Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, January 28, 1875, Page 1

int ok la BR anita one Fi T E sul se i 4 a. mf * mntual consent. ry j dusilo Improved i Che Chitagn Dailn Tribe. VOLUME 28. FINANCIAL. INVESTMENT. BONDS. rv OITy, Wo sont ia Feonae COUNTY, OO PRESTON, KEAN&Co. BANKERS, 100 WASHINGTON-S THE UNITED STATES MORTGAGE COMPANY LOANS small or large sums, in Gold or Currency, on improved : inside’ property. : ALFRED W. SANSOME, Secretary, 7 Union Building. ‘The Mercantile ‘Trust Co, OF NEW YORE, Capital, $1,000,000, eared to, inako loans upon Improved Uity and Are Geehtsy teat Hatato fn Ilinels at curront rates: M, L. SOUDDER, JR., Manager, 108 Dearbora-st., Chicago. MONEY TO LOAN In lorgo sume at 8 a ont anil Opercont por anoum, on ete ‘ADOLPHE LOEB & BROTHER, 12vand 13h Lasallo-st. MONEY TO LOAN On Chicago Real Kstato, improved proforred. MEAD £ OOF, 188 LaSalto.st, NERAL NOTICES. TAX SALE CERTIFICATES, Until February 15, 1875, Tax Salo Certifi- cates of 1874, hold by tho Comptrollor for City Taxos of 1873, can bo redeemed at 215 por cent premium, and Cortificates of prior years at 20 percent premium, On tho ebovo date the rates shall bo increased to 6 ond 25 por cont premium respectively, and on March 1, 1875, tho former will be increased to10 percent promium. Tho holdor of said cortiflcates is now ontitled to 25 and 75 per cent promium respoctively. 8. 8. HAYES, City Comptroller. HeCEs! HCRr: ‘Will fill a fow more Ice Touses with first-class ice, free fronmow, Apply at once to AUGUST SNSIDER, cor, Anilania-at, aud Wostorn-av, vw GROCERIES, IOFFER AT LOW PRICHS Malaga Grapon, Lisbon Parplo Grapes, Chocolute Mignlonottes, Vehesa Ralsins, Froues, Joao Muscatel Ialsins, Zanto Currants, Hus, Citron, Qeshgo Pout Lemon Poel, + Gh . erro Apricots Giketon, ‘Mirahelles Assorted Fruit Ulactes, Brazil Nut Paper Shell Almonds,” Huglish Mainuts, a Filbert Peoun Winter Nollls Panes, Oraty Faster Mucrre Pears, Yn Ghontnuts, Apples, luc Batter, Wortphalia Hame, Groen, & Ugckwelle Plam Luding in mm dhekary Nuts, Apnio itater, Peach Batter, Piekled Mushrooms, aga 4D ‘Tia. MANES, LAQUOKS, ‘and ail surte of GROCERIES 146 EAST MADISON-ST., C, TATUM Wine Merchant, FIRM CHANGES. DISSOLUTION. ‘Tho firm of Hrown & Dohnor fs this day dissolved by Mr. Hi. 8, Brown ratizes from the fitm, having dispoaad of bis entiro intorest to Mr, Gov. Hohner: HB. BROWN, GEO. ROHNEL, 8. B. EATON, ‘Ths hutiness willbe continued by tho remaining part~ ners, Mr. Gon. Hohner and Mr, 8. B. Raton, undor tho Hew putag of GEO, HOHNER & GO., the now firm cok Iccting all tho assets and sswutming all tha Mabliitis of ‘the tirm of Brown & Honnor, GEO, NONNER, 48. Ib. WATON, DISSOLUTION. ‘Tho firm of Piatt, Thorn & Blaynard, Commission Mer- chants and deators io Pig Iron and Nails, ts this day dle solved by nntual oensont. N, B. Pintt and Kdwin Thorn, ander the firm name of PLATT & THORN, will scttlo tho basinuss of tho old finn, and continua the Pig Iron and Nail business at 9 and 11 North Censl-st, 1. N. MAYNARD will continue tho Gratn and Prov. N, I, PLATT, EDWIN THORN, Chicago, Deo, $1, 1874, 1,N, MAYNARD. WITHDRAWAL. WM. RUGER withdrawa from the firm of R. K, BICK- FORD & CU., and his intercet and Mabllity cgase from, this date, {higuo, Jan, 35, 1815. sion Commalision business, The most desirable location in Chicago, situalo at Glurk and Madison-sts. Second, Third and Vourth Floors of tho Hlegant Quilding formorly known as “BROWNS,” And occupied hy HI, M. Kinsley as n Rostau. Font. Well udapted to Insurance, or Hail- Ford Oflices, legantly frescoed, Well hi ly on premises GLOUCESTER IRON WORKS, GLOUCESTER CITY, N. J. WN, Pros. JAMES P. MIVHELLON, MUR, Prous, Wats BEX ONT Bape niladelphia, 6 North Soventh-st. and Water » (ast Iron Flany ingand Steam Pipes, Stop Valves for all aizos, or Gas, FIR EY DHRANTS, Gas Holders, Telescopic or Single, “tee tud Wrought Iron Work of all kinds, for Gas DAVID H. atts 0 Heat. € _ARTISTIO TAILORING. ___ 10 Pr Cent DISCOUNT on ali Garments ordered of us during Janu uary and February, 1676, EDWARD ELY & CO., Importing Tailors, Chicago, IL, ESTABLISHED 1854, LAUNDRY, MUNGER’S Laundry, Pe sae ge a Dearvoreat., BO Michigan-st,, PLYMOUTH’S PARSON. They Are Trying to Make Him Out an Unworthy Shepherd, Moulton’s Redirect and Recross Examinations Con- cluded. Mr. Beecher at No Time Denied the Charge of Adultery to Moulton. Mrs, Bradshaw Placed on the Stand---She Has Lit- tle to Say. Franklin Woodruff Called---Part of His Testimony Objected To. Etohings in the Court-Room---The Kind of a Man Frank Carpenter Is, What Old Man Bowen Might Tell if He Would. YESTERDAY'S TESTIMONY. Special Disyateh to The Chicago Iribuns, New Yor, Jan. 27,.—Blr, Moulton concluded his evidence this morning. It was mainly m ro- ply to questions by which Mr. Tracy sought to eseapo from the position in which witnoes hind placed Lim by asserting that Mr. Tracy, a8 Mr. Beocher's couneol, had urged tho exclusion of certain private letters from Mr, Moulton’s ata:omont. Mrs. Martha A. Bradshaw was thon called, sn introduced —lotters_“ showing that Mr. Boecher advised ler, as woll ag others, to avoid any needless agitntion of tho scandal. Wm. I. Wost, of Plymouth Cbureb, was called to testify to tho fact that Mr. Beecher had angrily opposed the presentation of church charges against ‘Taco- doro Tilton. * ‘THR JAM. Tho snticipationa of tho appearance of new wituesses, and curiosity to know who they were to bo, a8 well oa to hear what they bad to say, filled tho court-room yostorday—as grent o crowd as that which, on tho firet days of Mr. «= Moulton’s testimony, mado tho room uncomfortable. On no day haw tho crowd baen greater or moro attentive. Possibly on none has it boen so undomonstrativo, and, at tho samo timo, more intensely interested, Asaconsequenco, there was perfect order, not- wilhetanding the crush, A few new faces ap- peared among tho andicnce. Mr. 3loulton’s or- doal asa witness cuded atnoon, Mr. Fullerton resigned him to tho bands of the opposing counsel fifteen miuutes aftor tho opening of Court, after having attempted only to gathor & fow fragmontary bity of testimony.’ Tho Tecross-examination was short, but it was also sharp, Myr. Tracy's questions wero prociso, and dolivored rapidly, and Mr. Moulton’s replios woro equally positive, Onoo, for instnnco, Mr. ‘Tracy asked whethor ho (Mr, Tracy) know what Mr. Moulton’a statomont to tho Commnittes was to bo before Mr. Moulton sppeared before the Committoo. 'No," answered tho witness, but you know what you wanted it to bo.” Gen. Tracy asked that the witnoss bo admonished for thus replying, but the Judge unhesitatingly rofusod, nayiug {that the witness bad beon tried and tortured for ton days by counsel on both sides, and bo should therefore be excused without any sort of ropri- mand. - ‘THE MOTTO OF THE MUTUAL FRIEND, When Mr. Tracy asked Moulton for his viows on the marriago rolation, there waa an ovidenco of merrimext on tho part of tho audionco, in apparent anticipation of somo elnguiar viows on the part of tho witness, but he roplied, unbesitatingly, in plain terms: “ Fidolity to your wife, your wife's fidelity to you. If you aro not faithful to your wife, you should bo punished eeveroly, If your wifo is not faithful to you, sho should bo punished oquatly sevorcly.” Of his views on divorce, Mr. Moul- ton said that they wore not fixed, but he did not now that he agreed altogether with Mr. ‘Lilton onthat subject, for he did not know Mr, ‘il ton’s views, UR, MOULTON GETS DOWN AND OUT. After hia examination, Mr. Moulton took a seat botwaen tho witness-stand and tho foroman of the jury, and thero sat until recess, Bir, Moulton was placod on the witness-chair two Wwocks ago to-day, and was under examination nearly oloven days, which amounts to saying that ho was angaged for very nearly forty-four hours in hearing questions and making replies. ‘MMS. DRADSIAW, ‘The eutranco of Mr. Morris hy way of a door leading into an anto-room of tho Court, a fow minnteu before noon, with a strango Jady at hia sido, cuused a marked seneation in the audienco, which was manifostod by tho visible utrotching of nocks and audible whisporings. Bho was pro- vided with » chair by the side of Mr. Tilton, but no eign of recognition passed betweon her and the plainti”, Mr. Beecher was abaout from the court-room, having gone to his honvo to earch for a lottor which tho opposing counsol Lad called for, but Mrs. Beech- er remained, and now gazed tixedly at tho lady, During tho tow concluding moments of Mr, Mouzton's testimony, this lady was tho principal object of intorest in the court-room, ond that in- tercut was heightoned when she was conducted to the witness-chuir, and gave her name, in low tones, aa Mrs. Martha A. Bradshaw. Mrs, Bradshaw is a plonsant-looking Indy of about 45 years of age, vory quiet” and tetiring in ler manner, and ovidently folt the embarrassinont of her position. Sho way dreesed plainly in bleck, and enveloped ina Ulack cashmere shawl, According to her testi- mony, she has been member of Plymouth Church, and has known Mr, Beecher for twouty- two yeurs, and has beon acquaitited with Mfr, aud Ars, ‘Tilton for nearly as long a time. NONE KNEW HER BUT TO LOY HER, Of tho latter, witnous had occasion to say that abo was @ most refined and sweot-minded woman, whom no one could know without loy- ing. As ubo spoko these words, tho yoico of witness, which had before been scarcely audible, sank to's whisper, aud her oyos filled with tears. During her examination, she aat almost immova- ble, with dowacast and toarful eyes, but sho gave her - testimony clearly, | snd without hesitation. In tho varions statements, aud in the oponing addross of Mr. Morrla, great stress wes Isid upon the evidence which Mra, Bradehaw was expected to givo, and, frum time to time pending tho trial, 1¢ bad beon hinted that sho would add inportant documontary testimony to the case in favarof Mr. Tilton. Whon, there- fore, the counsel, after & few preliminary ques- ona establishing her intimacy with both partios to the sult, brought outthe fact that she had had. correspondence with Mr, Heecber on the subjoct, as well os.» verbal statemont from Mr, ‘Tilton accusing Mr. Boocher, it was at once au- ticipated that a communication very damaging to the latter waa about to be produced. Auticipa- tions thus fogniened wero naturally disap ott od at the disclosures which followed. Her letter to Mr. Beecher proved to bo one saking advice CHICAGO, THURSDAY, JANUARY 23, 1875. as to what ho should do in reply to the summona of the Church Gommit- too which wae to try the * West charges” againnt Mr. Tilton for slandoring Mr. Beecher, and ask- ing him to deny Mr. Tilton’s etory to her, that aho might atato what alo would ho compelled to tell the Committee. ‘Throughout the iolter thoro io no intimation that sho helaved Mr. ‘Tilten's story, or doubted Mr, Beecher'a answors or his innocence. Sho assorted, on the contrary, that sho could not but hellove they had been calumniated, and, morcover, added that Mra. Til- ton, while joining in her husband's advice not to appear boforn the Committco as 8 witness against Mr. Tilton, had made no canfersian of her guilt. Mr, Beecher’s reply proved to bo an- other of many Jettors counselling silenco as the bost method of kitling slandors. MAY, BRADAMAW'S TESTIMONY SETTLES THR CARE ACI WAY, An an illtstration of how differently the now mattor impressed tho lawyoers, tt may bo sald that two of plaintiff's counsel united in de- claring that, thera was nothing elvo in tho cave, this correspondence — would bo conclusive of Mr. DBoecher's guilt, while, on the other hand, one of Beocher'a tnw- yor's said bis sido fait ptronger for tho evidence. MR, WEST SLECIFIEA, William F. West, formerly Deacon of Ply- mouth Church, and the porson who made tho charges against Thoodoro Tilton as a member of the Church, was tho first witness examined after the recoas, Mr. West is a mild-looking gentlomun of about 40 yonrs. Hisexamination waa inainly regarding tho manner of his placing his chargosagaiust Mr. Tilton before the Church, and regarding conversations with Mr, Loecher, at which the latter, the witness eaid, tried to make him withdraw or postpone the charyes. THE LAWYENS DO THE LAST ACT. Franldin B. Woodruff, partner of Mr, Moulton, was called at hall-past 3 o'clock, but, after auk- ing hin a few formal quostons, counse) became engarod In an excited debate an to whather the witness should bo allowed to give o detailed ac- count of meotings betwoou Mr. Tracy, Mr. Moul- tov, and himself, at which ‘Mr, oecher waa not present. The councel for the prosecution argued that Mr. Tracy was 8 representative of Mr, Beocher at these meotings, and that Mr. Beocher’s affairs woro the subject discussed nt thom. But the lawyera of Mr. Beecher con- tended thal tho meetings wero held for tho pur- oxo of devising n remody for the injury that Francia D, Moulton’s connection with tho scan- dal was alleged to be doing tho firm. Whilo that discussion was in progress, {he hour of 4 arrived, and the Court adjourned, "0 the Associated 2'xex9,) THE USUAL ATTENDANCE. New Yonk, Jan. 27.—The suit of Theodore Tilton against tho Rev, Honry Ward Beechor was resumed thia morning promptly at it o'clock, be- foro tho naual crowd in the Brooklyn City Court. ‘Two ladios, who entered with tho sssistant- pastor, took the chairs heretofore occupied by Mra. Tilton and her frionds. PRELIMINATY REMARKS. Judge Neilson admonished the counsel that 8 great deal of time was spout in arguments, which greatly delayed the trial, and asked them to ailrise him when thoy dosire to arguo avy aint. i Mr. Evarts explained, supported by ox-Jndgo Fullerton, that tue examination of tho witness yostorday, after ko iad beon informed of tho death of his mother, was at bts own (witnose’) request. MOULTON RESUMES. Tho redirect oxaimiuation of Moulton was re- sumed, and he deposed that at nono of his intor- viows with Becchor did he deny the charges of adultery with Mrs. Tilton. Witness’ attoation wascalied to tho letter written Dec. 26, 1870, and ho was aeked if be had scen this letter bor fore it was given him. He roplied ho had not, Ex-Judge Fullerton said theso were all tho questions he und to ask tha witness. | At this point Beecher and his wifo arrived, and took thoir customary seats, CHOBI-EXAMINED BY GEN. TRACY. Witness was then crose-oxamined by Gen. Tracy, and said: Tho speech made by Theodora Tilton at the Steinway-Lall mecting was not called,to my mind sinco about a fortnight after it was delivered, until I repeated 1t from recol- lection. Here witness’ attention was called to n report of tho epeech in tho World, and ho ro- plied it was like tho spoech made by Mr. Tilton, I think it dufors from tho original in having nothing about ‘freedom of epecch.” Still, on reading the spooch, witnosa eaid: I do not ro- momber him saying that ho believed in her, but Ido recollect tho words, ‘*vouch for hor ;" and Ido not romomber tho hissos which are here, I do not remember btm saying that she would ad- dreps them on tho subject of ‘social freedom,” I dictuted tho specch to Mr. White, who wroto it down, and I kept the manuscript. Witners’ attention was called to tho interview at the Fifth Avenuo Hotel, and ne was asked by Gon. Tracy if tho Icttore he (Gon. Tracy) desired him not to give to the Committee wore uot tho letters of Mra, Hooker—s lotter of John Ifooker to his wifo, anda lottor of Thomas Beecher to hissieter, Witneus roplied, I think not. Ata consultation at my houso tho next morning, Tranklin Woodruff, William ©. Kiogsley, my fatuer, my wifo, and myself, wero present, and it was agrood ag to what papers were to be sub- mitted to the Committos, NOT A FREE-LOVER. Thave talkod with you on the subject of free- love and marriage relations. I do not sympa. thizo with Mrs. Woodhull in her viows. 1 thint: I conversed with people for at least a fortnight on the Woodhull charges after their publication. Iuroply toa direct question, witness sald: You asked ims to koop back a papor of Meary Ward Baccher’s. Witness continued: I am not spread on tho subject of divorce, but have read the Goldcn Age articles on it, {could not tell Mr, ‘Tiltou's son. timents on the subject, Gen, Tracy here announced that these wore all the-squestions ho desirod to ask, TESTIMONY OF MItS, DRADBITAY. Ex-Judge Morris now left the room, and soon returned with a lady, said to bo Mrs. Bradshaw, who took a seat fosida tho ecunsel for tho prosecution, Witness (Moulton) was asked and explained a meeting hold at his house, Lt was connected with an interview of tho previous day at the Fifth Avenue Hotel, which was to determine what documents shoutd be presunted before tho Comnutteo, Moulton thon vacated tho witness-chair, and Mrs. Bradahaw was callod, Sue gave ner name as Margarot A. Bradehaw, aud said: I have resided in Brooklyn twouty- three yoars. My husband's uame Andrew Bradshaw. I om o communicant of Plymouth Chureh, and have been connected with it for twenty-two years, My uamo is still on the chureh-rolf. “I know Theodore Tilton and Mra. Milton, Our families have exchanged visits. Mrs. Tilton has Leen my most intimate friond. I sonorully visited two or three timosa week. 1 wow Mr. Leechor, Ie fraquoutly mado pae- toral viults to my hougo, but I did not very ofton pay social visite to hin house. I saw tho chargos mado by Mr, Wenbagainut Mr. Tilton of slandur- ing Mr. Beechor, Afler thoy were made, I waa assod to bo a wituess with regard to these charges, After ageing the chargey I bad com- munication with Mr, Boccher, I wrote to Mra, Beseher, Judge Fullerton asked for the lettor from tho defense, who waid thoy bad yot lad timo to'ox- aining their papers, but promised to find it as gon as possible, ‘Pho witness continued: I prosorvad a copy, Which I sont to Beocher, and had a letter from Bepehor. [Presonted and identified.) I always considered ‘Lilton's family an ordinarily happy one, I think no ono could know Mrs, ‘Tilton and not love her, I never know of any serious trouble among them up to within three or four yeara—throo years, I think, ‘Tho copy of the Ietter of Mra, Bradshaw was teal in ovidenco, telling Boechor that she had been unmmoned before the Church Committee, and she would AMIDE ENTINBLY BY WHAT HX WOULD SAY, gaktng for an interview, saying that Khzabeth Xt. Tilton bad made no confexsion to her, and directing him to reply. ‘The roply trom Mr, Beecher was also read, ated Oct. 7, 1873, thanking Mra. Bradshaw for hor uote, and stating that sho sould follow bis course and refuse to allow the public to meddle, end that whatover difliculty ind ariven had been amicably settled. ‘Tho witnogs resumed : I did not appear before the Committes to give my evidence. 2 Cross-examination of Mr. Shearman—1 think that after Bir, West had i ese his charges, ho read them to nie, to aco if they were coriect. It Was then a vory short time before 1 srole my fetter. Mrs, ‘Tilton was an_eininently-dovot wif and mothor, During 1869, 1870, und 1871 sha was au devoted ag I have over known hor, I have no spooial remombranco of her dumeanor in the fall of 1863, Iwas acquainted with tho religious views of Mr. aod Mrs, Tilton during these years. I seldom saw Mr. Beacher and Mrs. Tilton togethor then. Thoir conduct at those times was omiuently proper and docorous, ‘Tho defense avnounced that this was all they had to ask the witness, who retired, and the ‘usual recess was taken, TEBTIMONY OF WILLIAM T, WEST. Aftor the recoss, ox-Judga Fullortan called William I. West to the stand. Mo said: Lf am cashier in a bank in Now York, and roside in Brooklyn, 1 was in Plymouth Church from 1870 to'73, and was a meinber of the Examining Com- mittoo in 1870, Mr. Beecher requoxteil to bo ap- pointed 5 committee of one to nee Mr. ‘Tilton af- ter tha Woodbull biography was published. and ho was so appointed. Mr. Beecher reported to tho Committeo having seen Mr. Tilton, that ho Cilton) was in @ critical position; that ho lad had many troubicx, and had been surrounded by bad influences, and he thought Tilton should bo lett to his friends and no ac+ tion taken by tho eburch, I called on Boecher an Noveinbor, 1872, and informed him that he had beon sppointed ons of s snb-committes to BeO a in referonce to his position in tho Woodhull matter. Beecher replicd that ba was vory busy then, but would moet the Committes in ‘shout threo woeks. Mr. Beecher said that this story restod simply on the words of two whores, bat that if any person of responsibility mado thexo attacks, I woul sce how soon ho should dispose of them. I told him Tilton was. ® responsible pordon, and that if he put forth theso stories he should bo exnolled from the chureh, No card was published, to my Knowledge, in. the Golden Age denying thexo charges, ‘Tha next interview with Beecher was on the 27th of June, 1873, when L made charges against Tilton before the Pxamining Committes, The amended charges woe placed before the Committes on July }, 15 When my charges wore submitted to tho Committee, Boccher said tome that I was taking tho right course, but ho thought this was not tho propor timo to submit tho charges, 28 many of the members wore absent in the country. Wiien Boocher spoke to me HI8 TONE WA@ AXORY AND THKEATENING. Bofore I presented the charges tothe Commit. teo i told Beechor their substance, (Mr. Fullerton read the cbargo preferred by Went against Theodoro Tilton before the Com- mittee. ‘fho witness continued: Those charges wero. returned to mo by tho Comuaitteo for amend- ment. Mr, Boecher hud tho same knowledge of the amended charges ax of the former, leading out of tho third specification, [Tho amended charges wero read by Fullerton.] The amended charges woro submitted to the Committee ou tho Qd of Soptamber, 1873, ‘The Committeo adupiea the revolutions on the charges. Witnoss was askod tho nature of tho reao- Intions, but the question was objected to by the dofonse, on the ground that it hod not becn shown that Beccher or witnoss was present. Ob- jection sustajnod, after briof argument. A series of questions which followed were alao objected to, on tho ground that Loecher was ab- sent on the ovcasions referred to. Fnilerton read the minutes of tho Committee containing the resolutions adopted by the Committee. The witness continued: { saw Mra, Brad- shaw, aud ehowed her tho third specification in the chargos, I think this was in July or An- gust, "73. Croas-ezamined by Mr. Shearman: Iremem- ber at the intorviow with Beocher, Aug. 31, ‘73, he said that all THE DIFFICULTIES BETWEEN MIM AND TILTON WERE BURIED, I remembor Boocher distinctly making his report, after his appointment as a committee of one to seo Tilton. I thiok this report was mado iu_ tho early part of Novomber or Decombor, 71. I do not recollect thut Beecher was present at the meeting on Dec. 1, 1871. There nover was auy- thing dona in the matter of Tilton st a public medling. ofjthe Examiniug Consmittes before the eburch. ‘Tho witness waa shown tho minutos of tho Commiltco, and, after refreching bys memory, admitted thot Beecher had not been appointed 1 _ cotnmittee but bad been informally dirocted to visit ‘filton. Uo was olso shown a jiamphlot, but could not rec- ognize it a8 ‘Tho Lifo of Victoriy Woodhull.” Ho said, Leow hor ‘ Life" ou the'acws-stauds, aud heard it talked abont, MR. FRANKLIN WOODRUFF was tho noxt witness called. Ho responded in answer to Fullarton: I am a member of the firm ot Woodruff & Robinson, and partuer of Moul- ton, [remember an interview ut ‘Tracy's ollica between Moulton, ‘Tracy, and myself. We mot in consultation in referopeo to matters growing out of this scandal. ; ‘The witness was asked what took placo at that interview, bnt this was oajected to, on tho ground that Leochor was uot then present, and wlong argument onaued, counrol for the proso- cution arguing that the procecdingn at tho inter- view wore carried to Beecher, and ro bocama ovidenco against him. ‘The argument was still on when the Court ndjourned for the day. Es gh ETCHINGS, A DESPERATE FIOUT TO HE MADE AGAINS? TILTON'S APVEARING AS A WITNESH—WIAT FRANK CARPENTER 16—OUD AD TUL SECRETS ME NOLD‘—HOW Ht WAS IN, ,,TO SIGN THE TRIPARTITE COVENANT. " Spectat Correspondence of The Chicago Tribune, Brdounyy, N, ¥., Jan. 21.—This is our month Nivose, to judge from the abuodant—nay, the suporabundant—snows which havo fallen upon our vexed community, During the whole poriod of Moulton’s cross-oxamination, the skies havo beon weoping, ono day with o noiselesscataclyam ‘of snow, another with forco aud polting ehow- ors of sleot and rain, And that is why, it may be, that so mauy dismal faces, so many marks of deop depression, fill the ampbithaatre in which Eyarta and Beach, Tracy and Fullerton, Shear- man and Moirix, two and two, aro doing yao- man’s work and wrestling before tho curiously indifferent oyos of Christendom. By ‘Tuesday wo aru promived THE RELEASE OE MOULTON from the uusucceastul cork-scrawing of Tracy, upon which surronder the prosecution intend to collect his surviving sonsca and remold them in tho Tilton bohalf. Tho fow spparent dis- cropancies which tho crogs-oxamination estab- iebed, Fullorton’s sharp wit will probably dissi- nd, after a coat or two of the varnish “ro- this historical wituoss will gleam with- out acrack or a thumb-mark upon tho enamel of hia testimouy. Such permanent glazo sa Moulton has brought out of tho oven with bim— of which oven tho furnaces Were of a fury supra- Babylonian—must surely ast bim a lifetime, and afterwards beam through the murk of tradi- tion like a shining monument. At all oventu, so far thoro is no flaw in it upon which the Tracy microscope could be satisfactorily focused, When Moulton stops down and out from the rotatory chair iu which he has posed himee!f five hour a day for a week and a half, either Frank Carpenter or Theodore Tilton will be promoted to that ponitential scat, Despité the injurious effect of such a dovice upon tho jury, there is no doubt that the dofense will DESPERATELY RESIST tho telling of his own «tory by Tilton. . It has beon announced by Shearman that the plaintiff will not bo permitted to tuo the stand, aulans Judge Neilyon's shrewd Scotch head shall entor- tain the potion of ordering to the contrary. ‘Thoro will be a stubborn fight ovep’ this quos- tion, and the fros have beon blazing undor Evarts’ boilers fur a woek, Sach’ a load of steam as that clanking engina: of the law can carry will all bo oxpended in the prospective col- lision, It will be tho climax of the struggle, and the ox-Arbitrator must rush bis client through or burst. ‘That he will entor the hopeless crash with a vast explosion of force, I infor from the simmerlogs anda sputterings which tell of » ragivg aud swelling preparation within him, Bomobody ‘will, in Wilkeson's expressive plraso, keep company with the “Life of Chriut” by “going CED HICUUR THAN A KITE," if all my sugurios are tultilled. That stern old Governor, the Judge, will bang on to the safoty- valve and go aloft with the crowd, tuther thin budgo a judicial inch of his prerogative. ‘I'he tragedy depends upon the exiatonce of an outlot for Livarts' dynamite tomper. If there be none such, he will blow both hinwelf and his case out of court, and thoro will bo no doad or wounded to pigk up. Bo constam has been tho stream of adverto rulings and othor disappointmonts, and with euch strange ill-grace has Evacta received thom, that I look every day for tho catastrophe which I have outliued. Jf, indeed, on or about Friday noxt, Frank Carpenter takes tho stand instead of ‘Tilton, then the faith{ul are likely to be surprieed by a reat shook. ‘ho Beocherlan attorneye—notably he diligent Shearman—bavo all along blown upon their horas derisive tow to the conilng witness, hailing him In advance as an addle- pated person, a mirchievour, intormoddiing vis- iunary, a transpsrent jolly-fieh of a man, shak- on by hia own indecision, and trembling with inental infirmity. ' ‘The cuntradiction of this contemptuous prom- ino WILL DF DRAMATIC. Carpenter im oxnctly tho oppostte sort of crenture,—soft-voiced, but hard-hoaded; amia- ble, but resolute; courteous, but iniloxible, Mo in not the cynical homme dea affaires which Moulton is, uta rare typo of gentleman, gifted with arich mind, a vigoroua brain, and aa white aroulas over glowed it human’ broast. Him truthfulness is instinctive, and if, in hin ex- perience of Tilton, there aro iuclnded deaparaging reminiaconces, allof thom will ba placed in tho scales with a calm, religious, serupulosity, He has a child's faith in the tremendous attributes of God, aud, thorefore, a child's abhorrenca of a lic. Hin personal appearance 16 no frank, 80 winning, 6 utterly devoid of all outward signs of mondacity, that it will make an immeuiato and favorable impression upon tho jury. Last night [ mot one of the numerous Bowens entangled in tho complications of this case. It was one of the eons of due Bowen whom, after lit- erally building Plymouth Cburch, its more de- voted worshifers propos to offorup aga burit- offering and a vmoke-offering on its crumblung altar, Tho Tilton faction had subpanaed “OLD MAN BOWEN," ‘a wo call Lim, but, for some reason, he will be deniod the opportunity of exposing to the world alt tte dreadful history which is compressed within his scraggy bosom, ‘Liaore is no doubt that he hates both Beecher and ‘Liton with 5 magniticent hatred, bog held back from tha firing of their unctuous pera by an inspiration wich must steam up from Satanic furnaces. Ho bas an undiecoverable his terribte specchicesners. In bis lous, thin head is hidden the key to othor Eleusinian mysteries than that which twelve mon are risking their sanity to solve in tho City Court, Mo stands at the door of s charnel- house, with his cadaverous finger on his lips, and upon his tongue the icy silence of the grave. More confidcncos, more secreta, have been whinv- oled into that human eepulchre than could the breast of auy other living cronture contain. Ho is a pravestono ander which aro thodead of many tragedios, but upon whose faco there is nots single epitaph. On the Last Day, when the earth shail vomit forth its cornscs and the sea givo up its dead, then Houry ©, Bowen will have to yieltl the ghastly tenents of his brain. He i+ Beecher's motive for GAUNT NEMECTS, dogging him mutely with the constant shadow of Death: writting tsce tu faco with him and look- ing into his oyes every Sunday; sharing tho facramontal elements with him in the Holy Com- munion; aud knowing his secrets with & knowle ego possible only to his victim, aod their God. When Beocher looks down from his platform into that sepuichral face, what phantoms aro they which weil up in spectral procession from Bowen's yes? Bowen knows. Leocher kuowa. Some great bond unites Beecher and Bowen, ‘What that bond may be, the keonest intelligenco, the most persistent search, inv failed to dis- cover. Boren has publicly said that ho can, when he liken, drive Leecher out of Brooklyn. How did he schiove that tremondous influence ? Why as ho desisted from applying it? Bowon has more than ones opened his jaws, and let a mephitic story oscape from tho vault of which they ato the portals. Tho Plymouth party insist that they must be falso, because Bowen, in tho famous ‘Tripartite Covenant, withdrow all that ho bad over alleged against Beechor,— though, indood, after tho signatnre of that doc- ument, ho was only silent, aud never tho apolo- gist of his pastor. But Bowen’s gon toro that strange coronant INTO A THOUSAND STITS when he told mo, Inst night, that tis father ab- solutoly, aud with anger, rofused to sign tho paper when dtr. Beecher’s agents laid it beforo him. Evary artifico was employed to induco a cancellation of his testimony; but Bowen ro- mained obdurate, At last, Horace B. Clatlin, his old and trusted fend, personally implored him to sign it,—reminding him of tho fact that, won. owen was once on the verge of utter and final bavkruptcy, he bad stepped forward and carried LEGISLATUB Mr. Speaker Haines Again Becom’> fractor>. & He Shows Beyond Doubt His Rare Incompetency. The House in Confusion---Ab- surd and Tyrannical NUMBER 159, adhorenta then apponted to Halpin, Hise, Her- rington, and tho other Democratic loaders, now that the Repuilicans held Haines to his original position, ho ought lo be sustained, Iulpin wos ths first to yield, and, aa ho stated to Tis TrinuNe correspondent, nover cast so reluctant a vote. Ho rase and changed his vota to nye. ‘The aununncoment of the voto was datayed for the’ others to bo brought round to stand by Hainea, One by ono tho leading Democrats who lind not atood by Haines on tia appfication of the gag yielded, Hise last, ‘The previous questicn was ordered by 7 tofl nocd, and Merritt's substitute was thon carried. One result of this perlormnucs was that, for oure. a majority hed been brought to stand by the Spealor, MUCH DISORVER OFFER TNE LOUISIANA RESOLU- TIONS. That accomplithed, pursnant to the Rrammo decided upou at tho Tndopone dent caucns last night, the Louisiana, midiguation —rerulutions’ wero Apring — tpon the “Hor ‘These, ombodying the Louisiana i ayes proe Rulings. A Set of Louisiana Resolutions Passed by the House. No New Developments in Wisconsin or Minnesota, Both Carpenter and Ramsey Sure to Be Defeated, Gov. Randolph Elected Senator from New Jersey. After Votes from Nebraska and Michigan. REGULAR PROCEEDIN ILLINOIS, THE FOOLISUNESS OF IIAINES, Srecral Dispatch to The Chicago Tribune, Sprisqrieup, Il. Jao. 27.—Speaker Haines is moking a mess of {t bere again. Le began by training his Jodependents so wondrous flue that they reached with altitudiuons indopendenco thot they would do nothing save accopt what tho Democrats woul offer, and wouldn't take it then, ‘unlegs it wero by much the larger half, Haines duly oppropriated the larger balf, the Speaker- ship. Taatdone, Maincy began with appoala to the Indopenderts to stand by him in bis rulings, right or wrong = From then until now he bas been insisting that ho be stood by. He kept! in- sisting, and finally, uuder threat of going over to tho Republicans if tho Indepondonts didn't stand by him, the latter did staud by Lim to tho extent of reluctantly passing the caucus resolutions approving his rulings in tho Jones of Jo Daviess affair, aud pledging taemeelves to stand by him in his future rulings, Then Canunings, Hise, Herrington, and othor Democratic lenders, having expressed their disapproval of tho Speaker {in one instance, be insistod upon it that they should stand by hiro, aud succeeded in getting their eignaturos to tho card affiming that they ateo stood by the Speaker, and wotlt stand by the Speaker. [Tie catd of tho Vemo- crate ia published below.} This morning they all Democrats and Iudependents, cawo into the House pledged to stand by the Speaker, and tho work of standing by tho Speaker began, him ovor the chasm, Bowen, at tho time, in his profound gratitude, pledged himself to Claflin, with the solemnity of 2 Hobrew; and it was upou tho redemption of that pledge, by the subscrip- tion of his signature to tho Tripartite Agrce- mont, that Claflin at Isst inelated, Bowen re- deemed his pledge, and elgned the covenant. ‘Tilton signed the samo extraordinary compact to eave his wife and children from the awful ex- postiro which culminated in the current trial. What may bo tho preciso valne of an agrec- ment thus concoived and brought forth iss problom which T leave to be solved by the un- doubted financial gonius of Plymouth Church. Docrou Srxtax, —-— BEECHER'S CREED, Afaper printed iu Richmond, Ind., publishes sletter from Henry Ward Boochor, lately re- ceived by the Roy. I, UWughes, of that city, in which the pastor of Plymouth Church gives hia ‘yiews on certain doctrinal paints at considerable length, Among other things he soys : T believe that all men aro born into imperfectior and that a2 soon as intelligent action begins they fel into ein, and that no man over kept tho law of God with afl hfe heart aud mind, nor even with any ringle faculty, I bolieve that all men need a moral ‘revoin- tion, & chunge of heart, and that auch change, while it involves man’s own will, ls alo, and otfectutally, the reault of God’s apirit, Tholleve that tno Moly Spirit blesses parontal cxamipie ond teaching, in aowio eases, 40 that tho children are brought by the Divine Spirit into the Christ life at a very early pariod, and even without avy conscious chango—but, early ‘or late, tho hunian soul does not risa into » spiritual character ‘without the quickening and nourishing influence of Goil'a “Spirit, Dut 1 believe sud teach ine cersantly that conversion i only change, but not ebarscter, ard that Christian pracex, experience, habits, knowledge, sre tho results of du: eation in the Divine lifo; that, upon entering upon a Christian course, avery’ one becomes a scholur of Christ, aud, Wko acholara cf bunan kuowledze, learn by the' normal une of thelr faculties ; that dally honso- hold dutics, business carey and ditics, apecial rola- Hong, and the whole flow of ancular life, is the scliool Ju which God drills nen as really as in the closes or in tuo church; that tho whole of life ta, in the handa of tho Davina Spirit, a means of grace, ¥ differ with my brethren of the Evangelical Churches in aome details, Dut moro yetin tho philosophy by which the facts of Zellgion ato to be explained ; but Yam st hearty egreo- ment with them fn the Divizity of Christ, the Trinily, tho Hinfulnasa of Man, tho Univeral Need. of a Changa of Heart, of the Holy Spirit as the Eiicient Agent in Couversion. Y ani writing amid the excite hicuts and’ occupations of a trial waich fy now going om, aud cannot take tune for more than a hasty #iato- meut, — THE WEATHER, Wasurcrox, D.C., Jan. 27.—In the Upper Lake rogion, the Upper Mississippl and Lower Missouri Vaileys, and the Nortiwest, clear or clearing wesather,and higher barometer in the firet two districts, but varlable winds snd slight changer in tomperature aad baromoter in the wo last. LOCAL, ODAERYATIONS. Uurcado, Jan, 27, 4300 p 353 p_ n1,}29,65} 1,00) Calta, 40; S1/N, V ‘94 Station, | Bar. Uhr; Guiro..o.,./29.8¢} 63,8, 1, light,.| 9.03] Foggy, ‘Cinclansti,./20.80/ 45/Calm ia ese! Fougy: c! }.7U] 15/3, W., gentlel,,...| Falr. ay[N._W,, trea Threat’ning, Giouay. SiH, B,, wontle,|: FA DOIN, freah Gloudy, Cloudy, Light rain, Cloudy, iClear, idght snow, +03)Light snow, SM Poagy. Jet +49) | MISCELGANKOUS, Osaua, Nob. Jau. 37,—Tho thormomoter Lag fallon 23 degrecs within the past twenty-four hours, with Indications of being still colder. OHIO BILLIARD TOURNAMENT. Crevetand, O., Jan, 27,~In the billiard tour- nanient to-day, Mullon beat Coleman by a score of 200 to 74; winner's average 62-33. Mon- ing beat Ohoate by a score of 200 to 129; win- nor'a average, 319-32, Gallaghor br bys ecore of 200 to 83; winuer's sverage, 6 8-16, atoher beat Blulm by ry wore of 300 t0 131 4 winner's average, 8 1163! The Committee on Contingent Exponses, to'which hsd boon reforred the rosolution re- citing that the pay of the Spenker’s clerk bad beon fixed at 6 per day, when it was supposed to be but @4, and requiring that, within threo days, the said clerk be discharged, reported recommunding that the resolution do not pass. Dunlap, Moore, snd Holmes, of the Commit- tee, made a report recommending the adoption of the resoultion. Motion was mado to substitute the minority for the majority roport. Motion was made to table that motion, and tho Domocrsts alnod by the Speaker aud tabled the motion to substitute by 74 to 63. Jones, of Jo Davicsa (etriclly conforming to the letter of the parliamentary law now), entored a motion to reconsider, but was cut off from tho floor, Cummings, now in tho ebair, having awarded it to Albright. Tho latter moved to strike out Bo much of the majority report as tixed tho pay of tio Speaker's Clerk at $6, aod to make it #41 per day. In support of his motion, Albright stated that ho made it at the request of the Spoaker. A tondency to filibuster had been manifested on tho other aide, and to muke buncumbo capital out of ¥2 per day. ‘Tho pravions question was called by Tandra- gon (Ind.) on Albright’s amendmont, when tho Spoakor (Cummingr in the chair) ruled that tho amondment of tho report of the Committoo was not in order. Merritt then offered the following mubstitnto : Keaolved, ‘That the Speaker's clerk be pate $4 por day and uv more, MAINES OBTAINED THE ¥1.00R on the substitute, and began by atatiug that he had not asked for s clerk ; had always hereto- foro employed his own private secretary; aud bad oxpected to do «0 again. He had not known that the pay of hia clerk had been fixed at 6. By Iaw it contd bo but €4, and he had himsolf notutled the Audit- or that that emonnt was all that could be paid. Ho had not, as had been chargod, slgued the pay- rolls for €6 por day for hia clerk. Ifo then pro- ceeded to delivor bimsolf of « most bitter iuvec- tive ugaingt the Ropublican side. Ifo chargod that in this matter thoy pleaded tho baby act, confessing that thoy had yotod for a resolution withoat knowing what it moant. lio ebarged that the contest over this #4 por day, now that the majority had offered a resolution to suve it, was part of the achomo to hinder the businoss of the House by pointloas parliamontsry points, Busiuces had been eo delayed, and tho public press had inflamed against him, and it was now current throughout the State that tiv Speaker ob- structed buainces, Ho desired to muko it known that overy day (excepton one day, whon tho gentloman from Jo Davioas had obstruct- ed business) tha, Lusinogs on tho Speuk- o's tabla bad been yholly cloared up before adjournment. As he procosded he grow more bittor, referring to the Ropublican sida ad the minority represonting nobody and not knowing what thoy did, charac.eriziug the par- liamentary points made from time to time on that wido herctufore a4 unsble in bad faith to obstruct business, or in ignorance of what thoy meant, After having dolivered himself of tho bitterest invective and most taunting satire upon the Mvpublicun sido, he concluded with the gar- donio obgervution that to wave timo aia provent further obetruction of business, ha wi move the provious question op the substituto+ YELLS o¥ “cowsnD!" anv utystiE rose from the Iepnblican side, membersborang: to their feet and yellal Coward!” gre ty and, cat-calls were heatd; but Haines, who had ro- mained stauding, wslsted upon iis call of the previous question ‘The ayes aud 1aye wero called, Sloriington, Hise, end othg‘Domovruts, voted ageinot sua taluing the cal whon thoir names were reathad, ‘Atnidat grost confusion Maines now rose and sald that, of tt way tho wish of that wide (Oppo. tition), uedovired to withdraw his call of” the previous question, - Objection was made by the Republican sido, andthe wll-eall procoeded. Other Domocrats and Indejoudents fuflod tostand by tho Bpeater, and voteduo. Halpin, Hise, aud the reve wera pot staniug by the Speaker in his attenipt at an enforcement of the gag-rules, Haines’ offer ta withdraw bis demund of the provious ques- tlon was truse, Objootions were made on the Republicin alde to she withdrawal, and Maines’ indignation whorewith Haizea bad been bursting, and which were written by bim, wore offered by Turner, {ndependent, of Jo Daviess. Thoy wero as fulioy Resaived, UW State ot Ith tue authority, or ite Jncal affairs of a Bi exeeptin the meter ja the United Siater, aud Kemtreat, Toot we regard the growtt of military ine e within the United a4 fransht Sith ’ ailleer Rhowld laien to bo paraesty 4 to bo adoptod, and 7 ollicer of the Army fiat Congre violate (ue Cunstititios et the inws ino. to plea uuy portion of the parple of the United tates within the coutrel of tie militai 8.18 clare itto Loths right of all ct States to be protected in erty and, their rights condom all rovulii= and eutal order, ure the Preritent of the dmiuistration for nuiutalning «oral authority in ties the su-cuiled Kellogg Government, fn ope to te will of ihe peuple ns expressed at the | -bix, and crpoctally do wo condeiit the Deesidout for periuitting Federal trooys to intertere with the or lou of the Legislature of that Stato ou the air january, 1975, constlering thers acts atest und dalgezous invaninos of the tliahts of the people aud subveraive of Sepublican inetitation, STUENUOUS RESIBTANCE TO A VOTE ON THE RESO- LUTIONS. Forthwith a half-dozen Republicans sprang to their fect to inove the tabling of the resulutiuis, Jack, of Macon, who bad been rtanding dur tho reeding, demanded tho previous ynestio anndst groxne and iiseea from the Hopublican side. Jack anid ho did it to cut off amendmen%s, not to ent of debato. Clatlin rose ta a point of ordor, read the rulo that » motion to table took proecdence of tho de- mand of the pravious question, aud moved to table the resotutions. Haines, who bad now resumed tho clinir, miiwl that Clatlin, Lavin obtained the floor on a point uf order, could rot make motion to tabie, and ordered tho roll-call, ‘Tho ayes and ma; ine been do macdod on the demand fer ine pr tion, a dozer ‘mowbors yelled, “dir. Spes: Me recognized none, hammered with bis ¢ ani ordered tho Clerk to proceod. with the roli- call, Amidst great excitement tho voto wes taken, andthe demsnd of the provieus question wes subtzined by 75 ayes Lo 70 uays. Dlotions to ade joura were made in succession by ford, Downing, and Clailin. Tho Speaker re neither, and ordered the mun question. Clatin remained standing, renewed hiy motion to adjourn, and denounced ag mfamous tha gag rule performance, Joues, of Jo Daviess, attempted to get the floor. Nor wontl iho Speaker recognize him, and Lolh Clailin and Jones ro:naiued” standing, both claiming the floor, tho Speaker repping with his gavel tho while, and ordering tho Clerk to procoed with tho rol: 5 Claflin remained standin, and shouting “ Mr, Speaker 1" in the effort to force a recognition. “Tue gentleman from Maeou has tho iloor,” yelled baci: peaker. Clatlin remained stand- ing, claiming the floor, Joucs also was on his feot claiming, the floor. Downing suoved to adjourn. Wholly disregard= ing this, the Spaaker yetiod again : “Tho gentlo- mau from Macon ine the floor.” Jouea esked how Jack could have the flovr on as enll of tho ayes and noes. ‘Tho Bpoaker hammered furi— ously with bis gavol, and aunounced that the gentleman from Macon had tho floor, and calicd. attention to tho fact that the gentleman from, DuPage (Clathin) was obstructing the proceed- ings. Did tho House desire to take action in that regard? Tho Republicans waited for a mo- tion fora voto of censure on Claflin, but nono was mado, and tho Spexker ordered tho roll-call to be proceeded with. Starr demanded a divie- ion of the question. After more uproar, the di- vision was allowed, aud the Speaker orderod a Yote on the first resulution. Jones, of Jo Daviess, movod to table the first. resolution, The Speaker refused to reco; ; him, ruling that tue provious question having heon ordered, the motion to table was cut olf. Jones temained standing and claiming the floor. Jo asked if he was out of order, Haines, as tho other duy, wouldn't rule Jones out of order, but ordered tho roll-call to be proceeded with. Oth- er momber# rogs on both xidos aud shouted at the top of their voices “Mr. Speaker,” and tho din grow tromeudous, After moro hummer- ing of his deak with the gavol, the epenbtt roxo and invited tho attention of tho House to tho fact that the gentleman from Jo Daviess was obstructing the bueinoss of the Hfouso, Mernit moved a vote of consure, and the uproar aud tumult grow indeserivable. Halt tho members rose, and all were shouting at once. ‘The Spoakor put the motion for a rosolution of cennure. Tho ayes and nocs were domanded, Without heeding this, lo put it viva voow. ‘Tho vexponse in the aftirmativo was faint. Ho did not put tho negative, aud ordered tho roll-cnit on tye adaption of the first resolution, ‘ YOFINO ON THT: RESOLUTIONS, When the namo of Hammond, of Stark, was Teavhed, bo sald, as ho held there bed beon no military interferenco in Louisiana that was not according ta law, ho should voto aye. Other Lopublicans took this view, and voted ae- cordingly, tho result boing 132 yens to 7 nays. ‘The vote was ordered on tho second resolution. Hammond, of Siark, moved to table tt. With- out regard to Hummond’s motion, Haines put tho question on the second resulution vive voce, and devlered it lost. Tho yeus and nays woro then demanded, and ordered by tho Speaker. Aasrott, of Jeforson, who had not voted wheu his namo wascalted,rowo atid avkod leave tuosplain hig votv. ‘Iho Speaker ordered the roll-call pro- ceeded with, Miller. of Cook, whon his uamo was called, said ho belivved the resolution ac- cording to the Constitution, and voied ayo, It came tho turn of Miva, of Ozle. Ho rose ant eaid overybody know the resolution way o thrast attho President and Sheridan, He bad ore couttdonce fu them than in mon who fought on the other side, (Checrs.| Ho shonld vote no, When the namo of Wilvox of Saugamon, was called, ho roso to explain, ond seid he had ‘fought on the Unton sido, but had confidence in the ability af tho people to rulo themselves, and should vote ayo, ‘he sco- ond resolution wis adopted by 77 ayos to 62 noes, ‘The third resolution was put and yoted for viva voco on tho Nopublicun sfdo, ‘The ayes aud noos were demanded from the Domocritio sido, and tho resolution was adopted by 197 ayos tolno, Tho fourth resolution was then put ou tho uyes and noes, Boveral membors oxplaiued: their votes. | Wnat was most to the point was said by Bticknoy, of Cook,—that it was not tho buwiness of tha Houvo to moddle with Foderal polities, Ma hoped tho Monge could devuto itwelf to the busl- ness properly befora it, and on that account yoted no. ‘Phe fourth resolution was carried by 74 ayau to 67 noes, ‘tho uays, with tho excep- tion of Stickney, Indopondent, ‘bolug all utraighs ipo hice ‘fhe wholo resolutions wero then adopted by 73 yeas to 67 nayu, Mr, Merritt moved that tho resolutions bo tele~ graphod to Souator Logan with tho roquest that thoy bo road inthe Sonate. ‘The Speaker put tho motion viva vovo, though nearly forty lto- publican momboru called for the yoas and nays, aud declared it carriod, though, from the sound, the motion waa either lost ov the result was very doubtful, ‘Ehus did the Iu. lependents und Democrats, for ouce, etand by Haines, and to-night tae leading Democrats and Andependouty are disgusted with him, and with thomuelves, and ave tm in tho determination nover ugain to wtaud by him or anybody else in such performances us those of to-day, as com- pared with which tho circus-uhow heretofore bag been 8 model of decorum, A printed anop;mous circular was every Senstor to-day, which way injure Mr, William 1 fa anal tu opyuritin to Poti 4, Hesuived, That we cow United Btutes and i DUK Qnes= received by intended ta° Harper, Grain-Loapeoter