Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, May 12, 1875, Page 1

VOLUME 28, HOTEL, : T wem (reat Reductio IN PRICES! ALMER HOUSE, The Largest & Bost-Furnished House in the World! 160 Rooms (with Board), $3.00 per day. 160 Tooms (it Boaid), $3.60 per day. 160 Rooms ‘(wih Board), $L00 Der day. 100 Rooms (el Board), $450 per day, 100 Rooms Cwilh Board), $5.00 per day. No person should leave Chi- cago without visiting this HO- TEL, which, in point of costly magnificence, in both Building and Furniture, surpasses the Palaces of any of the Sover-| gigns of Burope. Tie Building cost over - - - - $2$UGU,UUU i Purwitore ot over - - - - $350,000 BOOTS AND BHOES: 0f Iadles' and Gents' T'ine Boots and Shoes. ] . WHEELER & 0, Aro now offering the most completo ond bost assortod stock of Gonts’ Fino Fashionable S8hoos ever shown to the Chicago public, embracing ovor 70 difforont kinds, of tho latest and nobbiost styles. % A New Thing in Ladies’ Shoss. " ‘Wo havo just recoived a largo ghipment of LADIES’ FRENCH KID BOX TOE Shoes, for tho salo of which wo aro tho oxclusive agenta. Wo havo also & flne lino of im- ported Gaiters constantly on hand, M. WHEELER & CO,, 74 Bast Madison-st., Sooond daar east ot MoVieker's Thestro. GENTS' FURNISHING GOODS. I e e e e . <7 COMPLETE LINES OF MEN'S SUMMER UNDERWEAR In the following goods, now in stook, vis; Bilk, Balbrigran in Brown and Fanoy, Lisle Throad in White and Brown, Oartwright & Warner’s Morinos, Gauze and Gossamer, Angola Flannol, Linen, Joan, &o. Handling tho largest atook of these goods of any Rotall tfouso in the country, enables us to soll at loweat prices, and to give each customor the goods he wanta. WILSON BROTHERS, BHIRT MANUTFACTURERS AND MEN'S FURNISHERS, 67 & 69 WASHINGTON-ST, CHICAGO. P _ike’s Opors House, Oincinnati, CARPETS. Hollister & Gorlan, 221 & 223 State-st., (HOUBE-YURNISHING ROW). CARPETS, CURTAINS, Uplolstery Goods & Bedding, AT THE LOWEST PRICES! CIGARS. HAVANA CIGARS (DIRECT 1MPORTATIONS) JUST RECEIVED. rLoorus o. PARDBEE, BUCCESSOR TO STANTON & CO:., ITALIAN WAREBHOUSEMAN, 186 ST ATE-ST COLLEOTION AGENCY. TP o g e, - e trom 3. L0 o it ames Gowon, Grovarille, Igh,, a4 18 _rmons; Bow Y Rastios ‘SOLLETION Auh?'u‘\!‘uumi'&a zhl"gl AK:‘ WANTED, lelUST FUND INSURANCE ABSOCIATION D GENERAIL IN ; A UH‘(!KA]H‘QX%E{&%?I&‘EJHMUY OF HAN meral and Speclal [.ifo-Insurance Agents wanted for . No more lapaed policjes. Tho sssurod alvage Soaendyd, For tull tnformation ad ML»I .l‘yu W B S At i o e, L 704" LaSallo sty Obioago. ' et Road Wagons, ‘We beg to announce that our stock of finished wvehicles, in VARIETY, EXTENT, and QUALITY, has never been equaled by any similardisplay, embracing thenewest designsin Landaus, Landanlets, Barouch- es, Grand Victorias, Double- Suspension, Cabriolets, Vis-a-Vis, Phaetons, T-Carts, etc. Including, alse, every wvariety of the “BREWSTER WAGON" INE STANDARD FOR QUALITT, Special attention is called to our “Improved Side-bar Coup- ling,” by which we produce a PERFECTLY EASY,LEVEL- RIDING, HALF-SPRING WAGON, without increased weight or cost. BREWSTER & (0., OF BROOME.ST,, Fifth-av., comer Fonrtoenth-st, NEW TOREK. TO EXCHANGE. To Bixchange. Examino this Diists 880,000, Realdence and 1,000 feok ground, unincumbers od, for pruductive business or residence propesty, 0,000, 11culy “Soibrnrad farm, anlnouinverod, esr statioa, 40 minutes froia ufty, for good inaide prop- orty. 40,00, Hiuity o Clark-st; blook nuder eod rental for ‘unincumbered farm in Illluais. 915,000 to 325,00, lirick resitlonce and clear lots, all un. {acuriberad, for resldence without basement on o, Houth Bi 810,000 tu 313, ncambered lots om improved X U rets or stork femn aoer sation withia 50 miles i, : 87,00, " Michizan-av. lot for rustdencs on West Bide. 7,000, Farm boxr Sterling, unincumby ¢ rosidonce on Weat bida, 7,000, “Irlincumbered loty for reatdonce na 1,80, lfdx or Univenity, uity 1o Maywood reaidence for any good props iheton.st.. Roars 11. e, EIRDL CHANGES. DISSOLUTION. The espartnership herstolors eslsting batween the urdersigoed, uader the firm.uame of DENSLEYS & WAUNER, s bereby dissolved by mutual consent. QEORGE I, BENSLEY, JOIN K. BENSLEY, DAVID W, BENSLEY, _Omicano, May5, 175, DAVID . WAGN; COPARTNERSHIP., The undersicaed bave assoclated thomuclves together for the trantsction of aGEXENAL CoMMIsBION BUsINESS, the Arm-name of BENSLEYS & WAGNER. Libera! casl advancos made on Consignmentso! Qralo, Beads, Provlslons, &s. Optlon Orders in Qraln or Y'ro- vislons eeouted promptly, OCssh property bought aud beld on marglny, or shipped to other markel GEOJLGK B. BENBLEY, JOIN B, BENSLRY, Cmicaoo, May8 1578, DAVID 0. WAGNKR, ARTIFICIAL EYES, TARTIFICIAL EYES Ot the beat French mal DR. GODFREY WALKER, Oculiast, 104 Bouth Olark-st., Ohicago, CHINA,CROCKERY, &o. p35 16 Is 81l wo ask now for a8 White Frenoch China Dinnor 8ot, 166 Picces. Bost Poroelain, Opaque, 123 Piece Dinnor Set, for 18, Buys Deocorated Chambor 8ot, bost goods, worth $13.50, Binco our roduction in prices, buys a $110 75 Daocorated Dinnor Set ---$70 & $100 Haot. Now buys a dozen Cut 9 Glass Goblots we always gold at $12, Buys a dozen Cut Glass Goblets, sold elsewhore at §6.60, Gots n dozon Goblets for $1. Woused to soll them ot $2.26. ‘We soll a beautiful Deco- ;xs\tod Chamber 8ot for to 65¢ is what wo ask for Fruit Dishes wo formerly zold at 760 and $1.60. In faet,if you want anythingin our line, it will pay you to call on A, PICK, Suocossor to B 0. LAWBENCE & (0, 2786 State-st. At Costl OUR ENTIRE RETATLSTOCK COMPOSED OF Decorated and Plain China, Dinner and Tea Sets, Ohamber Sets, Vhases, Glassware . Silver-Plated Wnre, Table Cutlery, and Fancy Goods, ITIVELY AT COST UNTIL CLOSKD OUT, ia- TOBITTVALY fiie Scuwicares and Favier. BOWEN & KENT, 262 & 264 Wahash-av,, Just areund the corner from Tlousekeeners® Row. WK M FINANGIAL, ~ CANADIAN BANK OF GOMERCE, HEAD OFFICE: TORONTO, - - - ONTARIO, Capital paid np) - $6,000,000 Gold Reserve Fund - -~ $1,800,000 Gald HON, VILLLA MHASPER, Pn An Agenoy of this Bank has Leon openocd at tho Offices, 128 WASHINGTON.ST. (cor, TFxohange Placo), Chicago, for the purpose of transacting a General Banking Buain: \Accounts of Country Banks kept undor spocinl arrangement aa to interost, eto. Bterling Bxchango bought and sold, Colloctions mado in Canads sud cluswhore cn the moat favorable torms, J. G, ORCHATD, Agent.fl I AM MAKING t losna on Gealn aad Provisions, aud loag oacs ea ertanas: M EALAZATLUB SILYERMAN, Banker, Chamber_of Commeros, ‘Wo have now on hand all sixes ot propared HARD COAL, For Stoam or Domestic Uso. F. M. WHITEHOUSE, AQENT OF MINES, 19 Chamber of Commerce. FOR SALE. ‘The following described LOTS and LANDS, viz: cth fractional halt Sec. 36, sud north and sast ef M, ozcopting B, Xof B. W. i of the N, W, X of sald saction, in Townsbip 87, nosth Range 14, cast of third principal meridian, contanlag 278 £3-100 scros, North bislf of Lot 18, Blook 84, belug 24 feat on Calumet- av., near Trenty-slsth.at, Lot 1, Block 24, at Highland Park. Lots 7, 10, and 11, Block 8, Kgaudals. ‘Tha above declrable property Is offored en advantageons WELLING, b3 Michigan-av, 1, Jcatad an the North Bids, 4o uarentess 10 por ten e by A luuu(m"'n. FOR SOOI L NI VIE ARE HOW RECEIVING BY VEMELS NEW SAGINAW SALT, AND CAN FILL ORDERS PROMPTLY, All Loading Brands of SALT, CEMENT, & STTUCCO. Tlking & Wheeler, &1, Lak ", akioat. = g § CHICAGO, WEDNESDAY MAY 12, 1875. BEECHER. { The Plaintiff Takes n Hand in IIE0rS 0 Knope Are Invited to examine the Btock of PINTI JEWELRY, WATOHES, OBJETS D'ART, GIMS8, DIAMONDS, and other Precious l;?(uncl, both sot and unset, at our Loune in aris, 57 RUE DU CHATEAUDUN (Chanssee 'Antin), Alsa to visit our Wetch Manufectory, PLACE CORMAVIN (nezr the Rafirod Depel), GENEVA, SWITZERLAND, Having combined the American method of vsing; labor-saving toola nnd mechinery with thoroughly skilled labor, we are onabled to produce FINE 'WATCHES &t prices which warrant o proferenco over all othora. FANT & (0, UNION SQUARE, Now York. WATCHES! JEWELRY! SILVER ] ‘Weo invito particular attention to our euperb sclections in Rich New Camoo, Coral, Onyxz, Jot Gold Jow- olry nnd TProcious Stones of the very finest quality. Gold and Siiver Watches from the bost inelkors in the world, HAMILTON, ROWE & (0, 99 BTATE-ST., CORNEE WASHINGTON. Watches. Horse-Timers ‘We offer ot low prices a very fina asgortment of Ladics’ and Gentlo- men’s Gold oy and Stem-Winding -Watches, Chronometers, and Quar- tor Second Chronographs, The col- ébrated ‘¢ Chas. B, Jacot & Co.” ‘Watches sold only by us in Chieago. N.IMATSON &0, State and Monroe-sts, OPPOSITE PALMER HOUSE, SHIRTS. SHIRTS! To order, from modium to finest grados. f‘\fll lines in stock of our own manufacture, Wo aro propared to make SBhirts to order in eight hours, whon noecessary. LSO BROS, MEN'S FURNISHERS, 67 & 69 Washington:st., Chicago. Pike's Opera House, Fourth.st., Cincinonti, s IEGANT IN D SIGN, Bopeth io wati- masaliip, Faultloas i it. HARRIS & gon, 174 H. Clurke-at. IRON PIPE. To Water and Gag Compauiss, INTERNATIORAL PIPE (0, OFFICE, 50 West Washington-st,, Chricago 1s prepared to sontract for and furalah CAST IRON GAS & WATER PIPE A FOR SALE, Soda-Water APPARATUS Of all kinds for salo by TORREY & DRAD- LY, 171 and 173 itandoiph.st. T0R SALE OR EXCHANGE 100 Marketentsy Nes . Fur cl's rsat estate, the Stock, kituris, aod Lesseo? & #irat-clavs boot suid Elos bloro, Host Location ta tha city. Batutaviory teatons for sallisg, Shdss T8 e ctice. omptly the Game of Rebuttal, Denlals Being Tromps, He Plays Them without Stint, COontradiotions at Wholesale Roll from Tilton's Lips, Beecher, Oliver Johnson, and Sam Wilkeson, Come In for a Share, Woodley, Tracy, Mrs. Palmer, and Bes. .Sio Turner, Incidentally Squelched. There Is Plonty Mors of Porjury to Bo Accounted for Somewhere, Important Statement by Bowen n3 to the ‘Iripartite Agreement, NO, TILTON UNEXTZCTEDLY TESTIFIER TO XOTNING UNEXILCIED, Spesfal Dixpateh to Tha Chirane Tridune, Nrw Yonk, May 11.—Counsel for plaintiff yes- torday surprirad almost every one in tho court- room by euddenly reealling sIr. Tilton to tho witness-cboir. Ilo was called by 3z Aorris, who turned to him after the brief examination of Mize McDouald was finished and mald, ina low voico hardly audivle boyond thae circlo of ccuaeel’s chairs, ¢ Mr., Tilton, will you take the witness-sisnd 2" Nr, Tilton arone, and, walking formard, eat down in theitnass-chair so quictiy that mapy in the audlerco were nnawero that the plainti® himeslf was upon the stend. nig A At firat Mr. Tilton's teatimony was given in sa low a tone that it wmust have been fuzudible 1n tho brck paris of the room. Mr.Tilton appeared very calm, ead gave bia whols attentigneo the examination, leaning ferward in bia dfir. with half prrted and his eyosrized on Xr. o scemed to cateh tho intent of the quettions before they woro uttsred, and anawer- ed vory promptly, beginniug to apeak nometimes almont bofore tho’words of the queations Lad loft the lipa of ke questioner, M3 ATDIENCE. The members of tho Plymonth delsgation amilod and whispored togethor, and ia the long pauses which trequently fntervoned between he questions many in the sudlenca conversed in low lones, casting side-glances at the witueso, Alr, Beecher wau not preseut, bat Mrs. Baocher was, and ehe Iooked straight at Mr. Tilton with & slight frovn whilo Le was testifylog. Bovers) jurors connulted together whilo the exsmination of Mr, I'ilton wos going oo, and by nods and eignificant glancea indicated that thelr jutereat wea fully aroused, “WELL UP™ IN TIE BCANDAL. Tilton had a large package of papsrs and let. torn, from which ho readily selested documonts which ho was asked to produce. e socmed to ba perfoctly fomiliar with the testimony which he wan callod to rebut, and once or twice seuint- od his counse! in finding the particular passages sbout which they decidod to question. him. When discussions between couneel were golng on concerning tho ndmission of his testimony on certain points, Mr. Tilton liatoned with fixed attention, sceming to bs impatient to join in them himaelf, and to chafo'under the reetraint which the Jaw put upon Lis niterances, THI COLORED GUNTLEMAN PRONOUNCED A LIAD. Mr, Tilton bogan u long series of denisls by declarivg that ho had not visited ira. Woodbull in Irviug Placo as the colored witness Woodley Liad asserted. Then ho sald that he Lad mover called Mrs. Woodhu!l ¢ Vickoy ™ in his life, and had unever spoken fo her br Col. Blood about publishing the ecandal, RS, PALMER (PAST, PRESIKT, ETC,—31) Pno- * NOUNCED & LIAL. Ay Ue contradicted soveral otlier atatemsnts made by Woodloy. Mra. I'almer, one of the defend- ant'n witnesees, had testified that intho early part of 1872 Alrs. Woodhnll road s portion of the proofs of the scandal articlo in the presence of herselt and Mr, Tilton. This AMr. Tilkon denied, saying that ol the date nssigned by 2Mrs, Ialner for this intervigw ho was absout in the Northwest lectur- ing, Mr. Tilton showed whera be was in 1871 and 1872, prior to Nov, 5, 1872, by readiog along Itat of plncos in various parts of tho country whera ho bad lectured during that time. GRYN, THACY PRONOUNCED A LIAR, FHodenied thet he Lad had what is known as tho *true story™ at tho Suudsy evening inter- view at 2Ir. Moulton's houss when Afr. Tracy, Mr. Moulton, aud himsclf wera present. That document had not boon written theu. Henlso contradicted Gen, Tracy's statemont that, at that iuterview, Mr, Tilton had unfolded the covoring of the manuscript which ho had brought with him, and had beguu to road the statement. In sevoral other particulsea the witnesa contra- dicted the testimony of Gen. Tracy, as welles the cvidence of various other witnesses for the dofendunt, MI58 MESSIE TURNED PRONOUNCED A LIAR. Tho liveliest intoroat was shown by the au- dienca in the plaintifi’s statements in regand to tho zcene at his house, whon Miss Lussia Turner azsertod that sho had heen koocked dowa by Mr, Tilton, Inavery docided wmanner tho witnoss deoied that any sach scono had ever takon place. Ilo was ssked it Lo hed mado cortain tutements to Lessio Tarner—among othors that it waa no wonder his gray hairs were going down in sorrow to tho grave. ‘' Did you usy that? " asked Mr, Morris, * No, eir,” roplicd Mr. Til- ton, and then added, without smiling, in a Jorw tong, * Ibnd no gray hairs at that time." Mg, ‘ilton wen: on denyiug statemont after stato- ment of Miss Turnor us thoy wore road to him from her testimony by Mr. Morrs, Those do- nlals, which wors listened tu in porfect silenco by tho audionco, wore made withont hesitation, a8 promptly ss the questions were put. Mr, ‘Tilton statod that Besaie Turner wsa sbsent in Keyport dunog the wholo titmo of Mr, Groeley's stay at his houso In 1839, D, PUCCHRA * OFF " ON THAT SLOBLERING SCEXE, M, ‘ilton deniod that the intorviow bad taken place, whick was spoken of by Mr. Boccher as oceurriog in 1871, when tha dofendant sald that hosaton Mr. Tilton's Lnecs, and that'uo sad 3ra. Tilton Lissed ono another, 1Alr, Tilton sald, howaver, that ho rorsembored a Bcens some- what similar, which had ocourred sbout ten yoars ago, and which” had refereuce to anothor matter, . OTOLR ALLEGED DISCREPANCILY, Mr, Tilton further denied that be hod read to Mr. Boecher from & alip of papdr tho statomont of his wife concerning fmpropor advances mada toberby Mr. Deecher. Ho wsald tbat Lo had read a very dilferent paper to Mr, Beocher. Ho tikowise doniod that saything had been ssid at the time of the erbitration in his prosonce about burping papers. Bir, Wilkeson bed uot suge 41 g‘uudw innisted on » deatruction of pspers to m. %0 CHOPB-UXAMINATION, 5 When Mr. htorris bad finisbed his examina- tlon of Mr. Tilton hie turned toward Mr, Fvarte, indicating that he could begin the croms-6zam- ination, but Mr. ¥varts ohook his hend, saying “ I huvo nothiug to ask;" snd the pialntiff stop- peid down from the witness-atand and resumed Lis neat among his counvel. Fho timo for ade Journment Lad nearly arrived nben Jr, Tilton's o, cxamination was finished. Mr. Ieach ruid that NUMBER 261, #3mo paper 1 read to Mr, s'mrmon, The first fgente=ra of Dr. Blorrs’ docunent, rolating to Alr. Daer & sslang Mra. Tillon to become & wife to hig' & wll that the name impliod, was incor- por . athaciatement . & 1RIPAD To M, nREOmED 57 Toad to sou n hriof statement of Mra. € & sn, and asi: yon a questfon in regard tolb., I <7 ng of tho interviaw which you had wl!h’ © w0 waa naked thin queation ¢ ; 3 .~ Wht w20 suid or done on that sabjecs 2] €2 uecessary to rafer to what precaded it, ho-' £ 0 the ouswor rafers to {ho subjoct, A— &7 enlie spole of tua tietion, X Mr. Mouiton would bs tho next witness, bul~~. d: *Eh o o Sha. WLty ‘ Enzabeth whil lio for mo._ Sho will' teil 59 that gootleman was not prosent, the Cour¢h. Y number of lica to clear mo. She loves mo.’ adjonrned, . s REBUTTAL MRY, MACDONALD'S TISTTHONY. New Yooz May 11.—3r. Boscher was absent when tho great ecandal trial was resamed to-day in the Brooklyn City Court-room. Mra. Boscher, Liowever, wan in court, Tho examination of AMrs, MacDonald was con- tinued by Mr. Morrie, aud she tostitied in sub- stanco an followa: 1 thiok Borsio Turuer went to Koyport Tuesday. 8 left Tilton's about noon on Mondav. I remsined nt Keyport four or five weeka, Dossle roturned stout s weel: Eofors 1did. T think Mra, Tilton had retucned from Monticello whon Bessie returnod to Hrook- Iyn. The foldinz-doors on tho secou floor wers gonerally open : I never saw them locked, and could not say that they wera ever locked when pulied togethier, Yihen the doors wera closod, the top part did not come together cloaaly, Cross—ezamined: T Laveheen in Tilton's fam- 1iy for over twenty-five yoars. Ilived with his parents at Kosport. I came to work for Theo- dore Tilton at Brooklyn for ten or twelve years, and weot backward and forward Letwaon the two places. When Iwas ct Tilton's the firat time, they were lvinz with Mrs. Michards. Aftor tucy went to Lounekesping, ATOUT FOUR YRALS AQD, Iwent to Tilton's to live, I was thors when talpls sy boru, in Juoce, 1860, bat ot loag Le- fora tbet. Xrn, Tilton generally paid e my wages, nad sometimes Mle. Tilton did, ‘lilton o1l 10 1y wages all of tho year 136Y, althouzh wad not there all the tims. I nevorleft Tilton'n family sltogother, and was living thero when Mrs, T{ton went awny. I was on iulitnate nud contldeatial terma with tho family. Whon [ was down at Reypor!, I was treated ge osoof tho family, I kaw Tilton give Aliss Turaer money o goto Loyport. Thorears two front rooms, connected by folding docrs, oa ths second floor of Tiltva's houee, Ttecireet czami) yeara oid whan ration: Dalph wens about 4 ilten veut to donticello, TILTON MECALLLD, Thesdore Tilton wa3 recalled. Ho tzgtifled: I 3 at Mrs, Woodhull's housa while eho naver lived in Irving place, I never said to M, Weod- Lull, at any time, or in any porson’s predence, + Victoria, you piblith this, aud you are 3 made women” (teforring to tuo ecsudal), I nevor callad Col. Blood swids at the Droxd stroes ofice aud talked to hira alous the weandal, Ho nevur said to ms that Lo would not haro anything to do with the publication, I Lad nos spukon to Bloud Eivco the month of April, 1572. 1 nevor v:aa ¢ the offico in which tho tcandal articls wos published. I was never present whea any proof- slipu of that nrticle wero thown, and mever saw d from 8 list the places A outside off Brookiyn, from Oct. J, 1671, to Nov. 5, 187] 1u anwwer to Mr. Morris, the witnees said that on April 15, 1872 Lo torminated his sequaint- aucesbip with Mrs. Wocdhall, The wituess continucd: I heguu my politieal campaign July 22, 1879, at Baltimore. Thiy1a the period whicn Woodley testitied that T wasat the ofiice, No conversation nas evor had abovt Beecher's congrogation paying $100,000 to sup~ Ppreso the pablication of thoacatidal. Ou the 4th of July, 1574, I did not atay ot Mrs, Woodhull's, but was ot my own house. This wea oue of the daya wheu I was coniusd to iy houso through illnoas, 1 NEYEP. SLEPT OX A SOPA-LED at Mra, Woodhull's, but have st my own bousa, 3lrs. Giles never waited ou Mrs, Wodkull snd myeell when wa wora at chickan and champagne suppers. I never saw champogne in thet Louss. Mrs, Woedbull and 1 wore naver sorved with ro- frosiments in bor bed-room. I never rode out with Mrs, Woedbull in & plaeion witha whito horee, 3Mre. Woodhnil never esid to mo that Boochier bad beiter preeids at the Steiuway Hal weeting, or Ao would mako it hoiter for him thon helt was bolow,” I was nover In her ofico ot gualight, 1 never went to Moultou's in a car- risge with Mra. Woodbull. Mr. Cooke naver was aaksd by rao to join 1m the Golden Age. T de- clined to take Cooke on the paper when he ra- quentod me to do o, I becema acqmainted with Mirs, Palmor about three months afier the Golden 4ge woa startad, at Mrs. Woodkali's ofice. It way imposaiblo that sho could Linve heard a con- versation about starting tuw paper, as it wag etarted long before I becamo acquainted with her. Tho slips of tho sczudal WLRE NEVER 8HOWN 0 ¥ in Mra. Woodhnll's oflica, iu Mra, Palmer's pres- ence, In the spring of 1872, or s any other time. At that time 1 was somewhero betwoen the Ohio River and tho Micateeippi, Tho witness was auked to fix the preciss lo- eality hie wan in rix woeks bafore tho 1at of May, the date fixed by Mes. Palmor for thio conversas tion. . M‘:i Evarts objocted. aud a loug discnssion fol- owed, Tha witness thenu continued : I did not ride with Mrs. Woddhull io the Kossel procession, atter it iad broke up, nor was 1 in a sariago that day., I went awsy with John Swinton, aud did not keo Mra, Woodhutl that dey. At the intere view iu Moulton's stmdy, in tho early part of November, 1372, when Woodruff and Traoy wore presont, I MAD XOT WRITTEN TRE *'TRUZ sTORY," norang part of it. It was not writlen o De- cembers I recollect it by my gaing to Dr, storra about it at that time, I mever uncovored 8 twanuseript, nor began ta read it, at that inter- viow, 1nover hieard « the letter of coutrition ™ spoken of by Moulton at that intorview oy a 1mere memoranda, A loug srgument ensued botween counsol on tho subjoct, and the testimony of Tracy woy hunted up and read. x'flm Court tinally admitted the answor of the witness, ‘I'ho witnesa then testifled : Mr. Moulton did not say It was ths memoranda or uotan of tho conyersation he had with Bescher, uor anything to that effact, AUr, Evarts OWJLOTED TO THIA LAST ATATEMENT of the witncse, ot: the grouud that, according to Gen. Tracy's evldence, Tilton was not prosent when this memorsndum or **lelter of contri~ tion" was spokion of. ‘I'ho witnoss wau then askod if Alr, Tracy raid to him last summer that 1f ho mado a charge of adultery againnt Boocher ho (L'racy) would not {feel hils oath blading on lim, and would ba ro- loasod frow his word to the wi "Ihis was objected to by Mr, Evarts, whoasked for time to look at (ien, Tracy'a testimuny, aud in tlie woantime the hour for rocses Lad urrivad, and tho Court rosa, Mr. Moteis (to 'Lilton)—~I waa asking you bo- foro recess in regard to Mr, Tracy's volitication to youof s iatoution or fooung himsolf ut tiberty to act for Jr. Meccter, I Lavo the evi- douco bofore mo, aud will read it and, call_your citention to s, Speaking of interviow—(Quos- tiou by Mr. Lyarts)— +Whoero did it accur, that Intorview—that con. voreation 7 A.—~I shink it coctuzed b the club, 4 Q.—"The Brooklyn Club? A.—The Lrooklyn Club. It may have beou at my oftice. 3ir. ilton was in the habit of dropping in at mny oitice frequontly, and he wao also {n tlio habit of dropping in st the Club when I wae taking luuc, or at diuner, and I mot him in tho strvet often, Wo Lid casual conversatiouy, wQ.—Vull, what passed batween you? How waa tho wattor julrodnced? A.-Loferriug to tho couversation in 1872, 1 sald $o Lim, 3Mr, Til- ton, aslong as you adhero to the cavo thap you thon atated to me, T shall ADUERY TO THIL PROMIST I mado you, but 1 deairo to suy to you that when o your cas agalnst Alr. Beccher, if you do, aud stato a differout case from what you atased to me. I sball uot regard my promisa theu made to you as binding upon me," ). ['Lo Lilzon.]—=Did auv conversation of thut kind over wvceur batwesn you aud r, Traoy prior to your weoting baeforo tho Committen ? JLTNn sir. Ho uever gave me auy such nolil- cation, Q.—You hiavo ralatod wlhat vceurred beforo the Committeo. At the Brookiyn Glub, or Liy oflico, or any vhere olso, did Le way that prior to that timo 7 A.—Never, sir; Dover, anyiling. ‘Witness contiuueds I road todLr. Beocher the v 8aid, +* Evon It T wera on trial for tho Hathan! surder, and alio had,oen mo_commlt the mot, | 1o you thinls that abe, if called upon to teatify—' cio you think that she would tell tho truth and; liavo mo couvioted * 3o said, ¢ No, alio wouid | ol Xow, do rou remember anything of that' Kind u-luguingr A~—Tho Janguage you hsvs, hm,'. m)fll;mfifi“"el‘l’;nlr. lv";flzoxud not know, ct, becousa it ling my mind. Now that you read it, PRt tiom 1T LOEN KOT COMI: UP. : Q.—Sho spoko about Mrs. Tilton having lot+ out tho only conl rooms sha had at tho Liouns,: and you usIng momo nipressions of thiy kind’ #Why does Xr. Beechor let her? Why don't Lo tako care of Lor?" Lixplain that? A, vecollect a meeting of that kind. ‘The ecircul stance3 wero theko : § waa viniting with Xr, on Cire. Ovioglon ou thor back plazes, and L) chaaored to msko & remarl: to this effoce s That I/ was sorcy tho piazza of my houro was uot in the, back part fustond of the front; that my piszza; was actually of no valuo to the family. In or-) dar to uss it they must oxpsso tucmaselvea to tho etroes, whernas that of Mre, Ovinglon's; could bo ecloyed in comfort, and the! family waiotain’ their privacy. I think s, Oviugion wado a remark abeat my bouso Leing cool and comfortablo in tho summer, in conrcquenco of Gallatm placo opouing fu front| of it I then made the remark thas that was' trao, but that I was very sorry tha$ %irs. Tilton; bed boen compelied t6 yiold up tha pleasantost! oud coolest room 1n my liouse, o #econd-story! front room, to Mr, and Mra, Toylor, who wers then occupying it, and I sddod, perhaps in & sa- tirical way, *Thik 18 0as of the conrequences of tivp sesudal. Unless I defend mymell sgninsy’ tue accusations Lrought g 1 eliall go to complets Tui Yerzatton as Lhat, y Witness continued: When Mr. Zoulton lived © in Ciinton stzvet, Xz, Boscher's portrait was i ny Loune. o6t 1o, 1 preswne, ' Home such con- I nover rezd to Mr. DoecLer on the 30th of Decembor 2 strip of prpor purpratiog: ¢o bo the confossion of 1oy wife inforvung row that Mr, Beecher had soliciiell her to becomo a wils o bim, with all the narce impliel. I xcad guite a differons utatoment fzam tha*, THEODORK: n DOUNLE. I koow Mr. Theodors H. Tilton, and have sesn Lim. I nover had & convorsction with Mr. Beecher fn reference to Theodora 1. Thlton, or #aid to Mr. Beechor that 1 know him (4his Theo- dors II. Tilton) to ba » dissainto man, having logsio habita, 3ir, Beach offred to ghow that at the time this allezed conversction waa sad to Lave taken place that the wituesh didu't know the facts con- cerving tbis Tl:codors H. Tilton, and that they had not then transpired, bot it wns ob- Jected to by Mr. Evarta, and a long discusaion easuad helween counsel, The witnees contlaued: At the tima the al.. Jened conversation s esid to havo taken place withs 3ir. Beecher, 1 Lucw #uch & person, but didn't know his charncter. X LESSIE'S TESTIMONT. Q.—Miss Taruer npoke of an interview bad with her up-utairy, in whiek you refarred to , tha red lounge. (Afier sows cousultation smong | tha couunsclors, 3Mr, Morris said, ** L will with- draw the queation.”) Q.—Have you read Lier scconnt of her inter- vim 8 given in evidenca? A.—1 have heand i xo Q.—Did any such interview as ahio relates on 2:; ‘c‘x.ecumn tahe placs betwesn you and har? ~-No, mr. Q.—An interviaw in whicl she apoke of ared lonnge, and also aa interview (page 480). I will call your attontion te baoth interviaws. Do you recoltoct interviewn as aho related them ? [Mr. Morris read from tha testimony of Dessie Turner fu regard to the alleged red lounge cen- versation.] Q.~—Did any such converastion occur? A.—1 nevor had with Bessis Turner at any time, in eny placo, auy conversation in regsrd to erim- inal rolatious botween Mr, Beochor and Afrn. almn; nor on any other subject rolated ta e, Q.—Do you rocollect of her (Bersie Turner) oorune into {ho room while you and your wifo wore having n conversetion upon tho subjoct ? Did eha como in unobaerved? ~ A,—Yes, ir. Q.—No otber conversation upon that subjoot botweon her aud you and your wifs oceurred ? Ar. Evarts—3ilus Turnier has given no testi- mouy s boing absent or ordered from tho room. 0.—MissTurnersays that ** When hasaw me he ordered me, saving, *Dama you! get out I'" Did snything of fhat kind occur?” A.—No, sir; nothing of that kind ocenrred. Q.—ow, I oak you the question agaln, whetlier st that mterviow, when you observed Biies ‘Furner iu tho room, auy conversation of that kind ocenrred? A.—No, air. Q.—-(3lr. Moriis reading from Miss Tarner's tentimony whete sho save sho Leard ‘Lilton taik- ing snguly with his. wifo continged)—Did any- thing of that kind vecur? A.—No, mir, and I never struck her, 84 sho soys Ldid. I never troated her but with kindnesa, I 05 THE UUDSZQUENT CONVEROATION which Besrie 'I'nrer uwears to took place, Inaver nud to hur “Elizabeth is #o used to being foudled that sho judges of other porsons by Lerselr,” Inever fold her thatl Lad scon Beechior and Ny, Tilton have sexual {ntercourse on tho red lounge. ().—She says ufter that yon repeated this eon- veruation nup-stairs, Did vou ank bor up-stairs, u{;fl repent any conversation 10 hor? A.—No, sir, ' Will you describs tho situstion of the rooms iu your bioise ? "Tho witveus desenibed the eituation of the roogms of hiy house, Q.—=\Which roows were fitled up for Mr, Groe- ley? A.—Tue two frout rouma. The front side of tho house, Q.—Whore waa Bersls Turnor's room when she gays you {ook Ler from hor bed? A.—She says ahooceupied tha room next to mine, Ioo- cupied the room noxt to Mr. Grecley's room. 3, —Thoso foldins-doors—wan thére ovor s key tothern? A~Inover caw them locked gince X havo beon in tho Louze. Q.—Aro thiey 3t tho wams condition now aa thoy swero whon Mr, Greoloy was thors # A—I presupio they aro, 'Tho origiusl priut iy on the door, and tho paint ovoer tho lock has nover been thrust avide by the bolt balug turned. Q.—1iow do you know 3tss Turner wasut Kay- port 2 A.--Froim mv correspondouce and lettors Lrecoivod. Miss MoDouald aud 2ies Turner 1aft biefore Mr. Greeloy eame to iny bouda, Aliss “Purner and Miza MeDonald lofs for Keyport oo Monday. Jir, Grooley arrivod 8¢ my liouso on Tueaday. Bonsio T'arner was uok in my housa for ono moment during Mr. Groeloy's visit, 3fr, Civooley lot: wy liouso threo wooks befure Dossio "Purner roturned from Koyport, ).—Did you dictate uby lettors to Misa Tur- ner? A.—I did not dictate or sugiost any writ- ing for Mles Turnor, Q.—DId you over say to Oliver Johuson that you had boen i bod with » woman, aud she bad remaiued virtuous 7 A.—~Nothing of the sort, uir, ),—Did Mr. Beocher ever sit on your kreo aftor Muy, A.~I hozrd Beecher's descrip- tiou of that vecurrence, It taak place nbout ton yoarsago. We biad boen having & disoussior wbout n sentence in a little work I had writton ond that wns the way it ended, No suc’ mmflmllf evor markod"our scquain.ance afte tho troule camo upon our honss. THE TRIPARTITE AGREENENT, Q.—At thu tine of tho arbitration did you heay suything said by ofthor of the arbitraios sbons buruing tho papsry? A.—I did not. Q.—\Vas unything sald boforo v srbitrators in your presauce concorniug your ditlicuttios with Alr, Beechor? A.—I don't rocall anythung of the kind that was said on that subject, Notbing that wus botwoeu we aud Mr. Beochor waain any #ongo reforred to tho arhitrators, Q.—Can you account for the fuct that tho tri- partite agreewont wes dated April 22 A ~Tho first draf of the covenant was made by alr. Wilkoson ou April 2, Chauges in ity termys wero mado by mo and Mr, Bowen, and then it was bandod back to Mr, Wilkeson to bs ungrosecd, and & fow duys aftorwards he & clonn copy of lt,~tho dato und all, Q.—I will call your atlention to aa interviow whichs Witkeson ralstesof your golng/to otico sud steting that Mr, Beockor Lad beon talien caro of, and Mr, Bowen had been taken caro of, but your money had beor paid, and the