Chicago Daily Tribune Newspaper, May 5, 1874, Page 2

2 i . THE CHICAGO- PROF. SWING, DAILY . TRIBUNE: TUESDAY, MAY 5, 1874 tHo 'amabdplnndnd to th allopations, When | Noyos sasmdd to bo about o make, 4b ¢ Mr. Rurd did so, 8o ¢! it {honanid th ¢ -86m- ho lid done 8o, Inaio wad.Jolnoa on.n atior Of | Blapeor tho prbceadingh. 1t fabmod o i tang | tom fio o choghty eensn o acliclo procoad. | Il fomication s ttor . S8 niales T ivg | pger o0 b0 kmow mow s 14 waa fatroduced | ae o dig undoratand him, o bollaved bis viowa faot, and then all the Praubytory had to db wna | tho ttus courab was to Ingiire whother the lngg tho acctsed should bo clfllnd upon to plead, | totled thio hntdor to whito faith and liolinase, botatss Trof, Patton wanted loave to explaln. 1 s hurch. If willing to try ¥, hother the bepro Y od, sud thod to pa of this drandfu] pago bt histor: tlott ddows: ngainet R tho caao, 1t should ba triod without any asporits to ;rly! v‘v’ m‘;ko nr:?fi:r n‘?‘tumh m:lqflmgmvm f.%‘,-%’e": hiad beon sorved, and thod fo. proceed Noyos, In ordor to sottlo thomattor, would [ § A drendtn legghm e R S A, Nn:Lna anid It wnd a8 Introductory to 8 mo= | of tompor, Ho waw no necessity for it Lo LY not make his atatomont, nnd ho movod that tho tlon that o . ;i ishod to mako his statomont, but : s, | aftor inane was folnod, Tho Modorator romindod Mt. Noyes thot the | aconnod have ; ictmont. | - CAUARR OF TH1 IDELITT, ; bl ’ OFENFIAL TALK, The Firsti Day of HIs | " Wlkor nikod it th motion was in ordor, | Prossyhos bai s ot omionsd o bhoinoman's | 05 A Bt o o oot e ey o Prshplertn Gl b | 1o was ovortuoc, wnd [ did, not seen 19,52 |l Swazoy esplnined Wis amendmont, 14 _ "0lio Modorator did not - thiul It a quostion of | Judioatory, and, if i undorstood ko drife of hia | almoat wnanissay L £omo » motireo. of actual fudollty, by ia-tercifio doce | foga that was doniod b © doctrin] viaws sonI hot mo eagtio R0k 800 why Trial. ordor. - Ho dosirod tuo Pronbytory to sattlo it by | (Noyos') romnrks, thoy would b moro propor 3 it ot bl Ty to e day of Sdwars, and sivce, | "o Nodorator. romatked tiat ho (Noyes) bad | octrinal vlews conld not bo settlod by comparing voto. aftat tho body had formally ontored upon the | . rue pMod TLEAD, s tle pletiixon of pordicn hava boen mucl mn st first, { 5t hoan” oyorrulod, I ho delred- (o prasont | Yoy 48 othor mattors wora, Mr. Halaoy falt that tho ronding of thorulo | trial in n judisial capaoity. e o‘frntnrulg now bacomen the duty of | indeod, to fr) m‘m Tiia. mwititudo, but much a4 | Bo lue_a u\m;\lo e ho desl rnll motfl' o Mr, Kittrodge sald tho motion was to brin sememating tho FrwotorsnF oy s |l Noves thom (8t o pontorone, e | st ecmtly e b sentousnor e | el ity M e, ko | gy Gt st b promi thore vl | a8 ok 4 ntuat Yo of 4o : ) 4 it Lin net, and, 2 nco. Dr. Patterson's Reply to Prof | so bttt bt ol it ns. | S Dty ol oo | 9 T ot i e s . | ket 8l S | 12l i T e o ot | U084 s b nlos o = g " TIOL, 8WING'S ATATEMBNT, nppineed of the blossed, Tho faggot) 'rof. Patton would confine his romarks to post 2 o'clook. Agroed to. S 's Protest, iug, wan fromatura, a8 thie body was not quite | his seat, . Prof, Bwing then approhod the Modorator's [ o raok, aud ihio bolling ofl were s rerort of potents | point, unlons thoro wore furthor objeotion, ho forit, The & CORDEIPONDING MEMDERS, {4 ates, for, if God wi lorying in tho ¢ t of 1 i S Patton's ‘ Mo Y SOTRLI T MU |y o O IR, | S5 S8 B o th o 1 | S T Gt g s o 1 oo ation wiouta i to b undorstood that ATTERNOON SESSION. ot xRSt i | s bttigly o Sty it | OO o ot o | TSRS ST N | it Sillaihe Wi bosmtomiont it | pon ot " Baopa vus i Madoratorgo again admonish the Conrt, a4 corrdaponding mombore, Yo bis {5 nowed, and the motion ny The Acoused Is Called on to Plead :hBuvm"nl\l(ulonKlm enuodlfor I-?m quostion on po?:‘:;‘ngi’:ll;; l«:l:‘%ul:l:’,u :Luc:xl,g l;vu’v’\‘ludu. :rl.vowuhliga :I‘x‘:‘tl: ;:::nhl::gl::fll lo‘}l (fi.l?."i' m{:‘ll}nl\l; xf:llih::: %‘g:é, fxg'éfi'u'fr?fl‘fl;‘}.l"m,'# i’,.’n‘i?x‘n"l'.?,’ b::]&l::lgl;: H ill?: g‘r‘]l\:rl‘wmud::v%fd% )=flfi%ak?‘rr l!“‘rtgm“?lm {nformation. wSmanded was ol o otion, and Submits His Defense, Nir, Wallkor inslstod that tho motlon waa not | GAno boforo tho hotso, * i mlting in & Judloal capaclty, 1t Ia entiraly | U8 smoation, But peemie e o, gt trom ono | el DOl oo 15 1o | , Bir. Rood movod to skrks out tho words * and o, i sl i oo o i | i it G o o 1. wou b | WPEREIMG f momite o, ho ey, | GG scrr® Bt g AR Wy | ity Sl otk ol 2 | it and ot r . ; 10 i Tl 3 milellxh Obnir was austained. . prfl‘. mel;:mzo lTkoofl. if it whe undoratood | 15314139, i any oxprosslon of fooling of thia | lib, " Ho"myat 1t was tho fomer cwn. | Hitnossos. Tlhoro might bo wome rosson why it i etatasi b oL Tasts 4 411 00 thiat Eliono wwho woro admittod undor th i kind, I"hopo silonoo will bo obsorved in tho | tury which prepared tho way umong onrmoiven | $hoy shonld fiob bo Litd, and, a8 o hnpponed | oplnion was ontortained by many of tho Proa. He Declares That Ho Is & NeW | ainr bt orts i o ke paetion o | SoCHon, 200 itk aition uader the mollon | toture. - ok o et (o o 3 T of Rk | 100 Souso mi oy’ SHoRE ok e e i | Lyter that such a conclusion would by rosohod 3 3 - . of evaugellc 0 dry forms of 1 dea 4 Dr., Pattorson was Inclined to think that it | after the body passad {uto a court, - SR o T b 1o etiey %flr{ny“,;‘,;"::,’:; orthiodozy 7 s AcrIMORS of hat Boriod were fof fho | b Souuoi. why th mply oftored the panar ia | ot tho prosceutor would gladly and jopfaily School Presbyterian, would be more in accordance with the oquities | = Dr. Patforson moved as on smendmont that | g mont part . o , . . . ahoub Cryplo-Colvinists, that Preayytory might whothoy | Withdraw tho charges, of tho eneo {o admit mombers to the vourt up | they bo invited to alt as corresponding mombors | 59T hars' 1y eout, Fhich I Lave groat doub | By, Byhpite, Mojorinin Antlnominas, Gat | grdor st tho Troskslory might say oot | T ) Noyos sald the. defondant dld nok wish ta io b fima whos fspuo vas olued. oxsept wlon tho Yrasbylory wau satug o ita i only oy iaormont b aort of oty P o eyt O pyspon of o papér.vas Uit madoril oo | avold rin, Xio (Sving) was not thero of b N i on the pary of the 3 most h hatituted for Hving faithy, wh of tho testimony could not bo had at that time. | own motion, b i futetlon was theh it on the mellon to ,,2"3{-,;‘;33;‘{‘:0 1t waa s nassusd thing | *rig Biotoseor thon rous as follows leveh aiacenen o tho et iriysan it | 1o mmply mado bla” afidavit to that s, | o t amemer :‘::,’;;”;‘:;;J_’;;’;“‘:fi;‘;‘;”gfim‘; w i oo } Br. Hwazoy gave motico that T mrt athers | priviloge sanctionod by thé rules, 1t was frae ”c'!fi:’ifim?; Rminde ol raas péocecdings to on- anda ‘Trenh bondagoto | a’x‘fi’m“%&‘l“";."uiaucifi,‘lf‘u’fi'. ?;"éf,t J{,“fi,‘,&’;; % jores mfih:[gl):{?fl f}‘ffl: ‘i‘-‘,‘lfi,‘i 8aw no nocossity for conforring with him. It would antor & protoat, bofore tho chsd closad, §o | 1ho Prashytory Nad & tight o oxclido fhe miaihe | tev g buL s o be 2Ult andspesitcations preseated | €a1ne simplo noseasity fos enosgatlo minda ks Lomn: | 138027 WCeclod wlthout, Ity “thoro wowld. by | TA5L0k compotont for any committoo to consids . **2 | tors, and to limit thoir rights; Dy Francis ing to conio to an opon breach wifh traditionnl Proteat. | DYEOEY P d or tho mattor, and bring in & _roport thnt should tho form of the clinrgos aud epecifioations, ] J rights; bub 1t would Do | by Francs L. Patton, Tbeg_pormission to submit tho B R tiomotiy o nothing on tho racord to show’ that & materinl | padect ! P 'Tho Rov, Mr. Glbson, of tho Becond Church, | unprecedouted if is wora dono‘ sud ho thought | £allowlugt T objeot to ths chargen aa too vatio and ns | {INRD: /5 7 in oposition (4 & theogeta | Witnoss wasnot prasont, aud, i¢ the caso wanb to | 1290t ovor 50 littlo upon him, without a trial. s thon neked tho usual conatitutionnl ques- | tho Prosbylory ehoutd look b o matter cura- | SRLrising o Imporisnt offonee, yot, not wishing to | Guiicas (o% simplotmoratly In ornostionta s theertlo | WEERR0 CH R ROt BESEECc MO 10 Mottt the | 110 was arruignad on spociflo chargos—not.vory | {50 any technival objactions, I enter the plea of ¢ Apocifie—nand yas thore to answor th Th tlons™ in ordor to muko him o full mombor of | fully, lest, in taking suoh & stop, thoy bocamo | Fif#RY iechnioal oblset i thoology of (he lInst coutury was chiofly to | Proubytery procooded notwithstanding tho ab- nawer them. Thoto thio Preabytory, ho having recently besn recolved | guilty of n broncl of courtesy, They would 7, 0 exiraats from sermonn and weit- | 3,00 00¥ (OF 1hO Db oo npoataey . from. tha o i wag nothing which tho detendant wishod to havo by Jotter. ' BT Raray oo tiat *tho“Lratieoh "woro | ot b U1, the vy o, conaitei | w0, ol (SRR VY £ 5 | sunco of matortal ooy, o sosponsty | miiod sxionsthscusai of i e o How the Church Is Quietly Slip- ping Away from Some 0ld Doctrines, Some Members Want a Committeo on Conferences i the clghtocnth contnry to tho ond of the frst third of 3 . conse. But if o commitico was desired to - THE REPLY TO TIIE PROTESY. might flnd someo friends among thoso prosont, A “"!(HTD‘GD PAEZADYTERIAN, o s FoRtn elt. b 1" | b ]4 irrelovaut, 0 conclusion thaf lora was no And Beliove the Troublo Oan Be Note | g2y Zttorson said it wos in ordor, s waula and I yould bo & very singaiar thiog 1o Satthack o fony anl tolisvn como Into contlleh with 817 | Gfectecs th tiwake. e mes mo rte i o on. | ““Elag Modorator held tho samo viow. f;"{,’{,:"u‘}“li';‘,';';lfi,"gfl‘xfufi_"u':l'nuf;’,’r’,;“_“d-“ soomed rond tha roport of the Committee appointed to | off. He novor know of ita having been dono, fnation witls whioh T sm conaeled, and T bex vormain- “aelves Lavo sown," Mr. Ely said If tho papor showod that a ma- UUE WANTH NOXE. answor tho protest of rof, Patton, 2r. Noyos anld if Lo Lind positlve Assuranco | alon fo enter s u part of my ples. the followiog siates | , Bich aro tiio ords of. a profound thinker who, to | torial witness wne sbosont, that was suiliciont No _objectis o, b ub- | that ovory one ndmittod to tho privilogo would | mentas 1, Regardin Jalions fo the Libi his famo as & thinker, ndds o parallel fama of ploty. Prof, r"nunn said the party b tho bar had joln:d‘:loj:fim:?:h:wms e g1¥0 his toico sud fniiones Wholly o £l sldo of |- Obrehen” 3. s iy 21y Ten(iom to_the Brasbyte. | Amid pomo”of o wnparailled doctrien of Tmoye f?rrlz.; gfl:“‘;‘mfi:’o’ _’L‘:\%\.vn\‘:l}?ntu:;luox?l'ogn]\:fi Plonded Nt guilty™ to tho ohargos, and ho N Ian Oliirob, Of those I ahall speak in thelr order, Ghurch arose the intelleotual rovoltof the prosent s = was in sympathy with what Mr, Noyos had said Thie Commites appofnted to draw up an suwer to | $10 seousod Lie should atill object, i D * | tmoa, ond wo can only cheolk tho progress of tho ovil' | Motk conkntnod thoy conld fiok ndé intoll{gontly, {ha Proiontof ¥rof. X, L, Tutlon nd ‘othore, mubmit | | Mr. Halaoy romacked, it the smomont 410 | ey or expiointss ine usality of the puio | B MNIrowing tho couse. It {3 uh ansinous feot gk | Bir. Trowbridg avkod thmb tho paper by red | % Sororenco o 450 nscloshyen of 8. Commltien the following : body passed into a judiclal uqmoh{ thoro was 10 | el Taoill atnte that of Aetecn I ircs delivored fu | tho liboral eread which {he ohisrges in this cano so nt- | and admittod as ovidence. confer with him, and could mob divies - tled at Once, But Both Acouser and Accused Demur to ;. Tho pratest prosonted by Prof, F. L. Patton and | longer indiscriminato dobate, aud hence tack b hiafly from that Iand which onco I By This. ;;';:"‘“';;ypgfi’"m{g&mfl Doy, Ioasieh e tio would bo no diffoulty, Hises i’i’x.'.fl‘i:’fif."fi?i-’:‘éfi?fi.x’“& om0 er0 00 | olly subject Lo tho nevors tenets of th Tarisnn. 7 | thar' ?u’&?’-‘lfi‘flffi‘é?fi?fifén"“m to.badums el ool e e oatera sobme: aoiuisace oheer N ! A LEAGONADLE ORTIIODOXY, . al agl action agninst whioh ghn protest s dircotod. ¢ [ - Dr. Paltorson would not hold 'a momont to | bt oe, reniunorstion wan doclued, Helico the apirit 1t agome to mo the woria 18 now Tully reaay for an | D Pattorson did not bellavo it propor to - | $P%y 10, SO Judgmont, and {n view of thg ‘Tho protest s dlrected agaliiat the action of tho | this smondment, if it wero undorstood fhnt tho | that promplei snch eotures must fiavo beoa notany | o i S30T0 40, TGP ROl now Ty ronty fonan | e upon putting tho papar on roord unless it | fagfy in bun oasd, 1t would not bo botten fonf 1ie t would b marked pardiality for the So-called liboral. socioticn, b Prof. atton Waats ontinunnctoce | B B SR it | oo vl b sl w7 o | szttt i, M G | B i b cr e | Sttt b S | ol Vel belal i Mr, Collier Is Away, sad specificationt tablot by Pror. Tatton agoiuwt iho | Mr. Farls inquired if ho Ind ever kuown the | oG Smis koer Ok Loould” suh the tho dn;‘klmenxugyfirmm(hnu Ldwards in gour wholo | tho busis for a motion that. any of thom might “fl,mp,.;:n,,?“m; ",",uuu:u'é ‘:‘;’; i‘,!tfl‘,fl‘u‘!hif:."? flor, Dt Selng i, o, far e titan Saciments | rulo o7 ofulon to b onforcd, e o thory ot xcopt it o | 5, Robing il i on ot am e | naosd to ke g, 18" Comiton sa15 o shoury en s - apaciticutons. 1L il ThGo f0 ntica Yry B16DY tho | gromia SO pado o0, ot Be vas mok | OB WL toWATD et wER, yono | ontah i ot Chaoh o g | e Modorator doldod tho motlon of 3t | 820,148, Commitas cllod b should sty ta 7 e ’ nmiliar with judicial proceedings, o y upon the basis of & wide fricudship anyona A e oung aut of ardor, on tho ground that It Intor- $ h Affidavits of Ministers as to What Colller Saide.- igned for tho proteat : away from tho roliglon of deapair, shid ins como unlo 1 ho would tall them in” advanco that it wonld Tosaons Firat—~1t 1a alloged that thiera i8 nothing in tho Dook {ormnfl{‘ l;nlunged foa churoh that very seldom | 9atilive woll thé fow yeats of this oxiatence, and Licuca Matint Biou, {nto tho atmospliero of Josus as Ife wos in | fored with the course of proeoduro. Tho wit- 1 P have no effect. He had mo objection to of Discipline providiug for thi intment of & Judt. | had such a thing a8 o brlal,[Laughtor. o deslino to locture on bohalf of & Unitarlan chanel | et Nt full of Taeo. nd forgiconesn. Aug | nosses shoild now bo examitod, I the Nrosc: S Shrieenlas peeriaiug foc i appolatrent e Tl | e e e it g g i kosety 1o oURGL a1 NouLd s good o | oL isonly G maccow feld Just latod i that | cutor wna Tomdy, he could. procaody if ank, np | TCCHIE 8 Sommittos, Riovided 46 wes nos {t16 not ailrmod, that {ho General Rule for Judioa- | motion of Dr. Pation was agraod to, with but | oxihoos thaploy oo vt 1oa o Tnve in nuy way deparled frony tho doctrines of tho | was willing to Hton to o motlon for n contluu- mmlitooto confor with him. [Laughter,] 1 ereed, St 1o protestod [ tionw, No, 41, doo not nuthorizs the Judiclal Commit- % o Trosbytorian Church, B i 0 proteated agninst the Prosbytory stult!fyin) too 0. rocommond that e prossoutor should bo re. | ON0 NOBMIVOVOte. s, g s Doter 1E0iny It con e e oy o Son gk s 0, OBOOF b mont. datinguenet of our thoclogieal | AUCS: | TXCept with unanimous consont, nothing | fisolf by Tassing a metion whish sowsais E quited to mako 1s chargos or spocifioations ore defle | o Afodorator—We will now onter upon the | Ministry rovesa ee)s frlendship toward il macking, | teachers in tho East has just written : * Thora i not ation. statoment challonging tho right of ono of ita e ho Modo! 7 oY n A on a1 80 108 4n they unfurd ihé baner of thelr own loye, | S10UEh in that indiciment to convict' ono of horsby, AIMEST OF PHOCCEDINGE, membors to bring chargos agaiust another, Ho i sy ooy b | e byt s op M, mombor | o AT SRR | o et Mo 0% ety | e et 2P Tl e o s o aparabin, S tho Generai Rilles for Judicatortes fecommondod by the | Prosont $o recolldet snd rogard thelr high ohar- | tho aivil polico drovo s Lalting sinner into the ¢ A s Tono et prd s one. Savlar, anc r. iittredgo bolloved lia would not obfect it * % Genoral. Assembly for tho ndoption of fhe infarier | Notor ns Judgen of & court of Josus Christ; and | Churen bfiauap ared, 40 tho mogern ‘Duiptt munt | fostoning i their fafth upon iHim ns a Rodoomet, will | g honrd the motions “And that acommujme or | Proposedto susiain charges, Shorey's Rebntiing Letter, Testimony to Show Oollier No Uni- tarian, MORNING SESSION. Tho Chicago Progbytery mot in the leoluro- { Jugicatorios. ‘Thess rulos wero adopiod by thia Pros: o duty iv whiols they aro about to act. | SOminunicate ita idons nlong the cliords of ‘felondsiaip, | €28% OF many of the forms which now porplox them,” INTERLOOUTROY BESSION. room of tho First Prosbytorian Churab, corner | byisey aftes tho rounion of {ho Ghutch,at Jta meotin fi,fi:fi‘m b e Lnquey 1 ¥horkor tho Blsues | S0 he Wit peretec the Mg cnin oty fondati e TIOLES OEANLIER, et e pflmffi';‘rlomu:f"‘;’;@' 51 et | ggAltor some more disoussion relativo to tho a Indian 4 | 18 Ocfober, 1871, and wader Rulo 41 tho boderator uag | GLiorjine tho firsb tnquir fathér up the largost and snost diverso multitude lnto | Deloved brothren, 1, hioldiug tho gonoral creod na:| ST IEOR, B0 630 b A constitutionslity of such sclion ns was con: of Twonty-first stroet and Indiena avonue, ab | uriointad A Judicial Committeo botore the charges of | C1otk Las isaucd tho cltatlons, (ho graap of his piiro affections roudercd by tho former Now Bchiool Thoologlans,I | understanding botwoon them, to goo if, it 5omo | tompiated by tho motion, Mr, Thrd & half-past 10 o'elock, for tho purpose of trying | Frof, Patton wore introducad. Ttfs mado * tho dut. “The Btated Clork ropliod that he had issucd UNFTARIANG MOT HEOEASANILY DAKNED, il in addition to sicl o gonotal statemont, rapeat o | way, tho trial moy not bo avolded "sThough tho | foepieeey by tho motion, M. I Juoyed thof Prot. Bwing npon tho charges of heresy and une | of tho Judicial Committeo™ to dfgest and arranga all | them to nll tho persons named na witnenses, 8, Dt Iok 18 Goimo ow lo- o granideat eason | 3O, arliclea of bolief wpolt which T am willlng (o | motlon was not stricily in ordor, tho rial having | W90 e b ey ) eiiory smglon « SnE D0 B y, the papern, and to_prescrilie, under tho Qiraction | Tho Modetator—Tho noxt thing in_order will | why & Troubylecian may oxpress fi muny wayn o [ oot lhio sducated world, and the sifoptical world, and | commoncod, yot ho kuiow io 8poko tho hioarta of grocd to, and Mr, Hurd reed repard or “th faithfulness proferrod against Lim by the Rov. Dr. Patton, Tho Moderator, the Rov. Arthur Mitchell, occupied the chair, and THKERR WERE THESENT the Reve. Dr. . W, Pattorson, L. J. Halsoy, A. Swazoy, F. L, Patton, W, C. Young, A. H. Dean, J. V. Downs, J. M, Iaira, W. M. Blackham, E. ‘W. Barrott, G, O. Moyers, W. Forsythe, W.J. ‘Wood, John Covort, E.R.Davis, E.L. Hurd, ‘W. F. Browno, E,Bcoflold, J. B. MoClure, J. Munroo Gibson, J, H, Taylor, Joseph H. Burns, * A, Mitchell, J. H, Trowbridge, J. H, Walker, M, the sinful world, using my words in tho evangelical T the following document : 640 mo-callsd ~ IdDeral s ) vory many, sud could make tho motion vary iogs, #Todigest™ {s $'to disposo in due method,” ont in $ho caso, to plend, socts, 6 -#ln of tho “lootare,” ag | BOUSO: Tho inspiration of tho Holy Beriplures, the | o st i i Bince ccolesiastical diacipline can hinve no forco, ex- thet. o, "t put ' In proper fann for frid, | *erpoudentin tho caao, fo pland, hordod, miis bo busot upos tho gesumpiion fat tho | riity, o divinity of il tho oiin of Qurlst ua n | SAICLY, otthpstly dosiving aud bollovinig tunt if ( coptfeoum s owm Juntice, L5 Apprabetton v b gr at lenst to counider and supgest totho Judicatory [ are Noves gaid it would bo proper to read the | URitarian secls ars cutcusts from God, haviug no hopo | Todiator whien grasped by ait obadient faith, ¢ ver | thmt : 5 partial public, and "the approval and beuediction of the form required by {hie rules of the Church, Ac. Noyss el Propar fo toad, intlis life to come. Tho nismea of Clianning, and | 4108 by dodu spicit, man's natural sinfulucay, and tho | trinl, a a > " Oluriat, cordingly, the Judicial Committes of tho GeneralAs. | SLBTgas firat ; buty as ovory one was protty fam- | Eiijowt, sna Huntinglon, and Poabody, in thepulpits | 2131 soparation of the righteons and wicked, I'io Modorator decided that, * tho motlon be- #ince our Book of Discipline properly proseribes sombly, whose dutles correnpond closcly with thoso of | iliar with thom, and the Tonding was simply a | of that gact and the Ohirict-lite livos of thotsmds o O sllitio ot bilo | 178 of & peouliar charactor,” 1t wad in ordor. groat and considorato caution i recelving sccasa~ our Judiglal Committes, ks often vecommended not | formality, he moved thnt it bo dispensod with. | the congregations of that donbmination, uttorly oxe 1{;{“} sow xead baloca Son i outilsio of. 5y tal o s THR DEFENBE OBIEOT, Uous or charges, and great delleacy and “ Christion only the {esuing of easex brought beforo thom, but the | * ‘M, Wood did not think, when tho book said §hude frow my mind snd my beatt tho 'most romolo | Jotlod and of oy, Surtatiag orceds It 38 for | Arr, Noyes—The rospohdorit in this casods | 00 rothotly tandorneas ™ tn treating any caso of Al oty BN Do g o (EIUBAS Of | tho clinrgos must bo read, that the rendlug could | 4éa thal in sholing Luat brotherhiood any Kindnows, | 328 o, " doclde whothor “duero s Tin ome | o SOHEOIE SRRORIO (B Prosvytory | 108¢d horesy In doatzina, T o el T o 'pApeals and bom: | 1o waivod. low would ofhor. quostions bo P etron sapbraYal to peraond outelde it | your brothorliond, Having confoadcd ovorywhére that | nr satisfiod, from $ho Announcomont, of by tnih Ganty by tho Toow B 13 befors th Kt A Bobold fhat the dudicial Gontmitien 15 not” bound ta | Bected by walver 2 ~Could the Coustitution b | [ Of the Guristlen eligion Ftatis beyoni the fomty | o valio o€ o ainglo lifo docs not. dopond upon secta- | vlows thls morning thint ho is nob guilty, it ia ot | Justly 't demand grodt. charity wad Isdtase of sous #uty " to recommend that oliarges and specifica- | 8ot nside by a vote 7 1 wholly zeputdiate, It s, indecd, tmy conviction that | TioB relnllanm 'm.‘ -u;;v‘nl mntnnc ieal or Ol rd atian ;fi nocossAry that o committee be sppolnted to glve | structton snd interprotation ; and since tho witnessen tons referrad to them should bo mada inoro definite, [ _Dr, Pattorson #aid it was, nob ompotont for | they do not hold a8 correet a vorslon of tho Gospol in Sious; Toam portectly. tiliing to crosas boundary which | information to this body to sny such purposcs, | ¢itod to sustaln sald apecifictions aro sovoral of thom if tey deom them not suilicleatly expliolt, thero is | tho Prosbybory to waivo the rule, bus, if it woro | shat snnounced by tho Evangelical Allinnce s fow yearn It S o alownto n;,g;{"m; u;;' S oyt | I hois ltiy, thero is nothing to do bt to pro- | inacccsstblo; and sinco the Prosbytory has heard tho 20 notbing in tho nktuss of thele offico to Jordid that. | dono by unanimous conent, ho did nok sce that | ARO, ot T Justsd oertain thatiha biessod Lord doos | i€ 8 ¥ Ahe cped with this case and issuo) oven to the oxtont | hatemout of Praf, Swing of his bello! In tho funda of tho fudieatory, thio whiclo rder of tho praceed. | Lo for tho Moderator to ask Prof, Swing, tho | Xind M. Wakeman, J.MoLood, W, R.Downs, J. T, o 3 el X shall 641l proach, tnless my mind’ should pass M Dathiows, P. Oardin, O, L. Thompion, O, Wis- | Siof 0wl inako such resommendationy and tho | yiorg conld b any objection to it v oamcas S e et pen tho mind | Birouhadreahiod of chasgestn fuo futuse, . - | Of bringing in o verdiob aguldet him. Lo fatal | Bobial docilion of e Gonocl ‘as espresct inlis por, D. J: Burrell, A, E, Kittredgo, Glen Wood, | roport and to ack upon it, witnin the ltaita of the Gon- | r. Reod movod s sn smendmont thnt the | vty g ieare:that loves and trasts 1. 1t ta posa | , F70m tho prosccutor of thia caso T would not with. | objoction to & committeo is thas it looks gelical scnse, h L. h. Roid, Jacob Post, B, H. Ourtis, David | stitution, oharges alouo bo ry uf; thot tho _venorable Dr. Hodge, of Princeton, holda hold my conviction {hat ho lasncted from nasensoof | lika some sort of a compromlse, If Wicknzas, Responaiblo parties, in whose judgmont Second-~1t 18 allegod that {he recommondationsof | 'I'ho amondment was agrood to, and the Clexk | u mors truthful view of Jeaus fhum may bo held by | 40ty s crofore, fo bim uad to souall, brethren, Tex- | tho accusod s guilty of tho charges | in such matterstho Presbytery have reason to havo cone the Judiclnl Commiitee In tho proscnt oaso ware of the | road, #e follows ¢ y : ihe dlstinguisicd Pesbody, who hes bt Toolired fam gondwith aud hopeiat b w; "’;“‘"’; Toliglous | on which ho 16 arralgndd, thon cortainly thotq ia | Sdence, and who have Lat oprortunity to learn the nffarian standpoint before thé Calviniats fn | $¢ (xaiethal, Jou wilt bognabled lo do whatds right | o noed for any ono to inform this body that | Pereonal bellet, and tho constant publlo toachings of Bwing, D. 8. Johuson, William Broteaton, Jamos Harrigon, R. K, Wharter, THE LAYMEN, nature of & domurser fu elvil courta, which should bo | gjaye Firat—Tue Tov. David Swing, being s mints. | from his o arae it ‘Lo onabled 1o do pereonal g mado by tho defondant, Dut the Frosbytory, fu such Preaby the Unfon Theologiel Bomiuary, buit wo can point t ol e g Vo ving LDrof, Bwing, tostify in n speolfic way tholr conviction The roll of cliurohos and {cir 1ay roprosonts- | Easee iy Grend Jum, Court. and PattSuks. il i acy | Lo OF the Preabytecian Ofuech Drctbytoms ot Oiarer | Hothing i to Tible that would indicato that esvan Diviommme, | 1% Tl tontohort 1F ke ok gt | ofbis o oo Tt doctice o tives was noxt called, and the following respond- | and tls first duty to #eo that the chargos sad Tnelflch Luna uot Been zealous and fallhful i’ maintsining thg | 98 to bo given to only the one of those two gionts whio ME MUST PROJEED, Mttt Vi By oty 'i'm Yy 3 speoting which ho hins been called in- quostior, thore. ed ; First Ohureh, J. A. Otis ; Becond Churoh, J. | tlons ore conformed to the Conatitution and tho des | $rathe of tho Gospols aud has not Boon. fatihital Shnd | mAY Juticad tllo cloatsr sporehonsion of a iruth, It | = Prof, Patton—Tho propor coutso “for tho ot want any commitice to sit upon this caso and | f 8, Gould ; “Lhird Cliureh, J. M. Horton; Fourth Ghueh, 0. H, Leo Fitth Ghusob, Elifah Binith Eighth Church, J. E. Tay; Jefferson Avenue Church, Tuthill King ; Grace Ohutch, Genrfiu H. Frost ; Ashland Avenuo Church, F. A, Riddlo s “Westminater Church, J. D. Wallaoo; Evanston Churchy, A. L, Wiono ; Hydo Park Oburch, H, A. Hopking ; Highland Park Churol, 8, B, {yill: iams ; Lako Forrest Church, D. R. Holt; Man- tono Chureh, O, A. Bpring ; Homewood Church, - fore cisions of the higher courts, both a8 to sub tinied that ants th - | try to offect’ o compromise. [ shall mostdo- | Jasoluod, Tt the Presbytory do not And Justifieatio form, hofora onsauiiog lo-cpnsidar tham anw avurt; | Cueht 18 (20 exeroco o tus publlo dulles of bisoftico | 07 b seatuned hat Goi grial Lie world saivtion | Deeubstory to pureuo la Lo ontor upon tho proao cidedly protost against auy suok notion, £ov procediing n's, JUGES Srvestigstion. wrd b i | &8 such minlstor, Y | oution, unless thore bo some roason for arrest- v and this, whothior tho accused party s presont and do. "harge Second—~Tho Rev. David Swing, bal # Rodeémer, but that God will graut this saivation to DR. BWAZEY ¢ therefore, tho Rev. I, L. Tatton, D, D., have leava to murs ormot. Tu ook of Discipiine, OLap. 1, Beo. &, | miranlé fieond=The Tov. David Buing, belo 3 | Only thono wio folly appranend s fact. 1 an laes | 08 tho procoodings ot this point, I can only Hoped tho motion would nob pass. The tripl | Nithdrawtho charges nd specifications againat tho 1t fa Bald tha “ notbing ought to be constderad by tuy | Bliten or Amevica: aiel & motmime Sel Prsbyirrod | Dot to bo onlertainad Hor Al mstent, for thin would " | 887 that X could wish that arch an atrest of pro. | LOP b s Ror, David Swing; that the sald pspers containin; Tadiont T mitted e oy'ay | Blatos of America, snd s member of tho Presbytery of 3 ol cecdings might bo proper, in view of tho candid | B11uld come to a concluion, i¢ it -could, prop- | 1y eharges an apecifications bo raturned o DS ueation, which ARSOL "o DrOVOL Uo. be. ek from | CLIcEdg, doss ok piuceroly recoivo and adop fho | o\ - IVE HEAYFK oRLY 70 ERILOwRMIES, intomant £ whish wa hava Just lstoned. T do | Sr1%, 8nd he thouglit that . conforonco botwoon | Patgor, snd that ho- s peaions g, etucaed o D, Hotipturs, of rom the romlbtiona b be #iich from | Confersfon of Talin of thin Ohurch 8 containing tho | And indeed only &9 thoso of this small clans who sball | statoment to which wo have just listoned. I do artios in litigatlon, if not o succossful ono, loft | sponsibility sttachod to & prosccntion of ohor pire, or trom the rmgulations and practic of tha | gystoin of ductrin taught n the Holy Seripturos, hiave mndo 10 fntollectunl mintnke, Looking unon the | not feol, though I have listened vory carofully [’h matter in & bad condition. In ofh { sty el yros rges GChureh foundod on Scripture, and which dooa not jn- T boNe W mullitudes who nesd this snivation, end sceilg that | to tho rending of tho paper, that I should b | Fi0 Matter in o bad condition. In othor words, | agafust s rinister bofore s Presbylory. Valve those evils whiok disciplino 13 infendod to pre. NT OF ORDER. thoy w0 compoted of common imen, women, and | justiflod in dolng anytbing slso. fhan proooed | Af the Hattek was voforred ta‘a committee, tho |, Jicsolued: That witlout any refieation upon olfhor of yont.” The Judicatory e, thorefore, (ke right, and | Afr. Noges destred to spenk to tho oliarges— | ohifdren who kiow hothing,of tho distictions of for- ing ey pmmgmm. of tho caso, aud mon Mr, | €180 would be projudiond eithor for tho acoused :3;;‘;;;yg:;a;;ggg;w;:;:mlm L ihl e 3 3 3 SoINAE it Totors fham e A e | G e’ undor W {hore assoni s R R et U | Bhooloator cupperd 1€ hers'anto e | ST s Pl st lereo s opaelot b | ng whih D Bvsaoy aid b Qo ik ot for hi hould bo o8 definite ns possiblo,” avon t e ., e gid insisting upon tho torms o 6 bool 10 | from tho presontment and answer that the proseatt i [ 2 Fe SascTAcation of T phaniae mboible ovan to | s i b o oward e vos b frrronhh ok et 40.9% | exminstion of witnossos Ahould bo procosdod | pna oy ciaimeat and answer that tho pioseattor | T tlior waro any sides in tho tontioverar. ho tho Confession, that aro ontd to be i M. El{rouunpo nt of order. Ho bolleved | b post 1 'y bumen, | SN A in_any “mattor pertaining to thls case, cxcept | Delovged to tho sido that was gaing to win, but Paghen. S e DRSS (288 10 | it tho vl ‘of procoic:adopled by b | 8ad wiae st oca s G, Y Duiton—Thatin ot cortct. o 817 s hroseatlon ond i Doty | thut wido woulaTomo It poonlias wiseing 1 the charges sud epocifications Do explicit, tho. Judioial Egfl% :g""l'u?‘; e 0. °I‘(§§::v &0 doton: r;‘l:"‘ The hiarinony oxisllng botwein ail iheeo brethren | Tho Modorator was ok infonding o raiso any o Prosbytery ; and, {urthierunoto, that 1 o duty orthls | papor wero adopted. o balioved tho Proge Committes may recommend that this order be taken. ne, S B A i & 1 and myself 18 not o harmony of vicws fu the mind, objection to tho afldayit, By comion consent, ;’"‘g‘ kel s _hflm'){h T '"'- yiory was made” up of good lnwyers, Aud in 46 doing neither the Committos nor tho Pros- | & demurror, he bad nothing to say, bukb | buta hsrmony of love in the soul, They each and all 1| s the prostontor to Soneider whiothor tho thtoreals | nnd 'nien who understood tho gotifua of tho Pros- is bound, to judge in regard to tho character of [ to bring to the notico of tho Court soma of the il theoldgy, we cannot but coneltido that paradise J. Coldwell; " Joliet Contral Ghureh, . | Hprens's, i Judse o regurd to the charmolor of frnnny Yociona Which mIght by adatiod bo see | Bol o he e emEn of topeoneiud fhat. pe Yoving, | Moderator, I dosiro to Land to tho Olork ordioseonserTalnla o auilohurahes (hat these nre times aalitng for 2001 and B gabers ppnsynood ~Ohurch, J.o H. | s matter of acoumation” Tn Dok of Disclplitie, | hort o wmotio £0 quash {ho ndiotomont. whigl. | Sbedient faith 1 Sosss Ontiat. AN AYFIDAVIT hioh would obviato tuis, and offe : Ry B ning fe druthe uf 1k Geael aud Hurlburt ; Rounien Ohuraly A, I Morrill ; En- | Olap, 4, Boc. & knd in tnG decitlons of 1710 sud 1824, | S5k gioh “aborions foil, £ho prosecator bl | . Whea we zomomber ticsa’ things, and_rocall that, | of my own which ho will bo ko enongh to read | Mich would obviat this, and oftored it cliasity, candor, and fotbearance in all contzoversy, lowood Ohurch, A, Drysdulo ; Dunton Church, | New Digest, pago 104, it is roquired that Judicatorios | ¥ inst tho acousod, In both tho | DZ,Iussc Walts was acoused of heingn Unitarian, 5o | to tlo bady, the reading of which will detormine | , And that tis bpfibltitmont of this Comiinittes is not SULE OP BUOCESS. . shall % not ' recolve or Judge of any cliarge but such | AraWn up against tho acoused. In bo! O | @imoult ofien is it to percotvo the dividing Lino, We | (ho coures tho Prosbytory will pursue. fo bo coustrued In any way or degree; diroctly or indi- | This paper provoked considorzblo dobato, dure W. H. Dunton; TFullerton Avenue OChurch, Morton Lowis ; Ninth Church, Georgo H. Loonard ; Joliot First Church, \V. P, Caton ; Wilmington Church, Willism Harb; Pootono Church, Houry Marsden, In addition' to theso, there wore about $00 spectators, Erluulpnlly ladies, who occupied sonta outside tho Iresby~ ters, tho latter sitting in tho body of & somi- oircle. : ) v it could bo read. ¢ - - iTho prococdings waro openod by sponding a | pLot S48 COUSE J0% e, Accieed, Wl both e | unloss, eucls wor the easo, Aho body was | know tint Tolfer widely from fhem, bt \bin ey | Iegouldboread: o Lo 3F 1 Prosbytory 16 mithiin Foom tho prasangiciv? | bylorian Churoh as woll as the loiter of fh fov moments i silent prayor, and then: the | feaure the herfofmmnce of A duty, presiibod by Gk | ot "R s S b e O P o ia s phivats i s fetlamanty trtimont | O i ot of tho Tov, Tean | tho ohivnes dactaes poip arnt Gonfossfon of Faith, Ilo was porsuaded thab Modorator askod Qod that tho spitit of & tzue | Constitution, without mny _intimation whatover on ( periiey 00 SHATHOS WATDE beon tend, Hho dor | S BYor iR i T love Trenbytoniomisms.n. lova | cla L. Beiion asinst o sav. David Swing befors the TUING TUEM TodETIER. thero woro mou_prosent intolligont onough to Christian brothorhood might bo upread over tho | elther side ss to tho truth or Justice of thoobatgesand | feRdaE S pload FUILY OF | jnleritod from all my ancestors, 12 on acconnt'of i, it | Presbylery of Obicago t Mr. Kittrcdge nocoptod the stuendment, Iro | Widorstand procisoly what -tho statuton of the ascombly, that Ho would bo with thom, and | Specioeations, uot guilty. Tagg lectsy for mp o abela s the lesst my gobi | Fraucls L. Fattom bolag duly aworm, doposes, and | wuy swaro, from tho boginming of the procoad. | ObUrch meant ab o presont timo, and what gulde them to just conclusions, Third~Tho third reason of tho protosfors sesms to | _Mr. Noyes presumed it was in ordor for him £0 | will toward all seols, T should refusa to pirchacs tho | says, upon ffo information aud bollef, that Tobart | fio "Wy, o hrothipn (Swing and Patton) | Va3 aud what was not conformatary thorato ; AUTERNATES ausuiia that only the defondant, or Lii couusol, has a | muko n atatemont, with the view of sliowing tho | Fresbyterian namn al ao dear a price, Luird Collier, who ia nanied nys witness tu support of | IE: thok o b brots it otlior, and ho | 2nd Lo had no doubt whatsoovor thak, howovor Tho businoss opened by Dr. Patterson en- | Dgut o quoslion the logality of tho obarges and | attitudo of. the dofondant in rogard to tha pend- THY BECOND POINT tho complaint, aud restdes 1n the City of Oblcago, lett [ hnd atood ab & diutauco from ench othier, aud 16 | ppye™ “golays thero might Byt specifications, which has been shown to be an error, i 3 o 0 Wi 10 bo allidzd fo was ny relations to Presbyteriantem, | hiy howe, s short tine beforo tha meoting of (hfs | bad longed and prayed that they might bo B "Fourtl—Th fourth reavon of the Presbstery In that {fi‘ifi‘;{“fifl"&z.“‘f’mfih {':"("fi';;g wodid enora, | A dinflnotion avIGsily sxiste.between: Deisbrions | Trbubstety: or s saun i Eorvage, opinjonag of this brought hoarer togothor. ‘heraforo, it seomod ;‘S",h:"i‘,‘,l&b;’& the acquittal of Prof. Swing thio Baok of Discipline, Ohap, 6, Soo. 8, euld off all | 3 4% % ¢ Floavo to do, Wiion ho Aad concludod | 12t 84 formulated in paat Hines aud Prenbytorinnism | sont nntil hext Soptember, sndy thoreforo, hia testl- | to him that, now that tio Btatomont'of. tha ao: e Ty, and o large and gencrous usiness at tha firat maeting, unfess with tho consent | S8 i d detual, A oreed is ouly {ho higheat wisdom of a par- | mony canuat bo obtained at tho prosont time, > | cuscd Lind boen road, if a committas wero ap- | Acduittal in tho Gonoral Assombly of the United of partles, except glving & copy of tho chnrgos with | 'his slatement, Moular time and place. Hencs, as in Blates, thoro fs | 116 furtlior saya that he had no knowledgo or tnfor- | [ei 1"y spnfar with tis bive, tho trial eonid b | SEAtoo: I£ Trof, Patton ohoso to oarry the onse the names of tho witnesies to thoe accused, sud citing Mr. Ely aid & point of ordor could not bo de- | aiways & quiot aupmz awhy from old lsws | motion of tho mutter montioned in tho fivst epecifica- | P! ied. Ha s b sotuntod b 1 fool. | 0 ®highar conrt he conld do so, and take the 41 partics o ppear at » subkoquent mecting, But ity bated, 81d road from (ho Discipline to sustain | withowt ~ suy " waillvg ' for s formal ~ro- | tion, nnder tho second clinrgo, untll aftor ho gave no- | 8voided. o ywas not sctuatod by Shnnopat fool. | roapongibility, but tho Prosbytecy should wash 1s piain, especially after comparing Disciplinie, Chap. | his position, Jcal, as som of tho old statules of Councolicnt aro | fico’to tho Presbstory of s purposo to prosont | Gk, but by love for tho ~ Church aud | 3ol TS BHE IO SOt hetiveon broth 4, Boc, 3, with tho chispter and seatiou oppoaled to by A Prosbytor nsked it Mr. Ely waa argulng as | lyiog dead, not by any legal death, but by loug emacia. | this complaint; “that, n fow days ofter | for 6hrlnb; and ho wished, for the good name abont whet it bolievod to B inl en tho Presbyters, that that sootion refers only to aotlon | 4oy ol for the prosecutor, tlon and Al utier nvglest of frisnd and fooi monall | that meeting, ho hcard a roport purporiing | mid honor of the bady, thit thay would elnk all trincs Iu the Prasbytorla 2 uhabAenkal dogs after tho clurgos Lava boen legally, entortainod nnd | COPMEe 0 rked {hat hio would be obligod | foRmuated eresds, Ostliolls or Protestant, {hero fs w | fo_como from tho ' Mtoy. B, M. obeow, | jesucs nud all lincs, if Any-hind beon drawn, and | ‘1108 b the Presbytorian faith. [Applause]. tho Court hns been chinrged in its judiclal capaolty. £ SO TOIMAT KO0 & By, | Brudusl, but constant, decay of somo article or word | of Meutucky, that Dr, Nobert Colyer, of Uity Churcl, | aitjva by lova, and prayer, and counsel, to brihg - BTAND DY THE THEOLOOY. Nothing furtheris {0 bo dono towards tho Judioial tn- | o mako the eamo oxcoptions prosonted by Mr. | which was once promiulged wmid great poinp and cir- | iu this city, on tho occaslon of deiverlag & Teoturs. Iy the Hrathran cue s tliat thoro might bo ng | ¢ JT- Holsey aaid the Church wes on trial, ag yeatigilon of thocharges, ¢ at Ui frst mooting (unless | Lly, Whilo ho wishod to afford the acoused [ cwmatance. And yet o Oburch js willing to confoss | Gynthisne, Tog., Auning (ho Inst winior. Lo states St "oF Judlcial prosaedin o g froll 03 hor thaology and slandnrds, That nmng whether DMr, Oaton, of the Joliet First hurch, and sovernl othors who had given in their names as roprescating churches, represont- od their sossions for the firat time in this meot- ing of the Preab_vtor{. or wera altornates ? 3Ir. McLood #aid this was the firat time Mr, Caton Liad been present, sinco the rogular dele- gate was not ablo to como. Dr. Pautorson knew nothing at all in regard to tho attitudo of the brothren with reference to the peuding trial, but, as he understood the state- ments of the digest, thadeclsions of the Genoral | {1/'c(liont of parties) than giving tho minfstor - 1 faoility, tho Tal Vi lolt, and it | its past folly nud Fepeal th 10 liad received s lotter from tho Rov. David Swing | noed of judicial proccedings. Dly coversd tao points ralutive o ajtae. | BY consent of pariies) than g the m reo | evory facility, tho rule was very oxpliolt, and it | its past folly nud ropeal tho injurions or nntrue, All, | o ind receivad 8 lotter from tho Rev. Day ng 1 3 + | theology was hor glory, and Lo folt ready - g::::: fifi:fi. e quou?!nn e o mxs'il | o gr‘:.l:‘: mrw,’ &c, But tils surely does not | was xmr!netry proper to call upon bim (Bwing) at | Catholic and Protestant, eimply agreo to remaln silout, | With o declaration substantially the ssmo as mention- ANBWER TO PRATER, to stand by ib ogainst oll 'comars. It was thot eabytory should proviously deter- 3 . TUFE QONFEARION OF FAITIT. od In £aid specification, and_theroupon fuquiry was Mr. Reld was an obaptvor of providencos, Ho i wheller or noh tho Corapiatat dhotld b alnnir. | {H6¢ time to. sny whethor o tras B oo | In tho Trowbyiorian, Gontosion of 3 thers aro | Sundb of DELRaport Collsoh who-sati so ebastas i | Bk Hoale et JCHeEvor of, proyidencas. | Ho theologs, 18 formulated, that they Liad alwavs ded ; that s, wheilier or not { will giva tho prosecutor | A1 thon, it ot ih l’.fl: fony B0 | about 200 formtas of truth, or supposed truthi, It I | informed, that ho lid never Toccivad aoy such states | hoing given to affairs, nnd yob f..d herdly hoped | 86004 by, and whon tho grand rounion was of- lowve to prosecuto bl oharger, Iu tho present camo | fo striko out any or all of the spaifications, or | u 'wondortul srgument In fevor of thia compendium | ment, and had never been in Oyntbiana; ot shout the that iv could bo reatized. Many prayors had | 1o0tod It whs on thous standatda thab the oldand the prosccutor was permittod to road his clorgos | SrgUO On sny action ho might desive. He Was | that not ouc-tenth of thesn have beon found falss to | Eamo'timo ho obaincd this information ho also heard J Y pray now #ehools camo togethar, and 1 was by thom toke tho places of principals, and, when s brother roturned, chauge back and forth during ihe samo sossions; and, second, whothor au alternato might bo admitted wheu the principnt pud spocifcationn, Vil Jley wore not aduwiticd | gorry to interrupt tho counsol, but thought his | fhe Biblo or falio to the Welfuro of socioty, Yo desigs | that Dr, tobort Laird Colller iad toctured during tho | KON up in antlcipntion of thla nation, aud ho bo- | Gt Y0900 camo & hud takon bis deat, during the samo mooting. | by g Jullcatory “*se & maller of eouia: | remarks wore niiraly ont of oror. - 10 | 1o DtbieeT falto o the welluro of socioty, Ko desig- | that Dr. loby Gynilinng, nod for the putposo of sscor- | lioved 1t way in suswo to pragar that thinga lad Abplaisel. The d",‘{,{";m‘fy ';‘,',"’m“,}"?.f‘m;‘ £ Hgfi:;fl :“T:E :lfi:c ;\n :‘n:u :n :mprn :?Pruulig\?g gm " : &;;.‘:1'\' : ‘:1:‘ np:l::lu‘ o w:wl%fl z )::.\,o“dllm(chl ‘T'ho Modorator falt that ho was compelled t fli‘nv e nlm(:lut l&nfl){ vlh’llblu &‘ulm, eu‘mmon toall (allnllln,lz :h'flmfl' g{ the m&m )r":f ;‘l‘?pou‘:nt ‘;{xmm.flu tnk&n tho uhn;:u t‘lssy l(.\lm}’. g}, o rxgjuh):;:% that tha {‘m‘, “they Werd Roiug to raconcila tho Dow. am 5 ommi . L ory, chur S erod ) 18 BACTO! e letter to Mr, Hobson, and aglte im {0 make o writ- otion was antertaine o Pres o1y, ant % $atvis vel o bim during that assembly. i th schveof tho baok, “ cutered upon tho coualdrt | SuEtalw tho polut of ordor by tho Isuguage of | U B0 GRS RS o | fe ateoncint of the Fcta. vemtiot by ost st | Jotion was anterlaluod by Lo, Frosby! cthot, it | Sdvanced viows with tho thoology a8 formulated. wblon ¥ of the cburgea: in other words, the complaint | tho book. At the same timo, ho Lopad tiat the Pr wwor 4 t lio rocolved an afi ‘hich, 13 cobhat o 1o knew nathing about actual theology, bocaus a5 appiying to tho Dresbytory. Tho quoetion b | Yia thed Iegally boforo tho Bresbytory for Judich ine | Prosbytory would allow bim to say tha, f Prof. | Joqie getuatl rresbyloriun Clhuroh I TR e R ?eryf 19| ke Camumltien {""““"{‘ L "‘fim‘j‘“ Sogother, | it variod In evary DArt)of. tho canntey. It wap L e A gL o and it | s, nd sotliug furthior waw dous,at it mooting | Bring, througl hhé counsgl, mada lraoné® | o imend ot repesl fomo ano arliclo, 1t voull éntail | Aud this doponeut furlies g tint Lo o Infoimed and thay aas, lown and oxplsinadand undorstood | oia thing in Cllopat, dnd " anatho i Philadel- ho court lclr] capa " ) 10 " or * nof ol 0 . leT 0] irt n 4] vy . 3 ing Al was shown, after a trisl had begun, it was fm- | nlinister a full copy of {his ohargest oter Nonldes, no mfi:'l:x it l;.u"him tfi:c :¥nun:nms“nl°gfig2?}npf o istond thun ..."t,"fi“?:'m‘.“‘t}m‘fi’;“. el nfl’l‘x‘im;u“bv::cd up Wi apors and loft them 1 atove 1 | 1o had long folt thab the grontest ariminslwas ‘J‘é.‘fif, uufin‘tm\xv‘fi;: 'flfeg:m‘ au ;: ?lu‘l’rtnfln"m proper for parties to entor,—that was, uftor evi- | objection was mude to the preliminary action of ‘tha. hould bo all tq bo | Westmiuster Assombly, As tho Qhrlitian world ayoids | Bomo pinco unknown to the dopoucnt, and that thoro | ¢ words, not men,” and it wns possibla that Trof, b ay, a8 formulated in denco had been takon,—but it was perfeotly | Prosbylery, by elther purty, o tio pround atterard | Scter of an anewor should boallowod tq bo | Memuber dxtomily, As the Qlilstian worid ayaldy | somo plnce Unkniow to tho dopoucnt, and that thero Suinga’ thoughts bo olothed 1 tho Jangirgo of | tho sfndard, wau talkied of, having come dawn onter now. defined by tho protcstors, * o that thio parties moy bo | 1Made. The book dld ot prosoribe tho exact | {1 0R,00 Fhe trénslation of th - on of tho papors without tho congent of Dr, Colli 4o dlotued in b B for 800 years from tho ' groat _Reformor, proper thut they en! a o y Tu form in which he shonld pload, and h s 1 would' probably ereato | e o pap “i: Prof, Patton, and Prof. Patton's in tho languagoe Dr. Pattorsen remarkod that a reforouce to the | falrly regardsd as luviug given thelr convent to the | luuguago or form in whick he should pload, and | ypong tha soots, %0 each pattioular Churoh pustpoues | nnd thero hasnot beon sufilclent {imo to obtaiu such | of Prog. Bwing, aud that hormony would bo ficl\:hefi:hul; thom from -tho Diblo and Prof, Patton did not understand the question procedure of the Preabytery. If, morcover, tho con- | if Mr. Noyes was about o plead substantially, | gs long as poseiblo suy formal moditication of ite i perminsion, And tho deponent submita these facts Lo know what thoology wi Algest would ?‘fi‘:‘l‘bfnfg"fi;o decision, aud it | SiFiction glven by tho protestons'to Disoiplfue, Ohay, | it scomed to him thet au acoompnuying state: | foric siatements of doyiner Tns mocaniler o0 e | by tory for the o omae oy oA fcee et | broght abotit. ‘meant and whora thoy stood, 51" A “3‘“:;‘ At hies to cosord with the Yok o el o rlsrc. a.gvun‘m:!i :};&v"uwn;ugv-;wmflgnflgm& mont should be permitted. oy L VIDTAL IS GANO % LAVES testimony of D, Collior ia mafertal ; that Mthamottuo | Koy Ink SEFENRD ;a;filflsfi:;dd ol PR PATTIREON . n presouting i “nt the Oref of " B D cannot suspend th f tholr jud; ault of tho deponent that tho oyidonca caunot now be 2 ‘ o Tatterson, bt bo did not tlulca¢ applied to he | fs atiorth sourtvas dly”orgunized sna charged | g4 51cr? toomia bo mo-sbootions > "ore "0 | Bl Comhn s, Shsats: Snbe (o Sk o | Fhodised Sh he BTOUBA s b R AL | Do ghiietaneony 0 (b eoene: soprehondod tho vary ditficultioa tho Presbytory s boforo tho Prosbytery. by tho. Moderator. 6 dungerous idea by law, (Ko Presbyterian Church | dficgtion tnder tho keoond chirgo sests, aud to enublo | Mr, Trowbridge moved that Dr, Pattorson bo | W24 Botting into boforo the raunfon was actom~ r Fifth—Tho protostors allego ag their ffth and last Aftex somo quibbling, the Modorator decidod i1 ho Prosh, fo determitio th ton tb by I 4 plishod. 1io did not_think Prof. Swing's views Dr, Pattorson dofoaded his position, Thecb. | Tirthothe brotseions allego e, Gunp, 5, Bos, 15, | that defluite ploa should bo mndo, and thon & | Bitereh Asieris o .‘x.':"r‘:fil‘x’,;‘:n‘r’?:n“é‘.'fl‘u?:‘é’:ni{‘ 2 [ e Sy Tt the L SR o | Chnirman of tho Committas, but subsoguontly | fcanaistont with po Nonest aubsriptlon to. the ; 't ; ! Tatzon Joot in making tho deolslon was that no dvan- | FEER U100 HOSE £ BIOP e St B Sec. 18 | e ant 01 o mads by cotmma) Tave thus far dévoted e ihis o | Withdiow tho motlon, ;] % ¥y N amy life, giviug it what I poasces Bubacribed sud sworn beforo mo this 4th day'of ' . = TR Y Confossion of Falth, as they had’ b acel gamight b taen by Eroslriorion wandiog & Lo dutormined uniil tho witkeswos avo ioard, " Bt tho | °_Dir. Noyos said tho atalomont Lo wiched to | of mind aud noats, - 7 % 61718 1 what X sty KD, : ’ Filor, PAFTON tomed to intorprabit, - Thior bad-bas mious: P “li!! l: YV RO, potaty VheR. (e Suml f.‘,‘ Ig\nl comam ia“ n{: 1&05 "‘éfi’.".‘:‘i““x norldlfldfl‘m 1ake was ouly in part an unswar to the charges, DARK TATALISM, « 4 (8igned) Foaxg B, Oraven, Notary Publle, Tiad p yomark to make, aa the motion reforrad to | dorutandings created. whioh it were bottor for D Emcn ko it aost T SOl BolA Tt | secaylory fecilo, supthing Whstaves in reosrd to | oy Jrepustory to s ples, whio {ho pooused | Gbief amoby the doctrincs Which aur lireh bas i 1817 15 ONDER? bimealf, Ashoundorstood 1, commitieo was | thg Prasbyrory ta cloar up by n brit, it would had once Lalkon bl aon w plaluod o had raspoct soluly i tho indefitencesf | Would asl permission to ontor wheu he (Noyes) | Passed by aa Veing invorroct, or elae au overovelop | The Olerk bogan ronding tho sfdavit attaghed, | o bo raised, with instructions ‘to uoo him and [ samove b tohpasries that the Prosbytery wai the end of tho sesslon, Lo -!,,,,‘,,.,u,m,o“,, got n.mugf%l sud Lo presumoed that in that form | tuent of Borlptural 1deay, aro all thoso formulas which | Jt was intorrapted by M. Hurd, who roso to a | iuqfro of bim whetor ho did not think it unwilling to investigate tho facts, and thoy A FREGEDERTS Tonides, the infarenco of tho protestors from the pas- | thoro coul A p o no objoction to his meking tho | 100Kk topard s ditk fatallawm or which destroy the hu- | pojug of order, Could tho aflidavit bo read, halt | would . bo batter &p witbdsay the prasos 1 i ! Mr, Wood ead a deolsion from the procoed- | yugetn ts ook of Bisciplineto suieh sy e | e 8 TH0 | o wil, oe Joulcate tho damoation, of bome tutunt, | PONECL PG Db Ho RNl Lo ond e | Sutior - whoph™ Hp Withdnaw the pruse- Ao e seriad ta tho Synod wudor vory grest iogs of the Gonoral Ausembly of 1847, whiloh Toue | flogs not seom {o be wurrauted by tha languugo of the | * Dr. Pattorson did not soo that the poin of | Trajority of 'tho rach to sverinattus detie 1e wos hee | porson? His polut was that $ho punor or depo- | tor . far tho oaugo . of Ohriat t1sb | At tho oxpipation of half pn hdur, tho interlo- to tho offect that & coutruction of tho Gonstitu- | ook, foritda provided i Discipline, Chsp. d, Sec. & | ordor was good, unlons. 1 was dnsistod that & | g asod ot bad foriume i mobagutll, TLHeG oen | Lo s tabon without L authority of the | tho prosccution” ehoula cense. Mo wished to Hiry Tmeating olos Sotio W oul] b 3 tion which allowed Commissionaers to hold sonts | alrendy quoted, that the Judicatory * shall not admit ttotion shonld g drate ton I ber of A I {ho Drespyt 3 {obary meoting olosed, and the imatiou of Dr. on o Elickn 0 DEGLE e OLEGHOTOLL iy ihing 00 & atter of acownation which cavoaie | very rigid cous ruction should be put upon the Jrivats toh inrge mumber of perous hostils to our | Presbytery, fulctho Drespytory whothor, It ho outertained | Kittradgo, and tho doowmont offrod by AMr. and thon resign M. Horton, of the | Proved to bo such from Koripturo, o from the regula~ | TUld8 of proceduro, ho romarks wore intro- | blitirch uud in ncavly wll cavos X have found thiole ios- | * Mr, Ely supposcd the afiidavit waa Intradnood | that opinion, fio would not hy #o. TTo did no | 1y was laid on tho table, = = Tho trial had not bogunwhan Ms. Hoston, of the | oo the Giurch, foundod. on Horiplure.. Tag Ju. | ductory o tho plonding, Still, if the prosoutor 1 s, s doctrisus Wicatod abovo,aild | with tho view of auking for a continuauoo of tho | think it nocofsary to appoin tho Committon, On'motlan, {t whs doglded ta hold sesslons of 3 i "Tho {ssuo betweon Prof, Swing and himsolf, God | tho Trosbytaty fiom 0:30 a. . t0 1980 P m, Third Church, was admitted, and it scomed 10 | gioatary g therefars bound to xjoot cortain clai was unwilling to admit thom B8 & part of the linve declared 1o them that tho Yrou. | &o0 ‘him plain that Mr. Oaton could it a8 tho ropro- | cuargey tn tiine s not entitlod to Judicial coni answor af the aooneod, ho hod tho Tight to do- Dierion ‘i{‘,‘f;fi,fln"',‘,‘.}“f,‘;,‘,’.fi}“““.,{.f.’i}‘:,lflfifi"’,flf;' an 1 “'whio Modorator remarkod that no one couldtell [ knew, was not p porsonnl ong. - Ho- bad \Jofor | and trom 280 p. m. to 5 b, ATTON'S AFIID, ora: gentativo of tho First Churol of Joliat, tion.” Tt thon afto¥ churgoy huvo been outorlained | yand that thoy bo exoluded. ar ezcellence, tho religlon of doapafr, In' my peon’ | botter what tho purposs wad than tho person | challdnged his persoual charaptor or his Christian o ;The Modorgtor outd Hhio bin) ki atrlotly boen | ixdn o ‘2&‘.’5‘:‘;‘;.:‘:":":3,??!!.’, eiimony o LET DI PLEAD, | JE iGisty s sivaple wilewos s oot ‘beon mgatent. | Who prodonted it standlug, yior lisd auy wordn of discouttosy or | . Drag, Tytha flion nskod that. the wTldavit Hoe ehtered upon. It was tmonnlev mwfix o tm:n [l S ity thoy aranot woll founded, 1f Mr, Kiltredgo tuought tuoy ware wasting }hlu. lml;lxe[nu, v;tmnny twos declared our denoy Dr. Patton said the object of introuclng it | unkindness nvortnusnd hotwsen thom. Thoro- | forg ailyded to be rend, sud movod that takien, and, in an oquitablo viow of gmli‘ln{. however, on Learing the ‘itucaeos, the cbarges still | timo, It scomod a very simple thing., Tho ag- !‘:""l’::l" 40 bo stuply a Glitpoli of the commion ovan- | was to ehow thio hecessity for a continuanco, Igro, if & commities wero to bo ralgod to Lring the caso bo continued for a rcg‘,nwm, thoro might bo no “objection to any brol "o | appesr linportant, snd seom ia "bo ‘yall suppartad, the | ousad or his counsel could gay * guilty ™ or * not ) Mr. Noyon inquired if” thoro was _any motion | sbout & holier state of fooling Lotweon | fimo: anggosting (W0 Tonths, us b worsy takg taking the place of anothor; yob it soomor Judicatory shall proceed s the seolion direots. his | guilty,” and then go on with his romurks. That INFANT DAMNATION, beforo tho Louse, thom, it wou Jnnogossary. o 1o was as rondy | nourly ol g rof, o oth n 5 n 2 time to procitre ‘tho' testimony, t it might be insisted that, having en- patruction preserves the harmony of the Book of 4 24 Toslded tho formulas of itn books, our Ohuroh hea Lt iod that t thou to take the hahd of I nfll?l mor {’;‘,‘;;“’;‘,on i trinl, tho' Jury showld. mog be ?f"“}‘}f.“mmn'n‘f“fi, ldlo that of tho protesturs Efl‘éfik‘.‘fé‘ff‘ui’;‘:‘c‘é’,‘fi;&:;:L..E,’:fi::‘ ey e e ouan e sau record, fiom ihio wil 1.;1‘1‘;‘;:%";‘&3&%&2:;:«tonzhan d’.‘z’lé‘a.?fiufi.‘."fi? was, and ha trusiod rof, S\vhfi? ‘{"Eu“'%o‘i.'iu‘“?u' Ao Lt ?fi:’é“f&gtfigul;ri:kfl::?h'-’fi;‘;{,. changed. . 4 b Fhatper, and wonld oblige us to conclulo tust no Jue |, Prof, Patton—Tho simple quostion 1s whathior | it b beon my frenuont. aty. to try to soparate her | Lho papor. take biy, i iy S curad, whether by sonding o commlns?nn to + Mr, MoLood thought, it the trisl had bogun, dicatory may rojact even tle most frivolous orjn- | thore Is an fesun to try, Prof. Swiug ey say: | fair and swectar present. ‘Thoro wers age when Mr, Noyes wanted to know how the paper was | TOE I88UE DETWEEN TIHEN ~ Europs, or by having some¢ compotert pora the Prosbytory had transcended the book, which definits charyes on any ground whataver, “Iconfess it in all truo,” Thon thore is wo | motlers wailed in swlul caony over s dond infant, be- | gubmittod. Was it in support of any motion ? was an leauo of fuot and an issuo of aw, Trof, | take bis dapopition, - voan eaid_ distinetly, under tho osption of * Process | “A IO Tupeottufly submittea trinl, and the V'rosbylory may pasy its vordiot, | ¢auso ihioy had beon taught that ‘oblldren “uot asipan | - e Moderator said it ywas not, Bulug admittod tho Issus'of faot—adinittad that | = Dr, 6 liod it Drof, Patt o aingt a Dishiop or Olorgyman s 5. W. Partrasow. | Hothay ksys 1t ot tiuo," n whiols cauo thera | 100 ™ wors sufferlng ou tho ot foor of hal,and that | 31y Noyeu urged, thety thnt it was aut of or- | b pod wand ties Jaae of faolradinfitad tha 23 Va1 ol Mot e ey parea Breparod yaust bo reduced to writing, and nalb!-lngfufl xu" £0 | mitted to rocord. 3 & oatogorical answor to the question: ** Guilty or | theas thoughts, mothors wsed to B s v, Wood remarked thnt it was presentod by | tlons; snd tho question - for ~tha -Court | ~ Trof, Patfon uaid he waa pat pmp&xqat 4 e dono at tu Mt mesting, unless by coneent of par- Aftor romo discussion this motlon wes with- | not guilty ?" and the ordar of procodurs Imd | tneir dead-bomn ' Httlo onea, pltaously Lesovching | common consont. i to dopida * wae, . whotbier such...acls _aud | anything. 1lohowever addod in ansiver anglau‘z; flos, thon glving tho mitister, & T4 oy of e | arawu, and snothor to “accopt and adopt tho | downiu tho book makos provision for nothing alie, | Ged to nits-Aat tho ssered siis, * 1o pun sy Hesoushliis ‘'io Modorator understood i ta be out of or- | unch lsnguage . wrqo ju- kooping with his questiony, that lio hiad not madg chiarges, w! roport” waa agrosd to, and the roport of the committeo mpkos prayi- | wall of infants damned, Luther himgelf ways, God | dor. ; siauding ag b .mombor .of tho Vrosbyterl ¢ 3 7 effortata prov ey '{’ ir:::t.::utll::;: &'fifififi'%fi‘{:&”.‘m‘:&& L clz)m{m:n FOR DEFENAK. wlon for nothing olse, 'I'he oounsel for the ng- P’“'\ll:'h o8 .}(Ih“;' d o th wnworthy; Tta | . Noyea sald 1f tho proseontor wished to ohurohgw ioh Lnd for ita - dockrinal b{uwr tul:la Seiodts, Dillisrs "?fo"x‘ffi“ fe BTy ¥ fn:;nerlthm fen days aftor such citation, 3 Mr, Noyos (counsel for Mr, S\vlhg{)-—Tho notl- | gused will hive evory opportunity to make all | Susht nob'to displeato you whon Mo damus the du- | makg nmiotion £y continuv, it would bp In orilor | lurgor and ehortor catoohume, aiid the Wostinine | 'Fha doposition wns than read, Tho subsarib . It the court had boeu constituted, and tho | fleation nbout the protost that s to be ontored | tho apoooh bo doafves, and it Prof, Kiwing wishes | "ft s doctrine of fatallam, as fmplied du the | £r tho aflidavit to bo sead, and for Lim (Patton) | stor Confoesion of Faith, Loy auld give ¥rof. | was the Nev, B, M, Hobson; o eitor the Pros- inat the indlictment would scem to call for | to mpke any etatoment in conncotlon fect Indy 7 f Go'n il 1 L to apent to tho mation, ut ho did not koo how | Bwing all -oredit for intalioctunl approcinti h YOI ot uym}“" Xy, chargo u&;mngg;“;,‘,’:“,;‘:&‘,‘,fi',“h’:‘t",‘ék, °mul he .'.53.3 statoment on the part of tho defonsoasto | with hls apswer, of course I bave no ul:’:::d”:et,‘:u;: n';; ‘n’:‘;‘.‘?‘&m ‘:’&:‘.‘.f.??’ifiu’.\'.k"n:‘.’.mn‘h"y"-'t tho ]lloumnnnt could otherwlse como in unloss as | and all credit for tho oxerciso of hh} lefl;‘l’d?;‘l:l v:l:‘l)x Hfi‘:‘ 2 égl?ltor l““{'}q‘f“ffi:& ‘“’l‘“ eruation bytery, nlynw trial wag now begun, or wonld | the views and position of tho acoused in rogard | objeotlon, Isimply submit that thigin ngb the | Linaboen sy constant duty, oa it scemed, to protest, | & mattor of privilego, & Judgmont 3. but ihey came togethor far tho elm- | jeoty, tfimt antloman -statod th l’f} cal . b Lok b the tor and Preabytery shonld | to the indictment, snd, us prolimivary to s mo- | Hmo, and lhese Dot tho oiroumstances wudor | and thus dafend our Ohuroh from tho fifhuonco of |~ fho Modorajor hind glven tho prosoentor por- | plo wattlemant of thio_fesua as to whother auoh | prosched nuiat inll] oo hat Lrof. Byin e when tho prosecutor & ¥ fion which 1 desiro to minko nt tho conclusion of | which it is proper for Mr, Noya to spoRk {danawo ropudiated by modorn thought., An ewfnont [ paiguion to sposk, but, A objeatlon waro mads to | fa ago contravoned tha Oonfossion. of T i putinlly such yiews an ho “(Cof+ hayo boen charged. cnrl:n‘i”n atatomonts which I wish to submitin [ A Proshytor remarked that all the 3 talle " wag | cbucchman, porhops Luther, said HAUL thtngutako | 310" trodiiotion of thia paper, ha ghould with- Hu%vml willing to sbldp by the duulgl;:: ot“tl‘nh .{“) g e | thatbo (Gollior) had writton Gato o :’;fi: many others as | roferonoe to tho indiotment, i would be propor | out of ordor, Tty e satat lfifl,}?fi:’,‘,‘,fl‘,‘;fl?ffl"{,‘hfl‘° draw that normission, bovuuso b was ouly by gou- | Qhurch, whon. that. doglsion shonld have ll_lu\;.l;i ‘\‘v‘n{’agt“x?\%lw L‘:“: wxl(‘fiw [hn staod, and tho movad that Mr, Caton, s ontorod on tho roll, | for mo to prosent them. Tho Moderator'was not familar yith trials,and BALVATION DY FAITIL, aral consont that tho presentation of the papor [ boon rondered by tho highest fudicatory of !!Lhuou understood t“’ bim—that iy, ay Ay, desirad ko have ol Whilo it wau trug NoT Now. volly dfd ot kiowe what bo do. Undor & ehriot | ot to tho bagefil Cuirlisse chilimt of sho wil, | wns ‘propor. “Tho noxt.thing o do, unior | tho Olmkoh, It 1t wars s cocabasy to flee s 2p o | SLobeom undorstaod I, oy word in- secbrd witi hia nocorded the P‘"“f 0 besn mado that tho Prof. Patton did not wish to Interrupt the | pud rigid conatritotion of tho teyms of the book, | comes lhr overstatomant of tho idea of walvetlonby | tho rules, wan to [érm:und to the oxaminntion of | far, ‘Ihere was ng noed of making it » porsonal {further atatin kfi:&‘ it ”‘m 1:“’“1.‘zr i Swing that tho nm;our:o‘u;n:?:\ in o judloinl capaclty, that | brother, but ho gubmitted that any atatomont | ho must call u{mn tho roypondont for » catogori- ;:‘m" ol ;l;g,l;fi.:lc‘gfll:'nfl‘l'lr‘}éfih’gfi;’éfil&mflg o i | witnoesus, and that would bo dono unloss thero | qucstion, no noed for ill-fauling. or » sundor- | tinue in the pgniuon J&"“.l.fif' c:c "I]"L']“d ' fony court was aboul which the defenso choso to make in ploading to | cal answor to tho cherges, and atter such answor " s waa anation for a contiyunuge, standings to arive, It wos o nhnslo. sinkted in- | eould do moro to advance thn!r et N e . _Btrlotly sponk- would, ho conld not destroy his salvation by sny sins, & A annouuooment was promaturo. Birioty wROR | 9 CR L ould be proper, and tho honso | ho would pormit utatetnonts to bo mado, If pny- howovor grioiois, unices He refuise o helieve,” s | | Dr Pattorson Ll consonted to tho introdua- [ Lollootunl quontion, snd why shonld. thoy bo . ; common vigive, ng, tho trisl bad nof begun, and would = heur 15 but ho bad somo doubt as to tho [ body wishod to spponl fzom thak dooisjon W0y | thon s ser e sin periner oy Boldiy be-,| tlon of tho paver, supposing it was Intraduotory, | willing ta soll ibs ] ! ! FORKMAK, A ‘|§' uotil issuo joined, * No iseue had | would heur I 1200 0, Hieve, From Qlrlst 10 sin sLAl sopetate, (oUBlLA | £0 BUCH & FaOHOR, &0A 0BlY o (aAb geound, Due | "o di Anothor deposition, slgnod by the Hov, Mr, and® wowld nob bo uatil | proprioty of making such & sialoment ay A, | coul 4 not understand Prof, B\;Ins. but go far | Foroman, of tho enwo town, Was alsg soon dolnod, wade,