Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, October 27, 1876, Page 1

VOLUME XXXL UFACIURERS 0 MANUZZD i surer of goods must aleo bo o fac! Th;‘":"": the acnsc of creating end regu- merc! ot ! { he et for what he has to sell. 1 IibE t::,!‘l“tx:;!,“;m\'lnnnc'nt popularity he must “ummd;mnm,xmd smake the trademnark known s fatte m:::";‘:c‘;‘urcr of goods favorably known | Toe mv“"cme his awn terms, and com~ oo AEAER s are WD to hecome etive mus!"':”;“! agents In lis Intorest, instead of s Wl anccees, 1d on thelr that bear 8 trademark are sold on th 1 Good ad tho business iadependence ace uefl“*h- maldng the trademark known to the qured DY {s worth something commercially a8 sumet » sense of personal satisfaction in n::nl; l,:muhlvlz to scll which {s popular with 11 pecopsuuet e in Astistic and Fino Goods for petert 10 o Yorsonal Use. e NG, . o NITURE, BEDDING, &0.— +CARE Efi’mno C:\ln"li‘ COMPAKRY, 0ld stand of ALLEN, MAcker & Co,, 253 State-ste FIREPLACE DEATERS— gALTIAORE {Bramhall, Desne & Co.) B. E. GIVAUDAN, 110 Luke-st. EDDING STATIONERY & INVITATIONS N, McCruno & Co., A w110 Stato-ste DIAMONDS— N. Mataon & Co, Cor. Btate and Monrue-s! ' ARTISTIO TATLORE— ELY & Co. \ A abadhears ART WORK IN BTERLING BILV_IRWABE— fanupAcTUIENG CO. Gomitt ]\x Boud-st, New York, LATED WARE— s MeripeN Britasxnia Co., N. Marsox & Co., Cor. State and Monroe-sts. . oL PAINTINGS, LITHOGRAPLS, " AND HPOKTENS OF WORKS OF ART— M. O’Briew, * 208 Wabash-ay. ¢ gEs= BTUDEDAKER BROTHERS, gouth Bend, Ind. ; 285 Wabash-av, §RO0L AND CHURCH FURNITURE _mmulndnrem)— A. H. ARDEBEWEA Co. WATCHOES— . Sy N, Marsox & Co., Cor. Btate and Monroe-sts, FINE WATCH REPAIRING A SPECIALTY with HamiLtox Rows & Co., Corner Stats and Washington-sts. 41E3 AND FINE DRESS GOODS— Cius. Gossace & Co,, 106, 108 aud 110 Stato-st. JEWELEES AND SILVERSMITIIS— .N. Matsox & Co., Corner Stato and Monroe-sta. PIANOS (Chickering & Sons)— A. Rerp & 8o, ‘Van Buren and Dearborn-ats. CLOCKS AND BRONZES— N. MaTsox & Co., Cor. State and Monroe-sta. PANK AND OFFICE FITTINGS OUR 8PE- ALY~ A. H. Axpnzws & Co., 211 and 918 Wabash-av., Chicago. BAFES~ Harv's 8arE AND Locxk Co., 147 Dearborn-st, ECALES— FamnaNks, Monse & Co,, 111 and 118 Lake-st, CUINA AND GLASSWARE— BURLEY & TYRRELL, 83 and 85 8tate-st. Travelers' Guide, SHERMAN HOUSE— Rates reduced 1o $3 per day for sll roome iove parlor floor wmmn’{ bnlhz. A, IluLpent, Proprietor. “RANY PACIFIC HOTEL— Cor. Clark and Jockson-ats., Jonx B. Dnaxz & Co., Proprietors. BREVOORT HOUSE (European plany— Madlson-st., betweor. Clark and LaSalle, H. M. Tutoymrson, Proprictor. fi’fl:mnh will appear dally In Qrst column 1 pige in Tz Ciiteaao TRIBUNE. STOCKHOLDERN' MEETINGS. BT A e A P AP Omcg OF Tux BaLTrxous, Pretnuunai & Cie wov Ranwar Co,, ItLINows DivintoN, Citicado, Oct, 26, 1470, NOTICH T tho Btookholders of the Baltimore, Bittsburgh & Ohioago Railway " Company, Illinois Div.t Mreliecehy notifed that m parsnance of & faulen of the Toard of Directors of 1 above: Edlne mpany nunlncd Oct. 25, 1870, A special Brigesof lie stockhalders of “the Haltimors, Dot & Chicago taftway Company, 1llinols &yon, Inhereby Catled to°ba old ok Wednes Athepobyis 870, at balf-pnst 2 o'clock p. m.. i I‘g cllice af the Company, No, 83 Sonth v Chicago, Cook County, 111, to consider of the g b0 the question of changlug the name Kallrgyy gmny to i Baltimore & Ohio & Chicngo o '"fiul:mr"ll A Inaccordunco with the atatuie Foridey. v“,. cnnl- in such cases made and JORN DYIALL DI . moro, = HORACE . WATYE, | Buran & Cote 4 | cago Rallway I WENNIS, | C 4 K. COWERY," ot 011 4 JAMES WWALSIL noleDiviaion. A QUANTITY op LD TYPE. ATPLY AT The Caunting Room of This 0ffce, \_‘__ Ty 0, Py 820 t‘fl sl |wl):m|d1'um when you can get the host Galeetangt 8 DR, NeChESNE'S for & Clark ang llnnak%",fl?m resortin tho city. “aNGE, GH'8 “O0BONA™ RANGE, /f;? Ba INSURANCE. GEO. €. CLARKE, 3 and 4 Bryan Block, AGENT FOR 4 LONDON ASSURANCE CORPORATION, LONDON, A. D, 1720, Assets (Gold). ...$1,4503,034 HOME INSURANCE 00, COLUMBUS, OHIO. Assots......... .-.8512,605 MANUFAOTURERS' F. AND M. INS, 0O, ROBTON, pasets...... -$1,209,419 HOFEMAN FIRE INSURANOE COMPANY NEW YORK. ASSetS...ca. oo -..$414,045 PENNSYLVANIA FIRE INB. COMPARY, POILADELFPHIA, A. D. 1836, Asgets......... -..81,659,853 PEOPLE'S FIRE INSURANCE C0,, TRENTON, N.J. ASBELS eeenvnannnvennnern.... 8573,220 NEFTUNE F. AND M. INSURANOE 00, BOSTON. Assets 3622,170' BOYLSTON M. INSURANCE QOMPARY, . BOBTOW, Assets., ...5$1,481,018 NEW PUBLICATIONYN. PPLETONS' JOURNAL. A i Anuum, A Monthly Ma Price, 25 conta per. Numberi 85 por +41Tho chenpest and most readable of the high- oluss magazines,” AT *$ The articlos are ehort, bright, discriminating, sad fall of life. "—CirIcAGO ADVANCE., ' JOURNAL. A Monthly Maga- cents per Number; $3 per Annom, PPLETONS' JOURNAL. A Monthly Maga. zine. 25 cents per Numbor; $3 per Annum, “4¢ Contans dellghtfal fiction. "—X. Y. Evexixo Marn. FPLETONS' JOURNAL. 25 cents per Num- ber; $3 por Annum. ** Alms tobe bright, entertaining, fresh, and in- stractive.” 4 PPLETONS' JOURNAL. A Monthly Magn- zine. 25 cents por Number; $3 per Annum, % Articlen many of thembrilllant and sparkling. ** N. Y. 'Tanune. y PPLETONS' JOURNAL. A Monthly Misce]- Iany of Popular Literature. Illustrated. 25 Cents por number. **Numhers among its contributors some of the most brilllant names known to magazine litera~ ture, "—CHRISTIAN REGIATER. PPLETONS' JOURNAL. trated Magazine, per Annam, A Monthly Tlus. 25 cenis por Number; $3 +44 Dererves a place in the front rauk of current magazine literasure. "—~Bosran Post, PPLETONS' JOQURNAL. Monthly. Iiustrated, 23 cants per Numbor, * 44 Pull of bright, sprightly, and entortaining ar- ticles, "—I'MOVIDRNCE JOUNNAL, PPLETONS' JOURNAL. Variety, freshness, sparkle, entortalmment, life,—n brlliant panoramn of the times. 25 cents per Number; §3 per Annum, ' D, APPLETON & CO., I'ablishers, New York, MOODY and SANKEY Gospel Mceting Each Evening This Week, Except Saturday, at 8 O’Clock tn the GREAT TABERNACLE Monroe and Franklin-sts. Mr, MOODY will preach snd Mr. SANKEY will alng, asslsted by the Tabernacle Cholr, * Tickets requlred. 12 o'cloc! Moody aud Sankey. TO REN Desiranle Dfices TO RENT IN TEHE TRIBUNE BUILDING. INQUIRF OF ‘WILLIAM C. DOW. Room 8 TRIBUNE BUILDING “CAM Goons, AN BNTIRIS NOVELTY. The ORLY TOKCH with EXTRA ATTACUMEN? for FLASH Will burn steadily for six hours, and allaw 200 flashes. Ono humdred of thess torches will make wmare dlaplay than 500 of any other, Blanutactired and for saly by the SHALER MANUFACTURING CO, No, 4 Murray-at., ow York Clty, WINTER RESORTS, THE ROYAL VICTORIA HOTEL, NASSAU, BAHAMA ISLANDS, Now open. T, J. FORTER, Proprietor. Steam- ers leave New York Oct, 28 aud Nov, 20. For full informatlon apply to JAS\IES LIDGERWOOD & e ey CQ., 768 Brondwiy. Now York. . OIL TANKS, WiLBON & EVENDEN, OIL TANKS Ann SHIPPING OANS, 47.& 40 Weat Luke Btroat, EXLONA GO, S 430p FOR GaTiLUME STOVE BOARD. IR Lo o - S ST PAGE'S “TILE"” BTQVE BOAED. Noouday Meotlugsat FARWELL TTALL dattyat to 1 o'clock, conducted by Messry, - EXTRAORDINARY AND UNUSUAL BARGAINS CARPETS! SN i & AN BROTHERS - NOTE THESE PRICES! 300 pioces Ingrain Carpots, choico patterns, at 35c up. 250 piloces Tsapostry Brussels in new dosigns, from 95¢ upwards. 260 pes Body Brussols from $1.35 and upwards, very cheap. OIL: CTOTELS, MATTIINGS, RUGS, MATS, &C., At oqually Low Pricos. Being dotorminod to reduce our immenso stock, wo are propared to offer Tiower Prices than any houso in this city. M., F. & M. Savings Bank, No. 75 South Clark-st.,, Chicago. COMMENCED DUSINESS 1862, Porfoot Beourity and Liberal Intorest, The Investment certificates of this hank are nc- cured on lmproved real entate, tho sccurities being in speclal troat, The certlficates bear interest, gnj'n ble in quarterly Installments, at the rate of 7d-10 qer cent per annuwm. They are more secitre than a direct morigage loan, and much more avail able, They may bo obtalned pemionaily or through tho mnils, In aums of 8100 or multiples thereof, wt thin bank. ln\ercut{_uhl 04 naual on sayings-book uccounts, BYDNEY MYERS, Manager. 7 PER CENT. Very cholee Joans on very oholce haninesa iy at BEVIING £40; 00 S0 000 80 K0, 810,000 B 14y B JUU_"_DEHL LASON, 107-109 Dearborn-as, EIGHT PER CENT--§250,000. We can mske Ioana at 8 per cent, with low commia- 1 missions, ot kood improved city El‘fl erty frum $5,000 10 $250,100. TURNER & DOND, 102 Wantiington-at. LOANS OX REAL ESTATE for a term of years in sums of $2,000and up- ‘wards made at current rafos by DAIRD & BRADLEY, 00 LaSalle-st. MONET AT TOW RATES Toloan on Warehouse Iteceipts for Grain and Provis: fons, on City Certiticates sod Vouchers, on Itents and Morigages. LAZARUS SLL,VERMAN, Lank Chutbir of Cominerce, N ELGEN AND WALTHAM WATCHES, ALS0 FINE IMPORTED WATOHES OF STANDARD MAKERS, SOLID COLD JEWELRY, SBILVERWARE, &c., AT THE BANKRUPT SALE, Cor: of Lako and Clark-sts. Lvery srticle Warranted. THE CANADA Fur Manufacturing Co. Madison-st., N. W, Cor. Franklin, Is tho only osteblishment whore you oan find the largest stock of Furs in ondless varioty, and of bost work. manship, at manufacturer’s pricoes. Any article can bo mado to order at shortost notice. BEAK & BUCHER. PAPER OIL CLOTH AL 25 ceats & yard, for salo by BARRETT, ARNOLD & KIMBALL, 104 LAKIS-ST. TTAKDLIN & PAUSONS, 511 Weat Madison-st. RUDOLFH FERL, 48 Milwaukoo-av. INQ, SANDRERG, 07 iivinton-st, . T, ¥, PUTCI, 170 Twonty spcond-st. GENERRAL NOWIOES, Storage Notice. On all Rejected Gruin recolved fu staro hy us on and after this date, extra storage aftor tho first twenty daya will be charged at the rato of one-half cent per buskol for sach sdditional ten days ur pact uf same, MUNGER, WHIEELER'& CO., YINCENT & CO.. ARMOUIL DOLE & CO., FLIN'T, THOMISON & CO., J. & B BUCKINGIAN, Chlcago, Oct. 25, 1870, Cook Gonnty Normal School ‘Will open Monday, Oct. 30, 1870, D. 8. WENTWORTH, Principal, TIA'TS AND FURS, Men’s and Boys® Dress and DBusiness IHats, lL)m-ga Variety. Low CC8s J.8, BARNES & 00,, 70 Madison st. MEATER, PESNEEY Lo T PAGE'S “B8T, JAMESY HEATHER, SULLIVAN. The Jury Make Their Last Appearance in Court, And Declare to the Judge They Cannot Agree. They Stand Eleven to One--Remarks to the Persistent Juror, « Application for Bail by Defendant’'s Coun- sel. Some Sharp Sparring Between the Prosecution and Judge MeAllister. The Court Positively Asserts that Sullivan Is Not Guilty of Murder, And Allows Him His Liberty in Bail of Eight Thou- sand Dollars, Public Sentiment Solid Against the Judge and IHis Rulings. A Numerously-Signed Peti- tion Requesting Him to Resign. The Judge Intimates Any Ono Presenting It Wili Be in Contempt, Explains and Defends His Position and His Rulings, And Expresses a Rather Opinion of the Board of Trade. Poor Juror Berry Tells How Ifo Was Abuscd During His Incar- ceration. The *‘Staats-Zeitung " Dopands Me- Allister's Impeachment--~Letters from Correspondents. 2 DISAGREED, ONE TO ELEVEN. ~ The culmination was reached yesterday., 1t was generally understood or supposed thut the Jury would be discharged, but whethier they would find a verdict was o question that exclted much interest, nnd attracted a Jarge mumber of people. There was, however, 8 natable falltug ofl in tho attendance, espeeially of ladies, not over fifty being prescut. Tho crowd outsjde the ar was of tho same <haracter a8 on the previous days, and the more partisan could not restrain o mantfestation of thelr sympathics.. Those an the rear edge stood on the backs of benehes as before, determined to see. Neither Mrs, Han- ford nor Mra. Bullivan was preseut. The former tnd no curioslty to gratify, and the tatter was sald to bo still suffering from nervous prostru- tion, At one minute past 10, Judge MeAlllster took his eent, and the crier opened the Court In the preseribed form. A hush fell n\mn the assemblage. The jury came In head- ;:;‘ by a bullltl, Great lumps went up and down BULLIVAN'S THROAT as he contempluted them, e turned a shade puler, and there was an, anxlous yet confilent ook ln his eyes us they Wandered Trom fove to faco of the twelve. When the jury took their seats every glanee was directed” toward then, ‘They were stolid, and, with the exception of the foreman, indlfforent, laviog little regard for t crowd, and eager only to shako ofl all remi lscences of the weary triol, and the long dava and nlghts of duress, The formallity of calling thelr nnmes seemed, to conmume mord time thuy usual, but, when It waa finished, The Court waid: Gentlemen of the jury, have you agreed an a vordiety Foteman Muothews arose, and, turning to the Judge, replicd, | ‘wWE HAVD NOT." Mony Al's of aetonishment and disappointment went up from the spectaturs, but they died away in un justant, 5 'n:'nr Court—Ja thers any prospect of an agree- menl Foreman Mathews—Thera s none, Tho lest wond was uttored with emphasis, aod the buzz which grected 1t was composed of 8 sigh of rollef and a breath of Indigmatlon. Twoor three people tln”ml thelr Lanids once, and several others begnn to hiss, but neither thy applausy nor tha hiswen Iasted ive peconls, ‘The Court (after conslderiug a moment)—T do not llh(nk 1t 18 oy duty o keop this jury together any lunger. ‘Pwalve countenances shono with delight at tho prospect of relessc, and hall a dozen smlted thelr satisfactlon. Mr., Reed—I think they ought to be discharged, Thuy cortainly have had time ¢uough ta decide the cawe, and they have tried to decide it. The Court—They huve been Lept outn great Tenzth of timo, . Ile thought for » few moments and added, ¢ Uentlomen, yuu are dlscharged, ™ Then the jury arse and Jeft thele bos. It fa doubtfnl if thero wore any happler mea ja Chicago 6t thut moment than they, " While Wednesday night was presed more cominttably than the pr ccdlllF wvening, and they baa had " **u good breake fst, Vihey were ulmont fagged out atd thoroughly disgusted—gleven ab the **stubnornnes™ of one who had kept them out thirly-six hours, and the ono at thy contuumclousness of the cieven whom ho donbtless thought were eleven of the wost “opinlonated ™ men in the workd, THE DISAPFOINTMENT was ittor everywhere, Wougti the disagrecment wasu reliel to Suthvan's irieads who had been leawt sangaine of his nci'\llllul. I'o him b was a8 siew lease of Nife, though ot u quit-cialin of the demanas the law Lus upon s, “While he hail exe pected n completo vindicatlon, he yet had realized he danger I which hestood; and ile absence of o condermnation, though thero wus a falluro to jastl= Iy him in his act, was ut least & respitu and the foundatlon for the ronewal of all Lis hope When tho Judge announced tho dlechargy of the Jury a elight tlush paseed over Sullivau's face, and “his whule manver brightencd, Ho had beon assured by Lis counvel, If the Jury fallcd to agr bo admitted to bull, aud that the Amu othier trial wus remote, If 18 existed af of the jurynien shook hands with Liw, sud the foreman sald to him, 1 TRIED UAKD POR AN AGREEMENT, but it was no use, Istuck out for Lunglug or ac- uitting you.”™ *‘That was righe,” lllffllllfld Suls livan, *Jlo wanted 0 comprowlee,’ contluued 1n tho peni. tontiary, but be wouldn't a *That was rlght, tcg;lul Sulllvag, The **ho" referred to was I, J, Berry, lnqulry was mado as to HOW Til# JURY 8TOOD. They were loth to tell at Arwt, but fnally admlitted that oleven wera for acouittal and uno for coavle- “in th tlon, They took only onc ballot, and that was soun after feaving the conrt-room Tnerday even- ing. 'The questlon was simply **guilty “or not waiity, " neilhor marder nor mnslanehiee hring mentioned. The vote stood fThose whao deposited ** or and 10 apainat, hallots are undees rtood to e The Intter, howe inn whort ‘time, Berry alo ginal convictionr, He'did nol " waa wholly _eniitles, and desiced mansfanclter, hut the othera would not listen to it They were very anzey at him, and, it 1% raid, insalted” and abused iy, And wentna far geto threaten ta throw him out of the window if he did not change his views, Tle fa the *one Jnror, " who, Foreinan Mathawa sald Wedneeday, when the *nr: came {nto court for instructions regarding tha aw of kelfdefenre, wanted to know whether the defundant was the jidzo na to,whn he ws in dun- #erwhen he shot ftanford, There werenll eorta of rtories tolg ahout him, but no: It was sal { he and ¢! o compromise on % of them were State's Attorney had asa friend of the de- ther. that iy customers were Metho- ind :P sta, onrd i e did not give a verdict azninst Sallbvan he conld not Jetout any more horsers amd carriages. Mr. ) iiee ever have ini hnd any busfuces with Herry ox Do pudd him rome money for a earrfare broken in rullrm‘fli‘ accident. Mr. Hanford ducs not. know him. _1le has customners who ure Infidels, and Catholics, and Presbyterians, and his teams wonld not remutn fdle whichever way ho voted, e fa a positive man, and clingss ta Dis opinfons with the tenacity of n Ball-dos e 1 Jonee, 8 member of ole Club,* who knows him well 116 hat the reputation of bein: v ally an of-ox, and he will always tal opporitewide, If a man rald n lame horse wa latic, Serry Wwould dony It. ™ Theru 14 no dieputing hud TIIE: DEPESSE WRAE BADLY SOLD when they accepted him. —O'Tiricn thought he was an Irlshuian und a Catholic, wherean ho ix n New Englunder, anl belunzs to the Free- W Baptist Chureh, When O'Brien first reached Chicagy, pese 8 ngo, Berey called an him_for Jeial ad- t I8, and paid O'Brien $ I rded him ow 8 fellow-country- When he uppeared an a iurur. he was i) Drien ‘eald, '*W wan. anly n few questions, and 0" 5 take him, " without ‘cansnltine his associates or Sulllyan, which hie did In evers uther Instance. M. Hecd was urpeiscd ot thin, knowing Berry, and snappeit him up as o trout does o Ay, renurke Ingat e thme, **They will be foeled about hiwm: he i u good man and o respectable man,” And so it tarned out. When he repurated from the jurors who gathercd aroutud sSullivan, he wan “*congeatulated® by several, - who ' prasped bim uy the band. As 'he, npproached n ronp of Iadiee, felende of Mre. Sullivan, seated neue the Hght slde encrance to the roowm, oue of themasld to be n M, ~— nrose—one who hail been n witness for the defense—aud, shaking her 15t {n his face, exclatmed *CYOU ARK A SCOUNDIEL, an infamons scoundrel: why wonld yuu not agren with the rest?” Mr, Berry” lookea st herin iild wurprire snd possed out Without o word. When he ot down #tairs, reveral followed hin to the Cleek's oifice, and there was ominots whisperinis In regard to M. "I'he mob cursed bim, and there wak sume talk of Iynching him. ‘They hssed him, and ono sajd, ** Damn you, [ wish your neck wad broken. You ought 6 bo' huny, yuu scoundrel, ™ After hie receivod hix certificape he went out on the widowalk, and o wcore o more of people hissed at him. e walked quictly to the hug.y of u friend and got In. Taking off Bis hat, he rafid to the niob wubstantially: 1Thave done my duty—nothing more than niy oath required, and, thonih 1 do not like tuls niasiifestation of diskatisfaction, T dongt care a wnup of my finger for it. 1 think I did what wus right.” And then be wis driven sway, fols lowed by more hisvcs, Immed l\uc{r after discharging um?nry, Joldee MeAllister adjonrned the Court until 10 o'clock 1his morning, and the erowd pushed und strnged for the door, In ten minutes the room was atmust empty. A few Judies, and u few of the moie fdle and corfous remained to see i any further steps wure to be taken. THI JUDAK COMES BACK. 1t was understood thatin the event of a disagree- appllcation was to be made to bave Sullivan A 'on ball y Mr, Moran of hie connsel was preeent, However, and it would seew from Lis silence that [t hadl not been ngreed upon, At lnlf-past 10 Mr, O'Bricn camc 1n_and asked Mr. Moran what had been e, Mr. Moran told him. anil hie seemed vexed that the Court had not been nsked tafix (he bail of the accused and let hitm out, **The Judge,™ sald he, **must be sent for.” And » messenper wos finrted over om the South Shla to tell his Honor to return, In half an hour Judze Medllieter was on the bench againg and In s row in front of hinm were Mr. Swett, Mr, O'Drien, ond Mr. Morsn, The State's Attorney was not there, ITe had left bis oflice, and no one D been anked 10 notify him. Nothing vould e dotie i his sbseuce. Ro. nfter Mr, O'firlen had rtated to the Court that they desired to have Sulli- yan's bail fixed, and promised to lunt up Mr. Tteed, the Conrt rescinded the order sdjourning untél the marning and set 2 o'clock for Ledring the spplication, : BAILED OUT. ANOTUER LIVELY SCSSION. ‘The doots of the Criminal Court room were thrown open slortly ufter 1 o'cdotk, and the Joungers who had patiently sat and watehed the cuse from the neeption of the trial, gradually camme tn and quietly resutned thelr seats. Thers was very little struggling for places of vantage. Tho gallery at elther end was not more than two-thirds full, while not to excced 200 people were congreguted on the mubn floor. About & dozen or filiteen ladics, divided into little gvoups, sust within the charmed circle devoted to members of the Bar and the representatives of the press. Sherifl Awnew, 1arvey Merril}, and three or fonr of the Court offivials, moved around, exchauging u word here and there with friends whom they eaw in the audicnee. Tom Barrett, the Clerk of the Court, eat fn his oflleinl chalr, quict ana solemn. About 2 o'clock State's Attorney Reed catne [n, accompanted by Mr. Van Arman, the nssovlate counsel for the prosecution. The two inclined thele heads clusely together, and fn- Quiged in an absorbing tete-a-tete for several minutes, in which they agreed upon thelr pro- gramme for the afternoon’s work, The sharp, elear-cut features of the State's Attorney Iooked sharper than usual, and it was quite npparent that agreat load was resting on him. His vs- socinte wus o trifle paler than usual, but be be- trayed ne nervousness whi ran and Swett wers ocenpied with several Je voluntes, mostly Wheeler's Criminal Practice the pogcs of which they rapdly scanncd and marked with little scrans of paver, fur futute reference, At 2:10 o'clock Judge MeAllister entered the court-room, and, with measured #tep, marched up to the judicial beneh, fmme- dlately upder the canoby surmounted by the eflizy of Justleo with her evenly-balanced seales. ‘Fhe curtaln covering the window fmmediatel behind the Judge's seat was thrown back, ul- luwing the entriice of a Nood of seltow light, i winch nothing of the Judee's fave could be seen exeept §18 nlmost eireilar contonr, What- vver emotions the wearer of the erinine was la- boring under could not be detected, The strong light vefled his features from the most penc- trating eye, und to ull the spectators he seemend to be a statue from whose fuce aud features all expresslon had heen eliminated, tier the Judge had taken his seat the buzz of couversation, which hud been golug on for nearly an hour, stopped with the suddeuness of o flush of lghtuing, and the sllence became palnful, The audicnce looked ut the luwyers, at the Court, and at each other, wondering what would be done. Presently n vole wis heard 1o the passwre-way leading tv oue of tho Jurs-roomsy all eves followed ™ the direction whenee was lieard the souml of approaching footsteps. In u moment the prisoner, uttended by W. W, O'Bricn, ane of his counsel, entered within the full view of the wudienee. Ho wos less pale than usual; Iis eye was brighier, wind though his demeanor was quict and npressive, it wis evident that e expected good nows, anl & temporary release from thu conflnement in which he hiad Leen pluced on that August evenlug when he sent the eoul of Fruncis Hunford ununnounced ta the bar of God. Bullivan took hils acat, o liltle in front of the reporters' table, facing tho Court, Almoat pimultancous with his appearance, Pernane do Jones, Louls W, Redwond Prindiville, Dro Tiver, anil G ¢ Taylor entered the room. — After theso gentlemen bad talien seats, sud qulet was Testored, & SR, BWETT urose and addreased the Conrt, Mr. Swfll—llhr it please the Conrt, the trial which hus just cloded ‘haviag resulied in no vers dict, or o mistrial, the prisoner deslres to mulks application o your ‘Hlunor for ball, Uhe practice upon this aquestion s 0 well settled and ‘uniforu in this Ktate, of viving Lail, following « mistria1 upon an_judictent ot (hin character, that I feel that 1 need only muke tho application, 8o far as L know, 1 huve uever known It to bo refused, and understund thut whero s jury bave disagreod it follows us u master uf_courso, Mr. Van Arman—I do not know; if yonr Ijonor please, &3 1 am ablo to asment or dissent fram what the coungel says, I have not had practice lmull;ih is state lu cascs of indictment for marder to wsy whetler any such braclico hus oblajned or mot. I lLave wothing to gulde mo in determining whethor o mau shonid be balled or not, excepy tha Constltution und the luws of tho Suie, snd thuse provide, without Folng tuto detall—in substance, that whorover tha Court {s salwiicd that, although the Indicynent in for murder, the olfendo Is soins lower degron of homicldo, 1f anything, then the Court should bail the prisoner; whiero tho Court, elther upon the de- velopinonts upun the trisl in open couri. such as we have had, ar In lur other way recognized by law, ia Informed to his aatiefaction, where the indictment Is for murder, tlat, in reality, the of- fense in of a lower eade’ than murder, or that the defendant Iy ;{mny of nothing. then § percelve the privoneeshould be batled out, Now, In this case your Hanor han latened to quite o 'lengthy trial, and i Ita courae weyiad a differenco of opinion as appeared nunt only batween couneel on this rido nnd on the part of the dofenao (for that 18 very common), but so radical und wide a difference be- tween th views evidently entestalned by the Conrt and the cannvel for the” beosccution, that we feel greatly emuvarrassed in what manner to addrexs yuur Honor upon the subject s and all 1 have to ray L this mage of the pruccedinga 1w (su far as [ am eoncerned) 1 can hardly wupposs 1t possible that Joue Honor could iave pasned_theach thia telal Istening to the toathinony an well us the arzuments on the rerpective sides, without having arrived at & concluaion, and o definfte_coneluxion, with re erence to It And it your Honor has alrendy d termined this question that bail stiall be granted, it \Lxl«;.nm be u Jistle worse thau Idle for us to under- iko TO WASTE TINE indlecuering it. And 1 Lave no disposition, if your Honor please, to cgnaume your 1iunor's time g my uwn, truitlesslyor Wy, A1 will say, therefore, atthin stageaf the procecdings fe, “if . your Honor's mind (s unnettlcd pon this aabject, and your ilonor desires or even ls willing to_ listen 1o un argument #pon the queation whether this 1 a cane of inurder or of xome fower degree of homle cie, we are prepared to vo into it and discuss It, Itut swe do not deslre to do so it your llunur bas already determined the matter, My, Swett—-I wonld etate that if your fonor woulll prefer Lo hearargument upon this question, that we lave no ubjections, We nuderstand that ball wuder the pructice comes as u matler of cul‘llt i In— Nr. tha {Vun Arman—As a matter of course? wett—Yex., 1know of no decirlons In this 8 to my mind now; end dge 1% concerned, I can “The clause in the Con+ #titution upon which it is based s Sec, 7of Art- 2 of the Conntltution of 1870, which Is Lut o continuatlon uf the provielon which has exlsted in thia State rince the Constitution of 18182 All personeshall be batiable by susmiclent suretfos, exceyt for capltal oifenses, where the prout fe evident OF thiE Presnpeion Kreac, Now those expressions **where the proof Is evl- dentor the presumption great ¥ have, a8 § under- stand [t, received o judiciul conetruction, Waere s sty iy indicted for miurder prima tucke, lie 18 not hailable. T'hie courts hold that the presentation by u Girand Jury [s upon proof which s **evident, ™ and upon the indictent that tue ** presumption #0 far a6 personal know! unly speak from practice, Isgreat, " and peama f a not baflable. Vet 1L 1y not unfrequently & inan {s indicted for murderand th ugbicr, or belteve counsel, Lunt 03 wrlt of babeas corpus, ad the Court gatea the facts; und if the ~ Conrt thut the offenee 44 really that of mansauehter, then he will be oafled pefore tetul, BuLif there is u trial, apd the jury fail to find the “defendant guilty, then, as L under- stand, the party ls ENTITLED TO BAIL hecutsy there s been o failure on the part of the proscenition to make out s cuse of murder. 1 do not say that that 16 <0 plain_that there may not be exceptions, | would aleu read to your Huior nuw from the opinfon of Chief-Justice’ Speucer in the cure aguluat Guodwin, tret of Wheeler's criminul cuses: The lawsiof esery free Government estimate pers AUl Jiberty w4 of thie must pa d aracier, and it 1ot {u ber 3 folated o whrl rial.But 1 Cages Where Hhere are Strolg and withoush (e pature ahd Kind of Bwaits thuse Wit UliL e legally e alter thie turpliiric of 1o oy the culislder: '§o LTS Dati would be 5 pecantary niictiui, then badl (oF nor: L e wilvdnt of tie probable’ Loe #OSWOTs eyery purgose, “I¢ the punielnient b deadior corjurml it Driraltient, & concluliziess O KUilL Wolld Drovanly faduce & Dbt wud eViston Of the UnINAIENL, Rl BAIILGK L0 holl, LueTcivre, TEARd 1oss be had 1o The Drovable gullt of the furly wnd the nature ol tha pun- whient Genianded. 16 Sppesns 10 me Tt tie iacs cfore me, e cunclusiun 18 iy Ik quite dountful whethier the prisonel SR $E RiTLs UITETCRD WHEtier e a1 T i i lend el taborious tris] the Jury have Do i aole fo 0 What proportion of tiem were £ eouviet. v (OF wCqUITHER Lus Dol becn showh, No Iuieren Lo ArAWiE [ruim the fact that the foreniun pronounced 83 erofch hut was dissenied §Tom by she {hira Juror: thaail the other Jururs wen: couvisting aud 16 may weil_be (At n DAFe 1afority of the Jury sgrved 1o Lo venlict na amsuined by the Toremail, f perecive thal all WG JUFOTa VW Lue cise asof & uillikaled churacter by $helr recomtmendation of the prieoner 10 uercy. MIUAL presuiie that [ ‘atablished Loa ot ater Intu for if the the were fmpardal, snd thot their nnal agreiueit procecurd frum the cousclen- tous differcnce - of opiuon s i ¢ Drisoucr's guits and 1 sm, Sheretare, Bound o et clude LUAt Tue bHAODET 1AY be Inuceht uf the olferse, wnd L1 #0Ch 8 cave, 031 understand tie 1aw, li titied 10 b bafied If ne can gise (¢ i agount of suidelent mhAlity, ailurding s fessonanle expectation Trom thie g nulii HFeLtuFe of tie recognizauce tiat L will wipiear auu stund srial, 0w 1 dld not suy'suything in order to press this quention, If the Court would liko to Lesr further arcument, 1 o perfectly willing 1hat it be set down for hear! fectly witliug that there ruouldt he the utmoss dellberation. But fevling as we do that the prisoner 1o of right uow entitied to baal, we would H%e 1o haye the questlon deters mined reasonably soon. We are purfectly wiil- inz, it your “lluner would like, that the argument be set down forsome future day, und we wiil mutuslly exumine tho cases und comu and present them. t Alr, Jieed—Now, If tho Conrt please, I submit that, after what' vecarred in Court this morniug, thut this is undue, INDECENT, AND RXTHAONDINARY HASTL, It chnnot be denied but tiat your Honur sdjouraed this Court until to-morrow {Friday) morning at 10 o'clock, and that we all dispersed and left. #tarted on my wny home sick and worn out, and went into the Falmer Houre to see a friend, and there 1 met Mr, Moran, onu of the counsel, and he eaid to me then that he wus requested to to be here this sfternoon at 1said 1o him, **There 18 uo court ut 2 o'cloek, it adjourned until to-morrow worning, And e then announced to me that your Honor liad Tieen pursued and brought buck—requented to come bick—ond had revoked and chunged the order, With what diligence 1 possersed, |hnstled around und found Col, Van Arian, sud requested him to cume here, Now, & decision by your Hooor that s defendant w entitled to ball, Is whats It laa declalun that the proof ‘s not evident ar ihe presumption great.* 1t s o dectaion of the case, Phis case, of course, must be pubinltted 1o another jury, antl & decision by your Honor that he cnn bo ndmitted to bail is 2 decisfon—is a statement that the proof **19 not evident and the presump- tion {8 not great* in the care. As ny umeociate s sakil, unlees your Notor dls 10 u condie h can b changed by this udmisslon—— “llri‘\' lu Armsnu bero whispered somviling to My, jteed, » ‘The Miate's Attorney continued: We want to know whether the miud of the Judge 1s o radieally rade up that it cannot he changed iy any diwcuye mot, My nssoclate and wyeell feel thut your Honur ought not o admit thls man to bail; untt i your Honor's mind {s In a condition that it may be changed, 1 submit that we desire 1o be heard, hecause we represent the Fcoplu nnd thele interests, Lnt I€ your Honor™ mivd is_firnly and decidedly mudo uply We can only stand by aud pro- test against his being adiitted 1o ball, Mr. Swett—=WHI the gentleman sllow mo to aek Bl e 1t would suit’ bl 1o exumine thia quese tonr Mr, Jeed—We want to know from the Jndge \v;nc\hcr tis mind 18 radically made apon tho quee- tlon, Phe Court—1 think, If this waa an ordinary case, without nny - 2oun 1y | < OUTSIDE CLAMOR and excltement, there would be 1o objection to ad- mitting to bail. It 1v the ordinary practice, and hios been done hundreds of thnes, Mr. Reed—I deslro to then, 1 cannot anewer for thut. | cun ce 1 linve had the man- agement of ey Which hiua been con- tinuously o uch o case as this, and such elréumstances, has never arisen (n this coun- ty, so that 1 don't kuow auything ubout tie prac- tige. "I'he Conrt—1 know of just such casca as this, Mr. Reed—In this caunty "I Court—There Lave beenno just such caresas this, but there hinve beon cases whero fu o trial for murder the jury failed to ugres, and the defondant wan then adinitted to ball, Mr. Heed-—** And then admitted to bail.” Inthis county, since 1802 The Court—Y cx 7, Jeed—1 bflf ‘aur 1Honor to suggest tome the case since 1802, g to Le referred 1o the case, 1 may have slept for wuntha of years, but 1 do uot Temember auy such case, “I'he Court—1 pucsy I can hunt up some. Sir, Heod=Thore has nover leet iy to my knowledge siuce 1803, That issll | laveto Sr, Swett—1 know, without uny doubt, that ruch was Judge Daviy' practice, 1le was upon the liench In the Eighth Judicial Cireuit from 1830 to 1802, and his iuvariable practico wos thie: It a i were fndicted for murder, and taken bofure It upon hubead corpus, he did not release hin upon Dall if the evidence shuwed that there proba- y wight be a conviction of murder: but if npon wn Indictmont fur murder the Jury failed to ag then e held, as u matter of conrse, thy party w entitled 0 bull, und 1 um clear I the Kliuwledze tunt that practice wus substuntially univereal while he waw apon the Bench bn that Ciecult. Les yond that, whllu 1 hiuve known of cases oulsldo of tio State, 1 buve no jntimate knowledge of the practice. Mr, Von Arman—I do not recozulze any sach rule; 1 never Leard of such s rule. [ have tried somo murder cases in my day—quite a number of them, on one sidu of the ather, aud if there v such a zule up to this hour 1 haye remaived i the most profounit ignurauce of it, “The Courl tiero is o fixed roleabout 14 every- thing depends upun the Constitution, Ar, Vou Armun—I recognize his sa the rule of lawr on that sublect platuly indicated i e Con- atitotion, and that fail o rule | know auything about; and that b4, that the Coustitution bue vewte: in the presidingJudgo the power aud rosponsibility In cach cany where hu s applied to, to sllow bail or reject ity according to hils convictlon as 1o the charucter of thy olfeuso, * 1 kiow of 1o other ruly on the subject whatever, except that luld dowa tu the Conntitution. The Cuurt—That {s the true rulo, of course. Mr. Vun Arman—It matters not whether an fne dictment has been found. An fudlctuent for nure der bs w0 bar 10 tho adwission of thy defeudant to PRICE FIVE CENTS, . bail, 1f he can s !nl'y/'h- ourt that the offense 0 he 18 charged with cony 2 1s of a lower ordos than murder, ke lsasf . & Entitled to be bailer foro trial i nfteriy 14 he in no more enr n“(:;dr ;:-, hml'n[mr i & en nnfl:e mu\lnnd th ea to aareo a0 was beforo the tria), he Constitution & e MakRs[ F It your Honor pleas/ - uprllm(l«m. and | 2 “I'he Conrt—The ¢ that question ane] ATINCTION, srule Is universal In ftg 'hm;lo:helfi rulla im‘z that, + better able to determine £ ctora the teial, cede that the Court has & lt‘lw |:lfiil uu_r (hnlt:u?. ta cther the offenxe Is of the kind charged, © 1/3) & ircely concelve of there bo- ing one where . """ 1 wonld it and listen to the trinl af & case {htimghout, when It was properly and falrly tried. witiout forming an opinton on that subject, ~that 111 be ntteely impoxaible, — Kcherllmr the oflense In manslanghter of somne lowes eree, he Court—It fs not possible for me to do It with- ontwaking np my mind, r. Van Arman—I don't think any one conld. T cotild not. Therefore, 1 remarked to your Honoe . when there has heen doveloped uch a “wide diffors ence in the viewa of those who reprerent $he pros- ecutlon, and thoss on the other side, snd the Lonry The Conrt—Tt ix not very unnanal,—n differenca betweenthe Court and counsel. One side or tho ::v',:’i;""" the caxe generally hus to be beaten or ruted Mz, Van Arman—I da not object to that. Al T have to «ay Iy Just thls: that, bigh ne our respect 4 been Jor your Honor's deciafons for 1nuny ears, and carefully us we have examined the mib- ect (] peak for mykelf now), we have been utters 1§ dmable to tuke the view of thi case that your Hunor has ecen it 1o tahe, amd thereforo we stan liere now and tn<dst that thin case 15 one of most unquestioned, downright murder, without any mitigating circumstatces, The Conrt—1 difer with yon. You stand In the position of a partisan. ) oil are on one side of tha care. You are employed to prosecutu this cnam 1have no such feel @ to Jook tpon the canous itis developed by the testimo: 1 never knew these parties—any of them, cr saw elther of them until they came fute this tria, and 1 had 10 prepuseessions, clther 1 0no wuy oF the other, Mr. Van Arman/ i, S Immrnrpommu =5 form his judauqa & Mr. Swett—T admit, it your Honor please, that there ‘malht be wiich 2 thiing ns a trinl withont ro flecting uiy lax upon thw question we are considers e, “For instan if w man s tedicted for i er | the evidence had vd, and - the jury hegan L, and one of ¢ aryinen Il falien “down and died man_apoplect anid thoere hnd been o mise trial, why, the Conrt wonld not th as a inatter of courset, bafl the defendunt, becanae there had veena mixril, But, where thers hasheen a faly *ubmirslon of the question to the jury, under (ne #tructions that they mixnt find defendant =milty of either nurder or matwanzhter, «nd they hod tuile wd to find him gullty ot anytil 1 inslst that the LAILURE OF THS JURY tofind the defendant gulity I« an ofllelnl fact of which the Court will tuke coxmizance ay reflecting the character of e offense, 1 wish aleo to ray that T do tut desire 10 e anderstoud 13 wresshing thin question, or wanliy: te in regard to K. Tam perfoctly wilting, i¥ the Court shalldesive ity o meet the pentiemmen bese ut any futnre day and aruue thix guestion. Mr. Heed—Just s moment, and I will elose my wonth. 1 do not belivve that qaestion whether the jury nas wrreed or zreed makes any ditfterence {u the caxe. [ concede fully and completely that sour tlonor has o bt (6 cone Alder the question ahethier he should be admitied 1o bail gpon u simple motlon of uron hoveis- carpu; And your Tlonor 14 to (elerming it nisto the evldence, and can paume tie responsibility, Whether the Juey has narecil or Alaggreed makiea o dbierouce. 1 want to protesy against one rentark your onor has just made ¢y assuciate, I your ilonor tutends to upply 1t tomyself. Thie Court—1 applled it to bim, in this rase, tha prosecution has an partisan 1 respectfuily submit thint 4t e hy case, § have never had n word or thonght or an nnkind fueilng toward him. | knew hine ensualiv, —simply as a lmnlug fricud, ana could not have uny such feeling i my heatt, The Court—You do not understand mo. I do not mean you have been employed. You repre- sent o prejudiced, une-rided case. ['Fhe Court was undersiood to kay this, Lis words not belug very distincly heard. | d—1 deny that. T aurt—It i« the trath. Mr, fteed—I ray, u+ | expect to answer beforo my Maker, aUthe Just duy, where sou ure 10 ape I never id any swch feeling in uy . 1 bave sat - here for the lnst eight or nmime doyR to comduct the triul a8 best 1 coutd do Ity employed o sub- eerve the interents of This people, withiouta raglo feellng in iy heart that conlld be attributed to sy Buch biwe purpune of desire, “The Court—"1here 8 no need now of givinga bit of demngogery Lere, when I did not make any remnrk that calledd thnt our, Mr. Iteed—You suld we were partlsan, The Courl—_wald_you reprosented s one-slded case, Do you dony it? Mr, lteed—I do qeny it. Was the case putina purtisan manaer to the jury? The Couri—You tried to'exelnde all the essential purts of the case of the other «de with the ntmost of your ability. Idonot want auy chivalric fecls Ix':g ufi'z up here, and 1 dou't want any cltpteup abont it, Mr. liced—I dislike to be charged with bolngn partinan, The Court—You repreeent o onc-sided case, Isu't that iUy Mr, Jteed faid somethlug that sounded liko **You cull it o, The Court—Wlth all your vicor. Mr, R ¢ ien’t partisunshilp, The Court hat Is Ly Mr. Swett—It lu one side, and we are the other, Mr. O'Brien—Light fsn't 'dackness, [Lunghter.] TUE DECISION, The Court—Tle Judse of & Court 18 freqnently pluced in positions where he hae toact, e canuot crcape the performance of his duty, und { know of 10 uther guide. 1 know very well there {8 storin of public excitément raised ognlnet me, 1t I8 bee ginning to buret forth, and it will continoe antil the fever—a rezulur Chieago fever to which it 19 subject occarinnully—pixees uver. nnd dies out ac- cording to the laws of nature. Now, then, i it 8 suppored thnt nnybody Js goinz to be governed the performnnre “of a jndiciol doty by that ex- cliement, by that outslde pressure, they nust ook to sume other man besldes me, for [ an not the man to do it, 1 have my mind honestly, care- lull{‘ formed and mado up 1 this cuse d tezard to the question whether this defendant 4 £ullty . of marder under the facis of this case, oand T+ cotild not holp aving that opinlon farmed. 1t In formed from the wirong evidenco udduced bero and discussed in avery nepect of it, and 1t 18 just simply this: Here in a mon' brought Into a posltlon withont any fanlt of his own, until e gets fnto a brawl, which muy bo u tmera outhurst of passlon, and cmounts ta bt very Mitle, He i then selzed by & strong man and ekl rigurousty tight, and while'he {8 1i that position - o deceased, according to the tetsimony In this case, beyond oy perndventure, came up and wan tonly strick hia wife iu the fave. Now, thew, une der the deflnltionof the law, under the common law, that fs a4 inuch o pravocations a legul pruvo- cation, as though he had been struck bluself, The former brawl hiad cuded. 1t was terminated, g fur ux the defendant was concerned, ho was unabla to renew t, and he Lud no o disposition to repew t, &0 fur o4 the tedimony wlhows, While he js In that pusition this blow waa strack, which has u Stendency nuturally fo throw him Into o heat of passiou; and witl anybody tell mo that when a man &ills another in such 8" heat of pase taking all the incidents in thls case an beardig upon the -condition_of hin mind and as aifecting his mind, that he «hall bo judged gullty of murdor? It la contrary to the cominon law; it i contrary tothe statutes of this State, [Applauso, ] One moment, now, This ls no place for applanee a4 1 have alrendy stated. 1t isno good to repeat it. Now, there has been a teinl “here that has lasted several days, where this evidence haa been addnced, #s 1 eald before, and thoronghly discussed, and the ury have disagreed, 1 touk palns to consuit tho fore man after the disagrecment of the Ju nd he ine formed me that eloven of these jarors for ac- 'x{“"ul and the twellil one was for wanslaughtor, Now, under thoss circumstances, with that opine fon I have thus formed und miade, 1 have the cont age ta vxprees it 1T go not care who suys to the contrary, Itis m{ vpinton, and I am the Judge of thy Colirt upun this occasion, and W ia my duty to dct_aceording to that “contletion, lat the conre- guences to nia personally be what they muy ¢ und 7 shall a0 uct, [ know that there will be public oxcltement; that there has Leen a disposition tu try cabed out of court, —1o furce couclusions upon wen. As | wus talking to o luwyer to-duy of cons shiterable cminonce, Lo #uld thoi e never befors, fn all bis knowledge of this cuse had heard the fu- le wae cme formatlon that the accused, at the thuo this thin: took pl; e wiriklug of his wife, —~wos bouni and Leld ekt by another ma. Ho never knew that fuct, It iwan lwportnat fuct I this cave, 1¢ bears upon the vexcitement. And w0 b, I#, —people ontslds caunot kaow the fucts “us the Court knows them,— us thuy sre shown in u court of Justice. whatever counsel muy do in thelr dlsagreotncut with me In startiug up expression, and starting up HUANDALOUS ARTICLES AGAINST ME, to be wut i1 Lo uswapapers, I say hiore that [ care not fur them. God knows my heart, and 1 perform my duty,hero sol nnl{ and drmly, willing 10 ko 140 consequences, and wait for the sobor, socund the people. {Applavse sud bilsses, ] Mr. Van Armau—Counsel have stirred up acan- dalous wrticlesy Does your llonor refer toany person present? “hu Court—It {s the manner in which this cas has been {ricd—an artful way of showing disre: spect for she Court, aml an artful way of muskiug 1 nl» pear that wy rullngs were ull one-slded, by niakiuyg the samy_objestions over sud ovor ditaily dozens of tmes, That fa tho way it haa beendoue, Mr, Van Aran—We Lhought all of your Honur's rulings weru out of the way, wald s0 frankly. Tiio Court—You vald 80, but when 1 w0 ruled, you would renow the objcctionover snd ovor ageiu. 18 was an uuusual thing, Mr. Vau Armao—We dld; 1 concedo that. -And we did it, o the hopo that your Lonor would see o guestion dulervutly, Bus a3 for gettlugup -