Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, June 11, 1875, Page 1

' e VOLUME 28. T —— RS @ITR"“NTEW?"@’R"‘WK PLAN O BE'ADOPRTHD. NUTTING’S PLATFORM. O Dectaration of Tndependencs, WHEREAS, The public are charged BIG PROFITS for Men’'s, <Youth’s, Boys’, and Children’s Clothing and Furnishing Goods, wo this day intugurate our Now York Flan for Chicago, tho corner stono of which wo lay, and take tho Front Position for Low Prices in the future. Plank RESOLVED, No. 1. WIE sssume an INDEPENNDENT STAND and shall maintain it to the END, withdrawing from the ranks of IIIGIL PRIOES, Our future is “ SLAUGHTER," t0 gain & businoas unrivalod in the WEST)| a8 we mow havo in tho HAST. RESOLVED, lbe OLINOHIN lof the Iargest in spond. Plank RESOLVED, Plank No. 2. THAT wa shall name priges in every department that will} 'G ARGUMENTS of thomeslves, and a visit to our stora, ono tho Wast, will well zepay the man or boy who has a dollar to| No. 8. D our stook, although now amounting to over One; THA ‘undred and Fifty Thousand Dollars, shall be daily increased to moot the do-| imand causod by be employed. Plank RESOLVED, thls great roduction, and an additional force of salosmen wil No. 4. HAT wonderful bargains and astonishing sales are con-| T stantly being adverttsod ; theroforo ture, in auch o soll goods at LO wo_ ahall of I way that Sreryene will be convi;ruyod of our_determination to| V&Eu PRICHS than over bofore namod in Chi out this, our New Dopar- lcago. .J. NUTTING, ¢. 0. D. CLOTHIER, 184 & 186 ST ATE-ST., OPPOSITE THE PALMER HOUSE. BASE BALL. BOSTONS vS. CHEHICAGOS, BATURDAY, JUNE 12, MONDAY, JUNE 14. Tiokete to Grand Stand sold for Wednos- day's postponed game will be redoomed, ex- ehianzod, or racolved at gate Monday, but ‘willnot admis holders to tsev%:Otlggw Ramo. JAME! v r C. B. B. A, . HOTEL, THE COSMOPOLITAN Hotel and Restaurant, 164 East Madison-st., near IaSalls, Bermarly the D!Wmllm:fl:;lnt bas pamediinto tire THIEBEN & ZUOCKERMANN. T bhouse 1 satlrely m&'flfi;fl the pazkrs aid beds Se0d Reems, (ood Accommodation ut frem &0 canta to $1.00. Meals st (he oid Prpular Prioes._Oall and oxam! e, LAKE NAVIGATION, GOODRICI NTEAMERS. Por Bactne, Miusukes, and West Blore ports, adon boet st e tarday A S T O Tom woral! Joseph sad Wonvoa Hasbor, Wil iades i, m‘ naba, Negaunes, Sonenes Blogedaya s Totirad For Graen Hay, Menomi a7 i QUERHOLD GOODR: . e CHEAPEST IN CHICAGO! . 'We can farutsh Dealors and Housekoopers at private eals 40 ver cent less than wholesale prices, § qREGULAR AUCTION BALL TO-MORROW, BaT- ’ £ & 00, Auots B DN et Ao GULDAY, Juns i3, REAL ESTAT For Sale--A Bargain. The Satory and b marble front houss N Tt et e, : Inndid locatf o LIL & . O, elies veey”law. AV AL Hoam 13 REMOVALS. B anmnna s R VAN o e WE HAVK REMOVED T0 63 AND 05 WASHINGTON-ST,, (The 014 Opers Hoase Block), EHADLARY BROS. & JO., BOOKHRELLERB AND BTATIONERS, COLLECTION AGENOY. DIC. Whes o debtor neglucta tu sattla s clalm when due i 18 e o S eton 12 bivecariod wil roeties ot 15" aftorts. Olaisms [o our Labds are 0% blgeoa- holsd, it umersa. " BARGAINS, dn Carpe k ¥ et bt ot 1At Aneu«: ‘lo-Morrow, Baturday, June 12, Wl\l;n:l‘r’ml‘ S e ” et 5 5 » s TO RENT, OFFICES TO RENT IN THE TRIBUNE BUTLDING. WILLIAM C. DOW, ROOM 10. STORE FOR RENT In the new Commission Market, No, 204 Jacknon.at. Apply 13 Chamber of Commaerco. OCEAN NAVIGATION. National Line of Steamships, NEW YORK TO QUELNSTOWN AND LIVERPOOL, 2 tons. Saturday, 28th May, atll a. 1. tarday, bih Jund, at 3 o, i, turday, 32t Juno, st (3 noou. aturday, 190 Juns, at3p. w, dtine 9, at8p. m. S Tiiovdng, dute 10, 1 b 1 riger “Rotaratickete sl rodcon tare ® tcketa from Liverpool at tha w worner Ol herinan ThowsoD, Cheams. ONLY DIRECT LINE TO FRANCE, , LARSQ! Tuandolph st (Opposiia How "Flin General T bomean Now York aad Hasraoopeny's dail Blasisehipe PrELEIRE, Daw une 12 FIANGE: Weadoliar: or" b VIGLK DI AR, Lashoss 5. iy o PHICK OF PASSAGE IN cludiiig wine) s Fies cabln, 4 boson, €5; (hirl 450 iaiien ok ucod raiow, Hisorags s it ? 2 iidstions, and "inciudiog i neosmsarios. wiitivus exirs OO EOROK MAUKIENZIE, Agsot, 8 Brosdmay, N.¥. WATOHES, JEWELRY, & N MATSON& GO, JEWELERS, Offer tho largest ard flnest agaort- mont of Watchos, Diamonds, Silver- Ware, Jowolry, Bronges, Platod ‘Warg, and beautiful Fancy Goods in tho Wost. Keop only tho bost depsartment, and sel low prices. State and Monroe-sts., OPPOSITE PALMER LOUSE, oods in evory at uniformly CLOTHING. NDUCEMENTS ETRARTIIARY 70 THOSE WISHING TO PURCHASE Clothing AND M FURNISHING GOODS. Our stock, which is vory complote in every dgpnrtmont,hus boon mark- ed “WAY DOWN,” in order to losson stock bofore taking inventory July 1. Call and exaemine our goods sand prices. PUTNAM ONE-PRICE CLOTHING HOUSE, 131 & 133 Clark-st., And 117 Madison-st. FINANCIAL. Stocks at the Naw York Stock FAI A AR SRS Privileges Negotiated at ana {0 two por cent from markat on mem. borof tho New York Exchanga or reapausihin parrice, Lacgo sums invo houn realized the past ® days. L'at or call costa on 100 shares $106.25. eneh, 00 Turthar riek, whily many thons profit may bo ealiod. Advicesnd (ulanatio Pamrilot, cantainti” valuable, siasistical informatin sad stowlog how Wall-st. operations are eonductod, sont Free To anyaddrom, Orders sollciled by mail o wire and prompily exccuied bs us, Address TUMBRIDGE & CO., Laskers and Brokers, No, 3 Wallst, Now York, Th First National Gold Bark OF SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA, PAID UP CAPITAL,........82,000,000 GOLD. Pxchar bt and Fxchange boght an Straddl daya withinol Prealdent..... GEO. F. HOOPER. Yico Prealdent, SAMUEL 1HORT. Cusbier ... L. Co WOOLWORTIE. CORTME:! DENTS. LONDON......BARING BROTHLERS & 00, CHARTERED MKRCANTILE BANK * INDIA, LONDON, AND OUINA, PARIS., {OTTINGUKR & CO. DUBIJN ......PROVINCIAL BANK O IRELAND, HAMBUKG, .. 1SS, NKWAMAN & 00, NEW YORK, .DUNGAN, 8HIIEMAN £ 00, BOSTON HLACKSTONE NATIONAL BANK. OHIIOAG! FIRST NATIONAL BANK. tandsd to and prompi roturns made at the Collactions Somest inarkol ratos of Exchaurs. §50, $100, $500, $1,000 Invasted in Stock Privileges in Wall-at., Loa many thousande @f dullnrs prodi, U Boosl splanatory clroulary, containlog detailed Tuon| d quotation prices of sll stocks deall in TW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE, s ‘”“'I.Lffif‘l{l&fi)’fi“n‘i‘kl"u':‘x‘a "7'&‘&. e s Opp. N. Y. Btock Kzchange. 13 Wall-st,, No Yo MONEY TO LOAN On property in Chicago and vioinity. Large suma 0 por cent. MHBAD & COE. £ Western Steamship Line, Yoik nd) direot. iablu Passago, $10; Faterinodiate, §45 Jragutaion tickota Applyat ey lako Shora & M, . (KO, MoDO CHICATD ACADENY OF DESTEN ART SCHOOLS, DMichigan-av,, corner of Van Nuren-st, Opon continuously, !drawing, Paintlog, Soulpturs, and Areblteoturs, undsr profossional fnstruction and guldanoo of B, FELI'K RKUAMKY, J. ROY ROB. m‘. DN, J, F. G )g“i(m“' Yrealdont L. W, YOLK, an \ articatars apply for clroulare, 8t. Moary’s Hall, FARIBAULT, MININ. . Ror, 16 11 W . 1., Tactar., PR A Ry o anced Toachars, L var whl vonuy THUIBDAY, B T far i (octor. o iy New England INormu! Musieal Justitute, . (R BRI . 1, A Hon-side Muttane Bt a1y o A% ot iroitars addrosa ) . TOUILI ki Aosle okl Boston., 20E_ HILL SE ° an.‘.’,grou.n.-flu. Dtebosy dontrt w %! . & Ahe-Hudseds ures ol Mudy cowprebened: A0 B s el 185 LnSallo-ot. CHICAGO MORTGAGE LOANS, At cureont ratus_of Intorst, JOSIAF ¥H.REED, 30 Nassaust,, New York, ropresonted by N F. AVERY & CO. ‘uicuyn. Firsteclans fucllitles nesutiutio o Chicago Ciiy l‘{.nfi\vny Co, Stock, West Division Railway Co. Stocle, Chamber of Commerco Stock, LLOYD ¢ 0 QAGE, Forsalibr Wasbingtonat, e FARDS CHANGES, DISSOLUTION. Thx firm of J. Houry & Jacob Woll bas this dar boen dissolved by wutusl colavat, J. HENRY. WEIL, Ohleago, Juna |, 1876. JACUE WeIL COPATRI'NIERSIIP, Tho undenlvnod bava this day forimed for tha purposs of buylug and sailiug lieal w414 1he luauing of woney, Yador tho tisw came ot Jacob Well and Gavige A, Beasorns. JACOI WRI Chicago, Juns]1, 1878, ! UEO. A :.{Vl:lma jold vut my laterest to the abuvo, firm, Vi SoHENTY whi laving Jully conmnad thow to iy Teivads, DISSOLUTION. Lating brl:;:fl lh'glllb Tusiasss, ab No. I Stale-st,, Ubi s o, 18 u dusclred by mutual cousent. AL socounts dus 1he'1at8 ria are so Do paid to Brak! Ji n i l';‘g'lg' | el 1, . M, W, g ae b Sl wil Ly Cendusbed bureaitar by Alte, M, W, l)s a8 Ne. Jfilflr’h 1, Wb MBA. ¥y W RLY, CHICAGO, FRIDAY, JUNE 11, ‘ho . BEECHER. The PlaintiPs Avenger Throwing Hot shot into the Enemy’s Camp, Mr, Beach on Beecher's Extravagant Btyle of Expression. ~ A “Horal Niagara,” * Section of the Day of Judgment,” Ete,, Only Mitd Samples. It Tilton Was a Blasphemer, Beecher Could Beat Him Blind. The Reason Frank Carpenter Was Not Called as a ‘Witness, Why Tilton Did Not BRevenge Himself in the Usual Bloody Fashion, Instances of Crimes Committed by Great aud Good Men, The Dofense Acoutod of Bpiriting Away Plaintiff’s Witnesscs, BEACH'S ADDRESS, Special Inepateh to The Clucago Tridune. NEW Yons, Juno 10.—Tho crowaiug, pusbing, and scrambling to got into tho court-room to-day wers even grostoer than yoterday, butthe su- dienco was 1o larger, simply becauso not another person could flnd sitting or standiog room in- side. - Thero waa tho same enthusiastic elemont in the nudiencs that bad manifeated its presence ou Weduesday, aud Mr, Beach was applauded not only upon his outrance to the court-room, but several timos while speaking, aud when the Court adjourncd in tho afternvon tho crosd of people who had assombled in the corri- dors clapped thelr lLands when the orator, accompauied by Mr. Tiiton, camo out, and cone tinuod to applaud bim until ho reached the street, Tho occupants of tho gallery appesarcd 1o b especially unruls, althongh applause and other demonatrations of feoling wero given in other parts of the room, and Judge Neilwou, after once sevorely rebuking those outbreaks, finally threatoued to adjourn tin Court unloss better ordor was kept. This threat appeared to havo some effect, sod thero was much less dio- order aftor it had been utternd, THE PIOMINENT ACTORS, Mr. Beeclier was prosoutanly during the morn- ing scasion. Ho lovkoed thoughbtful anu only oc- cantonslly glanced st Mr. Bench, somotimes emiling and sometimes wearing & look of in- eredulity, Mra, Boecher, from tho beginning of the addrenn, bas bocu ono of the most attentive listonern, Bho occaslounlly closes Lior lips tightly, and casts scornful glauces st the orator, and ab other tinos sho scoms to ba much amused at what she apposrs to consider the absurdity of #some of his stutcments. Mr. Tilton allows nothing fo attract his attention from the srgament, and Mr. Fullerton sits at the orator's slde ready with an occasional suggestion or roference. Mr, Moulton sits uear Mr. Tilton, appareutly a8 interestod & listonor as plaiutiff, . TIE STRYATN show no falling off or variation In the atiention with which thoy have listenod since the sum- ming up began, Tho foreman, Mr. Carpenter, doos not, Lowever, attend to Mr. Beach's words with tho gsmo obsorbod inlorest which showod in the eddress of Mir. Lvarts, This may be morely au inci- dental and unconscious chango in his damesnor, but i causes remnrk, aud thers are poreons amoug tho avditors who think bt ho s offended by tho remarks which Mr, Deach ad- drexsed to him at the opeuing of Lis spocch con- carning tho dofondant'a policy and resourees, At tho oponing of the morning scasion Judge Porter addressed tho Court fu roference to TUE ALLYOKD 1IMPUTATIONS OF MR, DIZACK in his opening spooch upon tho jury and counsel for defeudant. Mr. Beach roplied, disclatming any intontion of imputivg corruption to the jury or any member of it. Later in tho day tho orator assertod that it was in refer- ence o the procuring of wituesses aud othor machinery of the trial that his romarks about tho eyes, and arms, and gold posscssed by do- fondant's counsel wero applied. At this point occurred oue of the most atirring pussages in the day’s sddross. Roferring to tbe assertion that plaintiff had mot brought the servants in Mr, Tilton's family o witnesses, tho orator ex- claimod: **Servanta! We go to New Jersoy, bt we find A ‘tilton shead of un. Wo go to varioue placos where the eervanta acutterod from the Liouso can bo found, aud we find the 1ady zealots of Plymouth Church abead of us. ‘When gontlemen toll us that we do not produce thom, I tell them that they lave hid thow." These assortions, deliversd with all the power of elocution aud earncat force of msnner which Mr, Beach posuesses, wore rocoivod with a slight cutbreak of spplause, ‘There waa AnoTiEn ETIN among tho audltors whon tho orator announced that Lo did pot belleve that Mlr, Beochor had given his narrative undor the solomnity of tLat oath which tho jury might have supposed that he invoked, snd that he meant horeafterto maiu- tain this propoaition, TI COURSE OF THE SUMMING-UP followed the same Jino of argumout which the orntor began with on Weduosday, The states muouts aud argumonts of Judge Porler were o1+ sumined and opposed by counter-statpmonts and arguments, Tho plirases, ** paroxyewal kiss," “ithe brink of » moral Niagara,” ete, which Judge Porter said were unlike Mr, Boechor's wodo of expression, wero roviowod, and tho orator resd numerous extracts from defoudaut’s sormons and writing containiug ‘phrascs which he cousidered to bo slmilar, sud from which he argued (hat Mr, tsecchor might also have been tho author of those in question, The opeuwing srgumonts of Mr. Evarts were roplied to slo, Mr, Boach gave instances of wany cases of mine futers and othor wen, of supposed high charace ter, who had been guilty of dobauchery and crune. [T the Associated Prese.) ANOTIERCLUSIL, New Yorg, ‘June 10.—~The Brooklyn City Court room .this morniug wag the sceus of & crowd moro dense, if possiblo, than yestorday. Doepite tho lnumgunnuhunud byJudge Neilsou, when Mr, Boacl, who was early fu his arrival, onterod, ho was received with a storm of ap- plauee. ‘Tilton was present, but loochor and Lis wife woro abaent i JUDAR PULTER HAS A FEW WORDS, Portor atated that Evarts wass unavoldably absent, aa ho Lad to go ta Washington, and was {herefore deprived of hoaring tho remasks of Mr, Beach to<lay, but he would be pressnt to- morrew, Alwr & few remmks from Mr, Pertes, dls- olaiming any bitterneas in his attack on Tilton, and stating that he had not used the phraso attzibuted to him yestorday, * Down, down to bell, and say I sent thes there,” Mr, Bosch re- plied that he was sorry if ho had minanderstood bin toarned friend, but ho had Leard him may “Down, down,” to Tilton, and had paturally thought that he desired to consign Tilton to hell, snd indeed, said counwel, I thuuk so atill. [Laughter.] secher and his wifa enterod at this point and took their customary seats, THULY DEECHERIAN, 1'Beach then resumed his address to the jury. He sald an effort has boon mede to represent that the words imputed to Boecher by plaln- tif aud his withesses woro such 8a woro foreign Lo his ntyle, sod could not have been employsd by one so skilled in tho use of the Engliah language. Well, thore was no doubt that ail men accustomed Lo writing and public apeaking bad & tyle peculisr to them- selves, “Thus, if any of ihe jury should see a pamphlet coutaining Lo upeech of Mr. Evarts, with its titlo-page gone, ite internal ovidenco would bo sufticient to indicato its autliorship. s would sen if the expresyions iuputed to Beechor ‘wete such a8 to indicate another pateruity. For iustance, rounnel tor the defeuso had urged that the term "J)Arox)’umnl kiny ™ was an atsmdity, which could nover have como from the lips of Boechor, Thn word paroxysmal was a good ono, and wan kuovn to the law in conncetion with 1he subject of incanity, He had tha curiosity to oxamine the punhiliei writings of Buecher, and in & simgle serwon bad found tie word used ro. pentedty. Mr. Beach quoted numorous pasasges from thia ermon in which the word * paroxysm ™ and * paroxvamal ” wore used fu regard to re- Jientance, luve, and other mtrong ewmotions, Tliis camne proity near to & proxysinal kiss. o then considered tho expression, **a mora) Niagarn,” and the argu; t that 1t wan & picod of fulro thetorie whien her hed nover uned, any moro than he would have spokew of *wmoral hnystack.” Iie considered this to Lo & foreible aud proper phrasc to devcribo Buechor's positicn. _Livecher did stand on the brink of a ““moral Niagara,” from which only the Jury conld wavo lnm. It was n8 proper an expression ws Dr. Watta' « Gult of Dark Denpan.,” Alr, Beach then cited o upumoer of pasengey {mm Leosher's watings, o sbow bis fondooss ar EXTHAVAOA! and the Jiler takiug with v MHETCRICAL EXIRESSIONS, »nich b w: the havit of lich laugusye. Anot tieno wer Apotneumized pumphizss,” ** an oihical furraw," 1y corpee of an applo-pie,” “umbrell pockat ozean.” consciency, 1ou0 teaching, top of buppiuors,” * pulver irmav," * horso rapture,” *cunng volcanves with pills," wod mzny others, He did not queko thons by way of enticisiug Boecker's style, bt to show what his etvlo was. Such expressions wero naturul tothe man, and wero interepersed all through tho elu- quent addresxes which attricted lis erowds of liearers aud mado thew burat 110 aplauso even iu the Lomwe of God. Soras wo tho result of humor, which was promtuent stoug Beecher's oed gualitice, Tho exp ression of Deecher to 5 Manisan; thAt¥ho 3iovays 1w ssend hitn 88 & “xection of the doy of Judgment,” UAD DEEN KIDICCLED IY' THL COUNSLL FOR THY. DEFI2¥aEL, who sald that Deockor ¢3d not divide tho day of Judgment iuto soctiona, Well, when that ‘day camo, Lo thought wo should find out that it had »t Jeast two sections, [Langhter.] Mrs. Moul- o0 was conplaubly urgiog Mr, Jeecher to con- fenslou, was Loldiog before him the duy of doom 1o which his courss wny leadiug, aud Lo ox- preescd tho feeling which she xroaucoed upon bim io 8 munner natnrel to the man. Mr. Beach thou spoio of tho attempt to rep- resent ua biaspheanous the lestor wristen by Til- o0 10 i Wifo, in_which bio speculated upou the character which Chiist would huve uuifested 1n the position of marnage. Ho xawd thet there was 1o charnctor which Lad over given riso to ko snuch speculation ntd commentary an that of the Havior, and that this phiiasophical speculution on the part of Tiltou INVOLVED 3O SCOITEIN OR IRIEVERENCIE. Tilton spoke of Chnss aw 1 histosw, chiatucter, but Lo was #o regardet m coussg by beao asido from his eacrod eonracter. Beach quoted pasenges from Leacher's vorks and sermons, in which he upokc ot Christ us a bistorical charac- ter, auc ono open t0 speculation and investigas tion, 116 then urged that it ahowod s deptl of shought and relicious” Tuterest which was com- ntendable in Jilton, who was jmmerscd n the carea of businesy, snd turned to speculste upon ouch a subjoct without suy 1nwntion of irrover- euco or indelicacy of oxpression in the lettor which he wroto upou it to his wife. Mr. Beach roforred to tho love or reveranoo which all Lad for the Lord's Frayer, taught to the child at tho wothor's kieo. Ho then auoted au exprossion of Beechier in Teyard to it in which ho saig its_value was not lessened by the fact that whon Christ taught it 1ts sentiments were uot now. Thus Booc:bor HPOKE OF OUNIST A8 A PLAGIAUIST, snd as adopting for his 03vn uso whut lisd bofora Deen ropeated HNOUR meat. Mr. Beach cited othier passages from Deocher's works, as showiug his fatiiliar mode of treating Clrist’s 1ifo and attributs s, sud urgea tho jujus~ tice of soizivg upon Tutun's letters—not pro- cluimiog his theories up on the houwvton, but writtou in privato to his v 1fe—an au judication of utoral oblipsy. o t aen spoie of the posi- tion taken by Porter that & msn who could” uss wuch luuguage as Moultw @ had employed cune s Doscher, wan not o crodible. withoss spainst bun. Well, if tiyis wag 0, what wort of witnoss would Porter bo after such langusge as tio liad used in regard to the plaistifl, in regard to Beecher, nud ju regan 1 to women ? e noxt retorred ta TUE CHANGE OF TRI ZABONABLE COXDUCT on the part of Moulton, and raid that Lis rela- tious with Loochier werd. not chiauged by the sim- pla appomtment of the: Church Guinmittos, of which Moulton disappra sed, but by u-mr'jl Warg Tovchor's false aud cali imuious charge that tho long-tried sud self-#acrn tleiug friend was a binck- ler. This, after diowlion had boon sacriticing uwo, lun labor, Lis 1eputation, his morslity aven, w loocher's caus ', Baocher was a groar men, and his posilion, together with bis age, rendored it unjustitiable for auy younyg man to pay to hiv face that be wi s & hur sud villain § bug Monjton Was an 1NPUISiv O wa, a3 bo had shown alf along, nud he was eniarung under tho seusy of o groat wrong, Novor untll this chargo of blachimail way bronght sizamst bim did be use » dusrespectful word to Beos bor, TLY PIRTOL (HUNINESS, Mr. Boach referred to I'ortur's charge of cowe ardico agaivst Moulton, becauss ho curried a pintol to Huecher's house, sud sald shat Moul- ton, engagod, sy he was, m a busincss which took lum about tho docks und warchouses, aud uinony rude man, waa ju the habit of carrying & pistol for protestion in e3wo of noed, Tos whole wvidenco showed that ho nevor used tho weupou for the purpose of {ntindation, The coutwel noxt roferred ta the quostion why Curpentor had not boen calisd, and said it never had beon pretoudod by Morsis or auybody olso that Beechior biud confersed adultery to him in oxpress terma, Carpentor wa# hold to cons traddice Beecher in tho rebuttal, if tho Iattor de- nivd an inturview with lum, but tho state ot tho ovidence did 11.¢ rerlor it Tocossary, PONTLES ERITHETS, Mr. Beach saxd that in_ his profossionsl intore couras of thirty years wish Iorter ho had gatued o moss atfectionste raspect for him, and that o bad spokon iu kindnoss Woris of roprebonsion, which bix duty had compullod him to uttor in voforringz to tho miworlhy assaults of Portor upon pimintiff avd his witbesaes. Vililleation dul pot kill, and whou he bad eallod the stten- tion of thio Jury to the rauk injustice of Porterls opithiets, be hoped it would laat sham to retied with caro upon his arguieut, [Applauso in the pullertes. ""Iu Mr.lfivmv. in by extended argumout, had boen assigced what might be called tus hoavy pare_of tho work for the defense. With ths wonderful power of languago vossossed by that Tonticman. ho Liad endeavorod to cliange tho ro- fitions of tho partics in this caso. Tustoad of dafending Meechior, Lo had tried to place Tilton and Moulson anid Are, Moulton on the deteuso, and calted upou plainti’s counsel to cxvitpate them from the indictweut winet ha brought aguinst them. ) FVARTS' SOPHISTRY, Mr, Deach thau cousidored the proposition of Evarts that this jorm of action was au anomaly, and that to bring 1t was disteputabla. 1t wes uu estrsorliiary proposition to comes from an omi- veut lawyor that a Emcwdhu; sanctioned by law and brought within the law was a legal suomaly, sud that it rotlectod discredis upon the oitizen who resorted to it for the punishmunt of the seducer, Was thoro no puulsluont, then, nq weans of inticting logal cbsstisemeut upou lum who lovaded tho sanctity of & houwehold ? Aocordung to the position of Evarts there was ROQe, Qur homes Might be brokes, cur familios destroyed, our wives and daughters witlout any remedy from the Iaw estal protect soclely. Ho atrung was human feelin, apon this wubject that 1t protected the fnjur man who look” tha Iaw into his own hands, for- gotting the declaration, *' YENOFANCR 18 MINP, BAITH THF LORD." Whon hiad there ever boca a convictlon of & hus- band or a parent who sdoptad auch A courss ? Bat here & man comes into a court of justice, by the only path which was open to him, and re- sirained his Arm from tluat vengeancs which was opposed to the lasy of wan and uf tho Almighty. Ho was told that his Cbristian forhesranco sras Ignomimous, and that ho was & miscrabla sesker after polf, It was for tho jury to may which view tImfl would jucnleate, whethor they wonuld uphold the doctrine of Iawlowsucna aud blood- shed or nustain the teachings of Scripturs aod the majeaty of the law of tho land, Ho would endeavor to show, by-aud-by, what claims thera wero for this forbearance extended by Tilton to this boary-hesded seducer, and then they could determine whether this plamtiff doxerved to bs Lounded out of court. e bad no desire to de- tract from the extravagant laudation of Mr. Beecher sy & proacher and & pubhc mau, but when It was avsumwnd that 3r, Beocher could not ein, ho took ievas witn the counsel for the dofense, The doctrino ran all throngh their addresses that, bocuuss Beocher was a zreat preachier, a great writer, aud Lad dous a great deal of good, thoreforo AL WAS INCAPALLE OF BIN, and {f bie had ainned it was a nuraclo, It we ao- cepted this doctnine, what becamen of the teach- ings of the Bible and of our expericuce of the world? Wero we to accept the theory that the buman heart waa notdeceittul abovaall things, and desperatoly wicked ; that men no louger ntols tha fivery of heaven to kerve the Davilin : that mon mist bo good Loecause the peared good 2 What beeamoof the stonement undorting theory? What oced way thero for n Gnd to de- rcend from heavon and wacris ems of mon, If men could murlbla of Hnning ¥ iled bt he did rot winh to dirparage unjuutly the valuo of chaiacter. The miost eloquent worrds of the counnel tor defense hsd boeu expendodt on thiy ut. Ho reverenced churacter, and 8t holy character which shiouid at- tach to a minister of that God whom, 1f he did not aore fu n Christian spinit, ho at leant rever- 4 and fenred. I this cano rested upon oral lone, leaving out tiat of Mrm, Moulton, ate loag to believe that defondant could ba guilty of this chargo, althouzh it woy bronght by L0 men whom he bahieved to bo os pure aud houorabla ax any who had ever adorned the rauka of litoratare or of that businesy which Liad been 8o highly extolled by hia learnod triend, RS, The hour of rocess haviug srrived, Beach took hin weat. Judszo Neilson told the court ofticars that they must exact s promise of quict from the porwous in the gallery or the padery wonld bo cloned, He swid thet ho kcarcely knaw what 10 vay to pordons upap the 1dbr why had offeud- od against order, If Le had not witnessed their couduct, he could 1ot have boliovrsd that eitizens could biave cowme into cunrt and disgraced theni- solves by disturbing counsol and jury with an obtrurive expression of their opanien. Necces was then takon, "The crowd ufter recers una ns proat asin the morving. ‘Iracy aud Hralion spoke to each uthier, nnd lsughed as t'sov camo i, b circwm- stauce causiog conkiderablo surprise and com- wens among the audiel e, AN EDITO GIAL OPINION, Mr. Boach resumcd Lis sddress to the jury, sud roferred to tho m§re; exjressed by Porter that W, O. Dartloty had heen prevented from en- RRGING 048 coubres in this cave, Aw Mr. Bartlett was connceted izl & newspaper in tho Cky of New York, ho would quuto from that jourual what wight b cousidered ns Mr. Bartlett's pros- ont opnion, whatever i views nught hiave beon 1u tho early stages of this case. He then read on estracs from au editorial on this vase, which it sas argued that a siperiicisl good chinr~ acter d Al not alford inmght into the **trno - wardroes™ of a wan or inforin vne of tho cn lumselt for tha sne porfect and « thin doetrine, tbotom facts™ in o man's career; thee tho potrisrchs of Iarscl—tho men beloved “of Und—wers gmity of many eins, and that tho beet men ia all aged and countrios bad iHuktratod the truth of the West- nungier conleasion, that we all inherit & corrupt nutare, aud wo aro Inclined to all ovil. Theo ar- ticla also xot forth that Boecher had novor been inclinod to asceticiem, but biod always heen dis- posed to gratity the desires of tho flesh, o much, sald 3r. Beach, for Dartiett, AMr. I'orter—Do you meau to say that Mr. Bartlott wroto that > Mr. Bonch—1I miean to say that Mr, Bartlott iy closely conuected with that journal, and tu the liabit of muking to it eome of its 1wost able cou- tnibutions, ir. Deach then a<ked the Jury to LODK AT TIE PLECEDENTS of tofs kind, and referred ta iho cases of a num- ber of erufuent divines who had been eonvieted of ldulte?', and said: Lucifer, tho groat Arch- sugel, fall, aud, of two of the churen disviples of the Bavior, ono denicd tho Master, and tho other botrayed, Tho instances of mau's des pravity aud proneness to mn—proving that the moet oxalted azo not ouly not treo trom tompta- tion, but aro oiten too.weak to resiAt it—micht be multipliedan hupdred-fold. Mr. Beach then roferred to tho caso of I'rof, Webstor, of Ilarvard Rolloge, who, holding_the ivhest posiclon iu Loston, murdered Dr, Parkman undor tho ivfluence of mercenary woll ond, after » denial of his quit, wos tried, convioted, and banged. In tho tnmal, as hore, tho argument was that a wan of his provious lifo aud roputation could not possibly have bsen guilty of such a crime. Take away the shield of cbiaractor, Judge of Henry Ward Beechor ay of avy other wmal, according to the prepondoranco olthe evidence, und conld thero be any doubtas to what the Julemont on tlus casn would bo 7 Counsel quoted frow Lvares' address to the Jury witia regerd to THE FUYSIQUE and character of Beacher, Chis plos of Evarts' was ull illusory, Mr, Beochior says there is no need for mou 10 come to him und confess tneir ewm, for ho could read it in their oyos aud on tueir skios, aud won thouzht ~ that be- cauwe thoy committed their elos at night they could be Lidden ; and ugain that thers weto wotie men who could 1ot bide their predom paseious from the eves. Tuls, waid Mr. Bench, wag uttered from Plymontls Churets pulpit by Alr. Beecher, Mr. Boccher also mavs that ths intellectust forcea woro incromsed in s much | greater dogreo than thoy wers butors, but that ANIMAL PASHION HENAINED exactly the simo a8 thoy ha © Find me," vaid Mr, Deechor, * ut prefuts or Hishop who tade the world greater than bu fonud it, and I will find you sowe dross in him.” Counsel would not Lave cuterad iuto this sub- Ject had not Mr, Evaris touched upon it, sid bo would not ssy anythiug oxcept that which he balioved souud aod just, He bad nothing to ad- vauco ahout dofoudant's physical constitution or hin power of iucoutinenco, but if Beecher was ugasiled with theeo evils, comnuel would judgo him us ho would judge bimself or avy of the Jury, Counsol lare read quotatlons from the write ings of Beacher on the subjess of Jove, and con- tinuod s It bud been waid that Moulion hada fatling memory, snd Tracy hal conuted the unmber of times bo bod repiled * L don's know,” and eomo of the genttemen'bod examined the testimony of Beecher, and aithough not so long outho stand he had used tho expression 533 timos. llo uwsed * I think™ 245 {uues,and * 1 dou't rewmembor,” fifty-suven timow. ‘Ihore was AN INDITAULE THEORY iu tho caso of the defenso which was organized by Mr. Boocner, and shadowed forthin his state- wment to tho Church Conumitteo, and that theory he carriod with Lim o the withoss-stund, when lio gaye, not his ovidence, but u narration, which was givon under the solomuity of thst oath roe quired by tho law. Now, said Alr. Bueach, Mr, Livarts iquired, it this was o ciso of scaucuon, whero wero all the love-lotters ? A Jover alway: writen lotters, Hut when in a‘crim, con. cano liko this did they evur see tho lovo-lotiors vassitg botweon thio parties produced. Cuunsol was asked why ho did wuot prodnes theso love-lotters, sud the servants, Well, thoy had enough experienco with poor Kate Cary, who was _mssailed ou_all sides, When thoy went to New Jersey and olscwhiors in tearch oiy tho sorvants of e, ‘Lilton, the Iady zoalows of Plymouth Church werd thore bo- tuiw thom, Thoy had boen wet ofion with tho quustion why theso sorvants were not producod, but conusel had soarched tor thew withoub avail, sud, geutlomon of tho Jury, raid Mr. Jdonch, whon s person has goll at his conuusud it s tho casiest thing in tho workl to suppress ovidenco, Mr, Evarts #aid wo had no J’mo . Wo produced the Jotter of cunfossion, aud gave tea- thnouy beariug on the guilt of Alr. Baocher in Lius assoctatious with Alry. 'lilton, and bis pres- ouce iu $he houss in Mr. Tiltow's absence, and you thoy say wo aro all wrong, sud hiave uo prools of the offeuso, Adjourned, . alwaya boen, ! 0 Jo SaeaqiL o sda1Tuo; NUMBE A SEA OF IC Sinking of the Steamship Vi Collision with Ico in Mi Lot 43 Two DBoats Containing Fourteen Men Leave the Ship in Safety. Forty Poreons Bupposed to Have Gons Down with ths Ship, Five of the Snrvivors Arrive in New York Yestorday. Thelr Story of the Disaster and Thelr Subse~ qnent Privations. GIQANTIC ICE-FIELDS, Late Senfoundiand letter. There {8 no rocord of such ice-flolds as have besn aliding past our shors4 this soason. Tho aesling Cantainn report the 1co 1n many {nstances { 20 foot in thicknoss, and bard as flosting masson | of granite. Hail tho Hoason boen & stormy ono | thin jco would havn plased sad havon smong our | floct. From tho 8th of January, whon tho fco i first appoared hore. til tho 11th of May, it waa ! nevor out of sigit—n liugo river of ico slowiy floating past. Ships that ¢came through it roport- od 1t to bo 200 milos in broadth, Tts leugth la nnknown, but in all probability it extended from | Battiu'y Boy to the Gulf Stream, a distaaco of i 1,600 to 2,000 miles. Tho intouss cold of this ! winter scowns to have converted the wholo sur- {800 of the ses along Greenlaud into ico-folda, ;#nd no sooner was one borno mway on © the bosam of tho Arctio eurrent than snothor ono was furmed. Uno would supposo that such an onormnons ice dolivery would temporacily | Jower tho temporaturo of tho Gulf Stroam itselt and give us 4 cold summer. Evon at this dato, i vagt quantizies of ico aro passing south, tho: notin sight, ‘The frs! two outiard bounnd mail- steamora from Liverpool woro tunable to enter the Port of St. Louin owing to tho ice, and had to run on to Ialifax; and the samo s truoof the two ficet homoward-bound steamers. Tho third outward-bound mnil-stenmer, by which tuis lettar should bo conveyed, is overdue, aud may have paand us by. Tho ‘**oldost inbabi- tant " remombors 1o kush keason a8 this, SUNK AT S&A BY ICE. New Yorx, Juno 10,~The steamship State of Gennapin, which nrrived this moming, broaght five seamen of {he Dominion Line steamship Vicksbury, from Moutreal for Liverpool, whicl was sunk by ico on Tueeday, Juuo 1. The mon wero picked up Juue 5, nearly dead from oxpos- ure, but sinco then bad been rapidly improving. Thoy tell a fearful tale of distreas. Other boats wora lsunched with a Jargo number of persons, but tho greater pumber wero seon to perish without getting in the boats, The Vicksburg went down in the midst of fco, and the boat wad surrounded by fcebergsand a fleld of ico when picked up. Tha other boata Liavo not yot been heard from. Tho five men rescued bad their foot and logs very much swollen, 80 much so that thelr boots lnd to bo cut from their feot. 'They are still soffering from their gront exposurs to wet and cold, but are recovering as faat 08 could be ex- pected, JAMES CHOWLLS'S HTATEMENT. * Waloft Quobee on Thuraday morning, May 27, with n ship's crow of sixty men, all told, and eight ssloon passengors,—Gve gentlomon amd three ladies,—and about tweuty fu tho stecrage, of whom four wero fomales. Thg weather was fluo until 9 o'clock Bonday evon- fng, May 30, when wo foll in with & field of ico, and wero soon surrounded ov it, Tho sbip was stopped until daylight, whon wo proceeded again with but littte ico in sight, At 9:30 p. . Monday all bands wero ealled to shorton eail. 'Lhe ghip was stopped amongst loavy ico, and beaded to thoe south, when wo { proceeded ot full speed to get clear of the ico. | At 12 o'clock, at balf-speed i WE BTBUCK TIHE ICE. . The engiries wero immediately revorsod. Tho ship struck heavily afs, on the port quartoer, car- rying away the faus of tho propeller, and a bola waa kuocked through tho platos on that quarter, through whigh the sbip mode s great deal of wator. Oot sails over and ktopped the holo up 80 that but littlo wator came iv. Al hands wera employod in heaving the cargo over- poard, Tha sccond ofticer and myself wero tsken from {ho cargo to clear away the bonts. Tbis was abont 6 ». m, Tuesday, June 1, The Captain ordered the forward wells to be soundod, and § inchod of water was found, the alter stoerago thon being full of water. Tha maln-hold wells wero also souuded, and 54 feot of water found, Tho Csptain callod mo on to the briage and told me not to wind the boats, nud then callod everybody aft and told thewmn to Liave no fears, as lie could take tho ship to Bt. Jolins, N, I, It wae thon discovered that THE FINZS IN THE ENGINE-HOOM WERE DROWNED ocT. Tho Captaln thon gave orders to launch the boatw, with their respectivo crows, sud told thew to nnnd that tho distauco from 8t, Johuy was 120 niles northweat, I procecded to launch No. 1, which was iy buat, and 1t waa capsized 1 Jowering, losing the chronowmeter, watcl, chart, ! rudder, sud part of tho provielous, Blhe wad | full of water, O'Brien and L bailod her partly ont, when Grogan. Wilkinson, and Williamy Jumpsd . We conld not haug on to tha ship, | ‘bwing to thie heavy sea on aud ive ubout. 0'Brien | saw the Captain ou the bridge buckoning tha boat back, we having drifted about 10 vards trom the ehip. Wo paw the secoud otlioar's boat lowerod ail cloar, with nino hands sud bim< wolf in her. 1lio camo round tho bow aad puliol to windward about 60 yards, TILE SIIP KUNK about 10. oclook, Noatlug boat No. 3 from her chocks with tho _chief omicer and sbout thirt people iu ber, Sho 4ot clear sud pulled to wind- ward, O'Drien, aftor the ship woent down, saw ,the Cuptain and somo porsons Hoating on a balo of hay among the wreckago, Wo tried all wo conld to pick ‘them up, but owing to tho boat being balf full of wator and the ice about, wero not ablo to dosv, Wo shipped our mast, aud kept company with the other boats for sbout two houts, aud theu lost sight of them to the westward. Wo docided then tu stoer south to got clear of the ice. Ilove tho boat to with an osr, snd s bucket as a drag, til daylight ou Wudnesdny mnmlu‘j. Wo bad in the bout ubous 3 gallons of water, 40 pounds of raw beol, 14 pouuds of broad, wot with salt-watar, aud & compads which did not fall out wheu tha boat capsizod, Agsin wo put s.il on the boat, sud steered vouthy, tho wind blowing trom the northward und westward all throughout, aod be- iug bitterly cold, About 4 p. w. hsuled the voat's huad to the northeast sill Thursda morning, then tucked to westward till about 3 o'lock in the afternoon, and ngain lay to with tho drag till 9 o'clock iu'the oveuing, whon wo took iu the drag and mode suil snd stood to the northeast till Frday worulug at daylight. Tacked to southwest till midday; tacked sgsin to tho uurthoast tilt wornlng, when, abous Lalf-past 10 o'clock, L WEBOUTED YOUN 681V, Wo got out thocard and pullod away doad to windward til) you picked us up. I thiok that forty odd people, with tho Captain, weot duwu withi tho sbip, Wo hed vlankots in our boat for tho throo ladies aud tho Swwwardess, which were Jost whon tho boat capsizod. Wo saw no ladies in tho chlef or second vilicer's boat. DROWNED. Spootal Diapatch to The Chicage Tridume, ArToy, 11, June 10.—A boy about 19 ysars of sgo, named Jawes Kinney, was drowned i a pond near Btate streot, at noon to<lay. Young Kinnoey sud saveral other schoolboys wens bath. iug.durivg the noon hour,: bat e relurning da