Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, November 27, 1877, Page 1

e ity £ VOLUME XXXII. - 2 CHICAGO, TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 27, 1877. PRICE FIVE -CENTS. - 3 e WASHINGTON. 1A 4 como hera ta nee the thing 2755+ ilke to aee a deilvery with~ anlp extbane. ANMIE - LOUSE DRY GHODS, PUSSSUTUREI vl press that he should vote for him. 1f that was corruption, the Benators canld make the most of it. Ifa declared he had {nformad his Repub- Jean ssaoclates that he would vote for Kellogn 1f tha vare was brought up. It surcly was not 1fs fault that it had not heen, te attempted to arraign Conkling for his chargo of an nnkoly alllance, and Edmunds for .his vote in the Pinchbnck case, but ueither pald any attention to his romarks. It was pain- ful to hear Nhim. Thero was cvident pity for him in the minda of many, and disgust written on the faccs of many more. IHis caso wus a bad onc, and lis management of it, if pussible, woree. This attempt Lo arralgn 8ena- tors whom he sald had counseled President Ifases to commnit what wwith great vehemency he pronounced a blunder—the witbdrawing of the troops from tho support of the Chamberlain his regred that there was a | sppesred to me, npon the facts reported b Lo d 7 1 sectlon In which such barbarisms occurred, %‘;'j'";"‘l""r“'.mn he oplatons of & ver Yates 32\1‘«:‘:’::5‘::‘:5 k and that every member of the Democratle porty | Bent teadone 57 Lo o) Ansoclates, Now the ovl- | oat an audicy of what my feiend proposea fa to %, he honorable Benator from present justified them in it. Mr. Ransom ro- | compelme, i exactly the way he statos It, to_fol- Gearuia ll) @ was surprired at cortnin 9 o ¢S ilttea on I'riviloges and El plied with great warmth, and declared that | JOT Iy P21y srishos, becauee I cannot get at tho | tione. e ( 5 137 fenired to kAt Batine notllng but the proprietics of the Chamber !.“.fi'i‘n'.',“".',‘;",}fu'.'.i‘ e ?zl.“gflak‘ah:llhr‘-'rku:lm"lfl i hoand a.,-\ntfllhle-. fi:dm:“mfine;::- orovented bls using harsher langusgo thana flat { ton 17, ‘faroe of ono side. How it will aflect theL Q)8 T i Lot AL 1he perolah f the Sonf-7 8 b denial. He oxpressed hls regrets that thero | B @0 not' know, As le had T | eyled, -m’l’*f*‘"22::2321-2';6;‘::‘::“vl‘&tfl:;inl:i:s & reso mptions in favor of either, he wonid Ti Uad been tots, and sakl thai the South | Rave o snac’ i o vet. Tiad 782 £3's as well Infurined aa romo_othor yes and go it hblind, and. ’ had during the past ten years suflered great ;;""nllflyl- **First come. flr!tg-e"clh" “Fng fret .‘L‘#;S,’L’.'_-é’.‘,., "E?.?-':-ll!hlfl: ':‘:.I‘d ’::H!t‘;gdh e:: wrongs, for which the Republican party alone -n bl la proposed lio would have 10 vete tolet | Tucuday [ Tho world was notified of 3¢ [N waa reponsibie, Hs was’ marpriscd, nahamed; Forall that Lean por, that would hardly da, | througi v -| The Senate Republicans and Democrats Engaged in Mortal Combat. 4 i Por it hat Loan moc ! iyae ‘& & "ic press. s Tlo saw an extrct from T i that the Bennt or from” Matsaclnc. | RRCck of W Gortpora i WOk Darty Wi, | Aaisor s .o A MOk ne e B 1S Sape wetta had spoken sz he had of the gentloman | Ticre was 8 thns, somo twenty yours w8 | kabls appesied bufore tie Scoator, from Ohto claftnlng a seat from South (Carolina. Tidiana: wheta 1L 11 i thet party. hesk onel parey | apiiiched hla resclajlonion the Scnaie. aud iealied Mr. Hoar expreased his gratification that the l'le]ndlce according to the uaiversal jidzment of nwmc“l::t’:chr‘;;ll’:;m\“\‘hmr{lyc:nl:;'ur:vv:?r’uaol?m; Sonator had at Tast realized the airocltins com | nillizent mankindafterward, vet tho Constitatfon mitted at Hamburg. {eiligent mankind afferwne, vet tho Cunstitutiun | hore all nncanscionsof the blaw which was pend- Mr. 11111 denfed that the Bcoate had anything They Have Loocked Horns, and Propose to Fight to tho Death, Talnr partys. DAL hAn not e 006 of inte an | 1o 0 eltizens of Plibamiri wera aroseed and ad- g . ce fdats vised of tno great struggle, {48 ARRIVED, IN 00D HEALTH, I8 The South Carolina and Florida s sertit s o b i b st | Nl oen et e oot o e Logins OUR u : Leglstature— 100 with tho antecodents f & Benator-clect. | harir,mi will nat say of both, becanad I e | ot Elnorions sordiy il smb 1 16 wan t1s et REGISTERED AT THE GRAND PACIFIO; ] Cattlo Remain with Their DROUAIT POWS CHRISTIANCY UPON IN from a roverelgn State. !:fe\;hg wouid "not " be e e L b |t Hslmnato-gay; aot 1 ras s abites WILL POSITIVELY APPEAR AT With & forco of Togle wbich Patterson hat not | Mr. Wadlcigh replled that tho evidenco can- | TETui e oditglan of onl of Theirons PONDGHL | pe ooy aasenen onihe Seunts by toe Sond: », Parchasers. it oW ons 1he Menator wish 16, Brive gl | o e o e e oo i aas membora of that party, which still haa eome littie | tiona of the Commiltee, hut fo forbid the Com- vitality left 1 auspect, to do the samne thinz becagse | mittee from bezinning ita delinerations, and it ey donot know wiat thafacte arct 1f g dons e | scemed walf ticre were some. Jiepublicaie to ro- o taingea very goou way todolt. donot tink | spand quita as prompiiy, If not quite ax enthusias- AR Mt p';dflmx"'"" e | Ueallyy'sa the Wemocrats in favor of that prope port, hecanss it would fie a divided teport. Tnthare any praciical calve, lot me a2k my Honues | o e el " oot ahlofsiend, o b so latels come from tALrereney| pune - marraw on o wnain queaton 10" address . s o Senato at eome length, bat if I cs - e e S Yy Heeso o value lmcons | Hng that wll qiict i atetm of iny Repabiieaa a1gum X ! ro no valug In con- | frictida an this sido of the Chamber, 1 want to do suitations and tnvestications of Judges, sithudsh | 46, Tha Lepublican varty bae heen 5 bravo party, 1wy bappen ia- the end | thut the | it Cnaver saw it $0 Muticred in myiife o8 it fo gt il concor In el opimont oS3 [ Juntnow. and fornocanse in the world. What is say eTactly the réverse Wherefore, the unu. he questlon hefore this body! 'The question iaon ot i tht b 7 g S0H 18 1 g resoluglon to discharge the Committee on Privil- o Lo da this anomalous and extraordinary LhILg | ecop and Electlons from a consideration of 1h :n".‘;')"in_ e ;fl,“ "'fl,m‘“‘ a senator Lventure | of5 M e ot Saath Caraima. | Gentlenion ol ;; :'T i u'a‘f. :’,‘!h;’:l‘::»é‘ ml:flfgflggl'g“‘;-;{\lf‘: who riee an thia sing of the Chamberand find fanit T clelmants i upe claitaant from the biataof | [ienceriain, peaone, thele assuciales, Sof yotio hath Cataline, ahall bave nia. tara pamicd upon | 44.theY do, “on_tals rerolution, ehinald drs t " and confess whaose fauit it Witnout fuvestigation mnd withont_ Inquiry? | fomit fhL - GoOk e et ¢ v Y Can anrbody somwee the qdestion? I 1 | havo been In meeslon since the 15h of Ustobor, The Commiibes” say. that_ they' hava oy | 2 there has beenno movament, 5o repgrt from Lttt they hod many cisce, and they took the first | 18 Committee on Privilegen and Electlone, in re- ey 303 have denberatety ane dlijzeny proceed. | Eurd toany of these cases. | Livary Renatce on this It Dave now tuporicd ft, And 1bhe bisted bn | FWAofthe Chambethne knawn the snstety that fo- T Eewinanchs. of Tanly pesicraay ur. the | porieatoald be piace of Inesucares, Floquentiy Ao O T TCISIAY O gy tho | hve ) talidmy fricdn on thia sldG of the Cham oy WeIOrS at Kl Y chaneant | fhom | ber thatif the reportin (ho Kellogg care caine uo foro the Commitier, hod sppited to have I wonld stand by that report until It was scttied, foto | the jCommitics, | had sppitcd to havs | and [ nover told & Demacmt on ths other eido of It postponed. | Of coursa T do not kniow the secrels | (ne cluaialwr, excopt Gioh, Butler, that 1f this ma- of the Cowmittee, | do uot know how they £t | f1un was madain thin cate | usubld volo for It n Dublics and. af they are, Of contee 1t in rigit for | broforefiec ta vottng on the, Rollugs case, 4 told By v b thons 11 hot b eve, ty ey | iem. Butlersuat il e foeliogy, mport was, ek honorable frient trom Hinols in ‘such o tuirry in e vonid Tein oiia mation for bix Sdtieson: | respect 1o tnin mattor thot he s willing to furce | fyvouid asand by the motion, Now, \t that §a caz ' this gentleman Into the Eenato ngainet lLis own i e pement? . UF cnrie e Inmot. 1 | iotlos. call’ itcorraption, and miake the most of kuow my Lonurable frlend too well, 1 respected 'y him too Jang to suapect such a thing, 1 lllu'n-ll)ru Mr, Prealdent, [am n Benator on this floor, I appeal to hif Lo reconsider these auggestiuna that | HAve taken the eamo oath that every othur Benator Lo hias snade, and to think whether ft 14 not better | hoe taken. I propvse to do my duty, and thuto s for the trath, for justice, for law, that we shouid | N® power in the fenate o oatof itthat can drive, liave cven a divided roport upon n mere question of | e from what I betiova is rignt. 18m prepared to * Iaw. If that be well, wo aliall know then that it | Eive the Seoata and wuntr{ reaeons why 1 vote for ia 0 mera question of dnw" and nothing eixe, and | teadilssion of M, C. Butler ns Sonator from shatl have tho respective yiowa of the Nenators wyo | South Curullua, and am rendy to stanl ur fall npon e Chiged with th duty of the mvestization | e verdict of the puolicwlicn fglve thuse resons, O rniah Jint for wat own aabd | THerc has hoen wa tnach waud wix this quoetion {n anceand our ows instruciion. Let us take up | 1he newsuapore, there hos been xo much said on {hat cass which the Committes bias_renorted. and | thin question on tho sirvets, tint T do not proposs et e of coursy of Juat as high pRviiege as | W Ieply tosome things that bave been pad liere, the other, wo ail. agrce, and considet that, ond, { Jt13 eaid that [propuse o transfer the political. bofore we anail have dolsaed the considerution of | Power of this body to thc Democratle party. that, T have not the least queation wo whati have | N0 man diving Thas suthorlly - to quote 1 foport i this, il then wo ehnll g0 un fairly, | B for ench o parposc. T would Justhy, auidl ahal] not have fndicted n biow npon | fooner | lose my plahtoarm o than | do thio fundamental principlea of tho constitution of | Grytiing to omlanzer the'supremacy of the fepub- this budy In ruspect of iuembers that nre to be. | lican party, It voting tur ten, M. C. Butler be- cerning the JIamburg riots wos presented to show that the Senate abould take time to con- sider, and also to guow that thers was so much fn two countics that there could have beeu no falr election there, He waa questioned sbout the localities in South Carolina, and. qnite an nolmated collo- quial debate ensued, Mr, Wadlelgh flually ask- ing the Benators uot to interrupt him so much, a8 it confusod bline When the Isugh which greeted this sally subsided, Mr. Walleigh went on to disclalm any Intentlon to denounce the Routhern people hesause Lie brought forward evidence of a crimey, WILL NOT VOTD I'OR KELLOGG. A member of Senator Patterson’s family says to-night that, in viow of the treatment Fatter- son recelved from Repubtican Benators to<lay, he (Patterson) will not now vote for Kelloge. A PERTINENT INQUIRY. . Tothe iWestern Assoclated Pross. W ASIINGTUY, D. C., Nov, 26.—Iu tho 8onate to<dsy Mr. Edniunds submnlitted a resolution dirceling th o Attorney-General to communicate to the Senrto a8 soon as practicable a llst of all criminal _ prosecutions commenced fn the United States Courts _in Bouth Carolina since the Int of January, 1816, for offcneea agalnst tho lives, property. civil rights, or right of sufirage of ":f person, together with the names of alleged offenders, and a statement 2f the dispesition of such prosecu- flux:“nnd duh!iallcmlah B‘lr. Edunmdn asked Lin- mediato cousfderation of the resolution. Mr, ‘Withers objected. TOE DEBATE, UNINTERESTING PRELIMINARIES, Wasmixaron, D. C., Nov, 28—Mr.Wadlelgh, from the Comumittco on Privilezes and Elce tions, submitted a report, accompanied by a resolution declaring W. P, Kellogg entltied toa seat as Benator from ILouisiana for six years from March 4, 1877. Ho asked present consid- cratlon of the resolution, but objection wes wmade by Messrs. Mcrrimon, Withers, and oth- ers, und the resolution was lald over until to- morrow. Mr. Merrlmon submitted a minority report, signed by Mossrs, Hill, Saulsbury, and himsell, in favor of seating Spoflord. Ordered printed. ' The Houso bil to reneal all that part of the act of Jan. 14, 1873, known os the Resumption expected. If Pattersou bellcved the President should have sustatned the Chamberlaln Legts- inture, It _was of course because he (Patterson) bolloved that Legistature was legal; If it was Jegal, the linmpton Ircgislature was fllemal, The Chamberlain Leg- tslaturo clected Corhin, Why, then, did Patter- #on 10w snnounce that ho stionld vote for But- 1er, who was elected by the Hampton hody1 Tatterson’s attempted exzplanation of what passed betwoen himeelf and Butler on Thurs- day was Joose and fuvolved. Hafloundered and crossed his tracle, and Conover, 1o coming to his assistance, only Injured his own casc by rising and claiming, In corroboratfon of Patterson, that Hutler had not requireid him (Conover) to vote on the occasion Patterson referred to. Both were tuch discomfited by thelr first attempt at cxplanation. +Conover followed in A PREPARED. PERSONAL EXPLARATION. Trom this preparation ho fared better than TPatterson, but his reagons for handioz tho Ite- publicans of the Sennto over to the Democrats were suclias had no placs on thefloor. Hotried to make the case the same ns _ Pinehback’s, and to break the force of Edinunds’ strong words ana his skilled teadership by his weak attack upon his record In that case. After firine blank cartridzes ot Edmunds, he invned his battery on Conkling, but It was not effcctive enough to cause the latter Lo atop writing private letters. The Mcpubiicana lstened, or rather waltod, i1l these two worthies were doue. Then THR FECOND MOVA on the partof the Republicans was developed. Mr, Edmunds, prefacing his remarks with call- ing the attention of the Benate to tha story of. alleged corruption which was on tho strects, absout the Capitol, in tho press, throughout the land, and in the mouthy of everyhody, herc eent up to bo read po amendment to Mr. Thur- man's resolution, providing that tho Committeo on Privilcges and Eicctlons should at once pro- cced to inquire whother there had beea such corrupt bargaiuing. Tho whole Democratic slde saw tho effect of this, and was thruwn by it futo general exclte- THE COFCERT TO-NIGHT, Notwithstanding tho announco- ment in an ovoning paper yostorday that the seats woro ail sold, thero aro still Plenty of Good Seats FOR TEIB EELLOGG-CARY CONCERTS. " who ealo will continue to-day at Root & Bons Music Co., 166 State.st. MINERAL T GREAT EUBROPEAN NOVELTY, TUNYAD JANOS. .NEW APERIENT WATER. Boectally recommend- ed for richness in apee- fent salts, and ite cfl- cacy In Ditlounatiacks, provention of Gout, Plies, etc,, and as an ordinary aperient by LIEBIG, VIR. ity Phai mldN. and tho ontir medical profession in England and Germaoy, . K. BARN 1S, Hurgean-Genornl Us 8, Army, R B B eant I it oects of any of the biter wators." DR T MARTONSIMH, Now York, ‘Asalaza % ative, 1picferit o’ every other’ minerat wa- £ . WL A, TAMMOND, York. **The DR W AL LA eRelelof i Burgative DEPARTMENT AT THE FXPONIT LDING TO-DAY, Tuesday, Nov, 27, . And offer the entire RETAIL Stock saved fromthe FIRE! At prices on basis of settlement made with the Insurance Compa- nies! . This is the greatest opportunity to buy Davis, of Illinois, Casts His Weight on the Same Side. His Opening Stroke Parried and Returned by Ed- munds with Interest. A Charge of Corruption, and a Proposal for " Investigation. Refusal by the Democrats to Relinquish Their Advantage. Tactics Employed by the Repub- licans to Force an In- torruption. Grént Masses of Printed and Writton Matter RRead to XKl Thne. At o Late Hour This Morning the Ses- elon Continued, with No Prospeot of Adjcurnment, it LFRED L. LOOMIS, ke, ‘0T DI ALELD L b0 N N erents voctaly Saaptad for dtly use,” TIIE CRISIS. DR. FORDYCE BARIKER, New Vork, * lo. B get, which authorized the Socretary of the ¢ he 1 I ly and lecte 1 3 AN EXCITING BITUATION. a lungto It by turning it into n wers race and | Cinse he onestly and Fairly elected i to de- t"fi?&{f&"‘ TN 0 o :"""‘ Fpectal Dispatch 1o The Chicagn Tribyne, "“;;':" ondon, with fnsulting lr, ross and suid | TFUASUrY to disposc of Unitod Btates Londs nnd | scratiulo ot xful;uumu . oF, corrupt, Lz‘wuln, or giroy i Hepublican party, (ou kuowe it 0u3hL 1o Proe . 4 3 Mr. ' TOS ¢ v ) 2 ) 2 DR.LEWIN A, BAXIUE Nemm Yoric.s “rro- | B} WASRINGT, D. Gy NGV, B.~In il of 0 | \vould ot mol to, v Edratindstho words | Zoisn ead ernicel tha sreenhaek curcencr, was T urvoter, I b I L8 e e e | et o alecled o7 aiertion of ikt be(geu A WINEULABSFUL A DOSF. ; rain tho procecdings af, the Benalo attracted & | or ywajter, who hiad characterized the usc of A reforrod to tho Committce on | Mir, Mebonald-Mr. Presidont, T anould like to | HEHGH Y e -‘:'x-.n"n‘mh.’»ifi'n'.'i‘c'\-‘f&'fi..'nfia Tinance, The latter portion of the morning hour was dovoted to diacussing the resolution submitted hy Mr. Chaflee, calling upon the President for Information as to what Impediments cxist which ¥ tno bottla beara the namo of Tho Apol ML mteds. London, o Lol FTHED'E DE BARY & CO., 41 & 43 Warron.at,, New York, Bole Agents for United States and Canads. YOR BALE BY DEALERS, GROCERS, AND great crowd. The House not belng In sesslan, members onough were present to pack the floor of tho Seuate back of tho desks. ‘The gallerics were full at an early hour. Both partics were uncertain of the result. The froquent and pro- jor from Vermout if hie ias any evi- denca of any corrupt basgain haviog been had fu re;lwcun this or any other ciatter, ¢, Edmunds—1nald, as 1% atleged. T wiil an- swermy hunorable fricnd & further, how- ever, and Tsay that 1 do not u legal avidence, becase | have o them nsu baso and cowardly resort of malico and falsehood, Gordon intimated that stories were equally nrovalent that the Republicans had tried to mako every court of justleo acting In Patter- appuaite side uf the Chamber, and it I« not my fault that thycascof Kellorg i not before fha Seaate, and thal bis caso was not voted upon bes fore the case of Gon, Butlor was brought up, tisd 1i0_cuntrol over that mmtter, IF it bad een Teft with me | would nut have brought up Uhis res- Garpets, and DRUGGISTS, 1 od consultations since Thursday night hnd : provent him from executing the laws acainat tho | Tiill state for his informstion thut [ belleve ity olution, but It I8 bere, and 1 stand here D n'L'l".‘a"nZ‘é"m make :uhur slde nbl’;)lu{‘cly cor. | son's caso hiero an altar of sacriflee to party { Union Pacifc Nailrosd and ita brauches; but befora 300 il add nlow that§ boliave, nniess tho ;h‘niur- to, tepresent the people of Eouth Carollns, TO IRENT. purposes. ‘To this Edmunds rotorted that if ] reaching a vote tha motning hour expired, and can- | 1ty ‘of Hhiu body should stifto an Inquiry, it wil be | When 1 vote “for Gen, 3. C. Duller, 1 taln. There was a gencral looking around for Patterson and Conover when the Senate was called to order, but neither came till tho morne ing busincss had run on for somu time. This usually dull routiue never scemed more unin- teresting, but at 1 o'clock the srearinces it had brought ondeds the grave busincss, which was to show whether Republiean ascendency s to contibue much longer 1n the Senate, bogan. When Conover und Patterzon eame fn, sll cyes wero on thom at once. To the end of the gesafon overy movement thoy made was watch- ed. The bearing of these men was quite differ- ent. No Republican Scnators appeared to nu- tico them. Conover scemed ENTIRELY UNCONCERNED, ‘Thoso accustomed to his faco could detect no chaogednit. On tho contrary, Patterson's at- tetupt to appoar unconcerned was painful, The neglect of the Republicans changed this into de- flance. IIc was oftenoveronthe Democratic slde, and from first to last was i1l at ease. Under a part of tho day's Infliction he winced, but whenover ho spoke his air was defiant. Hoad not fall to maka good points and strong ones at varlous times, but they were felt by most to have little place on the floor to-day. Plnchback stood in the clonk-room door on the Republican side, and seemod delighted at tho tangle. In the corresponding door on tho Democratic aldo was M. C. Butler, Tourman’s resolution to dischargo the Com- mitteo from the consideration of Butlor's case was called promptly at 1 o'clock. Davls, of 1linois, roso first, Both ralleries and Scnators leaned toward Wim. Ina fow briot and clear sentences hio gave his reasons for sus- tatning tho resolution. Edmunds repiled, aud UAD TIE LAUGI ON DAVIS atonce by calling attention to tho fact that, while o iad spoken of the two parties in the Benate, bo had not so much us meotioned the tuird, which was Davis hlnself. o atso made a strong point on Davis for coming fromn the know 1 ant votinz lo carry out tho will and wish of the people whow I have the honor foor, IF tuey belleve he was clected, ‘The courts have decuded that tho Legia- 1ature which elected him i a legal and jawful boly, and I am bound to obey their mandate, and I yro- pose to do it. . 1 havo been n this Benate nearly Gvo years, and youcan ruferto_my record, My rocord Las bee siraight aud equare. 1meversoted to lower tho fiag,” Sume otharmdid,. 1did vot, Ido not knuw what my friend from New Yurk refers to by **haly ur unholy alilances.” 1 hive statel sil 1 hava o do with this question, 1 that is u Loly alllance, or it It 1s on unhioly alliance, or if itisa corrupt harualn, let (e world kuow 1t, and 1 will take the responsibility of iy action before my peopte antd bufore lue conntry, §am first reapansivle 1o my [uple o bouth Carolins for - my action iere, and 1 will lot them ey swhether it Isa cor- rupt burgain. 1 will let them say whether itis o holy or an unholy ailiance fur me 10 voto for thy wan of thelr ciolce, when ho was fately, and honestly, aud leymlly clected: 1 call upoen tho Demncrats on toe othoe side of the Chamber to a1y Wiether -1 over offerud. any teriis $0 them or pri- sucd any. 1 have n recolfection of talking to por- upa the Senator itom Mismalipl (1auac) ‘and the Senator from Gborzis ((ordua), and telhng thum that § woald vote for Butler, and also to my friend from North Curolina iitansom), I know distinctly, 1have told hin over and over agin thar § wanld vate for Butler, Mr. lamar—WIill the gentlemao allow mo & moment? [ think heis wndera misapprehensiv 1 have no recolicejlon atall of his ever having mnde any such slatoment 1o me. Mr. I'atterson—{ cannot recotlect; § know 1did 10t 141k 1 1ung, but 1thought § had apoken 10 my friend from Aissleaippi, 1t makes no daforen e, however; but this fs what I want to soy, thai it there has been ony unholy alliance, or any bangai, Lam not a pariy toit, $eny right hero to the Sene ator from Vermont that I hopa he wiil ask the Senate to appuint & committce of Investication, and Ict us a0 1f thiero ins bevn furmoed u corrupt bargain, und [ want the world (o know whether L am @ purty to it, 1challunge cuch un luvostigation, and § eay it e not fair, I sayitis kind, to ue no hambher wopde, for a Eenator lo riss on this floor and aseart thut e belleves there has been a cormpt Largain beeansa two of his fellow-Benators choose to vote ditfeee cutly from what he doos, The Senator frum Vere tont voted ayalost the oimisson of Pinchback, Why? Becsuse ho thought 1t was richt to voto that way, Did 5, who voiad for Pinchback's ad- niteston bggauso I thiouzhy 4 was rlght to vota inab wauy, ze¢ @i in tule body and charge s corrupt bars proved. Mr, McDonald—I deslra to say that T belleve of- fora bave beon mudo from Lho other sda Mr, Rdmunda—Certalnly, Mr. President, my honorahte friond has now added ta iy statement animporiant elrcumatance. 1 hud not suggosted that there was any proof against wny = hone orablo friends. 1" do not caro which shde of thin chumber a Sepalor aila who ala in any way fmplicated in any barzatn ur \mproper procecdtnge, Hie must Ledeats with, and if 'he Eonator is curny. tn his information, aud belleves ne vaght to unife with me bofore wo ad- mit anybody that haa snything to do with auch an affalr inito this Senato, or keep bini b, we shuuld havo an Inquiry. McDonald—1 siall join swith the Eenator ot me in seebing w javestigition Into that fact r o 14 ready for it, Mr, Ldmunds—tertainly, wy friend will have an opportunity if he llves s very snort tine, My lion. orable trend from Tlilnoin ‘has stated what 1 was very sorry 1o heat i state. ‘Phere is nothing im- proper {n tho fact lself, bat uohus reluered to procoedinga in anothor. branch of the legialutive t of the uoYermnent. js—I did not kuow tliat wus not In order, Edwunde—And he has broughe that for. wad as aun ({linstration, or an anthority, or o conaideration for thin stev which Kv saya he s abont .to take—diachargo this Committee, I canuot gu Into thess piroceed. {nis to show him o to shiow you that iy friend fuen misapplisd the fnatance, in_my opinlon, bo- caure Lum foroidden by the strict ruled of par- lismentary law &nd by that other cunsideration which sbould apoeal to every member of this budy and to uvory member of the other, aml would to my feiend, as I know that wocaunot go into discuseion of what takies place in cither Lloue, indepsndent of the more Lut on principles of tho highost Jropriety, OFf course if wu can debate theso procsedings ut all we must dedate them fully, Wo must go lo tho vottom of tho walter, and we can all gee that wonld naturaliy lead in many in- stances to o stata of feclings of bitterness, uf minreprosentation, of collision, and of crerything that jsbad {n goveenment which cannot be enanred, ‘fnat is the pr!nclrlu upon which the rule rests, 101 wery at liborty fo rofer in the alishiest duegree 10 what ks taken placo. | shoutd fee: nnlhur‘nd 10 siate, from the published proceedings, that that body, true to 1te high dizuity and its sensc of jus- tice, o0 B mere guestion of Liw onthe (uze of the papers, declinod to ulacharge ite committee; bat, 2 np C«Illnl’t{n into 1t at all. Mr, President, [ hupu that my honorable fricnd Gordon hiad any evidence which made him think :ll:i.nr::“flfilr: ‘(‘.:::n mlxm‘cg"nl; ma re:ulfln(’l‘mil llunu' it possible such atorlos could bo true, ho coutd | FrEE fher conaldoratt ‘;"' 'g'fl‘ d': L ections not too speedily bring it to the attention of the 5 ”;llll or, cm‘:mgc::c:{l as s.';iifir e?rn;‘-‘ ;fitll'z Scnate, arolina. s Mr. Davia oald tho contest now golng on In tho Edmunds met the Democrats who objectod t0 | gensio had atiracied ine atlention of ihe countey, Tits rosolution for varlous reasons with the gen- | and, from the peculiar position Lie occupied tn ro- cral declaration that whon the press was full, | 1ation to tho parties, o trustod it would nof bo out Py of the way for him to ivo briefly the s wh! and every mouth here was fudl, and R0 ahonit votn for e mation af the “Henstor TIE AIR 1TIBLF PULL OF CHAROEA _{lmmflohlcly fl‘é‘l‘:‘““\‘x‘)' 'rhar: wero llxbr:‘e seats In that corrupt bargains had been made In the very [ Hhe Heaate Ca e v onging 0 andthe others t fana, — Trasenta of tho Senate, 1 bocame Benators anil | N wes o somioe o eieat Miparisnce imc. tiey” va the fricnds of the clalmants aswell to fnvestd- | fitled. Tha leginlation of Cougress was binding : upon thone Btates, and the people thereof had the #ate thom bofora procecding further, Fhaht (0 0xpect that tio claims (o tlieao seats would Tatterson vr:lclled ;Rfll‘nlt fllfllulnlln(mw ot ::finc}.ed ué&n at ¢ the lm":t'.'i ossible m:mvn:‘:‘l:ln such o procecding, and alternated his protests v LIWW' whea thls ecmsion opened that 3 thies three seats would be filled or deciured vacant agalnst. investigation with assertions of in-"| SRS ORE GFing esvion. . 1 wan tao iate for thar, nocence and readiness to be linvutlznlcd: but } nm‘ng nx? mnc{, {n‘grlm{lnfl mn' “:.u}uln.non be- whon thio voto came ho remalned ailent, while | fore the enato, but tho maoxer o (Fhurmun) 4 robably know ihat his (Davie’) Jndgment did nat ?0{30:‘0" with brazen cffrontery voted loudly fpprnvu’ot the dolicy s s '+ No. Thurman affceted astontshment that Edmunds Rteelllon. 1o thouzht the Southern Stutos should be represcnted by pereons (dentificd with th in- should arraigna Scnator on n rowspaper ro- port without ovidence, o chargod terosts of thelr vcovla.d had been nugrested that that ft was ol 8 trick to hent 1t tils motion ~ to lschsrge the Commit- teo Wad suninst the uaze of ettt T80 Semen o, e Ha wcsotution, and clted soveral instanices whero | tasgef. tho bil for the readmission of Texas inta Senators-clect under eharges had been admitted. | the Unlonlumo!vm ago, and if he (Davis) might Ho roused the Democratic sldo cffectively; and, asthe result proved, Matthews on tho Repub- Tiead sllo, for as the roll-call went on Couover voted against investigating himsclf, I'attorson Ly llnwed to refer to_the proceedings of thy otucr House of Cungress, he would say that only last odged, and Matthews and Davis voted with the Democrats, and so for tho preseut week a Itepresontative from Maine moved to dus JDEFBATED AN INQUIRT. charge tho Comitnittce on Elsctions from further conauderatlon of the Colorado case, and Lats motlon rosalted In Axing o day for its h«.‘lrlny. o (ba aid not ace why this casy_should b longer coutin- ed (n the Commities on Privilegos and Elections. 1t did secgn to him thas the caso could ba decided by the Bunate npon concoded facts which appeared The faflure of this resolution showed the Ropub- | in bricfs of the raspective contestanis (Uarbin il Heans that. Pattorson_ and Conovor woro in the | Sutlen, 1f, the Commlites shoald examing thiy full power of the Democrats, but ono more vota was attompted to see It thoy Intonded to help tho matter out. Allison moved to go into cxccutivo scaslon, but this was lost, and the Republicans settled Jdown to o long telal of strength in continulng tho debate. South Carollna cass, such examination would After an hour's debate, with Davis' vote an Upholstery, Known for Years! FIELD, " LEITER & 00, BAKERY. C. L. WOODMAN & CO. Will on WEDNESDAY, Nov. 28, opon (helr new WILER] = BAKERY 2 At 61 Washington-st., Whoro cverytblng cholco {n th way of Bakers' Fiiin, _ Gold_and Nickel i\l trimmod, apd or ! 1 LS, Goods may bo foun m&.’[,:l;co":“fl,’f;‘“ Thoy will on thic samo day open ta the pablic the 208 NPATE N finest lunchi-room for ladles apd gentlenicn in the o OCEAN NTEAMNIIPS, city. AMERICAN LINE. Philadelphia and Liverpool. FOR RENT. - DESIRABLE OFFICES IN THE TRIBUNE - BUTLDING TO RENT. Apply to . W O, DOW, Room 8 Tribune Building, CUTLERY. undoubtodly rosult in_two reports, both of them able, no doubt, But what was the neces- sily for_theso reports, when all the facts wonld bo'teached in the open Benatul Hesldes, In tho evenly balancod condition of parties [n thu Senate §Uwos upparent that ihess bwo reporta would nab receivn that conslderation which roports in other matters ordinarily receive. ‘The Committeo on Privileges and Elections had to-day ropurted in tha Louleiana contest. and it was asked tat tble cass e acled upon befure the And other Bank Books taken In exchange for Theoniy transatisntic lina ssiling under the Ama excauitivo session was obtalned, aud this con- i ia be trom 1iinots, &nd my bouorable friends on the | Maile NG® | have 100 uuch respoct for Lim and Yiox bati n 'W t h J 1 d i h Fouth Carolfua case, 1t the Teport tuthe Loul | gthier side of ihls chamber, wili ba wiiling tuat this ] t St arors Thumpay from Ehuadeloh atohes, Jewelry, an gfiz‘:;'_'l"‘:&ffl“m';;fi‘_‘L'j':‘;"l‘:,‘g:n‘;{!;::;: B Tor moatly tw Hours. A% i closc, how. | siioa case L beot maie i thesenale before tho | Boy anail broceud Bow i0 do theso tiiui, In tha {00 e paepect for wpeelf o o sucs 3 thin body «f 1aststages of its callod wession, which are of the most avwolute importance Lo du, and which I can- not more particatatly refer towlih dours vpen than 1 now do, and then proceed with thess mutters of priviloge fnthelr due ordur. To that end 1 move that the Benate procesd 10 the considerstion of exccativa bistnes. oduction of thuresolution of the Senator from Ohlo (Tharoan) o discharge the Committee from farther cousideration of the credentiala of Hatier, Ho would have voted 10 cousider tho Luutsiana caso first, and agatust the zesolution uf the Seustor from Ohio; but, 34 that Seoator bad subwitied his rosolu. tion fest, it Wok precedunce, and o (Davie) be- Ioved that now was the proper time to decido the ever, tho Democrats atill carrfod tho day, and the open scsston was resumed upon the But- ler casc, ¥ Tt was expected that when the Senato came out of Its exccutive scaslon it would adjourn, slon. Why? Iecause ho thought ho was not eluct- ed. 1 voted for his admsteslon, not becauso he was a Nepublican, nut to waintain o Repubiican sa- Promacy in tia body, but bocause I belioved bo was vlected, Mr. Presmdent, some peoplo affoct surprise st my vole, ‘Phiero Is not udenatoron this eide of the ment of counsel were unneecdsary in scttling so grave a case. Edwmunda’ appeal for procecding with dus rogard to the rules and regulations of the Scnate, and sottling tho case with a proper regurd for law and Justice, and not in- RED STAR LINE, Carrying the Delgian and Unlied tatea matls. Hafll Exeryinciye dars, sternately tron) VILLADKLY nd uhmwn’;m"‘.fi :: ‘;L 4\"!0 ANTWrI o Aentn 119 R Silverware. E.V.RODDIN & (0., BONS, W, B LAWRKNCE Manager, Shleks; 1560 STATI-ST, troducing I the place of thcso partisans :“:n.‘::;n;l;: '“';'“:‘,l.:xl Hls. Jurvge) udl: thi can0 in opon Benate. . o And fl‘;fl“'x‘afé‘!‘dfi_";‘u’.‘flfi"fl‘,fi - Chamber #ho dusa Bot know that it was husiiauod TH YTIAMERY FURs, eambiag tor soats ou tha rosults of ncurrupt | VS 'SEASR TSR IR and, s w portion | Sefsie sstes v s epmIont s, Will the | follows; . e ettt W hon the Legtalatuso mok MA“; bTEAM]&“b bargalu, 1 his romarks, sont 4o tho Secrotary’s deak aud | A Etmunds—tr, Prosident, T bellevs my hon- | 4y, i e Makthow under the calt of Gov, Mamptun on thu Sith of 9 " [\ Ty Are oftering thelr larke o . orabla friend from Jllinows (Davls) is partly correct ot AN kel April, 1877, 1 wanat Columbis, The Chamberiali PEVONIA, Ded AR Rl Glesgom. (Jl “fldfl; whotesnlo atock i Ladi PRECIPITATED TON DATTLY, had read P speauiug of the evnaly-bulanced siate of parties | oot ** ity i Obrerument bad vantebed, Whoao fault was that? RN Se. s, e | ity Des 4 poon Hiacques of Ahotland mud | which ¢iit then had not taken definite shape, TIE FAMPHLET SRIEF OF CONDIN, Ih the Benate. Whethe? he referred to ol the | liruco; fion Uiy, 1'1bink there are ruand me sopie gentlomen who Now York lu Ulasguw, L andoudcriy McDonald interrupted to ask 1f Edmunds | the opposing claimant to Butler for the South Hurusda, e, e atood by the Prostdent, and who udvised the Prest- artits i the Seuate oF da_not “know, partiee I fug, Cen LA B thent tovompit what Tthiuk the greatcet blunder ot Fur Manufae. s st New York to Loudon dircct every Woduesiay, “l‘ a““ ac':‘l.l.nl. and uf their own churged that there bad been corrupt bargatning. | Carolina scat. 1t took Mr. Pllgfl. the silver- Laughter.} There sre two arties in the benato Howe. c WY, Jikive {Nov.), Baunders, Chatoo y famsCHT . ANGLIA, Nov. 24, 118, | AUSTIGALY A, Dec.3, 3 pm. ke, st manufaiturers that aro very nearly vvealy balsnced, How it ia . of hls Adminiatration, snd that was (o remov thy Cabind, 33510 10, Recouduabin, 340 ru‘um;u", 828, . rices. Also, ahotierlives | ¢ No," sald Edmunds; adding, however, with | toned Reading-Clerk of the Senate, nearly threo { with tho el § 0o ok know. {Lavghter.) Chmitancy, Meiiias, Wititlgha0, troops froms the Siate iTouse Ig South Carolina, [ Drafta asiad tor any o LAt currency rates. * t“l’"l" Go, O T 4"t vut ta- | @roat emphasls, “*but I belleve it 1" hoars to iet through this document, | M- Davieifuo (hird la unhy mous, (laughtar) | Costling. e {oucht that pulloy s Lok o & il A wien HENDERSON BROTHERS, 08 Waablugton-at, te] 9 [staicg ta tho history of the McDonald Interpoacd that hoforone would | to which no one pretended to laten. Riing s Lipts Vi il e Gondun, Mt I waa atricken dawn, sud my party wens down o Fur Trule tuat you can unanimous, as my (riend has fustatatod. [Laugh d b STATE LINE Madison and Franke icbseasipis filisbt | help luvestizate such o charge, and Edmunds | Bomo Somaiors —went down fnto the | ter.) I hupe wouhail have oider, , Mr. Prosideot, arrin’ aricrion. it sie Ay fieude asseuiblod b Coltle sttt L. . O B tonmo. Lot irve B pervenss” | retorted that McDouald could have s chance o | restaurant and dined; others enjoyed sholr | FEMUCERO QN 0 1 it rests with the Senator | & qenestiia), Han. hor: thtv QUEstOn, —awyors, and siembers of the MW YORK T0 OL-ANID FodboN Ditoie P01 BEAIX & BUOCELER. | belp if he lived muck longor, . clgurs fo tho cloak-rooms; others read the | from Vermont, (Laughter. bokse o h.,u,‘,"“ Thurmaa’ Bewnty, and niembers of the llouss who had voted pTATEOX EN No YL reday. Nov. %0 ———— T ‘Under all this Patterson winced and Conover | uewspapers, and a fow ol stagers endoavored | Mr, Edmunds—Then wo w 1l bave ordor. Tha F‘l\h: flu{"‘\?-.'). Mecrvery) Yorbos &'Ju"x‘fi;u:;'i'fl'.'.'r'““fifl m, .u'i.‘.i?n“fl,‘i‘"i; m"!;:‘:; LA 0o 3378 |~ mEiomANT TALOMANG, __ | vtiohwouni. Himunt, whobatbecn Kiven | toforely emseveafor e suaios moctuma | SIS A L R | bl R W plabiinad o, And oty sk e, i, 1) wioge: Tevyra tickvts at rodlced Fa ..é’uu.m?;f:a.e. TIiH BEeT | the mansgemont by the Nepublicans, then | struggle by sucozing on the lounges. | would see ita crror. 1t wua ouly the other day that | GAIIsuG. e, Witlzre-80. sent utlor,” Bui they sar the Hampton Leglela- Mcwsrs, Dlalne, Ferry, lamlin. Plumb, targent, Spencer, and Window, who would bave voted fn he apinnative, werv patred with Mussni. Uruver, Mazoy, Bamum, Afwstrong, Eaton, il and J0lnsoo, who woulld bave volsd i the neyatlve. 1o snnounciug the pares, Me, Eaton said, owing to a sad calamity in tis famnily of the Sunator frout Calfornls (Sargeat), he wias compellod o be al unlhlnd ho (Eaton) hud palred with blu es all polifical quustions. Mr, Hill said, fur s reason which he deemod en- tirely wullciunt and proper. ho bad patred with the Beustor from Aanama (5pencer), Mr. McMillan sald Lis collssgue was uecussarily abscnt frota the city,and had palred with Johosan. Mr, Coristlaucy argucd that the fucts rezurdiug the South Carvllna cure 80 lese lu dispule now than at.thu lest sceelon, when his Democratio fricude bad votea with i to wend it 1o tho Cor wittee for fuveetbrution. 1lo wae just s anxe fous as the gentleman from Hlfuols (Duvls) to have prompt sctou taken upon the pending caser, but e’ wishied Onat 1o bave thom properly examined. Ho intended to vuta in each cuse i oxact accordanc with what ho should find to bo tho law applicable to catablishod facts, but be uld pot yot Kuow what Judgment bo would ‘thus be led 10 form sfter due examination of the questivas ig. turo is tegal, lawful, snd conatitutionul. We taluk 18 12 better for tho peace, gulut, ana proteetion of our peoplo, and you shiould nut autayonizo thent on that question. and that you suould vote to seal Uen. Butles, | lUave plenty of witnesscs bero totha (ruth of that stdtemunt. 1 came o Woshiurjton in May. 1 bad an futuevlew with a reporter of 'th Nuioual Lepublican, b this city. In wich { an- nounced distincily tuat 1 would vote for Lutler's aduwstun, oud gavo tho reaseu. 1t weut sli ovee the country ; but bow, becauss my fricnds oo tals wids of the Chawbee, who dalloved Iwould not do 18, who belleved they could vervusds me ot to do 80, ~—porhaps ot of thew were slily enough 0 belleve they could bulldoze we into not dotwg it~ afoct greal surprise. After waat 1 have passed through in South Caro. lina fu eight years ln politicsl campaigne, 1 do ot Propost 1 bo bulldozed in this Seaate. It 14 uot good place to wiud up 8 bulldoziug operation. Lo show tho focling of Iteoublicans Ju south Caro. Tina, 1 mention that on last Thuredsy, , wheu this subjuct was befors the Benate, and - Jore we had voted on It, 1 received & dupatch, which I sball read, from a fricud $u New York, & citizen of Bouth Carollus, ou of the woat promls nent Ropublicans we have these, aud & 1au wle 20t as twich woney In the campalyu laat yearas s Blgor: sy triend, in reepect to the ‘casy of Eusils (L think thatis tho uame of one ot the Louisisns people), which on thu face of it was & simple question arising on the state of the papers as they. were read here by & Nenator, saw with hls ususl uickness and rness of spprohension that thore was & question of law Involved, —one tbat ought to be cousldered, a4 hu stated, 1 believe, himseif, by s Commitiee, snd reported upon. oot » dlepute of the facts, Lut that the Compiition vught to_report after careful atudy und fovestigu- ton and examlustion of the authoritice sud of litical history, sod o ou, iu urder that the nate wight ba iuformed of the stale of the law, Bui what ¢ wmy friend now iu & case from Eouth Carolina? Thers be thinks therg is no dizpute of facts, because ho ways the facts ato conceded in tho two brivfe. 1 do not kuuw. toas. What aothonity has the Benator (fll’ waying that the facts are cunceded! It may o hat sowe honorabls frieud of my political way of shiuktng may rise in his place snd aay that . pules tho facts asserted In the brief of Lutler, It may be that some gentloman on the other mido of the chamber, Lelouwing uot tu wy friend's party v ta wine, may riss and say that he docs not agree Lo+ the facts stated 1o Cotbin's brief, llow aru wo to know them? ‘There ls the ditticulty, and it1sim- oud Cabin, $40. Hetura tickets at puduced ral urfl{.un rp‘plyl‘:x'.’\'(?arlfi. A DWIS &5 e chtd, J ) Chizago. WIS . WAIItACh, Sio 124 Washilaztou- North German MOW. Tho steamers of this Company will eatl every Satur- t’ from Dromen Pler, foot of 1bird street, llobuken, Lates of o—Froin Now Yor 5 ndon, Hevre, a0d Bremen, At cabla, §10; second Eabin, lw,.?nfymnn 830 currency. Fur frelght e 2 Bowliog Urves, New Yoik. Great Western Steamship lLine, From New York to Iristol (Eagland) direct. Tucsday, Dec. 11 turday, Dec. 33 age, $30. § secrmediate, $43 RS 18T Tlekeia o4 FovoraLia raton Era: 4 Bteerago certl tea, $20. iy Lo WAL ¥, B A A e il T CUNARD MAIL LINE. Bailing throe timess week toand from Brltish Io‘n»-.’ 4 ‘wel’ll Prices, L Somn morved, iu order to allow the Butler case to go forward rogularly ss it should, andthat it might uo longer {mpedo fmportant busiocss, that tho Beuate should proceed to thy consideration of executive busiucss,—which motion was designed to test the purpose of Patterson and Conover Both on rotl-call answered no, Conover with do- clalon, Patterson with s volce he could hardly control. . All saw how tha battle was opening sud ho the lines were drawn whea the Prosident an- nouuced tho result 88 33 to 30. Tho uext move was awalted on all sides with interest. M Christlancy took thbe floor for s fow words, explainiog why he should vole agalust the resolution. Mr. Edmunds went up to con- sult tbe Vice-President and show him a paper which was evidently to play a past inthat move, sud Mr. Patterson went over fora talk with Mr, Tuurman, tho lstter being charged with tho lcadership on the Domocratle side. The electric lght in the dome belng visible ald over the eity, crowds were attracted to the Cabitol, and ths galleries wora kept tol- erably well filled. Tho spectators did not, how- aver, appear o take much interest In Curbin's brief, ‘When the document bai} been read there were motiuns to go iuto executivo scsston and mo- tions to adjourn, but TUR RESULTS WERN A8 UNCUANGED 8s is the multiplication table, the Democrats being invariably one, two, or thres ahead. Just before 11 o'clock Mr. Wadleigh, who had tha fleor, called for the readiug of & report on South Caroliua affairs in gencral, and the Ham- burg massacre iu particular, Mr, wallace, the Democrstic Benator from Peunsylvania, who was tempormily in the cbalr, cotertalned 8 motion from Mr. Whyto that this reading should not ‘be permitted, but the Vice-President fook his scat, the polut of .y Goae USENOSS rines Coumeren-s2s Fane; meres,. i et ultin l‘ffi‘g" Flae fon. fatiees & WLUS «1.B.HALL&OO, ITallors. 130 Dearborn-at, OFTICIAN. BIANANSE, OPTIOIAN, Tribune Bulldiuge Fire Sl‘;‘rl.\n o clpls. Upersn eoves Baruinciens 0 T STOVEN, PUSSTIURUUUURL. 1. & -~ SUPUPUVOIUSOBPOo, |z, somarmies ke i i oty {pared to miake zx¥=~ ufted Lo sll wights - Al e s no Oéntl, uorthweat cormer adolph. 0. < "ible to zel over It on Any other ihoory thanthat | volved. Hu was frve, bowaver, to way that, If ¥ wap iu the Slate (0 sccure you your scat and P DU VERN Cncral aestern Agent. crdigacily Low Prices: | M. Thurinan roseaud ylelded tosfr. Patterson [ order was not sustalned, and the monotonous | Sorible Lo KeL over I OF A O eator ways wo ara | forcud to voto without bppottuniy fur Jaytuatiat | 317 Weyee bls seat. Mo tologiaphod frum New PARLOR FOU 1977, (C0,, 58 BLata-st. for an explanation. it was reading of the dry documeuts was resumed. | likely to do, sud to wmorcly oxert tha physical | amimation, he would cortainly feel it hly duty to York o we as follows: BUALLSe o APFEARANGH Th spectators could not stand this, and grad. | Sitenath of party votcs, Witliout ruzard 0 law or | give the beaedi of any doubl which might theare: | o Youk, Nov. 22, 1877.—The Zon. J. J. Pz et —————ere ey 4 BEN2ATIONA ARANCH, i Rrad- | SUSmEth OF pa e o the. sironzest ta put | taln fu his mind o bls own pariy, Tho Commitieo | Puticreorl, Sanate: btavd gruly by Butler. 1 18 FAlBAKKS' SNANUSALS under sousational circumstances. Mr. Patter- | ually dropped off, but tno Clerk kopt on read- iu his political friends. Would tuat Bo s good | baving now ruporied 8 case which bas heretofore | iho ouly Nope we bave got. ! STANDARD son clalmod thas be bad been sud was atruo | fog. occapiod thelr time would doabtivss be adle 10 7a- | Therv {s oue rule | bave alwaye foliowed in life, thing for the Bepals of the Upited States Lo do? 1 do hot think It would. 1 bave had somo vccasion ta ba roviled In times gono by, when partles wero pertiape not quite 80 tqunll‘ ivided a4 they ara Dow, ~therg wers ouly twa theu, and {heroare three now, —for thioklog 10at there wua vatue fu loquiry into'the Scaatorial queation o Louisisns, and vot- fug sceording 10 wy convictlons of tho law a8 they porton the South Carolina copteat, sud be could Bot YoLo Lo discharke the Comsmities withont cast- 2 83 1mputation upen its mewbstr. r. Howo referrod Lo ihe rumors of bargalos by which votea wero to be given 1o tho Democratis party Ju the ouate, and sald bo was very glad toat so largs & portioa of the world as culd cigwd the gallerigs and that bs to take the adrice of fricuda aud people Who are ss much {utercated as wysclt ip 8 quoatlon, and 1 is preity safe. 1 mavery sozey (nat Gou. Butler iva Democrat. 1 wish howero & Kupublic- au. but I cangot change biw. It 14 oot wy fault. My friend from New York (Mr. Conaling), tar w! ¥ cutorian ss wuch respecs 84 f o for say “COUNTY ORDERS And Gity Vouchors Bought B AZARUS BILVERMAX, = émbcx of LUmIRErce. A3 TOS OOLLOQUIAL DEBATS FROCERDED, Mr. Ransom spoke of a remsrk of Mr. Hoar's as aquibble, This Mr, Hoar pronounced s stvle of speech nubecoming to his character and to the floor, sud bo procecded (0 oxXpress Republican; that bo loved the party as pls lfe, and would rather loss bis right arm than betray it; but be belleved Bulter elected; bad long sz expressed thls oplnion, aud had long since ssnounced -in the SCALES ALL EaND& 3 FAIRBANKS, MORSE & 0O, 31 & 113 Lake St., Chicago, Becarefultobuy only the Geoulne,