Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, October 28, 1880, Page 1

e Ohicago Daily Trib THURSDAY, OCTOBER VOLUME XL. Wi Open This Morning 50 Pieces PLUSHES! LUSHES! In all the Popular New Shades, AT ‘POPULAR PRICES. ALSO, Lalost Panis Novelli Brocaded Velvets, All Shades, Black Cloaking Velvets, Elegant Quality, Superior Finish, 24 Inches Wide, : $2.50 per yard. Best Cloaking Velvets, 24 and 27 Inches, $3.00 ) and $3.50. SPECIAL! Field, Leiter & Co. Stato and Washington-sts., Will offer TO-DAY Thursday, Oct. 28, 6,000 Yards PANGY VELVETS In a great variety of designs and colors, at & reduction of fully 50 per cent from present prices. . ‘Popular Lines $150, $2.00, $250, and $3.00 PER YARD, Reduged From $2.50, $3.50, $4.50, and $6.00, As this Lot cannot be duplicated, an early 10 Pieces inspection will be de- All-Silk sirable. Lyons Cloaking Velvet, Extra Quality, $7.00 per yard, Worth $10.00. STATE-ST. ichigan-av, and Twenty-sceond-st, UEBIG COMPANY'S EXTRACK. LIEBIG COMPANY'S EXTRACT 4 FINEST AND CHEAPEST MEAT VOUID NUK KOK SOUPS NADE SIES AND SAUCES | SOUPS LIEIG COMPANY'S EXTRAGT “Is A success and a baon for 3 should feel, gratetul."—Beq Pancet,” "Liritish Mau- Wine gntr with the facesimlin f Rcrovathe Labaie | Sauature in Blue ine “Consumption in Bngiand tocreased ton-fold 1D two sears.” UEBIG COMPANY'S EXTRACT MEAT, ‘Te ho bad of all Bt q ‘and Chhmusta. “Sole Auonts for ihe tates (what i INSURANCE, (cean Marine INSURANCE! (HO. C, CLARKE & OO, AGENTS, {G1 & {63 La Salle-st. IMPORTS OR EXPORTS. Certificates issued payable in London if desired. EDUCATIONAL. Martine’s DANCING ACADEMIES, 65 Aducst., | 2 Chlasu-ay, 2140 Indlanit-av.. xe Hershe TEI open Jr. At CLAM: BARA HE v1 pot MR. AND MRS. BOURNIQUE’S Schools for Dancing. Woat Sldo~Nutatorluin, iit nnd 50) Woat Madinanvut, Bouth Side—t3y Twenty-fourttieat, near Indisna-ay, NORTH GERMAN LLOYD. New York--London--Paris. Heamers sail Heery Saturday from New York: for Southampton und Bremen. > jenyers honked for London and Parle at Rates of unuxe from Now York, to London, Haves. and Bremen, first cond-cluss cabin, $04; atuorngu, £8) Kes if tL reducud tuted, OBLIUCHS & Cod lowing Green, N.Y. ‘Tho ‘stueriko Tuto by the ‘vith torruan Tlogd from Mreruun 10 Chiengo 19 $41, tnd tho unly ayonie authorized to roll these tickers ue AUSBENLUS & CC 0, BCHOOL MUSICAL ART, Hershey Musie-llall, + Chicago, SUK, lL Agunts. ToGtaszom, Liverpool, Hunlia, Huliast, und Londons derry, from Ne¥s very ‘Tauraduy.. First cabin ti jh hocordhig, bo accommodaiiun Second Cubl AUBTIN, BALDWIN & 60. Ibi Nandulpa-st, Ubleazo sorts Stunucer. EMAL nd for Now Clreu poral Director, eclur, 8 Broud dOuS BLE ANCHOR LIN BOLIVLA, Oot aay f BE OT Glasgow. Tupiis received atany thne. SUCABLA, isiy. ny yin RACHon For particulars wend Cor catalogue. ‘heey steninors do not carry cattle, PROF. COHN SCHOOL of LANGUACES ENTRAL MUSIC-HALI, Itoom 1. French aud an by the Natural Method,” Classes moot day wontiug every dus. At Birk, Instiinie, 1s Ashe " Now Fork to London ‘Stuw! 1 Ft, nN BUT tscTes, wo w: , CUNARD MAIL EI Sinlling ewico a wouk to and frau Beit 7 Pas | lund-ay, J. aE leh oct Fie tlekets trow Liverpae, Queunstuwn, Glosxo ru il KONING Alt Chin, Multuat, wid Landandursy Kt jowast rites | Directo tle pays Uillee, Clark dnd Rundotph- = es Cheat. Uratunase uh wind uyrwarda, we luwues rates, MADEMOISELLE ‘TARDIVEL, i, DU Y. ¥ S West Farty-al x Te n't Western Aue 5 Ixth-st., Now York, reopens Bupt. 27, = wats | Hoarding und Duy tonoul for Yau ladies and chile Greg, ‘borough teachings dally lectures} languases spoken within six months, Druwlng und musteal ad- Souragus unsurpassed. Publicoxaipination fur grad wates BOSTON SUNOOL OF ORATORY, Full course TWO YEARS, threo hours daily; shortor course, ONE YRAH, ‘Torn buglae Oct 7% Applications Py jHolmerietat Boat, Ay Gay ulter Oct, 1, frou Ww wor clre et Zs Feet NE GAYMOND, Principal. Ww Antinarun, th Gy Use 2h 2 NGTUN, 1, C., Uct, 23 SEALED PROPOSALS will be received st this No- Fettwent unit 13 o'clock noun on the auth duy of annuerr, tsel, for furnishing w wow kind uf inail locks Eid keys, for tho auty anid exclusive usu of the United ules Ubuogh registored malls, * nett, UULlLG UXyuaucu und Nuarehitg oxumtuation ace a ER ON DETR AT mary to inthizent bidding on any proscribud ME, DA SILVA & MIS, BIEADFORD'S (FOR- Rodel of a luck wid hoy would tend tu wie, IE wut re ae Often ilumnnntay eauiish, Brenen, “filial dustroy, the fueuteruuility of audi india and | and Gorman Hoarding and. Duy School tur Lount {ozs for tho tairpusen uf thy wai tie Hoatioaster~ | Fadteaand Culidreu, 1F Wout ilrty-olaueh-st. Nu thet pres 08 mudel ur wrap dot York, wilt roupen sopt 27. Application may be wade vvnulty eine Hon on thy muunuuicsl sKlil wid | by loltvr pervunully se nbuve. : chs fair comperition miuony inyont BEEP wreby Lavitad, ies subai MAN, ELOCUTIONIST, 1OOS 20 then. et yeree eee iad oy W tetra slusie-linit’ Avg. uuier. slant ans ahbeclicalons of the conditions and roqulroments | $natructions Mundny viva ati Wrivato lusauna dully {0g to proposals, saunpied, contract ge, we wold Prue ot propos, will be furnished on wpblication ei ior to"tiie Bucund Asslatang Pustmmster-Gen> |. Leche tad So proposal witi f ess itahall b Ni T (@) seoniuerniat wessuntaeon enn tates | MONEY TO LOA ‘The contracts \ ved (i ferafiris Whaspselieadns and ihe wosapted pros | Od improved Cily Properly, at Current Kates, Oy thdult of ght ie, bowovur, rusorved to roject ‘i MEAD & COE, JAS, Ne TYNKR, 119 Ln Hatto-st, HATS, Gent? Dress Silke Hata, Broadway Style, Superior Quality, on hand and made to measure, Price, $5.00, at BARNES!’ Hat Store, 86 Mad- ison-st. (2'ibune Building). i hea tenearraarrans nnn nen Aulice to the Creditors of Coggswell, Weber & Co, STATE OF ILLIN vt ¥ . O18, COUNTY A¥ COOK, 88.— Foperior Court of Cook pina ea Buith,. 4h Brulth, and 0.0. Leng va. Phowes Coxgewull, ulleg sinurour avon fut h taltors entitled to pa van tual credito! F Uctyutein the aleibution uf thu estate Uf sald dufeade Ubud chi ty ss cree 4 uisiouee, on Moma tho tat uay of horomber ate | RUBE GOODS, arose bone oe + WOSSAMER COATS, eens Guy be thy ci ud at “Ladios’ Circulars, wte.y Hever aad Cobangs INES ISON, Wuolvsul wud iaulle busy, CsBeety Of thy Buperiur Court ut Cook He 2. WHELPLEY, Wi Cblgayo, Got, 3, A.D, 180, and 1S Lake-st OFFICE DESIRED, “Sorry? to trouble you to read this ad- vertisement, ‘bit’? tis a good * yertKen?? why we should be elected to the office of Furnishers of Man-kind with modem adornment forthe Head, forthe Feet, and ‘shetiotet and between,” thet is, “all- overall.” PAID OUT TO THE WORKHEN AND THE WORK WOMEN ‘Of Chicago during the past ten months by WILLOUGHBY, HILL & £0, America’s Greatest Clothiers, WHAT OF IT? All the other large Clothing houses around us are owned’ in New York and Boston, and employ a manager here, whose business is simply to send “daily every dollar" they take to Boston and New York, and it is “LOST FOREVER" to the PEOPLE OF CHICAGO. “DOES it make any difference to You?" Think it over. “ YOU" may conclude per- haps ’twould be well at least to LOOK AT Willoughby, Hill & Co.’s goods, and leave “YOUR MONEY" there, ‘'if," of course, the goods and price suit. Willoughby, Hill & Co. are “NOW" prepared to prove to your entire satisfaction that their prices are under the “EASTERN BRANCH” stores, and the fit, make, style, just perfect. Said to be the “LARGEST " dealers in clothes for the male sex in the world. Corner Clark and Madison-sts, SOUTH SIDE. 420 Milwaukec-av., Northwest Side, Cor. Blue Istand-av. and Twelfth- Bley Southwest Stele. LEATHER AND FANCY GOODS. UIVERPAGE 52, cHOYNE 6.00.25" RETAIL STATIONERS, 18 & 120 Monroe-st. Wo offer an unusually clegant and complete line of LEATHER AND FANCY GOODS, RECHERCUE ARTICLES, AND. PHOTOCRAPH ALBUMS ‘Thoy have been aclected with great cure from the best Hues Imported, 6nd aro offured at very moderato prices. 377An exnikinntion of our stock ts sollelted, MINERAL WATER, A pollinaris “THE QUEEN OF TABLE WATERS’? : . Grittah Medical Journal, “LIEAU DE TABLE DES REINES,~ Le Gaulote de Paris, ANNUAL SALE, 8,000,000 BOTTLES AND JUGS, OF all Minorat Water Dealcrs, Grocers and Drugglste, CAUTION. To insure obtaluing tho genuine Apolinns Hi an that the corks bear tho Apolinuris wind ee GEN.LN. STILES, President of the Bar Association, WILL ADDRESS THE BUSINESS-MEN AT ILERSHEY HALL TO-NICHT Law Reforms Needed in Cook County. > UPRIGHT PIANOS. Pronouncod the. BEST in Europo, America, and 9 Chicago. SOLD ONLY AT REED'’S TEMPLE OF MUSIC, UNO KTATIEST., near Madison, ENTS. TMs, AN Complete Outfits, Muatrsted’ toque of 116 pages Lyon & Hoaly, State and Monroe streets, Culvauo, Fino Spectacius suited to al! sights on rctontiag principles. Opors and bluld Glasses, Tulescopes, Mle Goscopus, Barouietors, ote. eee Arnold's Patent Ready Cut Election Sticker Blanks. Just the shag ter: the ewerguney. All widths in ckuld f stock und TOA YY 8 RADNER SMITH & CO. ily bavare 28, + ____—_. mite. "aT ow: 0 J? days, 1880—TWELVE PAGES. 99 « oe PU Kenward Philp, Chief of the Democratic Forging Service, Run In. He Hopes to Escape by Hav- ing Written “Gaifuld” for “Garfield.” Unanimous and Unqualified Testimony of Veteran Experts. * The Prisoner Held in $5,000 Bail until This Morning: at-1% O'Olock, Barnum, Meantime,, Uttering tho Forgeries with Asinine 2 Assidnity. ; ee, 2 A Trainful Flying fo the Pa- cifie— Western Wires Sagging Heavy with His Lies. | The New York ‘Sun” Calls Barnum a Fool, and Soaks Its Head in Shame. Complete Aspect ‘ot the Glorious Ropublican Campaign Now Closing. Garfield at Mentor ~ Grant at Rochester—Neal Dow in Maine. « The Ometal Reports of the Recent Yote Cast. in Ohio and Indiana. - Viows of the " Parsee Merchant" on the Need of Tariff Re- form. NAILED TO THB CROSS. CATCHING YIM. HOW IT WAS DONE. Spectat Dispute to ‘Lhe Chter.s Tribunes New York, Oct. 27,—The juan who wrote the bogus Garfield letter,,Zenward Philp, was arrested to-day and arratgned for matl- etous Mbel. ‘That this event would occur Iwas clearly set forth In Tun. Trinvne of Monday and ‘Tuesday last, fn advance of any other publication in the United "States, Your dispatches, published “Monday and ‘Tuesday, on the Chinese letter forgery, were Dased on the reports of experts who, on com- paring the manuscript of Kenward Philp, one of the editors of the Truth, reported to John I, Davenport that Philp was the forger. On Sunday afternoon four exports, not knowing Phily’s name and neither ono knowing that the others were at work nt ft, but all haying befere them Philp’s man- useript, reported unanimously that the author of a certain editorial artlele published In Zruth and headed, “GARFIELD'S DEATH-WARRANT,”” was the forger of tho Chinese ietter: ‘Thoy had before them the edltorlal fn diferent shects,—that fg, each expert had portions of the copy of that ciitorial, ‘Chey detected not only'a similarity between this manuscript and Garfield’s, but they detected also Gar- field’s nome tn four places so closely similar tothe name In tho alleged Garfield letter that there could bo no doubt that the author of the editorial was tho writer of the letter, Three of them came to the con- eluston: that there was no forgery, and that the author of the famous letter could not be hetd under ony known law, for the reason that the signature to the Chineso letter Is y NOT “GARFIELD,” DUT “GAIFULD.” It iselaimed by experts employed by Truth thatthe Identity of Garfletd iy so firmly fm- pressed on tho letter that there can be no doubt of its authontieltvy, But the testimony of Ames, who igs quoted by Raueh as the best expert in the country, fs that tho letter is a forgery, and thatthe dotting of tha “r'? Instend of the “41 Is 80 manifestly tho’ work of a man to save himself that he would bo willing, on that fact alone, If he had none other, to fasten tho gullt on the man who wrote the editorial on which Philp was arrested to-day, In the manuserlpt of the oditorial, which Philp con- fesses he wrote, the name of Garfleld ts used, and “THE DOT 18 OVER THE “Ty” and, bealdes that, the whole nano {s such & close imitation of thesignature to the Chinese letter that Mr. Ames mado tho remark, and was substantinted by Mr, Payne, another ex- pert algo at work on tho case, that the writer of that word coulit be convicted of the for- gory on that word alone, ‘They found also all the characters of the Garfield totterin Philp's handwriting, and, comparing thei, arrived atthe unanimous conclusion that Philp was the author of the letter, At about this tine TROURLE ANOBE as to the charge that ahould be made against Pallp. John f Davenport at first insisted on forgery, but the trouble with the Repub- dean party in New York is that it fs cursed with lawyers, ‘The point was made by the legal advisers that the forger could not be held for forgory.. ‘They claimed that, while the moral evidence of the man's guilt was complete, under the eireumstances he could not be held, and that, if any actlon was taken agalnst him for the forgery, the prosecution would fall, THOMAS ¥, LONENGAN, the detective who worked up tho case and furnished tho evidence, contended that the only safety In the premises lay in the estab- lishment of tho forgery, and thata charge of alesser nature falled to accomptish the ob- ject. He admitted that Philp might be pun- Ishod = for = Nbel, but clalmed that such action . would. be the’ ruln of the party, because it was & quasi-confesslon that the party’could not disprove the authenticity of the lotter, Ilo was met by the argument that ft was iinpoa- sible to carry the gullt home to Philp. ‘to this he responded that, if the exports’ report was correct, it fastened. the guilt of the Jet- ter as closuly as It fastened the authorship of the Nbelous editorial. TO-DAY Philp was arreged for nullatans Ubal. the charge being based on the editorial headed “Gartield’s | Warrant.” LATE ON TUESDAY NIGHT, when the atidavits liad been drawn, Mr. Bliss went before Judge Noah Davis, and, upon fis deposition ant” those of several well-known experts, a warrant was Issued for Philp’s arrest for having “falsely, wickedly, and maliciously write ten and published of and’ concerning one Jrumes A. Garfield, @ certain erlininal Nbel.”” ‘This warrant was given to OMeer Thomas Stuart, of the Twenty-ninth Pre- einet. Yesterday morning Philp was found infront of the Park Theatre, Brooklyn, and Was srrested and taken fo police head- quarters in thiseity, At #220 o'elock he was taken to the ofics of the District-Attorney, trrned over to Detective Fleld, and detained in one of the rootns In the Distriet-Attorny's office. ‘The office of Mr. Bell, the Assistant- District-Attorney, was ina few moments oc- enpied bya number of promntient Repub- licans, and, after some consultation In the office, at 8245, TIE PRISONER was taken Into the Supreme Court Chambers, The court-room was half full of spectators when Judge Davis entered. At the table for counsel there appeared a3 prosecutor Mr, Bell, accompanted by Mr, Stoughton, Mr. George Bilss, Mr. Henry E. Knox, Mr. John J. Davenport, and Mr. Joel 8. Er- hardt. The prisoner, Philp, sat at one end of -the long tnble, attended by his entnsel, Mr. Charles W, Brooks, ex-Judze Weeder, of Brouklyn, and Roger A. Pryor. When Mr: Bell began to read the affidavits Mr. Pryor objected, and stated that Philp was rendy to plead. ‘The Judge ruled that they mlght be read, when Pryor again in- terrupted, saying they proposed to waive ex- aintnatton and go before the Grand Jury at once, and have a speedy trial. ‘THE AFFIDAVITS OF THE EXPERTS were read, first coming that of George Bilss, one of the attorney's, of New York, and who made up the case. After traversing the fact of the publication of the forged let- ter and editorinis Hbeling Gen. Garfield, he said he had caused an Investigation to be made as to the authership of the forzed let- ter and of the article upon it, and ascertained. that the proprietors and managers of the pa- per had caused SEVERAL HUNDRED THOUSAND COPIES of the papers containing the articles and the forged letter to be issued. “After o careful examination,” sald Mr, Bliss, 1 arm ted to belleve, and do belleve, and I therefore charge, that said Ietter was written ‘and = forged =o by =o person named Kenward = Philp, one ‘of ie editors of or writers for said newspaper, and that, having forged sald letter, he wrote and caused. to be published in said paper tho ‘artlele re- ferring thereto.” Ie further stated that the article reflecting upon Gen. Garfield was a false, minlicions, and wicked libel, and that the article was Intended to assert the genuineness of the writing, which Philp knew to be fraudulent. Mr. Bliss, after showing that the libel wus versisted in, went on to say that, subsequent to the publication, the proprietor, as he was Informed and be- Ieved, ENTERED INTO SOME AGREEMENT WITH THE DEMOCRATIC NATIONA'T COMSITTEE or sume members thereof, by which it was arranged that large numbers of salt forged letters should be efreulated, and to that end, since the knowledg¢ of the denial of its au- thenticity by sald Garfield, “have deliv- ered or intrasted to said Committee the said forged letter - for : the pur- pose of having tho same. «opled aud. photographed, or lHthographed, and that the sald Committee have caused many hundred thousand copies of sald forged let- ter to be circulated In various forms, both In the English and German language." The affidavits of J. E. Paine, A. F, Southworth, and Daniel ‘T,, Ames, TUE EXPERTS, were unanimous In fastening upon Phitp «> the writer of the Chinese letter, An a tempt was made to secure the discharge of the prisoner on tho ground that the evidence his detention. Gen. Stoughton said that “The Hbclons article, standing alone with out reference to the forged letter, without proof of any letter written by Gen. Gartield,” was “ undoubtedly a wicked. and criminal libel.” JUDGE DAVIS BATD the affidavits presanted two charges, elther of whieh, if made out, wold be ground for holding the accused for trial, ‘The first was that on letter, purporting to be writ- ten by Gen, Garfield, had been forged by the neeused, and uttered, and ‘published’ ‘The character of the letter was sucli as to beeome libelous If false, beeause it tended to bring disgrace and odium on the writer, If trae, it would justly bo of serious Injury to the writer, Another point was .that after the al- leged writer of the original letter had = denounced «ft a3) 8 forgery, the accused, In an_ article in which he an- was “a Har,” thus holding him up to odlum and contempt. This wag n Ibel, unless the letter were true, Under tho law, ifa news- paper alleges that o eltizen Isa Hur, the act of publishing {8 a libel unless the party pub- lishing it {g able to prove his statement. THE ACCUSED MUST DEFEND TISSELE by showing the truth of this letter. ‘The ac- cused, after Gen, Garfiuld had declared tho letter false in every respeet, published the dcclyration that Gen, Garfield, In making that tlental, was a Har. ‘That amounted to to put this cuse in mation had been shown by tho allidavits. ‘Tho prisoner was held in $5,000 ball to appear to-morrow morning, BEFORE THE BAR. TUE CHANGE, New Yonk, Oct. 87-1140 p. m.—Phillp was arrested Inthe lobby of the Park Theatre, Brooklyn, while In conversation with ex- Shorlif! Daggett and other gentlemen, ‘The arrest was made upon a warrant issued by Judge Noah Davis, presiting Justice of the Supreme Court, I¢ eharges Philp with maliclously composing And publishing an alleged forged letter, Philp and the ofllcer, accompanied by Willlam Veeder, -a lawyer, eno over to police headquarters In this city, Aftora briet detention Philp was taken to the Supreme Court, Judge Davis being tem- porarily absent, ho was detained in. the Dis- trict-Attorney’s oltice, Ie will be arraigned before Judge Davis' lator in the day. ¥ ANOTHER CHANGE, New Yous, Oct. 27-2:30 p, m.—Philp, tt mallclous: libel, and not, as at frat reported, for publishing the alteged forged letter, CONSULTATION OF COUNSEL. New Yous, Oct. 37-3 o'clock.--A long consultation toak place In the District At- torney's ofice between Assistant District Attorney Bell, United States Conmuissi oner John I, Davenport, and George Bisa, who, it fs thought, with represent the prosecution, and Gen. Roger A. Pryor, ex-Surrogate Vee der, and Hows and Hummel, retained by the defense, ‘The nature of the consultation was not made known, WAITING FOR THE JUDGE, A few mluutes before 3 o’clock Philp was taken to the Keneral-torm room of the Su- prome Court, where the arrival of Judge Dayls fy now awalted. Ex-Miuister Stough- tou. Ellhie Root, and Henry K. Knox alsa aon ofthe experts was jnsulllelent to warrant’ nounced the denial, declared that the writer | at adinission of libel until Justified. Enough: fs now stated, was arrested on acharae of | pear for the prosecution, John I. Daven: port was also 11 court to wateh the proceed- ings. TUE PRIGONER ARRAIGNED, New Yonk, Oct. 15 p. me—dudge Davis opencil court at 6 o’elock, and Mr. Bell atited that he desired to make return to a warrant issued for the arrest of one Ken. ward Philp, who was charged with having published a ertininal libel on James A. Gar field. Mr, Bell was proceeding to rend the afitdavits on which the. warrant was ob- talned, but Me. Pryor objected, and thedudge dectded to allow them to be read, ‘The first was made by Col. George Bliss, and Mr. Bell had hardly commenced when he was again interrupted by Gen. Pryor, who stated that his client waived examination and desired to have the matter presented speedily to the Grand Jury, so that an early trial could be had. He was ready to try the case to-morrow, and under those eireune stances [ft was not proper to read nfidavits, "The churgoof criminal fbel, Mr, Stoughton explained, was in order to guard agninstany possible diMculty in sustaining the simple charge of forgery. Philp appeared very noneliniant when arrested, and, when a friend asked him what was the matter, he replied, *L believe fam ARKESTED FOR — FONGING 'REAUTIFUT. snow,” The evidence against Philp consists in part of expert testimony as te the forzed letter, but it 1s understoon papers containing writ- ing of the same character, ng that of the “forged letter have been secured, AFTEM SOME ANGUMENT. District-Attorney Bell read an naMfidavit of Col. George BMss, who testified he had ex- amined the fae-shnile copy of the letter with others itt his possession from Gen, Gartleld, and declared St a forgery; that he compared the photograph copy of the letter. with the writings of the necused, and on Information ond belle? thought Philp was the author of the letter. Aftidavits sworn, to by Joseph E. Payne ant Albert F. Southworth, experts in handwriting, were read, and were of similar purport. Attached to the attidavits was. the original copy in the handwriting of the ae. cused of the artlete published In the Truth. A motion was then made to have the war- rant distnissea, on the ground that the al- davits were not strong enough to support it. THE MOTION WAS DENIED 3 by Judge Davis, who held that the publiea- tlon of nn article after Its authenticity was dented, which tended to bring odium on the supposed author, was erlininal tHbel, ‘The examination was adjourned until 11 o'cloek to-morraw morning, Philp furnishing $5,000 bail to aupear. Gen. Pryor, counsel for Phitp, demanded a speedy trinl, As the crowd was leaving the court-roam, three cheers for Hancock were called for and given, The person who start- ed the ery could not becuught, though Judge Davis ordered his arrest, THE EXPERTS, THEIR EVIDENCE, New Yonk, Oct. 27,—At the examination of Kenward Philp to-day on the charge of having forged the Garileld letter, Joseph E. Taine, expertof handwriting for thirty years; Albert F. Southworth, expert for more than twenty years; and Daniel T, Ames, expert. for twenty-five years, all. testified that, after careful examination, in thelr belief the letter was: unquestionibly a forgery, and that It was written and signed by Kenward Philp. DISSATISVACTION. LONERGAS’S OPINION, Spectat Dupatch to The'Chicaga Tribune, New York, Oct. 28—2 o..n1.—Lonegan {s thoroughly disgusted with the way in which tho ease has. been manneed, and at one time to-day threatened to take" the ease away from Davenport, tha Com- mittee, and all, and carry ft through on the basis of a forgery. It may not help the Republican party any'to relate that the managers Jn New York have madea blunder, As indicated In former dispatches, there Is not tne utmost harmony between the National and the State “Comu:ittees, and itisto this Inek of friendship that the finsco fs ta bo attributed. Tt was claimed fo-day that tho arrest of Philp would do away with the effect of the bogus letter, but the troubles whieh have cul- minated in the charge of malicious Ibel against n Presidential candidate willdo more harm than had no action been taken. It seems strange that under the elreninstances some agreement could not have been: ef- fected. ‘There ean be no possible doubt that the esperts lave deteeted tha forger, and there must be some protection even for a polltician ayalnst such an outrage, “THREE BEERS,” PHILP'S SESS OF POTTAGE. Speeiat Dispatch to The Chteaga Tribune, New York, Oct. 27—Philp is a unatural master of the pen. Not long ago he wrote from memory [Taneock’s letter of ncceptance, vith signature attached, and, then offered to pore a bet that he would write a letter from Tarfleld thateould notbe detected, and which “would: ralse hell in the country.” ‘The het was three glasses of beer, and It was pald Tuesday afternoon, When first accused of writng the letter, Philp made the remark, that his only regret. was that he had been accused of putting Demoeratic spelling Into a Republican document. Hu never denied the forgery until threatened with proceed- ings, and then stated he didn’t write the letter, because he wasn’t sure where his ball was coming from, AMONG PUILY’S COMPANIONS thore is not a donbtof his guilt, but his Democrntle friends contend that it was only a joke, and that ho really dida’t mean any thing by it, Acbet was made in New York to-tay that on Wednesday next Philp would confess, He belleves nothing can be done with him, ond to-night sald that, if S, B. Chittenden had lls $5,000 reward ready, ho (Philp) was prepared to collect it. ‘The sub- stance of the wholy business Is this; Philp forged tho letter aud does not hesitate to say that hy 13 prepared to take tho consequences, ,—— USED TO IT. PREVIOUS SLIPS OF PHILP'S PEN, Bpectat Dispatch to The Chicago Trioune, New. Youk, Oct, %—The Tribune says: “It is said that this is not the first thne thot Philp has — tried Ilys hand = at forgery, although in the previous case, he did not get into the courts,’ In the Kings County Demo- cratic. Convention, in 1876, " thero was a sharp contest for the Suryogateahlp between Mesars, Daly and Livingston, and the latter was only success- ful by one vote. While. things wore at-a. critical point a (petition purpart- ing ‘to have been signed by -proml- nent citizens = of = Brooklyn was handed to the Convention, urging the noml- nation of William D, Veeder, the then Sure rogate, It was afterward ascertained that many of the signatures tothe petition were forgeries, and it ly sald that the forger was Kenwood Philp. ————— CHICAGO ENTERPRISE, OF WHOM WE ARE WHICH. Spectut Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune, New Yous, Oct, .—Tne ‘Truune cere talnly hag reason to congratulate Itself on the enterprise it has shown In this matter, Aaron as the vublication of the fuc-slinile . PRICK FIVE: CEN i, ch was made here, and there was basis on ° which to work, your correspondent aecuréd thy, evidence of nenrly* all tlie leading - balikers of New York as to the character of the signature appended to the letter, as com- pared to a comparatively genuine document, : nnd not one of these men, who were ace customed to paylng out hundredsof thousands of doliars dally on signatures, hesitated to pronounce {6 a forgery, and to add thatany man who would pay on that signa, ture was untit fora bank position, Immedi- ately following this testimony, ag elfictted from parties inno manner connected with . the Investigation, came the additional and hnportant statement, on Monday morning, that the experts had failen upon Philp as the tian who was guilty of the erlme, This was followed Tnestay by further exclusive evi- dence, and to-day oi TUF ENTIM MATTER CULMINATED |, in the arrest and arratgninent of tho man In-* dleated. It was not until this morning that the New York papers gave any hint thatan: Investigation ‘was In progress, or that any. arrest was contemplated, They hind an ins, timation on Tuesday trouble brewing for somebody, but even the most enterprising of the dallies could not run the matter down, which had that there was! alreatly been published in Chicago thirty-six - hours before. ‘The Democratic papers to- morrow purpose publishing afidavits from Lynn, Mass., and elsewhere to show that’ Morey lived there In 18738 They have not the decency, now that the case is proven against them, to acknowledge the existing documentary evidence. BY TELEGRAPIL BANNUM'S LATEST LIE: Special Dispateh to The Chicago Tribune, San Francisco, Oct. 27.—-Chatrman Bar . num, of the Natlona!l Democratic Committee, with an enterprise worthy a Vetter cause, has © flooded the Pacific Coast to-night with a paid document of rbout 2,000 words which he has addressed to something like a dozen news- papers, {ueluding, itis understood, some of - the Enstern press. He starts out with the remarkuble asseveration that tha New York Truth to-day has made good its promise to prove that Garfield did write the Chinese lets * ter, and that he lied when he repudiated it. Me then proceeds with much clreumlocution to set hls own private word against the testl- mony of experts and against the irresistible array of facts: showing that there wns no: Morey, no Employers’ Union, no stamp like that used on the Morey letter, no possible chance that the letter was ever written, mall- ed, or delivered, and divides his nsseverations into four heads: First, that Garfeld’s hand- writing has been indentified as the snine as that In the Truth letter; second, that Morey . had an Identity; third, that the Union did exist; fourth, that the postmarx was genu- ine. He declares that the establishment of either one of these propositfons would brealc Gartield’s defense, and that Trufh hag estab- shed all of them. - Ife sets threo experts up (whose names, by the way, have never been heard in this fair Innd) to disprove the testi- mony of half the bankers of New York as to the fuentity-of the writing. Ag to tha other f three heads, he only relterates his alrendy + exploded statements In a way which evinces the desperation to which the Democracy has arslyed, and which will certalnly be far from convineling any man on the Western Slope of auything suve the usininity of the writer and. the weakness of his cause. +. BAST TRAIN, | CARRYING THE TRUTIT WESTWARD. Swectat Dispatch to The Chicugo Tribune. Wasitxaton, D.C., Oet. 27.—It Is stated: at Republican headquarters that tho Repub- Heans had made such arrangements as ta. their special train from New York Clty which was to carry the antidote to the Chi- ' neso letter to the Pacific Const, that the antl- dote would probably arrlye ln San Francisco + aday ahead of the regular train, aA special train at the rate of thirty miles an hour can make the distance between San Francisco and New. York two days sooner than the « regular train. i A SLAP IN THE FACE ADMINISTERED RY TIE LEADING DESO CRATIC JOURNAL OF THE CouNTRY, Speeiat Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune, New Youur, Oct, scarcely noticed the Garfield forgery, speaks of itthis morning in the following forcible way: “Garfield ig not, at least, a3 vile a3 tha detestible man who, in order to defeat Gar- fleld, forges a letter in his name. The heaven-born principles of Democracy, the doctrines of liberty, of equal rights, of exact Justice, need no leprous support from falst- ters and forgers,. True Democrats: pant for ., vietory for: the sako of thelr own country- men and for the sake of oppressed humanity £7,—Tho Sgiy, which has - throughout the world; but to, be glorious It - must be a victory nobly won, with God and + shee the Devil at Its right hand.”” HORN-UAULING. THE DIRTY eigen NEA FROM NEW ; you! Spectat Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune, Wasiixatox, D.C. Oct. 2%.—Tho local Democratic Committea made a fornial chal.’ lenge yesterday to Postmaster Ainger in the © matter of the Post-Ofice marks on the forxed Chinese letter, bat, application belug mote to the Committee Inst night, the reply vhs . given, * Walt uutll to-morrow.” To-day, ta those who Inquifed at the Democratic. hend- quarters, the statement was made that the Committes did not consider such work with- in Its provinee, The Democrats haye proba- bly heard from New York. It Is rumored In connection with this stamp-forgery that evi- dence has been discovered hore to show that astamp has been inantfuctured in imitation of the offelal stamps. That would be ‘an easy matter, and would not require the work |. of many hours, BOURBONS NEVER LEARN. WILAT THEY ARE NOW PROVING, New Yonk, Oct, 87.—The Democratic Na- Honat Committee hos issued an afidavit signed by reskienta of Lynn, Mass. stating {hat there was an Employers’ Unton In ex. * Istence in 1877 and 1873, and that soveral meetlugs were heli. . —— CLOSING . DAYS. MENTOR, i GEN, GARFIELD'S ALERCI.TO A DELEGA ; WIUN OF CLEVELAND LADIES. Menton, 0., Oct. %—A deleganon of ‘ about 000 ladies of Clevotand and tntermedl- ate places visited Mentor to-day and called | ‘on Gen, Gurfleld, who, -in response to ‘the | usual introductory address, spoke 03 follows, 5 ag reported by the Cleveland Herald: , Mus. MANTIN AND Laptzs Ov Cuxveranny 1 amu glad to recoly'o such a grecting a6 this tens : dvred by your preseneowiil by the words of Tone chal Finan, Feaeeras meng J jook upon bly assvinblaze that thefo could be no such, seune usthis wane buts trea vauntry, und tor this reason: In ull mionarehicai nations the gov- ering power does thy governing Nseif, Our fathers roversed that order, and the real gov erning powor in this country never does tho uetual work of the Govermnent,.but causes 1b tw be done by agents and servants. The xovern toy power atuys at bom und sends ita servants to do the work of the Government. During army that fought, thuso suppliod tho army, and tho peo dluser to the gavereign Loart, who inspired bath perce and fighters to oxucute the Nation's will. ‘hat third and funor tine was the home line on which wi the patriotig women of Amer-ca lubored and loved, und gave thelr best inaplras lon 10 Wie Nuon iu ity bour of perl Bo jad our lyte War there were three grgat force > “e. howe, sik