Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, November 2, 1874, Page 7

THE CHICAGO DAILY TRIBUNE MONDAY, NOVEMBER 2 1874 kl _— ‘grm ot $1,07. Corn firmer: yollow, 8@00; mized }’;Mrn,aafif Ot mprovinig at 63@3 FprnoLrys—Lower and nomiunlly 104@10%s fo refimad § 8@ ‘g for cendo n bulk, 850 fn varrols, Winisky—Fitm at $101, Yiorseu—Dasiors Woslern choleo city, 30@3203 8, 33@34c. o 3 Gtot and firm; Westorn, 1003 prime, G184, Soos~Lasy; Weatern, e, o DALTIMORE, Bavrmone, Oct, Ul—lLoyn—Dull etinugods Giiisx—TWheat dull and unchanged, Corn quict] mixed Westorn, lc 3 held at 83GA&I ; white, 80@#30, Oata dulls mixed Wontern, B8(@67c; while, G0@U0C. Tiyodull and uncbanged, Provisoxw—Tork nominal ab $21,00@22.00, Bacon —Suoulders firm at Ble@sdie; ciear vib dull at 1350, Tard—Defined, 15 GLLLE TwriEn—Dill ahd wichanged, vrgk—~Eirm ot 19@:0)¢, Wittasy—Dull snd nomfin at $1,00, BUFFALO. Doresto,Oct,OL—~Dnyabstirra—Wheat—No. 2311 waukeo clilh offercd at 7. Corn quist ; salcs, 1300 Dbu No, 3 mized Western at 82c, Oate neplect o negieeted, Barley quiet, 2 TnEfQuTs~Wheat, Uco: corn, Blic. + OLAWELAN and wne Ve , Oct, Bf,—Unaui—hoat steny and wnchanged, Corb—-Now {0 raquest and unch. ged ; ol DIul Satsod whalled fT7e, - Outa sloady and uii aaged, PErnoLEns—Sleady; standard whitt, car lots, D)gc, Obt Bata ot Tace ] mall way, @20 higter, 5 Trorirza—Wheat, 1,400 buj corth Bidlt buj oats, 1,360 bu, MARINE. o e Port of chlemw].( ‘g‘n,x 31 and Nov. 1. ATRHIVE arcta, Dafloy Tlarbor, tellor posta, ook, Manintee, lmbory Belir Johu Mbier, Qconto, lumber, Hebr U|1ul|xlngu£rfi‘lfi\;:l;gél,;;‘x;’x‘h i Shicago, Ma ) o, e e aylor, Ford Tiver, lumber, Bebr Jierala, Saniaico, lumber, Bebe Ltlian Allen, Megoniinec, lumber, Eehr Driver, Corlton, woody #Bobr James Norrls, Kinenrdiie, salt, el Edward Blake, Totonto, hurlcy, Prop Ira IL Owen, Bicaanba, fron ors, Eclie Jesslo Linn, Tecanaba, iron oro, Bobr Mosello, Alanec, railfoud bies, felr Ellen Spry, I'engaukes, lumber, Behr Flying atist, Menoninee, hwnb Bebr Neciprocity, Blenomiuee, Jumber, Behr Imporial, anominee, Himber, Cark Nalud, Otonta, lumber, Helr Groat Wost, Odonto, Tumber, gelir O, L Jobifon, Munkegon, lumber, Prop Moliawk, Bustaio, eundelds, - Belr . M. Davideon, Clevelaud, coal; Belir David A, Wells, Grindstons City, grindatones, Fobr Prumou Moss, Little Sturgeon, touar posis, Bl A. M. Beers, Greets Bay, fumbér, Selir Skyiatk, Grien Bay, luider, ebr Jolin Tibbelw, Munistee, lnntber. Selir Tyvo Brothiery, Matlated, lumbse, Sclur Ifana Grocker, Pensaukice, ltmber, Schr Ralelgh, Ludingtot, Iumber. el Jello Walbridie, Scargeon Lay, lumbar, Selir Iuduatty, Baugatuek, hunber, - Echir Potomat, Kyg Harbok, oedat poste, chur Bello Mubwcom, Duitalo, coal. gebr 1. . Bientloy, Buitalo, Cosl, Sebr Pathtinder, Clevelind .fiv:l o drom, o n £ilir Gralm Dok, Groe: Trop Mayllower; Doy Oll, e Trop Anivie Young, Exe, eundtice, Prop Geowe Dunbir, Miskeyon, limbor. Dack Favrite, Alpenis, lumbor, Bchr 8. R, Watson, Clicbuyga, lumber, ficr I\, toville, Alyons, Yamber. sickr Forrest, Gioon Iny, fanber. Belir dFary Colline, Duncin City, lmbsr. Tharge Sonorn, Meomince, luntber, Tlarge T, . Reotaan, Mendminon, lumber, Bax o Whillws, Alcnominee, il Bazigo Meuchuhiee, enomiuce, Iimbir, Bage Lo 1. Tyan, Menoiiice, (umber, Bargo Ira 8, Robison, Aenominee, lumber, Trop Favorite, Mononiinee, sundrics, Behr Jamco Couch, kiriey cual. Bebr Willivm iy, Buduld, coal, Prop elelum, Buiialo, coal. 3, 11, Lt 1o, coal, Eebr Kalstod, Buftalo, coal. Salir Aunko Vougle, Erie, coal, Febr Nevada, Oaveiro, coil, bite, Oswego, Toflrond dron. DBlake, dacksonport, cedur posta, asudrico, Trop Cu} Ll Tachion, Rivor, lumber, Selit Georgo Slierinan, Cleveland, pig-ron, Selr Marda Martln, Etle, casls r Muskegun, Muslegon, sundrica, R, A, durton, Ucout, tniber, CLEARED, Sehie William owme, Kingatou, 19,653 but wheat, e Argonaut, Buitalo, 94,116 bu oats. e M. J. Wileox, Dufialo, 22,000 bu wieat, ebir G, 8, Nazurd, Bufalo, 55,000 bu wheat. Selir C, I, Windeate, Buffalo, 21,600 Lu corn, Sebr Black fawk, Lincoln, %00 bu coru, 100 brla flour, 120 brle bieef, wnd sandvles, Scbir €, B, dones, Butfalo, 53,£00 bu wheat, Stmr Culeago, Manitowor, sundrics, Scbr Souvenir, Pentwater, 1,600 bu vate, 10 tons fecd, und imirien, L, Jubuson, Muskegon, 15 brls pork, 15 bris c. e % Prof Moluwk, Butfalo, 10,440 bu carn, &30 brls flour, 191 Lizs cheenc, €0 by pork, aud wuiidrice, Schr Duncan City, Ditnean City, 590 brls fiour, rop M, Grob, Manistee, 200 ba'cors, 600 b oits, 6,000 LFiel, 10 bris beaf Beirr Twllight, Kingstan, 12,662 bt wheat, T'rop Intcr-U -eits, Butfalp, 72,230 Lu oats, Schz I, &, Hulchinson, BufTaio, 50,000 bt corn, aplon, Bivifalo, 35,600 bit v Hebr North Btar, Wuskegon, 1,100 bu oata, Drop ‘Waverls, Duftalo, 10,000 bu wheat, 1,100 bris four, 400 aecks oil cake, 500 bage sced, 25 bales Liay, 43 tons pig iron, nufo Young, Buifafo, 510 pigs lead, Frop Aunio Younts, Lric, 1,500 bels flou, 200 bags flax recd, undrits, And twebty-oue vessels cleared light, Tiake Freizhts, Afew cliarlors wero mado at 4c for corn and 4o for whoat tn 1infialo, They wero: Sclirs Champion, X, €. Hutchisson, and Ozar, corn at dc ohr Windiate, corn_on_pri echr Huzard, wheat at 4}j0. To Prescott: E, I, Diake, corn at 82, Total, 0; capseity, 30,000 bu wheat and 100,000 i corn. Ty tho afiernoun the schr David Stowart was talon for 000 Lu_wheat to Baffalo at 43¢, and tho fihra Woolruff, Nimrad, and D, £, Bafley for about 120,000 bu corn at 1/c (3n'advaneo of J5¢) to Bullelo, Miscollaucous, ] atticauo. Trers wers fifteen luwboi-laden vessels at ihe maniel last evenieg, . —Iho selir William Grandy, which hos beon ashore at Tucine Reof, arrived hero yestorday morning leak- lng badly, Sho had twe sleam-pumps on_board to keej lior flout, Sho hau leon taken to the Gas Works %0 wnload ier cargo of coal, —Capt, Jobn Rice, Mariuo Ins, Fyel in tho city yeslerday (o Ioa af tlo sebr William fimmlx'l. —A dispateh recelved bero yestorday afternoon stats thut the sehr Melvina, on her way from Oconto 1o {Ma city, went aehoru at tho naouth of Green ey, Thoprop Xua Laura luft horo aat evening to pull ik a1, § roustilo. Sl wator in tho rivor was 8o Jow lnat Saturday s 1o sp the bargea Inter-Ocean and Argonant from got- ngout, They clésred yeatorday moruing, o selrs Amorica, itate Darlcy, Golden West, nnd Geclprocity, went into winter quarlers last Baturda. LLSCHUENE, Tho acow-schr Williem Yanatla ia reported nshore betneen Clovelend aud Fairport, —flio scur II. B, Mooro, from Chicaro, lght, Sor Pentnater, went ushoro Priday nlght bolow Lo Nowl River, whera it lies high and dry. . : it Detroit, Thursiay, duriug the gale, a smal wood ucow, tied up noar Hlio water-works, broka oo, and xas driven ocbora &t Bolle Tsle, and another 1 pur o stave-vorksgiwau Ladly damiged by pound ng sgultet tho wharl, "_1 shiort e ago, when off Onfonagon, the &t Maph Leaf was catght iu a gale, and came very n e Foiog mabore. In order to kavohimeell, tho Capt tln 1 tor at Buflalo, ar- afler the {nterests hrev off nearly 16,000 fect of plane and 50,000 ob in- ylex, After the siorm she returned to Buyfield for ixo- Gthe: deckload, . cupt. Grunimond, at Dotrofty manned tho tug Wity low vith two steam pumps and othor wreckivg apiue ratu), sud stasted out with the ownor of Ly vessel, Batwrday morning, to visit the zche Thomes P, S - don,izmded below Bar Pot, Lako Ere. Tho wad, 1t v thought, had aufliclently subsided o commen oo —ho prop Dradbury took firo in the bLow at pay Cly, during the Ralo Wedneaday, from 2 apa:dc {ros tug. Slo was run up to the dock, bowever, atul o e esisguied beforo any groat damage wexs ong —ho wind yesterday played havoo with the ahip: pingin tuoriver, Sovernl ‘Yexecls went ashioro or g% agrowd, Tho wind camu so nearly down tho river ra 10 Ll tho waler into the lake, loworing the water vers grealy, Should the wind contiiue towday from the swm¢ quarter, serlous results must follow,—2'lecio Contnerelul, i —Tho atem bargo V. Awain, which trades betwoers Oloviand and Lake Suporior fu_tho oro trade, (o~ gethe with her cousort, the A, 0. Maxwell, got ashoro’ Gn Peho Tskand Thursday dusing tho bilght of tho gnlopud are roported burd on, ‘Che stwamer fral Weutashors and the vesrel soon ‘afierward, Noither arc laldug or likely to sustain eerious daurago seids’ Iromdaloy aud tho orpenso UF guting releaned. —undinge taken Jast weeld slow o channel be~ tweei tho plers oy Iwo HiYers an followa: Depih, minipum, 10 feot; wazimum, 13 foct. Width of chaniel for above depib, miulmum, 30 fect; maxle Tty 100 fect, Vesecls inaking thid horbor shonirl Erepout about 40 oot cant of Weat yier 11 withm 100 foet & tool-housa on weat r]1‘!.'!, thence about &) fecl 148 alrenst of 00)-liowso, after which thoy will fiud not Jota nan 10 feey of watcr within 30 feet of west plerto tho dvers, Soandiogs of the bar outeido will he tolret ayeoon £8 the wreather will perimt,—Ecentng Wscanin, — Adlapateh from Cleveland atates that the burgs Ecllye went ashiars 0 mfles cast of Dlick River fust night Nalyvos ol Tho vessel {4 not badly dawae sgedant canbo got O, | Tho elipto iad tio mac cBindy taken out of her in thia port, aud way bolng tawel 1o Huron by the tug Yosemito, Tho wind wag 80 stong that (b tug, with her anchors out and uudee 2 fu) biead of steam, could not hold ber ground, aud, 10 oiro borsalf, was oblizny to cut Lier tow loose,” Ths Yorquito ron bnck In salcty, ~ho four-musted wchuonier Riehard Winlow, Jate Wediesday ulght or eurly yesterday moruing, gt agraud ut the head of Teuchi’ Tulund, Tale 6t Clilr, Thry tugs yesterdsy nttempted to get hor off, bie witheat success, Tho water iy previance of sontbwest winds, and, until tho onrreiit Bets ek, tho Witslow will 10 apt fo romain whera bl b, Watens extenvive Lightering nhall o dono, £ far arheard from abo L wusialried 10 dainoges b not Inown to be leaking, Ier pasition {a nola_dan- Toroia oue, ut, the botiom belug racky, tho bull will $a maject to stiaining. Numorous bowlders azo also aald o exiat (@ tho locality.—Letrait Post, g w on’ secount of the DR. SEYMOUR. The Rev. Dr. Locke Explains the Causes of His Re- Jjection, The Panio in the Uonvention on tho Subjeot of Ritualism, Documents Presented at the Sccret Session of the Tlouse of Deputies. An Interview with the Re- Jected Bishop. What He Says in Reply to Dr. Forbes. The Rev. Edward Bullivan on the Re- strictive Canon, DR. LOCKE. 18 IDEAS OF THE REJRCTION O PROF, BESMODUR, I'hé Rev. - Dr. Locke, who has just rotirnod from New Yorlk, spoke as follows yestorday oven- ing, on’tho subject of tha rojection of Prof, Seymour by tho Iipiecopal Convention: Ilaving just roturned from tho Genoral Cone vontion, of which 1 was n mewbor, and Imowing bow ansious peoplo in Chieago must bo to havo &et boforo thom the .rongons whick induced the ITougo of Clerical and Loy Deputios to refuso to confirm tho clection of Dr, Seymour, Bishop-olect of Tilinole, I binvo thonght it my duty briefly to 1oview the action of the Convention in that mat- tor es clearly apd ag truthlully as licy witkin my ability, The position of the Dioceso of Illinols before tho Genoral Couvention was this: We hadin opon convention hero, aftor & thorough come plianco with sll the canemeal rogulations, chosen for our Bishop a clergymen of good standing in the Chirel, on whom thera rested no canonical difliculty.;Tho ohoice had fallen up- on no obscure man,upen no tuere undistinguish- ed Presbyter; wo lad electod ono of the most celebratod elorgymon of tho Clureh,—tho hond of tho only Theologienl Seminary which s calied Goueral, and of which all ' the Divhops, - and s large numher ot tho wost prominept clergymen and laymen arc Trustees,—3 man of well-known ability and_long-tosted administrativo powor,— o man of fervent pioty and doop opirituality, Lnown for his !Elf-llflllyln% oud self-sacriflcing Chyiatian_pbilanthropy, or was ho elected without thought, or without dellberation, His namo had sppeared u tbe public papors ; o lotter wrging bim had been read in the preliminary mooting of canforouce bofore tho Convention ; and, aftor tho nomination of bim by tho Rov. Dr. Donn, thore wns & long and animated dis- cussion of his morils and domerts, pro and con, 1t wns nrged by his friends thon, just as it wonld bo urged to-morrow it wo hind it to do over azais (for nothing has ocourred to chango thelr opinions), thatinlearning,in oloquonce,in enthn- siaum, in dovation to work,in sound and thorougia churchinanship, withoul any extremos of any Iind, he wau well suited to bo the Bishop of this splendid Diogesa of Illinois, Nothny was done in thatConvention that any of Dr. Soymour's frionds need be nshamed of, and on the fitht comploto ballot, that of both clocgy aud laity, he was olected by n constitutional majority of soven. “Tho noxt morninyg his testimonials Were nigned by far more than that cumber. Indced, it wis thonpht that ovory member of the Convention bud gigned them, and it was not kuown until somo time aftor that avery fow, six or eight had, from one reuton or another, not ulpunJ them. Of courso their legal ofect would have beeu perfect 1f not a singlo ono hind sigued othor than the majority, by which Dr. Seymour was eleeted. Soon after our Convention it was rumored awmong us Luat, outside of our diocese, by parties utterly foreign to tho State, elforts wore boing mado to_crente a projudico sgainst tha Bishop- elecl—eMorts originating, as s well-kuown, tn porsons whom Dr. Boymour, by ona of thoss chances which no mon of eucrgy and charactor can avoid, bad managed to offend and to turn into porsonal encmies. We, however, did not giva that much leed (whon I By tce, I monn tha majority of the clergy and lsity representod in Cotvention), aund we ‘weut to Jonvention with- out much foar of any advorso result. We soon found that thoro wan to be opposition, and that of the most rigorous kind; but wo slso found that we had many aud strong friends, aud that no paing wonld bo spared to bave justico done ua, The delegation, whoro personual ia woll kuown to you, was s unit, with tho excoption of one member, whose courso has beon most fully dia- cussed, and no comments of mino are neodled. The matter of Prol. Soymour's coufirmation was fised for Wodnosday, the 14th of Oatobor, and came up on the resolution of the Commiiteo on tha Consccration of Blshops ; Resolyed, That this House proceed to confirm the election of Dr. Seymour sa Bishop of Xiinols, I'ho whola cngo was considorad in secret sos- slon, aud occuplod from Wednosday the 1ith till Wednesday tho 22d. The yow of gecrosy hay been removed, 8o that it ia compotent for mo_to stato tho lme of solion. ILwnsa wonderful and a brilliant debate. Tigh Cabinct oflicers, Judgos, and lnwyera of distinction sny that rarely i any logislative body could thers ba heard g0 rare a treat of intelloctual ability and leen appreciation of argument, aud, abovo all, it was_a porfectly courteons and Christian do- bate. In oll that loug time, and with men ox- citod to fover heat, no word ever dropped from tho lipa of any spenkor which callod forth re- monstranco§ nor was any man called to ordor for any intomperanco of language. I was proud of » Church which could conduct %o ex- citing o themo jn 80 beautiful o spirit. I con- sidor that it wns o groat Joss to the Church to have been deprived by tho seorot soasion, of the Dbright examplo of mon restrained by Clristian courtesy from exciting remark or porsonal ro- flection. T'he first charges againet Prof. Soymour vore of unsoundnoss in doctrine,—that ho'held exag- rerated views of tho Holy Bucharist, and Ritunl- istic opmions on the subjeet of the Confessional and the rendoring of the publlo servico, It wus asked by his friends, Whero is tho sermon proschied, the word written or spoken, whero is the testimony of any witucss, that ho does hold or toach suoh orrors ¢ Nothing in the way of avidence was preseuted but o crude fragment of & young man's seminary oxorcise, which it was vald Prof. Boymour did not' condomn, Lettern woro rond from Rituslistio womon oxulting over Reymour's clection, and lottors ahowt young women flivting with foollsh thoological atudeuts; but all that was, o8 ono speaker ro- marked, o thousand million miles away from touckingz Prof. oymouss nrong doctrine. Tio distinetly avowed, ovor his own signature, in o lettar writton lon bufore he lind auy thouglht of the Bishopric of [Ninois, that he disapproyed of {hat young wan's sormon and doctrino quite a8 fully'ns any of his brother professors ; bul, by .their own action, was provonted from showing 1t by hisvote, It was eaid ho had presonted tho young man for ordiuation, 1o showed that tho young man had to Lim aud {o his Bishop ro- nounced tha orror and the wrang doctrive it coutained, snd that thia ymmE man, aftor cross-oxamination by sevon Pros ytom,hml bean ordainod priost by ono of the moyi oareful of our Tishops. And, byono subhorized to sposk for bim, the most distinct rud satiafactory statemonta ol his porfect soundncss in the {aith wero made ; and 1hio yery wordss were used, *I do not adors, nox would I over, uor hava I evor, tnught my peopla to adore Chirlsy prosout intue sacrament under the form of brend aud wino® Prof. Heymour distinotly stated, through friends, that Lo hold 10 other dootrines thau those usially held in onr CObureh, and thoso in no extreie way, ‘Fo mo, aud to those who wonted to be convinced, the ovidence was overwhelming that no chargoe of unsoundness fn the faith could be proven even by iuferenco. Then it was urged that he favared and ine dulgod in Rltualistic practices. ‘Phio only specitt- cation known seomed to bo that, at an ordina- tion, hio hiad beon secn to romain on his Inges during the whole timo of communion, & practico 80 common hero that many of us woro porfectly surprised to hoar that it waa constdored oxtrome, It was nddod thut he beut his breast during thut tmo, nud indutged n strong goswaren, iy ho donled over hiw awn signaturo, 1 ¢annot go into all {haf wau said on this point, but I appos! o any ouo who bend it, friend or foo, whother it was proven thut Dr. Bovmour hind, to auy estont, or in wny way, been guilty of what 18 cormmonly ealled Riturligm, 1o donlod in his own writing that Lio bad in any way. hon his towper way wiged ng & but to bis confirmntion. 1t wna sialed that ho wna so violont in temper thnt ho vould not governn dlogoee tranquilly, audold uorrnyoudmmo and burled pamphiots wera broupht in—corro- spondenco and pamphilate which had beon withe drawn, and forgiven and forgolten. 1 the Sominnry troubles woro brouglit np, althowgh it was known that & commission of Distops hind oxuminod nto all that, found wrouz on both sidos, and had adjusted the matler fully, and it hind romnined adfustod. 1 was shown that Dr, Hoymour had been vory miunch oxasperated by wriaac ho thouglit unjust troatment, and had used oxpresalona which woro hasty, and for which ho way soery 3 aud it wos shown that oveu Alascs and St." Paul conld not have boon confitmed Dishop {f hostiness of tomper was o cardinal objection. Quick tomper genorally gocs hand in’ hond with much earnestness and gront conthusinsm, ‘Then it was urred that somo of his intimato friondu were Rtnnaliste, and thorofora ho must ha; but it wan shown that such an inforenco was unfoundad, and it was woll known that somo of tho most moderato clergy in the Church were at- tached to him, A man for whom Dr, Ilale, of Jrooklyn Dr. Burgess, of Massnolusotta; and Dr. Leeda, of Maryland, could vota—whom thoy could respect, aml nbout whom his own Bistop (Bishop Potior, of New York) wroto tho mnst Iaudatory lettor—could not bo put down by the cry, " o is known by his frionds.” During tho lnst days of tho sesslon, & lottor from # Bishop was read aflicming that Dr. So mour bad allowsd a colobrated Ritunlist to lo turo to the studonts in s private room. Dr, Hoy- mour_dovfod this over Lis own signatiiro, and statod that bo was thoro without his kuowlodso or consont, and he had nothing to do with it. Tho membora of tho Convention, according as gx_n folt, bollaved either the I'rofessor or the ishop. - 'Fhis 4 sbout tho sum and substance of tho debate, for I neod not speak of tha littla pratost from 1ilinola, nor of sny Argumenta faulting tho Illinoia tostimoninls, Thoy producod no offect whatever, and, as far as I remember, were nover even referrad to by any speakor on_tho sido op- posed to Dr. Boymnour, save by tho one wha o thom. You may ask now Why, thon, was Dr. Boymour rofectod?’ Ou what ground sas tho rofusal to contirm basod? Simply on this, avowed openly, and instated upon as snficlont : papular proji- dico connocts him with Rituallsm, Whother in- nocent or guilty (and s ono of Lla oppon- onts saids **In any court of law ho would be thoroughly scquitted”), he must be sacrifived to this popular projudico; ono man cannot stand 1 tho way of a church aud, matter how hard it may bo for Lim and for Iili ois, the high state of foclingin our Church d mands that ho should go under rathor thau that tho whola Churel should bo misunderstood. To me, and to many athors, this doctrine of oxpedi- onoy scemed n hard dootrine; but it has often Loon ueted upon in tho world, and we must not o surprised ot its swaying any largo assomblage. At _all events, thab was the ground taken at last by Dr. Seymout's oppouonts, aud on that ground, Y'thiuk, alono was he rejectod. o was ably aud brilliantly dofonded. Out of forty-two spenkors, twouty wero in Lis favor; and among thom werg some of tho most ro- nowned layyors aud clorgymen in our Church, and mon who could no moro bo ncensed of Rit- ualiam than of Mobammodanism urged strongly the justico of his cause. e bud, as you know, o mimorical majority (145 to 140), hud all tho dit occses of the Stato of Now York, whero bis whole lifo Lins been passed, voted for him, both of which rosults have groat moral woight. Wo vote, however, by dioceses, and every dividea dioceso counts in tha nogative, and & diocese with ono clergyman and ono lnyman in its re‘prn- seniation casty tho anmo vote as ono with four clorgymon aud four layman,—peculiar arrango- monts which maka it ditlioult, aud perhups it ought to be, to securo tho roquisite majority ro- quired of Loth orders by tho constitution. ‘The result was the effect of a sorios of cir- cumstnucos, Tho Ohurch is very much exoited on the subject of Ritualism. Prof. Soymour's name was connected with that by certain par- tios, a prejudico arose againat him, and tho bat- tlo of Ritualism was turned on tho side issue of ulg confirmation, and so ho falled. He rotains the post ho Lias 8o long and honor- ably hold, and the lovo and conflidence of all who have known him well. Indeod, he has endeared himsolf moro and more by tho boautiful spirlt in which bio Las borne this cruel blow, Lie iad boon proven gnilty of false doctrine or exag- gerated Ritunlism, I should considor it & delivor- anco, for certainly 1 favor no oxtromo viows., I am 1ot awaro of aver having dono ono Kitnalistic act, and the sorvico in this ohurch is performoed oa it i in the gront majority of parish churchos in this land. "My doctrino has never changed winco I am here, and I purposoly read over s kor- mon I preachiod on_tho Euchorist fiftoen yeara &go to seo whother I had varied in my views, I found that I taught then a8 I tench now—no strange dogma, simply the true spiritual pres- ence of wy Lord in the loly Bupper, rocoived b{ faith slone—tho body sud blood of Christ fi veu, takon, and recoived aftor a spiritual and envenly mannor by the loving heart. But I do not consider that any charge of falso doctrine or oxtreme ritual was at all_proven agaiost the man whom wo hind choson. Ido not think that ho was g'umy liablo to ovil report for “ error in religion™ or for * viclousness in lifo," T think that ho was foreed to give way to o panis about ritual, aud was condomnad bocnuse it was thought the good of tho Church demanded it. Let us all bo calm znd pationt undor this trial, The Goneral Conveation was porfeotly compo= tout to acc. It hus acted, and our duty as loyal churches is to submit to tbst action, Lot us not uso any hasty or bitter words. Lot na pray God to onlighten us, and keop s from preju- dicoand from passion, Lrobnbly in January & spacial convention will bo ealled; and botweon that tlme aud this thinga will hava eottled down, and wo will bo ablo to laol at thom more dis- passionately than we now do. Just vow 1do not think wo can judge what is bost. I truss that wo mny securo a good and earnest mau to bo our Diehap; that we will all rally around him, aud that under his lendership this great diocese may do n noble work for Obrist and His Church, It is a novel policy, this rojoction of & man on suspioion of wrong doctrino. I do'not know what ita results may bo. Of Diocesan Bishops only threo othora have over been rofectod; one on account of illegal slection, one for chargos of wmaladministration of proporty, and one for provod fatso doctrine, God grant it may bo many years bofors tho Ohuteh wndergoos another such trial [ and God graut thnt the man called upon to go throuzh it muy como ont as pure as Dr. Soy- mour comes ont! Idid my best, sodid my col- leagues with tho excoption of the opposing mom- bor; so did all thoso who sympathizod with us, Lyeryting wos {air andabove-board. We (ailed, but thero was no exultation, only the profound- oat sympatliy; for 1 think tho groat body of men in that house nctod from conscientious convic- tion. Let us loso no heart, but go_on with our duty, and leave tho issue in tho hands of God. —s THE SECRET DOOUMENTS, From the New York papers, Oct, 30, The doouments submitted to tho sccret sos- sion of the Houee of Deputies over tho confir- matlon of Dr. Boymour, Bishop of Illinois, have beon made public. They are only six in num-~ Dor. The firat is tho report of a committos of tho Mouso of Dishops, which Investigated o doetrinal difloulty botween the Doan und Fac- ulty of tho Genoral Theological Sominary, in this oity, wnd tho Rev. Dr, Seymour, Profossor of Ecclosinatical Hintory therein. A DASIS OF AGREEMENT was proposed by tho Committoo, and tho foi- lowing was finally ndopted : The Commities doputed by tho House of Blshops to vleit, the General Theolugical Sembuary, consluting of o Bishups of North Carolina (Chairniau), of Iiliuot, Liastun, Vermont, New Ilumpsbixe, aud the Anristant of largiatid, bolng iasembled iu tho Faculty room of the sewlnary, offerad ta the itav, . M, Forlica, Deau, aud tho Ruv, Drs, Seabury, Efgenbrodt, und Seymour, Pro= fessors of the Bemniniuty, tho following paper, an thia buals of an agroement botwoen the Dean aud tae two firut-named Lrofessors on e onu patt, and Irof, Hoymour ou the othur, o sirst—1The Dean nad tho Professors present, who acted with Lim, dectaro tlat they had no_futention, in the action of the Faculty in March, 1870, o deal un- generously with Dr, Suyniour or to furce him fnto a ulse position on tlieir vocord, They furiher declare that their expresslon of surprise aud grief ju the reso- Jutlou of Qo 670, *that thoy Lud not tho vone currenco of tiielr collcagno in upholding the disclpline of o seminurs, aud (u Kecpluie Jn-dulorcts +fu burmony with (o Bible sud the Tnok of Common Prayer,! referred to the mutter then beforo the ucnlty, and Was not fntended to fmpeach the general vonduct and toachlug of Dr, Boymonr, cither as o Professor of tho sowmluary, or as a Presbyter of the Churels, Second=Dr, Buymour having, In conscquenco of tho above dechratioir, withdrawn tho pampitiet cutitied A Defunso of this Profossor. of Liccleaiuatical History Against the Assanit of tho Dean aud the other Pro- feswors,” &e,, the members of tho Faculty now prcsen{ase of o opulon thabthe proambles sm rono lunk adopted by the Bacully Oct, &, 1471, onglit also (o o willidrawn, sud not Teporied' to the Board of Wrusteos, ‘Tho Dishops of the Visiting Committes, without wiahilng Lo imposn & rido of action on tha Faculty, or any member of the sauwo, for thelt future guidatice, ununiimonly thunk the Tuoulty for discountunsneing the error shat tha glorificd person of any Savlor Ohrlst i present In and lndissolubily uulled to io consccrated lomanta of tlio ioly Busimrisl, aud oxpress tho Hoys ihut the Facully will continue’ to guarit_agalust tho wamne crror in $ho studies und dlacipline of the somni= iry, “I'ho shove, haviny Leen read by tho Chalrinon of tho thoe students, iz, uv, 1, 1672, the Rt, Itev, A, C. Coxe, D, D,, LL, ., Dlshop of Westers Now Yor! *Lent, 1874, tho Ro “tinu woul Viuitiug Coninuition, i accopte by tho mamibera of tho Tavulty presont ; and 1 wituess thoreof they subscribe tuolr hamen 40 't presonco of tho Dishops, J Nurray Forbes, Doan; Sawucl Heabury, Lrofcssor of Diblieal Loarning ; William E, Flgonbrodt ; Georgo T, Heganour, Profexsor of Ecoleninstical 1tintory, Tho following LETTER OF BISKOP COXI, snd roply of Dr, Soymour, wore anong lhie pa- pers: Nrw Yonr, Oct, 17, 1674, My DrEAn Junar BYrT 1 'Tho facta kre snbatantiaily an thiey finve been reported to you, T could say many thingn in favor of (his candidato with entiro trith, and teatimoutaln might ba mulliylied i bis favor wathont amy dupieity, 3316 tho wisole trutlt would rovest an= other cinss of facts, and I mx;tl‘mm Dr, Boymour himn- sel€ wonld not deny that, na n Professor {u thoeminary, fie hnn wtendfaatly reslated the noble offorta of Lin calleauies, such as Drs, Hoabury nnd Vinion, who havo laborod to mainémn tho doctiing of this Gliurch, reapecting tho THoly Enolinrist, and_(ho provistanu of tho Ttubrio for ita kolomn celbration, pure and wie defited, : : “Thioso things became known to 100 in thio dlscharge of my uflictal dty, as o © viitor,” and o momber of o comnittee, s I regret to say that the learned Pros fennor wau forcail to confesn tme tnty with his knowl- odgo nndl consent, n yoverond gentieman weil known a8 an active agont of the O, 11, K., or of tho systom it sutain, was pormittod to lecture o students of the soiniuary in.a TFivate room on biu pocullar vlaws of tho ¢ 1loly ucharist.” 1t 48 with oxtrome rogrot that I mentlon theas facts, whicl I havo desired un opportunity of atating in the Board of ‘Truatock of tho seminary, and only there, An you well kriow, however, the imporsibihty of asem= bliug that Nonrd, of uny fair proportion of them, lna operated to render the investigation of facts au impos- sbility for many yonra, Tho facts ought ta.ba known, liowover, and Hio Gliurch must be swekencd to or ro- wponslbilities i such momentons concorns, Felthful- Iy yours, g y i o A, CLr D Coxr, Distiop of Western Now York, The Hon, Judge Smith, T novor nllowed or kuew of any priest of the 0, B, 8, heing in_tho seminary or locturing to tho studenta on any accnsion whntsouvar slnce I hayo been in chntgo of tho seininary, 1 hinvo nover permitted any one to lecturn or nddresns thaatudonts, fn any case wliatsoover, withont the cone st of the Kaculty, Gso, ¥, Sexuoun, et 20,1874, Tho following dosument was nlso prosouted : UENERAL THEOLOGIOAL BEMINALY, Nuw Yons, Oct, 4, 1674, T authorize tho Iov, W. I, Spalding Lo state for mo that I dirsvow utterly and ontiesly thio doctrinal stato- ments of the extract of thamormon of the Rev. Mr., =—, placod upon the minutes of the Faculty and of £io Truntoos, whicls has been brought befor tho Tlauso of Oterleal ‘i Lay Doputies, 1 alioalivm that T over pormilted suy oun to address the students or Jecture 1o thewn on any occaslon without tho kuowl- @lgo and consent of tho Faculty, and that, if such tbings have been done, they have occurred without my knowledge and consout, and, in case I had knows them, would liave beou probiblied by me, Guonde ¥, Scrsovn, MMr, Wolsh, of Peunsylvania, read o copy of o lottor writon by him to Bishop Coxe, with rofor- enco Lo a communication sent by the Bishop to Dr. Forbos. Tho followlng was TUE REPLY REORIVED BY MR, WELSI : 31z Dran Mn. Wissi : I do uot feel at liberty 40 ro- fuse you the nse of my letter of Oct. 4, 187, thio exint- encoof which I Liad quito forgotten. But cousult with my felend, John Smiith, who knows tho extcoma reluctunce with which I buve pexmitted my testimony to bo used in your dizcussions, 1 might haye mndo my statement much longer and more delailed, for tho caso was a very grosa abuso of power. o do nat sond our candidates to the Bemina. Ty {0 be fnstructod by omisuarics fram forofgn nociox tiea 3 but when Lexprossed my surprive ta Dr, Sey. mour that a volunteer Professor had boen lutroduced by him within the walls of the Semluary, be defended imself on tho genoral ground that the porson was # i+ Proabyter of tho Ohurch,™ *In roply to another question, I must add that fn examining oue of my candidates, who roluctantly nd~ mittud bis kuowlodgo of the facts, 1 found that ho hd - Deew prosent ab ouo of theve volunteor lectiires, in which oxtrayagant and faleo views of the fIoly Euctinr. it wero Inculeated, Nothing but a very extraordinary duplicity can put any coustruiction on theso facts which oo men ean accopt as atisfuotory, Faithfully yours, 4 CLEVELAND COXE, ‘W, Welsh, Enq, Bishon Western New York, o lotter reforred to Lud this paragraph : L linve tls prosont actiuy Dea's own ackuowledg ‘mont that b permitted ** Father? Grafton to visitand indoctrivato tho students Inat winter, The Rov, Dr. Stringfollow, of Alabama, predented s paper indorsed: ** Questions and Apswors from Dr. Scymour, presented by Dr. Stringfellow,” ag followy: Q. 1.~DId you over roceive any gontleman or gen~ tlomon well known elther as sgents of tho G, B, 8, or thosystom 1t eustuined, or were nuy such porson or Tierons pormiitted by you to lecturs ta tho students of tho Semuacy iu & private Toom on bis or thelr pecnllar vlows of tho loly Euchurlal 7 A~—~No person or per- sons, sualy ot fomnle, bave ever heen permitted by mo to deliver lecturea or addresses u privato or in publio to the students sinco 1 have beon conuected with tho General Theologleal Sominary without. tho kuowledgo and consent of my colleagies ; 50 far as I can remom-~ Ler, tho following persons only, with iny knowledge and consont, bave dulivered lectures or addressen to ames Long, M, A., on India, of tho Archdloceas of Culeutts, fadin, Lwo loctures; Juno, 1874, Prof, Gharles Short, LL, on the Vulgate transiation of tbo Bible, ono ‘lecture; tho Bluhop of Now York delfvers ench winter lectures to bia condie dates, oud to such ather members of the Senfor Clssn 58 chdoss o attend, Q. 2,~Do you deny_or adinit, ns & Profesnor in *ha seminary, that you liavo stendfastly realsted tho noolo offorls of your” colleaguos, Des, Seaburs and Vinion, ¢ labored to malntain tlie dootcitiea of tho ioly i proyisions of tho Rubrle for the colcbrution of tho Buchnrlat—piira and undefled ? A— T deny wost emphatically that T huve aver so resisted my colleague, Drs, Boabury and Viuton, or any othor Teotespor. 3y difforeuced with my collesgued liavy Veen liaily’ua (o, questions”of yolley and nodes of adminlstoring disciplie, By yamplst, i pfeparod with tho expresn and #olo” purpose of prolecling mysell sgaiust sich a cliarge, and my colloagtiof, ut tha visitation of the six Tishoys, on Jan, 7, 187 distinctly whhdrow flint charge, and i1 cousequonce of such withdrawal I with- droyw my pumphlct, Sco basts of aguevment propared Ly Dishops, Q. 9,—Did the Ttoy, Mr, Grafton, with your conscat or Enowledgo, over lecturs to or nddress “the students of tho sewmlunty upon sny subjoct, and if so,upon what subject, and “under what circlmstances 7 A—~Le over di with my knowludge oud cousent, Q. 4.—DId you over confess or acknowledgo theaflir. mation of theno facts to any person, Diehop, priost, Dencon or layinamy na specifiad In fusstion No. 37 A—1 never did 80 anfoss or acknowledge, sines sicl B confession or ackuowledgment would 'bave becn contrary to tho truth, Tho facts were simply these s oo Rev, Mr, Graftod upon ono occasion called upon » student ot bis room in tho seminary, and whilo thera othier students in the nelghboring rooms hieard of his presence, and cam o es bim, and requested lim t toll thons about Cowey and tho plan and pirpose of thio brotherhood of wiich Mr, Gratton 18 & membor. The Rav, Mr, Gratton, a8 I wsa informed nftor tho ocenrrencs, hud no dewlgn when ho called of Jolding any such conversation; it wan elmply sceldental, 1 did not learn of it uutil some time atter it took place, uiud 1 had_nothing whataoever to do with fb. Al th interviows T hiava ever bad with tho oy, Mr, Grafton since I bave kuown hia would not amount in oxtent of time to four Lours, I was introducea to the Her, Mr, Grafton yeara ngo, when he was assistant to the Ttey. Dr. Wyatt of 8t. kxmll't Chareh, Baltimore, Md,, and liava uéen bins aaly oecatoually ainee, Q. 6—Did any peraon, Dishop, priest, Deacon, or Inyman, ever challenge your ackuowlodgment or con- feasion to baving pormitted the Rev, Mr. Grafton, or any otlier person not connected with the scmiuary, to lision to or sddress the students ? A.—I never ao- kuowledged or canfessed to haviug done so, aud honee 1do not see how auy ono could have ko ciailenged. Q. G—Did any persou apoak to you on tho subjeet, if -Yeas tiishop Coxe, in a vieitation which 0 seminary fu the winter orspring of 1873, inquired about the visit of the lev, Mr, Orafton, and 1 gave him in substanco the information which I have submitted in my answers as ubove; at that visltation thie ehiarge wusnade thot a presbyter had beeu prowl- Ingabout theseminary sor several days; on inquiry I foun that referonce was mada fu this allegation toa presbyter who hind comuo to the seminacy for tho pure pous of being with the mourners and attending tho funeral of the daughter of tho late Prof, Scabury, and whille i thie soutiuary waa tho guost of ilie widow Sea~ Lury, then resiling i the semuinary gronuds, . "T—Ias Jt In accordinico witl tho standards of this Clurch to teach, elther by word or act, tho adoration of our Blessed Lord under tho form 'of bread snd wine in the Ducharist? A.~I hold, in accordance with the ataudards of the Church of Logland, * that no sdoration i futended or ought to be done elther uuto the sacramental bread or wiua there bodily re- coived, or unto any corparal presenco of Chirists nntural flesh or blood, *For tho sueramental bread aud winio remuin atlil in thelr very natural substanccs, andd, therefore, may not be adored (for that woro fdolu~ try to bo abhorred ‘of all fajthiful Christiany) ; and the natwrul Lody and blood of our Bavior Christ wre in heaven, and not hore, it being agatust the truth of Clriat’s patural body to Lot ous time in more places thau one,” 1 hold, also, in accordance with our "I'wenty-eighth article, thut +*{ho body of Chrlst 15 i, taken, and eateh in tho Buppur only. afier su heuvenly and epiritual manner, and the noans where- by the body of Obrist i recclved {s faith.,” I hold, also, with (be sanie article, thut *iha Bacrament of the Lord’s Supper waa not by Chrlut’s ordinauce re- servod, carried about, liftod up, of worsliped.” Q. 8—Ts attendunce on the sscrument fortho pur- pore of auststing u the pacrifice without the recoption of tho efements consonant with the apirit of our otlices ond articlea? (In othor words, tho oflices and articles of by Protestant Eplscopul Q].Illfll‘?. A,—Buch at- tendance, with muck a purpoas, ought, i my judgs mient, o be discouraged nn not i auy way recoguizod by orle ofiices nd_articlss—that $ (o’ oo and articlea of he Protestant Eplacopat Chuveh, Q. D—Does the habit of privato or sncramental cons feuslon, wo-called, foster a8 n means of grace igher typo of holinese thun the disuss of such confession, oxcept in the \vn{ and forthe purposcs lllllh‘,:m)‘tl i the warning apgointed Lo bo read before the Holy Come nunton? A~—Iluyo never taughi, vucournged, or practiced the Labit of private or sucramental confed- wlon, and 1 huve uover seen the frilts uf such 4 prao- tica [ otherd, nd benco Iam not able to ey whit auich frndta wonld be, Iunly know of coufeesiun as 1t {4 taugit and_olowed by the standardu of the Prote catunt Eplscopal Cliureh aud sangtloned by the Dishops in thefr Yustoral of 1871, Q. 10-Did you, or da'you aver, when present ot the Holy Cowmuiilon, practico bowlngs, crowmigy, kneel- ings, genuiloctions, or nuy boiily uct, intending there- 8 any adorution of the sacrament? A.— i uuy occuslon, done 80; o conld I ‘ponaibly da 80, slnco I da ot wikh, uor Lo £ ovor, at ity titae, deaired, ta pay such utoration, Huch sduru- 1 be contrary to my convictlon; 1t would Lo Gronox I Brxsious, an awful tmploty, Oct, 21, 1674, Hhortly before tho veto was taken, THE FOLLOWING LETPER way road by thy Scerotary to tho flouse’s Ty, the Olerical and Loy Depuiiesa the Genral Conen- ton ¢ Tivenunp DosTupey AND DRETUREN OF TUE Latry: The nnprecedonled courdo which hoea been ndopled and purdned by tho lousa of Clerinl and Tay Depiities in reforonco to the quention of my coti- firimation to the E,y[l\mplle Justifios mo, I ventira lo anbmity in uddeesslng this note to your veverend and honorahlo body, fo crave tho priviige uf being ale Towod to bo prencnt o tha fiver of your hiound to anmwer for mynolf (o oliases’ which may be inade agalnat me aa to snything that 1 have oversald or oo, ’ Vaguo rumors reach mu of serlona meoudstiouy, whicli, #0 far au T bavo Dieon able toancortan tlin drirt of theth, are withont exceptign founded on wistske, and aro onnily corractod and refited. Lok in ot polnta they fonch npon thing fully known unly to my. Aelf or two otliers, who are not mcnibers of ‘ynur houwn, %0 that no oxplanatiuns eont throngl third persons can Lo enticely satiafactory 4o you or Just o e, T ean truly sny from iy heart that I never souglhit or deaired tuo Eplscopal oflice, My prosent patnful post tow, sa & Bishop-sloct, {6 ona 4nto whieh I waa gud- Qenly forced by elrcimstoncets over which I had no control, Gladly would I, had 1 the power, replace my- self whero I was whon thie Diocdso of inals elocted mo, but thia I cannot do at this atago of tho proceed- g, or niucteen poars and moro I havo sorved fho churel as Deacon and presbytor, and I leava it to my Tiiahop, and miy brothren of the clergy and the_lnity, who hiave known ma from {ho firat, o toll how I havo lived and bow 1 hnve lahorod, ButI will sny for my= aulf that the Protostant Eplscopal Churol hus mover had & more Jogat son than she bas it me, 1 will sy for mysolf, and nll who Inow me will bear mo witness that it In true, that thero I8 nothing which is further from my nattira than concenlment or evasion, “Thio queation with mo js uol whiether T om to bo made n Hishop or nob, My auxioty is altogatber for my Iifo and ugofulnesa aa A clergyinnn and ln{ clnrace for an a mnn, With great reapect, very faithfully sud truly yonrs, Eonax I Eryaoust. Gouoral Theologleal Beminary, New York, Oct, 221874, Tho request to bo allowed to addross the dopn- tics wag, a8 by already boen mentjoned, donied by tho Hounso. ——— INTERVIEW WITH DR. SEYMOUR, Fyom the New York Herald, Oct. 30, « « » Dr. Boymour spenks rapidly and with groat earncstness, and yostorday his munnar was that of & man whoso foolings had boon greatly wrought upon, and who was smarting under a grioyous wrong. 1 hiavo road tho etatomonts of tho Rov. Alr, TForbos,” [published under tho hoad of *Re- liglous News,” fn yestordsy's paper.—Eb. Tupuse] Dr. Soymour bogan, with quict dig- nity, *nud I havo not tho slightest dosire fo re- ply to his nssault by attacking him in tho samo mnnnerin which he hee attacked me. I shall simply confine toyselt to the grave chargos which ho bas proforred against mo, and which roflect upon my charactor. And, before pro- cooding further, I desiro to Asy that tho Bishop- tic of Llimoia 18 nothing to me compared to the vindieation of my iutegrity, which has heon go grossly nsuailed.” “Y¥ou woro once consured, Doctor, by the Pagulty for nssaulting tho Desu'in a pamphlet, wars you not 2" “ Yeu, Iwas, I published a pamphlet as o do- fengo against the unprovoked assnult of the Deau and the other Professors uf the Sominury, Tho opposing party of threo Professors and Deau diroctod a eriticiam upon my pawmphlot to bo mado upon tho minutes, bus this censure was subsequontly DIDECTED TO NE EXTUNGED by n Committco of the Louso of Bishops, who, ak oy solicitation, paid a visit to the Bominary in order to oxamine into tho charges which the other Profcssors had proforred sgainst mo, Af- tor atayipg horo a week the Bishops drow up o bosla of agreemont [published above.—Iin. I'mipoye.] upos which' the Professors might meet ogain wm accord. Upon this baais tho pamphlot alluded to was explicitly withdrawn and tha criticism upou the minutes oxpunged, and to bring this now forward again is an opon Lreach of faith." * Dr. Forbessaye that ono of the groatost ob- Joctions ta your coufirination was your intimato asocintion with Rituslists 2" Dr. Boymour roplied to tiis question with much honest emphasis: * My rule of action hag Doen invariably o preach for any olergyman of rood standing, bo ho o Iigh Clawck or a Low Chureh muu, as loug a8 bo iy rocognized by the covlesisatical authoritics as o minister of the Gaspol. Lvery clergyman is my brother, and [ allow uo differonces in creed or thoological opinions to interfers with my social conduct. “ My house, L say it frankly, is opon to tho Boptist and tho Prosbytorian, as well as to the Epiacopation, and to tho Grook of Roman Cathio- lic, aa woll as to the Jow and tho Ritualist. Xam on terns of cordinl friondship with o Jowish rabbi, and with soveral Iresbytorian clergynton, whom I osteom highly, and, if this bo & wrong, 1 freely confess that I AN OUILTX OF I Dr. Seymour X:usnd at this point, and, smil- ing, osked: *And, by tho way, if Ido receivo Ritunlists, and welconie them to my Liouse, how do thoy know but what 1 um trying to convert them to tho true dogma?” k * Dy, Forbes algo charges ?au with prevarica- tion nnd disingonuousncss in your pamphlot " I want the fullest investigation into every act of my lifo,” Dr. Seymour roplied, m & fear- logs tono, * and welcome overy oharge if it Lo made by responsibla parties and aupported by proof., My oxistouce bay passed in this my native place and ite cloae vicinity and is open 10 tho closout scrutiny, My whola life is in tho hands of my brothren, and I can truly aay that I have nover beou guilty of holding baolk anything or enlertnining religious views which I'would not openly avow, Can I say more on a chiargeso indoflnite 2" * Dr. Forbea stated that you wera ‘lublo® to evil roports, and conld theroforo_not receivo the cartificato from the Convention ?” *Tho cortiticate does uot say ‘liable,” but says distinetly * juetly liable, Our bloesed Lord Tfimself waa ‘liablo” to rumors, for whon Ile camo eating and drinking they prophesied ¢ Be- hoid a glutlonous man, a wine bibber, n friend of publicans and sinners.” Now, I gay that I may Do * liable,’ but that 1AM NOT *JUSTLY LIADLE.' ‘Why, the best mon are lisble to rumors, You may vidlt a dyin porson in s housie which may turn ont to bo nu abode of prostitution, and ag rogards these romors it shoild not be forgotten thut » numerical majority of the Couveuntion ac- copted me.” *Dr, Forbas also atates. that the burden o proof lay upon you to ghow that these rumors wera falio " * How could 1, when the Convention sat with closed dotors, and I wns not oven auflered to know what wera the ohorges against me? This in the firat time in_thae bistory of the Kpiscopal Church of the United States that a Convention, in tokiog up tho guestion of confirming a Bishop-olect, lias sat “with closed doors, and im- posed the obligation of secrcoy upon ity mot- lu!rs 80 u to keap Lim in tatal ignarance af the charges preferred against him. They rofused to allow me to be heard when { sent them = writton request to that effect, and thon they brought the chiarges in piccemenl, so that a fresh aconyn~ tion aguinst me was brougbt up at ' o'clock, when tho vota waa to bo takcu at 4 on tho same attornoon (i o tono of subdued bittaruess). You see that, withont even roforring to tho merits of the guestion, mine was » vory Lerd case.” “Dr, Forbes quotos thoe coso of Dr. Hawks ag » precedont.” “iAh, hut Dr. Hawks was prosout on the floor at the'Couveution to auswer to tho chinrgay pro- forred agniust him. And thou the Convoutiou Bat with opon doors, 80 that thore in a world-wide differenco from that case. Aud now to the chargoe that I had aliowed an extremo Rifunlistto come to tho Sominary fo talk with tho studenty, &e. This utatoment ia . TOTALLY UNTRUE, ° T nover permittod muy person to deliver a leo- tura privately to tho students, but, of course, avory respectablo man is at liborty to vinit his friends among tho studouts. I ostablish no eaplouage over them, aud lonve thoir social inter- course totally unrostrained by wny rule oxcopt that of respovtability.” “ (Tow nbout the charge that you defonded n young alemf'mnn who had deliverad a sermon on iho oucharist, tosching Roman Catholio doo- trines? " *1The porson in quostion was not a clergyman, but & student who had not yot been adwmittod to holy orders, My dofenso was not u defeuso of tho sormon, but moroly a proteotion againet what T considored an unwiso policy, that of consnring oftlcinlly the oxerciso of a student whila o s i lonrnor and not a toacher, Iinmated (and I still entertain the pumo opinion) that such n policy wan fraught with dangor to the Seminary, and wauld kava an injurious effect upou the students, iussmuch wa it pus them upon their trisl on all points covered by thoir thealogical studiea from the vory outset of tholr courso while they wers learnors and not tonchers. The discourse in question was writtou a4 an exorcise in thiv iusti- tution, and not as » publio sermon,” Dr, Boymour thon added that this was all ho Iiad to sny, 1l did not desira to vast any uspor- siony upon the character of the Rey, Dr. Torbes, :d had merely dofended himsalt galuat tho rgos made agalnet Lim. 1l was porfoctly willlng ta abido the isdue, ———i THE REV. MR. SULLIVAN, TITUATINN AT THE ENECOPAL CONYENTION. The Rev. Edward Sullivan, recontly roturned from the Episcopal Convoution hold at New York, discussed in rinity Uhurch, corner of Michigan avonue and Lwonty-slxth straot, yes- terday morning, on tho esuon adopted by tho Conventlon forbldding tho iutroduoction of new and uuncccssary forms futo the communion govvico, ThoNoverondgontioman said the com- munlon service waa tho yory lLioart, tho sost, of rituallstic lifo. Thoro bogan all the postutingand othior forelgn systoms of worship, which, under thewamo of Ritualiam, bad fnvaded tho Cliich in Romo diatricts of Amerioa and Great Britain, Bomo genttomen wt the Convention held that thero way little or no Ritualiem in tho Episcopal Ohurel, at homo or nhrond. He begged loave to diffor from thom—thoro was. In Eugland ho remembored that petitions in favor of Ritualism hod been prosentod by no less;than 483 High- Churchimen, whon the Barl of Bhaftabury ox- oressod lis groab nlarm upon tho subject, In Awmorica thore wore, perhaps, 3,000 clorles in tho ministry, and, out of that number, ho be- hioved that thoro was o vory fair-sized minority moro or Joas givon to gonitlexion, or mottors of that kind, Bome mon in tho Church wero fuclined tothink this & moro triflo. Thoy eaid, in effect, *Why donounco Rituslism, which la but weak, whils Rationaliem, with groat ecientists at ita hond, is malking such !“numl inronda in tho vory lifo of Christinnity 2" Ha did not bellevo that Ration. nlism_was'80 vory poworful in the laud, not- withstanding the onuncintioss of ' Irof. Tyndadl. 1lle Lolioved that thoro wna an inward =~monitor in {ho heart of man which forbade Athoism. Unbalief might bo upon tho Jips, but it was, au a rule, foreign to tho honrt, I8 chiof oblection to Ritunlism was that it took away the simple, apiritual form of rolig~ fon, and substituted i its plnco what was called *“ body worship.” Ho was led totalk on this par- tloulnl reatrictive canon beeatso it was apropos of the occasion, and Lo did not havo tinio to deal with other polnta that came up m tho Conven. tion. Ile, as & Churchman, was opposed to tha oncroachments of Rtitualism, and, therefora, ho cnn{;mmlnled the mombors of Trinity Churcly, as woll as tho Church at largo, on the wizdom dis- fayed in forbidding, uuder sovero ponalty, all urthor attompts to convort the communion ser- vice {nto o Ritualistic display. ——— Pocket=Moneys In a Ponnsylvania statuto for the protection of hotel-keepers, which provides that they shall not bo sccountable for proparty stolen from a grest which shall have beon deposited with them for snfe-kooping, gcenrs o clouse of oxception ng follows : ** Nothiug herein contained shall apply to such an amount of mouvy, and such sriicley of goods, jowelry, aud valuables,as is usual, com- mon, and prudent for any such gnest or bosrdor to retzin ju his room or nbout his person.”” An iutorauting cass undor this statuto hap just been tried before a rofereo, in which tho planti® do- manded tho restoration of %105 stolon from him in & Dittaburg hotel. The roforce has decided that tho sum named was too larga to ba carried a8 pockat-ntanoy by any propurly enutions and pm;h:;n man, aind tho easo will probably be ap- pealed, —DPark-Comminsionors Willinmson and Stew- art, the Committee appointed {o investigate tho dlnuppulmncu from the Central Parl carnivori- um of tho bull-dog ** Dangor,” who was captured by Mr. Bergl's ofticors aud confined in the mo- nugerio, yoktorday oxamined o number of park- knuqam and laborers 1n relation to the mattor. Their ovidence failed to afford tho slightest clow to the wheronbouts of tho dog or the manner of bhis disappearance. ‘*Dangar” was supposed to Lo the flucst specimon of Lis kind ever seen in t,llys country, and was valued at §800,—New York imes, AMUSEMENTS. MoVIOKER'S THEATRE, Last Wook of tha Charmning Actross, MISS CARLOTTA. LII CLERCQ. Mouday, Tucaday, and Wodnesdny, Last nights of THE SCHOOL FOR SCANDAL, Lady Toazto 1185 OARLOTTA LE CLERC Bir Petor 1 VICK] ‘o e, o, 11 Me 3 EP~"P'o praduction of this cosiedy is adunitted by all t b (e draatlo ovoRtof (ho. senscn.” 1o Ls Hover beow oxcelled In the country, el ‘om Taylor's beantiful drama, Next Weok~WYHBERT RREVE as COUNT FOSCO, GRAND OPERA-FOUSE, P ovpualto Siacwaz lowde, MONDAY, Nov. 2, Third woek of 1he Kventof tho Se: Kolly & Leon's Translation of Ufenbrelrs Carmis Opci XE: Ac\ TR . I i Dson T AN=NIGTITO) K ¥ LEON. With tho Most Gorgoou B RES thd Y Kelly & Leon's “Frmons Minstrels! 11 outive new Kthoopian Camlaalitios. Every Rvaning and Wednseday and Batarday Matincos, HOOLEY'S THEA'XRE. TRITUMPEHEANT SU'CCESS Of Bartloy Grinpbioll's Graphie Pictura of Amarlean life. MONDAY, Nov. 9.-During tho wook, and at tho Mati- nees, Seaond Week and Laat Nirhits of THE VIRGINIAN! Thio it of the Your—Ercry Act ifncored:—A Splondid Cast, **A puro and wholosome play.”—7'ribune, **A tonder story, full of truth and besuty, itaes, . otfoctivo deama.—/nler,Orean. Baturdaz, Nov. 7, ** Hame ot I praparation, *+Tho Telrof Primiross Hall," *Tho Wilow's,Victi, " **On tho RBI0, " ot ACADEMY OF MUSIC, First appearanco In overal sears of tho popular actor, antlior, an4 voontisty R W.d. RIS, EF L. OREIINCCIED ! Monday and Tuesday Lis world-famed chsraoterization of CAFT, CUTTLI DOMBEY AND SOINN. Wodnesd andSaturday “nights=NO Thoraday, THOROUGHEAT ciday uight and 8 Male THOROUGHEATE rlday uight and Haturdsy Mot SHOEMAKERS' BENEFIT BALL ! To be held at tho Workingmen's Hall, cor. Twol{th and Wallorssts,, WEDNESDAY EVE., Nov. 4, Goodmuslo STAR LECTURE COURSE. THREE NEW BOOKS Y Gen, G A, OUSTER, JUSTIN McCARTHY, THEODORE DAVIES, 1st. QIN. G. A, CUSTER'S GREAT BOOK, MY LIFE ON THLE PLAINS! Onavol. Eva. Printed on lald tinted paper ond olo. gantly Hlasteated and bound with 'fancy biack and goid samplng. | Prico, A "This book by our groatest Indlan flghtar, containing facty strangor than fictlon, will ba cegerly welooniod by thoussuds of ruadery, 2d, JUSTIN McOARTHY'S BRILLIANT STORY, LINLEY ROCHFORD. sloth, fanoy bluck stampin, ad, LOSING: TO WVEIN & A Novei by THEODORK DAVIES, one of tho brightost or g viatohwhitars on o New Yotk daihios, " Hhtes One vol., 12mo., fancy olot] One vol.. I2mo., papor, RECENTLY PUBLISITED, THEODORK TILION'S NEW NOVEL. TEMPEST TOSSED One vol., large 12mo,, tinted paper. Price. $1.75 T story {4 ono of marked powoer and haauty. Mr. TILTON wlelds a very gracakil pub, snd poasenaes & vivid Imagization, THE WETHEREL AFFAIR! By ol J., s\v, DEFORKST. L00. BY JUSTIN HcCARTHY. Talr Bazon A FETTERED FOR LIFH; Or, LURD AND MASTER, Dy Liltio Doveroux Blak. e 81,00 BY MRS, AWNIE. EDWARDS, Tdwards fv ons of tho brighto: M the norel-wrlars of SHELDON & COMPANY, PUBLISHERS, NEW HMEDICAL, NO PAY Dr Kean, sty JU0 HOUTL CLALIC AT, OIICAGY, A ody . fros of ohan nn'llill Ffi;}fi:’fl ,‘z} n‘e‘,":f.;;'."fd.l:.‘:i o e JREAN s lis Sy physiotan n tho ity wtha mi 4 Ol Houre, 58, e 16 8 bo i BUBdAs froiad 10 2. R, QOEAN NAVIGATION. NEW YORK TO CARDIFE, ThoBouth Wales Atlantio Htesmanm 0 FIrcnn T ponet CidarmuE oammemt ey (o £sil trom Pouuezitania Tallrond Whath, dorsar Gilys PERBNOKIC...Oct. 21, [DLANDRUAN... Oct. . nrrying p L throu, p Rt R T ARS Putieneory B TRl rates from Bristal Oliannel, and ail otlioe points in lngland, TS e s A e ot b oo g bl ity a8l e ipiovomants ok 1o auiatortas UABLN AND STERRAGK PASSENGIRS. Tirst Uabin, 875 and 880 aurronor, Bocand Cabla, 883 W curroic, qurmrmey.: it W0 X Teuali Stoarako onrtiilcatr $ SElin 1k BF At wowa i o Cardil N Tor futtticr. partienian, auply fo Cardiff, at tie Oame pany's Ofticos, N | finmivee ook ARONTA LD AR S 00 e e 00,, Arent Now i tfrondirars STATE LINE. . New Yorlk tn Glnagaw, Liverpool, Belfast, Al Londonderry.—Luose ‘segant, now, Olydo-hailt stonmers will gatl from Pior Nu, &, North Ktlver, aa fol- Tows: STATIE OF INDIANA, Wodnordev. .. STATI OF FLORIDA, Wednesdny., nd ovory Wodnesday thoreatier, taklog nassongars af hraugh £3t0s Lo A1) Durta o Greas Lt o Looinad: Norway, Kodon, Dommack, and Germany, Drafts for £ andnoward, For froight or passake apply to AUSTIN BALDWIN & CO., Agents, 74 Uroadway, Now Yorl Btoorao Ofice, Ko, 45 Sroadway, {tasrags as fow aby any vther line, N K. EATtLIs, Giail Wentorn Agont, il Olaricat.. Ghicago. National Line of Steamships, INOTICE. Tho most sonthioriy ranto hos {uis Coupany to uvft{zh;l_k |='ohiflfifif{‘i§akfifif' Soptad b o Wi b ory SATU DAY 2nd QUINS- Yok ez London (directy vy fortnight. Ui o 7 Hokots st Lovast raten. - 520 upward, o P B, LA itSON, Westarn Aeont, Nartheast sh'{;u Soener Clyek snd Randolplsts. (opposiaaew » Oot. 28 - Nov. 1. Great Western Steamship Line, 1 Ni Great w'fi‘a’{aer'é‘l.'"’x'\“-'gfi?.y.“fi"‘""%'.:”l’;‘:?fi."-’-‘u'l“%‘dnm. 12, Arrago aday, Nov, 24, Cabin P, 5 2 Int dfato, P R R AT 0! 20, Lalko Shure & M. R R, "= GHO. MCDONALD, Asost, RAILROAD TIME TABLE, ARRIVAL AKD) DEPARTURE OF TRALNS NCE MARKS.~1 Saturdayse Monday i 3 i endar exoouted. L Ax HICHIGAN CENTRAL & GREAT WESTERN RAILROADY anid 78 Canbetes corner o Sadivens T & Handolphy m. ¢ 8:000, ma :|* GER: e CHICARD & ALTON HAILROAD, J Chicayo, Kantus City and_Denver Short Line, oia_Loutrt. ‘any Jfo., and Chicago, Springjield, dillon and ST, Fosts Through Line, Union Depot, Weat Jide, near Hadiscna, Uridgé, Yicket Ofices : Ab Depol, and 121 Kandolph-st X, Teave, |_drrive, 2. m. . v & n, EX, via Jacksonvilis Divisioa.. .| 2. Bpringtiold Bxpross.. H . Bhelnggold Fant Kxp o Jenerson Uity Kxpron . Peoris, Keakuk & Buelinxton. .. b m, Chicagto & Pailucah Ratlrosd Fix. o, m, Steeator, Lacon, Waslitngton 1iz. p.m. dotist & Disiielit Acsommiodstion, &, my CHICAGO. MILWAUKEE & Sf. PAUL RAILWAY. Onton epot, enrner Y 4 Canaleat 63 Soth Ciarkeat., opposite Sherman House, ar Leaxe. Mitwaukoo, Madison & Prafrla dn Q100 MAlreevears oo o|? 9:00 8. . [*11:008. . Milwaukee, Gréon i Biaions’ Puint, Paul & Atinneapolis, h 4| 9:30 2. m.|*4:00 po s H " Fa e e, £, 7 orthern 1ows ail. 103 p, m.|* 7:50p. m. Bilwankco, Bt, Paul & Midaoip- " H olts, Niglit Xxyrose, t 9:30p.m. [} 6:45 5. m. ILLINOIS CENTRAL, #AILROAD. Late. ot foot o {00t of, Tecent deot, TYch DT T o iy ke T e, Bt. Iouls Expros: * 8. \ M. SE Tonin last b 0 Carok Now Orloans b . Cafto & Now Orloans 1 Peotia & Kokuk Jix Dubugquo & Sioux Dubuano & Sfoux Oliy Ex!, (a) Gllmal PAsIOBROT.o .. {a) Ruus to Chazpaign on Saturdaya, Ui, "0a, m. 200, m. CHICAGO, BURLINGTON & UUINCY RAILROAD. Depots~rtout of . Lakeats. Tidiana-av., and Sicloenthestsy Canal anil Sceicenthesid, ' Tickes Uficss, Noy 63 Clarke Mail and Rpres: Otimwa and Sires Dubuguy & slouz Oity Jixp. Pacitic Faot Line, for Omaba, Kansua Ulty, leareaworth, chison & Bt, Joseph £xi Toxas kixpross.., Aurora Passonger., d: Uttawa & 330N, 10t ernes Aurora Passenger’ B Dubnane & Slouzdity Exp, PaaiticNight Exp, for Omuba, . f{ Kaunsas 0";{ Jaavonwort ohison & S, Josoph Exp. Downer’s Girovs Accommord| l)uwnur"n tirove Accotantodation Dowai rovo Accowmodatis “kx, Sundore, 4R CHICAGO & NORTHWESTERN RAILROAD. Ticket agiecs, 63 Clistkests Shermans House), und 75 Ganats Tt cormer Naditonites and ui the g 23 £ G LAk Kaproa &—Iepot cornor of Wl ‘b—~Dyvot carner of Oan! Devot, corner of Vandiuren and Shernanta, Grand Pacifs totels Omaha, Leavonw'th& Atchison Ex| Poru Accommodatlor Nlght Fxproe. NOTICE, " Vesael Owoens and asters, We, thie undorsigned prapristors ad managors of tu buats 1uNTbg o il Cllosgo River aud vicinity: horcby ive uotica tbut, on and niter Nov, 1, 1814, tho lollawing How rates of discount will bo mado ffom tull taplif rates, 1t billa paid within 32 daya froin dato of tow, 50 pex ot diycount. (rom full tariil ruto; on bills paid after duyu, and Within PO doya (com (ato'of tow, 10 por cont dis wount from full tariil ratos; it not pald within 90 days, na discount from full tarll ratos, Ot all bills mada in 1874 previous to Nov. 1, and paid beforo Jau. 1, 1875, % per et diveonnt feou TaTl tarill raton: if aot paid bofare dha. 1, iy o dhscount trowy tul acifraton, *1 3.V, Toylor, Preat. Vorl Owhon mg Com Josso Gox, gl Gox'a Linu? William acmone Agt Union 1. A, Urawlord, Agt Howman & Crawford Liney Dinbam, Agt Dinban & Aoshor Lino: A; Burto, Aut Burton's Lino; A, Suvort, Agt 8 & Shields oy 1 Van Dojson, A ina F e WA %o SHiiors and C. Noton; 8% 11 Siritln, At tigs A, Lr Sinith and DMartin Groen: L., Wilson, Agt tag Moulters K. Waraor, Agt tug A, ustaphiove, Chloagy, Nav. 1, 1911, SCALE! FAIRBANKS' STANDAKD SCALES 3 OF ALL KINDS, A FAIRBANKS. MORSE & 0O, 111 & 113 Lake St., Chicago, — ' Bezureful tobuy only the Genuine, e = AR A~ -~ MRS, SYLVANUS REED'S Inglish, 1 Gorman Doanding and_ Day Sohool Jioelil, Veanch, e ORAC s Bos thied at.,” Nuw You # for the next year wiil boxin st a, m., Oct. b1 shiould be pros- 1, when all 1 st INuw':ulwl‘ln Will' ruport. Sept, €9, Whor toachors i olazy ¢ $5.00 ljgckages FRAGTIONAL CURRENCY IN'EXUILANGE FOR Bills of Natiggal Cnrrency, TRIBUNE OFFICE.