.. JERSEY OITY—A HIGHLY houxe- Seaper, of as ‘Sappsslon. an in toe refer- NTRE 8T.—TO. BOTEL > cane ire 257, paee. at carving. wants’ sheantion ‘eis 222 Bast TH sr. uP STAISS, FIRST FLOOR the coutiry. Address, for days, W. A. 8, in Sarat fatal noo) postion to goto the coun- SITUATION try for the summer months; natiefesiory retesonce. Ae dengced Ta 2 ee eM aon ioe jerald 0 23 EAST 53D BT., ae Exo —A YOUNG LADY, Obra or music store, oF ‘a first class store, ¥ EDITOR WISHES FOR A REGULAR EN oe in any ef afer ete peer 2 free men ‘ment on a daily or weekly journal: ten jean bring the very from @ New York daily. bes! ean ines pabiity and honesty. is very be in, fOr ery aiatidg oalary. ere Ne FRENCHMAN, SPEAKING SPANISH AND. lite % wishes to obtain Beavarment is & n'a hoases 2 47 ATLANrgo STRERT, BROOKLYN RESPRO-. | of business, w ‘wholesale or retail, or 7 good tuble young woman, # sftuntion, aa ehambermald, | references. Address 0, F., Herald olive, se te . oF ally refer | CTTUATION WANTED—IN A PRODUCE, GoMMIaSTON Sites diay by @ thorough ‘Addreas B.C. H., olive. 301 4TH AV.—A RESPECTABLE OuRG.' Rg tigs mee! ahousckeeper, near the soa shore, Sida lady: in willing (0 assist 40 any business; wages Do GTUATION WANTED-BY A YOUNG MAN, FOR THR. object. cloth or clothing Bastoves: on sae well rear - ee 3 tt Te FREYOH PERCON DESHIES ay | Lee a le Se eee warove wilh same atl UATION WANTED, BY A fron or du tady's mal or lady's companions boat of Ome Cana rte te aoqualnced with the business: cane enve'aiven. "Addrone M invest ubsat 600 f desired. “Addcons 1. Vo, Herald oiice, iapeekarow SINS deuteas, | Addion, 2 Sate rae S50 EAs te ft ck eect care 'ANTED—A SITUATION, BY AN ACTIVE YOUNG. Een ne ort i inhee “mun, in town or country’, wiliag tomakge himself us3>- Is willing to in washing or sronit $0, 69 to the n, in oH : oeneye Gam give the best of city ‘Can be seen, eee ier fer in read aud write well, Address T. for two days. [ON WEST 99TH ST., SECOND FLOOR—A Yousg ANTED—BY A E coume ae MAN, A fhe pape sald take take aly part eit ‘lther eee | oF 351 Woman as ay's iid oF tonmatrees;, can cut wepeni eo ik fliy Competent fo hair dressing and all kits of sewing, or Fotall; salary NO 0 een operate oe W iloafsmachine; good cy Fe | Se Pe Set oase reg 357 Nast NTH SE—ATOUNG QIRL AS Good | ___ CLERKS AND SALESMEN. pega Serene ene oe Q77 PARK Row, ROOM 2—A FEW 00D SALES 37 men for the city. Onlce hours from oA. 41 ‘small family; m general housework, in a good plait cook, trover. andi BAXTER ST.—WANTED, A COMPETENT, ACTIVE: {ea ecm Col eae 79 Banas cork ins wholosilo, and retal tea aud eo ee: N SOFH AND SITH STS.— 4 426 28 i 1TH yotng meri Cnt ny aca ae reas oF stony: nome bal those who have worked behind a couater “ure ‘objection to countess uss Ge ben of me reference from her last cme PPG, CLERK WANTED MUST BE COMPETENT ployer. and @ selosman, ‘with city experience. Avply, with refere: rigana. 439 Est stu st. BETWEEN, 9TH AND lTa to H. P, Monaghan, Dr Mor: ave—A cook; has no ADVERTISER WILL GIVE 10 PRR CENT OF 1118 ‘ebjections to assist iu the vashing.abd ironing; tas ‘the best ae ry for six months, to any one rocuring Bin, La Te. ‘of city reterence from her last specie situation; has some knowledge of writes a fair hand, good references, eon willl ‘ys jomaceh i 551 2 3D AV.—A pyaar i money hasty pon Inquire of or address C. Ni ‘washing and sewing of a few gentleme: nce din ie oe nent Un ne ne Doe acne et Ee TC 1 _ tae meen camer ahelanhial 10 pRvGOSETS A. CLERK, RTT. ETW! tent Pe in a Broadway store, desires a first class situation after= 572, Moca dant roar tar aatreonnan designee | May'i aire Experi ssation Se ao at would somata cham pe ge I Seat of elty reference. A. Widow Gaby OF Position 18 DESIROUS OF oB- taining ene ‘situation of housekeeper rat class fam ily: capabilities and references fully sat Pecilatactory. 1 cota sta YOUN@ LADY OP REFINEMENT AND EDUCA- tiow would ilke a situation ae, how ager ficmnan or widower where the are to “Lidroas, for one woek, enjoyed; best of references . Miss Catne Linwood, ‘New York city. YOUNG LADY, OF ENGLISH BIRTH, AND DE- Birous of returhing to her native country, would ike ‘ANTED—AN ACTIVE, ENERGETIC bef yee me ‘ail salesman; one who can conti ill be Lr igare remunerated; article first rate, ‘and Tully colate [dress box 3,245 Post office. Wa ae FIRST CLASS heen Ie er SALBS- 2 Uman,_“Aliabes. ben Saney Meena nae tesa man, Address box 1,485, New York ANTED—A FIRST CLASS. SALESMAN WITH reference; must have city trade. ie Oa 4 peed who are fully competeat in the trimming er B Hleidenreich's, 1bd Chambers st ANTED—A | SALESMAN WHO. UNDERSTANDS meaat gahly soe ons jobbing business and can a situation as t setos Geky, of gphccen: idresa V., would go for the voyage over or Tor a traveling tour, Or reference given and required. Address soma ———————————— _CUOACHMEN AND GARDENERS. 10 westenu st. St, PRIVATE Ss Coacit Bertecly iy tonsperate umd. steadg bost references.” Call oF ane one RN YOUNG LADY WOULD LIE TO GO TO EU- aac | A rope as.companion 1o some lady; good reference given. Adarens J, 8, A.,-statlon @. 4 RESPECTABLE | ENGLISH PROTESTANT. | 45 of ago, af nurse tleman’s READE ST, UP STAIRS.—A GARDENER, HIGH coat ed from zi aan Ma ite sia ee ‘first class mapa vite chee ot Shitared, ‘wife an excelisat cook, For pariiealars spay as a BROS oe oan a SINS ONG 2 53 arene 8 LADY'S MAID OR -NURSE—A | PROTESTANT 59) WASHINGTON 81. HOBOKEN, X, J-—GARDEN- Re eS gg EEE arte like to travels understands hal 2 good Tr iaees aed ace ane. Address, stating terms, M. M., station C, Pak y York uatior ft wee dn ail its brat place. Address J. B., DOR ‘it He Heaton rendu ingans ot MEN WANTED—TO DRIVE. i Oh gong jarrie, Morrisauia, Car ay.. ate me: YOUNG LADY, pe sacral HAS @aD yee sOclLaL years of age, 1d hike leusa' N "York ot Sees eds ant posion es Hew Yon ty as governess LADY GIVING UP HER HOUSE THE 18ST OF situation as housekeeper, onto a idk lady. Address Mrs. MW ite maton Be ee Sraeee Simos COOK OR CHAMBERMAID 5 can Sateciate 5 store diem triage” nS OO ee ANTED—BY AN py ob el A PRL ba As Ed. do bor 1 herald oftee eee ee "ANTED—A GARDENER FORTHE SEASON, G. P, cur, io Land Office, near Court House Hsu ee ANTED—ON LONG bie | A poe st gee ep ger aud waitress, 18 any respectable, ference; "a Ferry. on ‘Hud ‘deon Rive ‘River Hattroad, foro. Ne pega WANTED.-BY A FIRST ULASS COOK, washer and lroner. at her present factory reiereaces. None olase, ‘answer. Bane ahit war shove Ulin ara Hest | SAR Gall tacts SS ie Rigel! WANTED.—A YOUNG LADY OF EDUCA. tion and refmement desircs to travel as > la@y’s com- ITUATION WANTED—BY A IN@ WELL EDU- ee ee sae noand understands foe American HELP WANTED—MALES, . Ae pak tein: LOCRATIVE SITUATIONS IN MER- on LYNN & CO., 61 Nassau at, aeuahrgen, watebinen, A°pe WANTED—TO SELL AN ARTICLE WANTAD Gal oa or house, hotel, ad and coun- Address P. P., box 12 ANTED—SITUATIONS ay TWO YOUNG LADIES Wt as copyiats. Address A. C. Be Brookins, oflice. ANTED—A, a BY A YOUN Were Sereee eek, Speen companion toan elderly indy, alld, ieveling ‘abroad; has given, Address box or address O. M. SSISTANT BOOKKEEPER, | CLERKS, = Week een es this im ‘smoraing. ng. O84 mae SOP RSE Set IO W MAN WANTED—IN A Fil LASS . Praroushly und ynderstands ands his business as one Eee WAN interest wan ness, GERMAN D—" DO PLAIN pa Sekine weeding saa trouing Poe a bean easly “es ih ee eta en pe Madison av. Are YouNG Una ronda, an Tom, 14 conan Fi iT Soy te 4 corner Sona! WASH iebiubed tt Information ae, WARZEp, LAME DIATEE: HALF established Bi “A RESPRCTABLE GIRL W. ee OE ET sores untry for the GOOD COOK Rp big ote 3 nn th In Seen Scare Se es ee rate, OX RANTEDIIN A DENTAL OFFIO BY oe ih be pena —S ee fo nll busi ut jroni wre Sermald, to assist in wait- | required. 101 West 224 st. mquind WiWetmt Te OX ah aad A BILLIARD Sal 5 BY SDERS AyD EupnorpuRERS eat giuiee bee Dna LAppls wi are “not wea ee one, Baron stoned Teferenoo. At sway: “entrances to ne workroom of Grand Hho, Br Tequired. Inquire at 11 As M. at 69 RESSMAKEBS aes 7a ne Ft IDBR- BY ven Keeper A BROKER’ . ir nh rte ONE stand trim Pie ts bi Sede ti iretwovn 9 ant 109 Pine ae Back oes JPNVELOPR FOLDERS Ww. = LOY: ere AGENCY—008 B CONDU: Hy mont to drat class hands. Apply at No. 7 8pruce st Apply at Wee wornen ot Mis od under pacrouage of te RDNA 7, 00% oa. Keepers, parler, Copyist, veh wanted to-day. ARD, Superintendent, ONEY.— FIRST CLASS CANVASSERSIWANTED M. asst aby room No. 6, at CON TA: 13 ANTED—NEN WHO WRITS W ‘aavist In the preparation of ae Rear beet iy Directory. Address { t tucen, Ke B. Hallock. 82 reuse st FPANce BAT TROOIERS “AND Pawor eTRAW HAT TRIMMERS yes D ard STRAW sewers wanted: “Aero rae aR peer as IRST CLASS CLOAK RS AND OPERA RS on W Lord & Tay- iors, corner of Grand and hryatie ia By*inaateoense wings funn nase fore ted, Addrean Saat, box @96 Fost ofice, a ee Teferences requit Sem, box will not be attended to, Polen whan b- TOONS Seti genie Bg gourmer teaser ae ATED A WELL caer YOUNG MAN Teferences required. Sam, box 698 Post office. dea own hapdwriuing, W, vs S. Herald © ress with particulars, i ALESWOMBN W, og a HAVING cette TN ats BS ladies’ and aleo one accua! to take rire fo a fnpiog and tose Oreo wee re aor NAR DNR fe WANTED =4 YouNG Pi PROTESTANT are, 13 4270 18 Wert er good wren aha’ sth Thatieree id Herald fir Rataubied Tafreuce roquled. Aadrns “DSi, WAGES NAMED, SUNDAY, a¥ THB CASINO, Woenendeg a ok aa MU! ‘aed Borpielan Co., 91 Cham! seen a tg Wantep-* oon fe. Ses eas tisements fc commiasion. mane a fj “ANTED= 70 . tad can ADI Air el Ve ud ae aN Nr: Cyiterinae cada weten, Onit from iota lt Ace 7 wisn ATRD AG} EXT TO Aes A NEW FAMILY COOK. Very res) ruses are ma Jo oreny day. Call at 479 Lat av., in 7 ANTED—PIRST CLASS DRESS ildfen's : tna Brosaway. TEXGED OLOaK OUTTER Waters fof ohureh at, up D—A CLASS MI LINE, Fo MAKE We as ° mallery spastarest in pal oe Rm een none, bE RED SERVANTS; A FIRST CLASS Wig aE Vea eae eet ‘ eae clamber OR ee 1D CLOAK MAK: Baker's ine; at That ad